Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Wrong.

They're an attempt to silence criticism by appearing reasonable. Unfortunately for them, if we take "probably" into account, then the whole "higher power" bit is irrelevant.

It's like saying:

1. No human power can help you.
2. Speak to God.

And after someone points out that it's religious, etc. as we've been doing here, they amend it to:

1. Probably no human power that you know of can, in all likelihood, help you most of the time, and we're not even sure about that.
2. Speak to God as you understand him. But it could be a rock.

As if no one understands that the added words don't change a thing.

^^ This, this, this. ^^
 
I still baffled at the apparent inability of those arguing that AA is a religious organization to critically, or even accurately engage some of the passages that the insist mean that AA is religious.

For instance, they see the word "God" in the Steps but do not address the phrase that immediately follows: "as we understand Him". Similarly, they have repeatedly misquoted the second item in what Tinyal has called the ABCs. They write it as "No human power could have relieved us of our alcoholism", whereas it is actually written as "Probably no human power could have relieved us of our alcoholism".
 
I'm baffled at people's inability to see how much of an insult this is to the intelligence of the average person. The history of AA that it is a religious cult. People have tried to make it secular and a program and a technique, patch up the Frankenstein, and declare it is secular! This is by far not the only cult to do this. Look at Transcendental Meditation, is it a technique or a religion? Equally asinine conversations are happening on that elsewhere too. The correct viewpoint is that it started in religion, became a cult, and then they tried to make it a secular technique. So that's why it is the way it is today, and if you try and have a conversation that treats it different, the conversation will go nowhere and explode.

Just admit it always was a religious cult, and that you're trying to move on from that and make it inclusive. Then we can move on to talking about how we can improve the 12-step, or integrate alternatives.
 
I'm baffled at people's inability to see how much of an insult this is to the intelligence of the average person. The history of AA that it is a religious cult. People have tried to make it secular and a program and a technique, patch up the Frankenstein, and declare it is secular! This is by far not the only cult to do this. Look at Transcendental Meditation, is it a technique or a religion? Equally asinine conversations are happening on that elsewhere too. The correct viewpoint is that it started in religion, became a cult, and then they tried to make it a secular technique. So that's why it is the way it is today, and if you try and have a conversation that treats it different, the conversation will go nowhere and explode.

Just admit it always was a religious cult, and that you're trying to move on from that and make it inclusive. Then we can move on to talking about how we can improve the 12-step, or integrate alternatives.

I'm baffled as to how you cannot see that your post is one huge genetic fallacy.

Is Planned Parenthood today a racist organization because Margaret Sanger advocated selectively sterilization poor, inner-city blacks?
 
Last edited:
I'm baffled as to how you cannot see that your post is one huge genetic fallacy.

Is Planned Parenthood today a racist organization because Margaret Sanger advocated selectively sterilization poor, inner-city blacks?

If Planned Parenthood's literature continued to the present day to advocate this, then yes, it just might be such.




Well, does it?
 
Wrong.

They're an attempt to silence criticism by appearing reasonable. Unfortunately for them, if we take "probably" into account, then the whole "higher power" bit is irrelevant.

Thast might be your interpretation, but it isn't mine nor anyone elses within AA that I have met.

It is interesting to me also that you will happily ignore, reason away, remove or redefine a word so that a sentence or thought aligns with your bias. Would you call this honest debating, or just making things up as you go along?
 
Last edited:
I still baffled at the apparent inability of those arguing that AA is a religious organization to critically, or even accurately engage some of the passages that the insist mean that AA is religious.

For instance, they see the word "God" in the Steps but do not address the phrase that immediately follows: "as we understand Him". Similarly, they have repeatedly misquoted the second item in what Tinyal has called the ABCs. They write it as "No human power could have relieved us of our alcoholism", whereas it is actually written as "Probably no human power could have relieved us of our alcoholism".

So you're baffled because you haven't read the thread yet. Big surprise.

We've adressed the "as you understand Him" bit. "Him", first, doesn't give much wiggle room as to what we're talking about. Most reasonable people wouldn't assign the word "God" to a rock, or a nebula. The universe ? Maybe, but then they're again falling into the supernatural.

There's simply no way around it.
 
If Planned Parenthood's literature continued to the present day to advocate this, then yes, it just might be such.

But that wasn't Joey McGee's point in his response to what I had said. He insisted that because AA started as a "religious cult" it is still a religious cult today.

Well, does it?

I don't know, and it is frankly irrelevant to my point, because, as stated above,
Joey McGee was saying that AA was religious because its origins were religious.

That is a textbook genetic fallacy.
 
Thast might be your interpretation, but it isn't mine nor anyone elses within AA that I have met.

Fair enough, though interpretation isn't the question.

It is interesting to me also that you will happily ignore, reason away, remove or redefine a word so that a sentence or thought aligns with your bias. Would you call this honest debating, or just making things up as you go along?

What are you talking about ? The words are there, and their meaning is clear.
 
I'm baffled as to how you cannot see that your post is one huge genetic fallacy.

Is Planned Parenthood today a racist organization because Margaret Sanger advocated selectively sterilization poor, inner-city blacks?
Are there still social scientists calling for that in this day and age? Because the problems I have detailed, the links I have posted, the testimonies I have quoted, the people I talk to on a regular basis, this stuff is all still happening today.

That's a separate issue as to it's religious nature, it has the tone and words it does because of that, you can't figure it out or end the debate until you acknowledge it. Many people refuse to go to any more meetings, and then find out there are secular meetings and attend those instead. AA tends to mock these people as having character defects for not being able to deal with AA. "It can be a rock, you so stupeed!" It's insulting and the attitude is disgusting.

AA is not a professional organization, they should have professionals running things and an accountability program
 
Not really, I can be cynical and mean to people who tackle me first; I will happily respond in kind (so much for Christian religiosity and turning the other cheek). I also relish stupid.
You haven't responded to any of my arguments properly (small sample Alfie?). AA is anti-psychiatry, always was, and still is in many places, and your defense to this is that it's not on their website. This is INSANE Alfie, you're not having a serious discussion here, you're running defence carte blance with no shame at all!!
I repeat: I do not believe I was disrespectful rude nor insulting to Nanny Ogg. Nor was it remotely my intention.
No, the lady from a few pages ago, nice counselling work there bucko.
You on the other hand... :)
So far all of your attacks on me have failed miserably and you can't dispute a word of what I said.
 
Last edited:
So you're baffled because you haven't read the thread yet. Big surprise.

We've adressed the "as you understand Him" bit. "Him", first, doesn't give much wiggle room as to what we're talking about. Most reasonable people wouldn't assign the word "God" to a rock, or a nebula. The universe ? Maybe, but then they're again falling into the supernatural.

There's simply no way around it.

There is a it has been explained at great length to you; you have just chosen to deny it.

The Big Book was written by one or two specific people and is heavily colored by their perceptions of God. Each new-comer is free to agree or disagree with that conception and find his or her own conception. The fact that the authors of the Big Book believed in an anthropomorphic god doesn't mean anyone else has to.
 
But that wasn't Joey McGee's point in his response to what I had said. He insisted that because AA started as a "religious cult" it is still a religious cult today.
No you misunderstood what I was talking about. It's a religious cult today which is obvious if you look at the evidence I have provided (apparently you can post a cochrane review here and people won't read it before attacking it, so I imagine people didn't read those either)

And if you want to understand why it has the language it still does, why it acts the way it still does, you have to look at stuff like The Oxford Group.

Nice try though
 
Last edited:
But that wasn't Joey McGee's point in his response to what I had said. He insisted that because AA started as a "religious cult" it is still a religious cult today.

You are confused.

You asked a question, and I answered it as it applies to this discussion, then asked a follow-up question of my own.

You have not answered me, but have instead pointed fingers at Joey, as if that's the answer. It's not.



I don't know, and it is frankly irrelevant to my point, because, as stated above,
Joey McGee was saying that AA was religious because its origins were religious.

And these "origins" are still present and utilized to this day in "Alcoholics Anonymous," aka "the Big Book." The Big Book has not been re-written, and the religious origins are still in this literature, and still used today.

Is Planned Parenthood today a racist organization because Margaret Sanger advocated selectively sterilization poor, inner-city blacks?

You asked this, you dragged PP into this. So, again, I reply:

If Planned Parenthood's literature continued to the present day to advocate this, then yes, it just might be such.

Well, does it?

I ask, because the AA Big Book continues to this day to advocate its religious origins in its main piece of literature. It has not changed or been updated to remove, amend, or alter the religious content.

If Planned Parenthood continued to this day to advocate its racist origins, it would be a racist organization.

AA continues to this day to advocate its religious origins, and therefore is still a religiously oriented organization.
 
No, Mijo, I must disagree. I didn't have to include flora and fauna as agents which have the power to remove your shortcomings. I didn't need to include them in my definition of what is and isn't supernatural. Because they are nature, they are natural. Do you see the difference?

SUPERnatural is that which is beyond the natural. Life on earth in all its forms is natural, not supernatural. I thought that would be easily grasped without my having to spell it out.

God as you understand him is just...gah, the word I want is eluding me, sorry. It's just lipstick on a pig, essentially. But that still isn't the sense I want to convey. Hopefully, it's at least somewhat clear. Even if your concept of god is different, even if it is, as some have asserted, "whatever you want it to be," it's still god. So, it's still religious in essence.

You forgot to capitalize the "H".

"God as we understand Him" has a distinctly Christian flavor.
 
That's pretty much what I did. I found value in doing just that. I'll say again what I've said before, I'd love AA to reform in these areas. There is something good in the organization that gets lost in all the religious nutty wording.

I'm starting to feel like a moderate who wandered into a Political discussion, both sides hate me :p

/shamelesstryforpity

:rub:
 
Er... I don't mean to be picky, but doesn't that kinda disqualify PEOPLE from being higher powers ?

It would also seem to disqualify anything lower than humans including doorknobs and cat turds.
 
There is a it has been explained at great length to you; you have just chosen to deny it.

The Big Book was written by one or two specific people and is heavily colored by their perceptions of God. Each new-comer is free to agree or disagree with that conception and find his or her own conception. The fact that the authors of the Big Book believed in an anthropomorphic god doesn't mean anyone else has to.

And yet you can't complete the program if you don't do the 12 steps.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom