Again, the "Primary Texts" do not hold the same exalted position in AA as other Scriptures do in most religions; they are the narratives of the founders and usually nothing more.
As far as meetings in the USA, you are simply
wrong. Incorrect, wrong, not-right, however you want to interpret it. I
personally have been to over 11,000 meetings all across the USA - this gives me a strong (perhaps, among the viewers of this thread, even a
singular) ability
to comment on the process and methods of AA as a whole.
I have also been involved -
recently involved,
officially involved - in AA world services at
nearly the highest levels. I've created districts from scratch in several states, begun AA relationships with more than 6 major regional hospitals. I've spoken in front of more than 1000 AA members at a time -
by invitation. I've been directly involved in the
creation of several of the pamphlets you see at your meetings (assuming you purchase AA literature) material that I've come to regret I had any involvement in. - Ive been at the meetings where their contents, and the contents of Public Service Messages, have been
created.
I am even slightly involved in creating a few new ones, whose contents I am not at liberty to reveal - and that's all I say about that.
The point is, if you go to an AA meeting -
any AA meeting anywhere in the USA, and make the 2 statements that I have previously (and continue) done, you
will receive massive, intense, and
immediate out-group responses.
AA is a Faith Gaining Program whose members & officials claim has the side effect of eliminating the drink problem - a claim not supported by the evidence available. It has at least a 95% failure rating, and our efforts should be directed to finding those things that really work - no false faith required.
No
religion required.
For those few who've forgotten those statements, here is one of them - I'll leave it to others to read the thread for others:
1. "I do not need a higher power or any God/gods to get, maintain, and stay sober. And since there is no evidence of any such creature, neither do you"
Try it sometime - and see what reaction you get.
Do it 100's of times,
as I have, then come back and talk to me, at which point I might pay more attention.