Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Plants are supernatural? Bacteria? Uni-cellular eukaryotes? All non-living matter?

I do understand that it is a bit of a stretch to call the emergent properties of human communities "not human", but what you, and other posters who assert than AA has to be religious because its "Primary Texts" mention "God", have done is ignore that one of the other threads of the narrative is that of many alcoholics trying to control their alcoholism on their own and failing individually but succeeding when they got together to help one another. Whether they did so by externalizing the power that they found within the group and calling it "God" is largely irrelevant, because the power that they found within the group is what kept them sober and that power is not supernatural nor is it inherently religious.

Except that's not what people are doing when they use the term God. And it's not irrelevant. What is so hard about forming a Godless 12 Step Group?

Then you can just toss the Religious 12 Steps and the Religious Big Book, and rely just on the support system that a group offers.

GB
 
Because, as has been mentionned more than once, it can't be people. So it can't be anything you want.

That is not what I have been told by other people that I have talked to at and outside of meetings. My experience within the actual, contemporary, living organization (which is anecdotal, of course) does not reflect what those who have little to no recent, on-going experience with AA, which also happen to be those who arguing that AA is inherently religious.

We won't get into how rocks can't be higher powers, either.

Again, the "Power greater than oneself" can be anything that you can draw strength from. If you can draw strength from a small pebble of a cat turd, it can be your "Power greater than oneself".

The reason for choosing a "Power greater than oneself" that is not oneself becomes quite clear when you read the chapters preceding "How It Works". The alcoholic therein described is a person that has tried literally everything to stop drinking and still went back to drinking compulsively. Moderation didn't work; complete abstinence on pure "will power" didn't work; and medical intervention (with the exception of institutionalization and/or lobotomization) didn't work. They had come to believe that they simply could not stop drinking on their own, through their own personal experience with alcohol.

How are such people supposed to trust at all in themselves enough to abstain from alcohol, when they had repeatedly demonstrated that could not quit through their convictions in themselves?
 
Yes, I understand the difference, but, again, that is not literally what you said.

Whatever. I've explained myself adequately, and if it's not good enough for you, that's yours to deal with, not mine.


The Steps do not spell out what is meant by "God". It is clear from the context, though, that Bill W did understand "God" to be a supernatural. However, there is no point in the Steps or in any of the literature that I have read that requires one to understand God as Bill W or anyone one else in AA understands God.

Why do you insist that "God" must be understood in the way that the Big Book implies that God should be understood?

I'm not saying that. I'm saying that having god in it at all makes it a program with a religious bent, influence, or overtone. I don't give a rat's fat behind how anyone understands god, god is a supernatural being. Period. People aren't god. If your higher power is people, then it isn't god as you understand him, unless you understand god to be other people.



Assertion, assertion, assertions.

If you choose a "Power greater that oneself" that is completely natural (as the emergent properties of groups are), how is your program inherently religious?

G.O.D.

and I'm done playing this game. Play with someone else.
 
Except that's not what people are doing when they use the term God. And it's not irrelevant. What is so hard about forming a Godless 12 Step Group?

Then you can just toss the Religious 12 Steps and the Religious Big Book, and rely just on the support system that a group offers.

GB

I myself do not have the social capital to do that.
 
<snip>

Then you can just toss the Religious 12 Steps and the Religious Big Book, and rely just on the support system that a group offers.

GB

That's pretty much what I did. I found value in doing just that. I'll say again what I've said before, I'd love AA to reform in these areas. There is something good in the organization that gets lost in all the religious nutty wording.

I'm starting to feel like a moderate who wandered into a Political discussion, both sides hate me :p

/shamelesstryforpity
 
No. The higher power thingy can be people, as has been mentioned more than once as well.

If you want to have a point about religion in AA, Slingblade had the best one:

"That probably no human power could relieve us of our alcoholism."

That one is hard to get around, period.

Er... I don't mean to be picky, but doesn't that kinda disqualify PEOPLE from being higher powers ?
 
That is not what I have been told by other people that I have talked to at and outside of meetings. My experience within the actual, contemporary, living organization (which is anecdotal, of course) does not reflect what those who have little to no recent, on-going experience with AA, which also happen to be those who arguing that AA is inherently religious.

Well they should be careful when they write "That probably no human power could relieve us of our alcoholism", then.

Again, the "Power greater than oneself" can be anything that you can draw strength from. If you can draw strength from a small pebble of a cat turd, it can be your "Power greater than oneself".

But that's wordplay, at best. A higher power is something that can guide you though the process of quitting. That leaves people, animals (maybe), and gods/spirits. When's the last time a rock helped you out ? If you're talking about some effect you're getting from just using the rock as a higher power, than the effect clearly stems from yourself, which again contradicts the whole meaning of the phrase "higher power". Any way you want to cut it, rocks don't qualify.
 
Er... I don't mean to be picky, but doesn't that kinda disqualify PEOPLE from being higher powers ?

No.

Why?

I can agree with needing a higher power - or else I would have quit on my own, years before.

No "human" power, well that is different. Two people may have more insight than just one, three even more so. To go back to your example, a therapist helping me can be more powerful than me alone, a psychiatrist even more, and so on.

I guess you are saying the two ideas have to agree, and I am saying they are separate.

I'll repeat what I've said before that my experience with AA may have been atypical because I was an athiest going in.

ETA: I personally equated "higher power" with "something more powerful" than just myself. I can see how "higher" sounds religious, while "more powerful" is more in line with my thinking (group/expert help), but not the actual words.
 
Last edited:
<snip>

But that's wordplay, at best. A higher power is something that can guide you though the process of quitting. That leaves people, animals (maybe), and gods/spirits. When's the last time a rock helped you out ? If you're talking about some effect you're getting from just using the rock as a higher power, than the effect clearly stems from yourself, which again contradicts the whole meaning of the phrase "higher power". Any way you want to cut it, rocks don't qualify.

I agree with this.

Again my personal definition which has no bearing on anyone else: Higher Power = Myself plus outside help.

A rock does not count, :p. As much as I love my dogs, they don't count either.
 
Tinayal, thank you. Those are all the things I remember from my years of involvement with AA, as well.

Thus, I simply wasn't getting all this "suggested' and "optional" stuff. As far as I knew, if you worked the program, you did the steps.

Also as far as I know, human power is the only sort of "power" (of that nature) that we have. There isn't anything more than us, it's just us, and our power is all we have. If we can't do it, either on our own, or along with the help of other humans, it can't be done. I don't consider that a higher power. Just human power, which is prodigious in itself, and not to be sneered at, disregarded, or dismissed as inadequate.

To suggest anything else is to suggest sheer woo.


Yes, a good point, similar to what I had asked a little earlier in this thread. I suppose it was viewed as a rhetorical question...



Really? So talking to people who are experienced and are successful (in anything) is a waste of time 100%, always? I'm not trying to strawman you, I am asking for clarification. When is it a good idea to look to a successful group of people in any endeavor, and when is it not. What is the rule of thumb. Are we to never, ever take advice and strength from others? I'm not John Galt, I'm an alcoholic.

I know that this will lead back to the "does it work or not" derail, and I apologize for that.


Wow. Please re-read what I said and then ask for more clarification if necessary.



That is not what I have been told by other people that I have talked to at and outside of meetings. My experience within the actual, contemporary, living organization (which is anecdotal, of course) does not reflect what those who have little to no recent, on-going experience with AA, which also happen to be those who arguing that AA is inherently religious.


So how about you address the points made by people in this thread who have extensive, recent, ongoing experience with AA who argue that AA is inherently religious?



The reason for choosing a "Power greater than oneself" that is not oneself becomes quite clear when you read the chapters preceding "How It Works". The alcoholic therein described is a person that has tried literally everything to stop drinking and still went back to drinking compulsively. Moderation didn't work; complete abstinence on pure "will power" didn't work; and medical intervention (with the exception of institutionalization and/or lobotomization) didn't work. They had come to believe that they simply could not stop drinking on their own, through their own personal experience with alcohol.

How are such people supposed to trust at all in themselves enough to abstain from alcohol, when they had repeatedly demonstrated that could not quit through their convictions in themselves?


This is AA's unique theory in what alcoholism is and how to deal with it; this theory was invented in the 1930's and in the intervening 80 years, a huge amount of information about the brain, addiction, habituation, drug interactions, and techniques has been discovered, tested and implemented.

To me, it's telling that the AA World Organization has made NO CHANGES WHATSOEVER to update and incorporate these more effective treatments.

I believe AA ultimately fails because conceptually, AA views alcoholism as a spiritual ailment which requires a spiritual solution. It simply isn't.
 
That's pretty much what I did. I found value in doing just that. I'll say again what I've said before, I'd love AA to reform in these areas. There is something good in the organization that gets lost in all the religious nutty wording.

I'm starting to feel like a moderate who wandered into a Political discussion, both sides hate me :p

/shamelesstryforpity

Well, I'll give you some of that. ;) I think you're doing just fine in expressing your opinion on the matter, and I respect your opinion. I certainly don't hate you, or hate you for your thoughts.

Dat mo' bettah? :D
 
This is AA's unique theory in what alcoholism is and how to deal with it; this theory was invented in the 1930's and in the intervening 80 years, a huge amount of information about the brain, addiction, habituation, drug interactions, and techniques has been discovered, tested and implemented.

Ah, but the Bible hasn't changed !

I believe AA ultimately fails because conceptually, AA views alcoholism as a spiritual ailment which requires a spiritual solution. It simply isn't.

Yes, that is the failure of AA, whether or not someone sees them as religious.
 
Wow. Please re-read what I said and then ask for more clarification if necessary.

OK I'll try. You quoted whatthebutlersaw:

Unless your local meetings accept only centaurs, I'm fairly certain "the group" is human in nature. You know, human, as in "could probably not help us". Its ability to affect your actions is no stronger than your susceptability to peer pressure. If all you need to get sober is to be susceptible to peer pressure, you would have quit because your spouse, kids, mother, father, co-workers, boss, siblings or friends wanted you to. To imbue "the group" with higher power than all those people who presumably meant something to you - how is that not supernatural, nay - religious - in its nature? Unless supernatural stuff is in play, the group is human.

And said this about her quote:

Very well said, and something which I had never thought of before.

I suppose the oft-said response to that would be something along the lines of, "only another addict can *truly* understand me!"

Now, I do understand there can be some value in that sentiment, but it's really more of a barrier to treatment and health than anything else. I don't need my therapist to have been suffering from depression or megalomania to understand mental illness; I don't really care if my doctor suffers from extreme nerve damage or shingles to be able to successfully treat whatever I have come down with.

And what I was trying to get at is that there is value in talking to other alcoholics, both those who are currently struggling and those who have been sober for decades. I, personally, don't see it as a "barrier to treatment" and was curious why you'd say that. It seems to me that there is always value in talking to someone who has knowledge and experience in an area that I am lacking. That person does not have to be a professional - although I think that therapists and the like help as well. You don't have to boil it down to "only another addict can *truly* understand me!" or peer pressure. Just outside help. Outside help* can be, uh, helpful to some of us. :p Your post seemed like it was too dismissive too me, which is why I asked for clarification. Probably did not phrase it as well as I could have.

*To be absolutely clear, I am talking about humans when I say things like "outside help." Not religion or gods, but that's just me, YMMV, and again I wish AA was more like that.
 
OK I'll try.

And what I was trying to get at is that there is value in talking to other alcoholics, both those who are currently struggling and those who have been sober for decades. I, personally, don't see it as a "barrier to treatment" and was curious why you'd say that. It seems to me that there is always value in talking to someone who has knowledge and experience in an area that I am lacking. That person does not have to be a professional - although I think that therapists and the like help as well. You don't have to boil it down to "only another addict can *truly* understand me!" or peer pressure. Just outside help. Outside help* can be, uh, helpful to some of us. :p Your post seemed like it was too dismissive too me, which is why I asked for clarification. Probably did not phrase it as well as I could have.

*To be absolutely clear, I am talking about humans when I say things like "outside help." Not religion or gods, but that's just me, YMMV, and again I wish AA was more like that.


Thank you, I appreciate your thoughtful reply.

My somewhat snarky reply to whatthebutlersaw is something I've heard a great deal in and around sobriety and most especially AA. I did say, however, that I am able to see some value in wanting to talk to, get support from, emulate a person who suffers from (in this instance) alcoholism.

My personal experience from a multitude of angles is that the concept of "you don't really understand unless you've been there" is used more for excuses for not listening to good, solid advice from (again in this case) non-alcoholics or saying that non-alcoholics can have no constructive or thoughtful criticism or input into AA, either in whole or in part.

IOW, I have seen it used more for dismissing the "other" rather than ignoring that entirely and focusing on emulating successful behaviors, regardless of the source of those behaviors (if that makes sense). That's what I meant by being a barrier to treatment.
 
Last edited:
So how about you address the points made by people in this thread who have extensive, recent, ongoing experience with AA who argue that AA is inherently religious?

I am pointing out the heterogeneity of experiences across AA members, not trying to minimize one persons experience because my experience is different.

The whole point is that the "AA experience", insofar as it even makes sense to talk about the or an "AA experience" is extremely diverse and that insisting that AA is religious because the "Primary Texts" use the word "God" or that one person related several anecdotes about bad experiences does appear to take into account the multiple possible experiences that people have with AA.

This is AA's unique theory in what alcoholism is and how to deal with it; this theory was invented in the 1930's and in the intervening 80 years, a huge amount of information about the brain, addiction, habituation, drug interactions, and techniques has been discovered, tested and implemented.

And those would be?

To me, it's telling that the AA World Organization has made NO CHANGES WHATSOEVER to update and incorporate these more effective treatments.

Do you have any evidence that these treatments result in a statistically significantly increased recovery rate?

I believe AA ultimately fails because conceptually, AA views alcoholism as a spiritual ailment which requires a spiritual solution. It simply isn't.

That is problematic, not in least because "spiritual" is a poorly defined term.
 
Thank you, I appreciate your thoughtful reply.

My somewhat snarky reply to whatthebutlersaw is something I've heard a great deal in and around sobriety and most especially AA. I did say, however, that I am able to see some value in wanting to talk to, get support from, emulate a person who suffers from (in this instance) alcoholism.

My personal experience from a multitude of angles is that the concept of "you don't really understand unless you've been there" is used more for excuses for not listening to good, solid advice from (again in this case) non-alcoholics or saying that non-alcoholics can have no constructive or thoughtful criticism or input into AA, either in whole or in part.

IOW, I have seen it used more for dismissing the "other" rather than ignoring that entirely and focusing on emulating successful behaviors, regardless of the source of those behaviors (if that makes sense). That's what I meant by being a barrier to treatment.

Ah, that makes sense.

FWIW, the meetings I went to were not like that at all. There was always someone there to say "we don't play dr. here" whenever someone would try to preach against therapy, medication, and outside avenues to sobriety in general.

I had many members tell me when I was new something along the lines of (paraphrase coming) "Do whatever you have to do to get sober - AA or not - but get sober." That's been my motto even after I stopped going to meetings. I'm not big on offering advice, but that is what I say when asked - try AA, try therapy, try rehab, try the latest cure you found on the internet if you want just try and don't quit.

Sheesh, that last part reads like something from a movie :o
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom