Gandalfs Beard
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2009
- Messages
- 1,548
Plants are supernatural? Bacteria? Uni-cellular eukaryotes? All non-living matter?
I do understand that it is a bit of a stretch to call the emergent properties of human communities "not human", but what you, and other posters who assert than AA has to be religious because its "Primary Texts" mention "God", have done is ignore that one of the other threads of the narrative is that of many alcoholics trying to control their alcoholism on their own and failing individually but succeeding when they got together to help one another. Whether they did so by externalizing the power that they found within the group and calling it "God" is largely irrelevant, because the power that they found within the group is what kept them sober and that power is not supernatural nor is it inherently religious.
Except that's not what people are doing when they use the term God. And it's not irrelevant. What is so hard about forming a Godless 12 Step Group?
Then you can just toss the Religious 12 Steps and the Religious Big Book, and rely just on the support system that a group offers.
GB