Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Not without the individual's participation.

I don't see why group power would be considered a "higher" power. It's still just us people, doing what we do, singly or with a group.

If people power isn't enough, then tough luck. There isn't anything else.

Have you never heard of "strong emergence"?
 
Have you never heard of "strong emergence"?

Nope, never. So, I looked it up.

It doesn't seem to involve gods.

ETA: however...

Regarding strong emergence, Mark A. Bedau observes:
"Although strong emergence is logically possible, it is uncomfortably like magic. How does an irreducible but supervenient downward causal power arise, since by definition it cannot be due to the aggregation of the micro-level potentialities? Such causal powers would be quite unlike anything within our scientific ken. This not only indicates how they will discomfort reasonable forms of materialism. Their mysteriousness will only heighten the traditional worry that emergence entails illegitimately getting something from nothing."(Bedau 1997)
 
Last edited:
ETA: however...

Regarding strong emergence, Mark A. Bedau observes:
"Although strong emergence is logically possible, it is uncomfortably like magic. How does an irreducible but supervenient downward causal power arise, since by definition it cannot be due to the aggregation of the micro-level potentialities? Such causal powers would be quite unlike anything within our scientific ken. This not only indicates how they will discomfort reasonable forms of materialism. Their mysteriousness will only heighten the traditional worry that emergence entails illegitimately getting something from nothing."(Bedau 1997)

Is like magic =/= Is magic
 
"Requirements for membership" can be "what we require to let you join our group," or they can be "what we expect you to do once you have joined our group."

For instance, in order to become a member of a particular group, I might be required to fill out an application. That would be a "requirement for membership."

But that says nothing about what the group expects of me after I've been accepted into it.

The group expects nothing. There are no forms, no requirements for initial or ongoing membership.

And if I ask you what the program does require of you, you will tell me it only requires a sincere desire to quit drinking.

But that's disingenuous. Lots of people sitting at home might have a sincere desire to quit drinking. That desire alone doesn't mean they suddenly joined AA while sitting alone in their living rooms.

They could if they want. I know a number of people that for years could not get to an actual meeting. They used literature, did meetings online, rang central offices etc.


"Optional" is the same as "not necessary," isn't it?

When I make oatmeal cookies, and the recipe says "1/2 cup raisins (optional)," it means the raisins are not necessary in order to make the recipe. The flour, on the other hand, is not optional. It is necessary.

If the 12 steps are not necessary, then why is AA called a 12-step program?

This was my point originally. You say the pogram I ask if you mean the 12 steps? The 12 steps might be part of my program, that does not mean they are part of someone elses. "The program" probably related to the stwps, but again, they are not compulsory in any way.

I am not sure how many ways one needs to say this before you understand it.


Then let me ask you: if the 12 steps are not the program, then what is the program?

Whatever you want to take from the meetings can form your program. Like my mate who is nearly 50 years sober without the steps; his program is different to mine. Mine program includes the steps, his doesn't.

Is there anything one must do as a member of AA, or is everything, including sobriety, optional?

No.

What does it mean to "work the program?"

What is the program?

Maybe it would help you if you thought about it this way:

How do you (or I) work your (or my) program?
 
Did I say it did?

sigh.

No, you seemed to bring it up because I said people power is the only power we have of that nature. That if people can't do it, it can't be done.

I don't know why you brought it up, since it doesn't seem to contradict what I said. If you were agreeing with me, then it didn't translate.
 
To assist answering the question Slingblade asked "What does it mean to "work the program?" and
"What is the program? " I rely on my 20+ years AA experience, and attendance at many thousands of meetings in the USA.

The Answer? The AA program is the 12 steps, or (for a smaller yet significant percentage of active members) the ABC's.

AAAlfie surely remembers the ABC's?

A. Admitted we were alcoholic
B. Admitted probably no human power could relieve us of our alcoholism
C. Admitted God could and would if He were sought.

Sounds faintly religious - xian even - to me . But what do I know?

:)

Acvtually I have never heard of the ABCs, perhaps Tinyal could show me where these came from? They seem a inaccurate excerpt of some of the steps. Perhaps Tinyal could also show me where it says these are compulsory or similar. I doubt he can (in fact I know he can't).

And while your at it...

Did you do the steps and accept God Tinyal?
If not, how did you do your program?
 
Last edited:
sigh.

No, you seemed to bring it up because I said people power is the only power we have of that nature. That if people can't do it, it can't be done.

I don't know why you brought it up, since it doesn't seem to contradict what I said. If you were agreeing with me, then it didn't translate.

Strong emergence refers to properties of ensemble that cannot be decomposed into the properties of the constituents. All I am saying is that there can be naturalistic explanations for why groups of people can achieve results that individuals cannot; therefore, reference to a power greater than oneself does not have to be that of a supernatural being, which is generally what a god is.
 
What makes believing in a power greater than oneself inherently religious?

Can groups achieve what individuals cannot?

If one wants it to, sure.
While I think the question was rhetorical, it was worth answering.

If people power isn't enough, then tough luck. There isn't anything else.

For you this might be true, but not necessarily for everyone else. Your systems, values etc are not everyone's.
 
The group expects nothing. There are no forms, no requirements for initial or ongoing membership.

So one can get sober by going to a meeting, drinking the coffee, and going home?



They could if they want. I know a number of people that for years could not get to an actual meeting. They used literature, did meetings online, rang central offices etc.

That isn't what I said. I said it must take more than just a sincere desire. Lots of people have that desire. But without some sort of action, it remains just that: a desire.


This was my point originally. You say the pogram I ask if you mean the 12 steps? The 12 steps might be part of my program, that does not mean they are part of someone elses. "The program" probably related to the stwps, but again, they are not compulsory in any way.

I am not sure how many ways one needs to say this before you understand it.

I understand what you're saying: getting sober requires nothing. Nothing at all. If your AA program involves doing nothing, that's fine. Nothing is required.

I can't figure why there are any alcoholics at all. It sounds so easy to be sober.


Whatever you want to take from the meetings can form your program. Like my mate who is nearly 50 years sober without the steps; his program is different to mine. Mine program includes the steps, his doesn't.

So he doesn't rely on any "higher power," then?


Maybe it would help you if you thought about it this way:

How do you (or I) work your (or my) program?

Nope, that doesn't help. I don't have a program to work, and I've no clue what your program is or how you work it.

The question is whether AA is a religous organization. And this:

Our description of the alcoholic, the chapter to the agnostic, and our personal adventures before and after make clear three pertinent three
That we were alcoholic and could not manage our own lives
That probably no human power could relieve us of our alcoholism
That God could and would if He were sought.

clearly makes it religious.

Because there is no god, and human power--of whatever magnitude or emergence--is still human power, and all that is available to us as humans.
 
If one wants it to, sure.
While I think the question was rhetorical, it was worth answering.

You are quite right that the last question was rhetorical, but, as with all rhetorical questions, the question was meant to illustrate a point. In particular, it was meant to illustrate that the interactions within groups of people (that, of course, do not exist when people are not isolated) can in fact lead individuals within the groups to achieve what they could not do own their own.

While the above achievement is not necessarily an example of strong emergence, it is an example of an at least weakly emergent property of group that come together with a common cause.

On a side note, there is some interesting research on how strong emergence can be conceptualized as arising from global constraints on an ensemble of systems.
 
slingblade-

"God" refers to the power greater than oneself.

If that power is not supernatural, is AA still religious?
 
So one can get sober by going to a meeting, drinking the coffee, and going home?

Some might. I couldn't - I needed to do a bit more than that.

That isn't what I said. I said it must take more than just a sincere desire. Lots of people have that desire. But without some sort of action, it remains just that: a desire.

Are you talking about membership now, or sobriety? :rolleyes:

Remember? "The only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking".
There are no "requirements" for sobriety.
There are some suggestions and the examples of those that preceeded us. Nothing however is compulsory.

What don't you understand about this?

I understand what you're saying: getting sober requires nothing. Nothing at all. If your AA program involves doing nothing, that's fine. Nothing is required.

Is that what I said?
Nope! I just checked, I never said that at all.

I can't figure why there are any alcoholics at all. It sounds so easy to be sober.

It does sound easy doesn't it.

Go to meetings and don't pick up a drink one day at a time, under any circumstances.

That might be someones program - I emphasise the "might".

So he doesn't rely on any "higher power," then?

Yes he does, but it is not God.

Nope, that doesn't help. I don't have a program to work, and I've no clue what your program is or how you work it.

Correct: You have no clue. :)
 
Last edited:
What makes believing in a power greater than oneself inherently religious?

Can groups achieve what individuals cannot?

Only the fact that the 12 Steps and the Big Book EXPLICITLY state that the Higher Power is God. :rolleyes:

I reposted a couple of posts somewhere in the last couple of pages. You might just want to check them out before jumping to conclusions.

GB
 
Only the fact that the 12 Steps and the Big Book EXPLICITLY state that the Higher Power is God. :rolleyes:

I reposted a couple of posts somewhere in the last couple of pages. You might just want to check them out before jumping to conclusions.

GB

*yawn*

We've been over this many times before: one does not have to believe what the Big Book says about a Higher Power in order to get sober through AA. The Big Book (at least the portions you quoted) is an account of what Bill W and Dr Bob believed, not what one has to believe to achieve sobriety in AA.
 
*yawn*

We've been over this many times before: one does not have to believe what the Big Book says about a Higher Power in order to get sober through AA. The Big Book (at least the portions you quoted) is an account of what Bill W and Dr Bob believed, not what one has to believe to achieve sobriety in AA.


Yawn indeed. Throw out the Big Big and the 12 Steps then what's left?

Sorry, but you're just blowing smoke like so many before you.


GB
 
*yawn*

We've been over this many times before: one does not have to believe what the Big Book says about a Higher Power in order to get sober through AA. The Big Book (at least the portions you quoted) is an account of what Bill W and Dr Bob believed, not what one has to believe to achieve sobriety in AA.

Correct.
There are people with far greater experience in staying sober and helping others achieve sobriety that Bill and Dr Bob. I tend to listen far more to their practical and first hand advice than I do to what is written in the big book. Bill and Bob gave their insights and experience, I give mine. No opinion or experience is more or less correct that of another: we all do what we do to get and stay sober; that is our experience strength and hope.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom