You asked
"Membership requirements" for the program would be somewhat different from the program itself, wouldn't they?
I responded:
The "suggested" 12 steps you mean? (as in the 12 steps being "the program")
You said:
No. I said what I meant.
I remain confused.
"Requirements for membership" can be "what we require to let you join our group," or they can be "what we expect you to do once you have joined our group."
For instance, in order to become a member of a particular group, I might be required to fill out an application. That would be a "requirement for membership."
But that says nothing about what the group expects of me
after I've been accepted into it.
They are optional. I would not go so far as to say superfluous, others might. A HP is optional too, not superfluous. A sponsor? Again optional, not superfluous. And on it goes.
And if I ask you what the program does require of you, you will tell me it only requires a sincere desire to quit drinking.
But that's disingenuous. Lots of people sitting at home might have a sincere desire to quit drinking. That desire alone doesn't mean they suddenly joined AA while sitting alone in their living rooms.
So we might say they are "superfluous" as far as he goes, but not others. I repeat, optional.
"Optional" is the same as "not necessary," isn't it?
When I make oatmeal cookies, and the recipe says "1/2 cup raisins (optional)," it means the raisins are not necessary in order to make the recipe. The flour, on the other hand, is not optional. It is necessary.
If the 12 steps are not necessary, then why is AA called a 12-step program?
I am going to give you the benefit of the doubt and say we are at cross purposes here. I asked you whether the (suggested) 12 steps were the program and asked you if that is what you meant? Like I said, confused as to what you mean.
Then let me ask you: if the 12 steps are not the program, then what is the program?
Is there anything one must do as a member of AA, or is everything, including sobriety, optional?
What does it mean to "work the program?"
What is the program?