Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I really question the idea that six drinks a day could constitute alcoholism.

My observation would be that it is very PC in certain groups to assign the alcoholism label to moderate amounts. AFAIK, cessation of this level of consumption would not produce the well known withdrawal symptoms.

It isn't what you drink, or the amount in which you drink it, or how often you drink.

The basic criteria for determining alcoholism are: does your drinking cause problems in your life, and are you unable and/or unwilling to stop drinking, in spite of those problems?
 
I doubt it would produce withdrawal symptoms either. That said, I client of mine did have some moderate withdrawal symptoms after cessation from her daily glass of sherry. She had been drinking a glass for some 30 years. So who knows?

It is also true that not everyone in AA is an alcoholic, but I am also curious to ask how we determine what is an alcoholic. Generally, binge drinkers do not suffer the same withdrawal as a daily-top-up- drinker. Are they alcoholics or not? Where is this line drawn? It seems daily dependance is not an accurate measure.
The definition does seem to vary wildly. We all agree that someone who drinks a bottle a day is an alcoholic, I also know people(who have never touched a drop) who think that my own consumption of around 3 drinks makes me one.

I have my own ideas as to who would qualify: someone who drinks every day, generally not just at night, and to excess. I would say that the real trouble starts around 12 drinks per day. A person who couldn't suddenly not drink anything for a week without repercussions.

Subjective, of course. Where would you draw the line?
 
The definition does seem to vary wildly. We all agree that someone who drinks a bottle a day is an alcoholic, I also know people(who have never touched a drop) who think that my own consumption of around 3 drinks makes me one.

I have my own ideas as to who would qualify: someone who drinks every day, generally not just at night, and to excess. I would say that the real trouble starts around 12 drinks per day. A person who couldn't suddenly not drink anything for a week without repercussions.

Subjective, of course. Where would you draw the line?

I sometimes use the red shirt metaphor; not foolproof but a guide.

The red shirt is alcohol.

Ask a someone who is not an alcoholic to "not wear a red shirt for six months". Their answer will be "sure, no problem".

Ask an alcoholic to "not wear a red shirt for six months" and watch them squirm, bargain, make concessions, excuses etc. It gives some insight I think.

No offense but I rarely think that the amount one drinks is an accurate guide. That said, if someone is drinking a bottle of scoth a day, they might have a problem with dependance. But again, not every alcoholic has a daily dependance.
Which is why pharmacotherapy (eg naltrexone) wont always work that well and CBT might have better results.
 
Last edited:
Then I am not sure what you mean when you say "the program".

You aren't? Really? That's odd. Did you not say:

The "suggested" 12 steps you mean?
The steps are not "superfluous" as you say, they are merely another option within the program.
?

Thus, it appears you know exactly what I mean when I say "the program," having used the phrase, yourself, as above.


I didn't say they were "superfluous" either, I said they were suggested. :)

Apologies. I assumed you knew the definition of "superfluous," or if not, might look it up.

Definition of SUPERFLUOUS

1a : exceeding what is sufficient or necessary : extra
b : not needed : unnecessary


If the 12 steps are "suggested," and not required within the program, then they exceed what is sufficient. They are superfluous.

After all, you know someone who's been in the program for almost 5 decades, and he's never used them.

Funny, though, that AA's usually referred to as a "12-step program."
I'd have thought my meaning would be quite clear. You seem to me to be obfuscating just a bit.



I meant the general "you" as in anybody; not you specifically.

I don't drink alcohol either. :cool:

It would have been nice if you'd answered my original question about asking God to remove your shortcomings.
 
I sometimes use the red shirt metaphor; not foolproof but a guide.

The red shirt is alcohol.

Ask a someone who is not an alcoholic to "not wear a red shirt for six months". Their answer will be "sure, no problem".

Ask an alcoholic to "not wear a red shirt for six months" and watch them squirm, bargain, make concessions, excuses etc. It gives some insight I think.

In which case I am

- a sex addict
- a ukulele addict
- a Jaguar addict
- a Thai food, Indian food, Italian food, pie and sausage addict
- a running addict
- a cycling addict

There are many, many things I enjoy doing that I would not be prepared to give up for a period of 6 months to satisfy your whim.


That being said, I probably do have some kind of dependency on alcohol. I only have a few drinks a week but there's no way I'd commit to not drinking for an entire 6 month period.
 
It isn't what you drink, or the amount in which you drink it, or how often you drink.

The basic criteria for determining alcoholism are: does your drinking cause problems in your life, and are you unable and/or unwilling to stop drinking, in spite of those problems?
I knew a guy once who drank a bottle of Jack a day. It didn't cause him problems, although I'm sure it killed him eventually. He built fences, working all day while drinking from his daily bottle. No wife or kids to object, and he hardly ever missed work. Still an alcoholic in my opinion, though.
 
I knew a guy once who drank a bottle of Jack a day. It didn't cause him problems, although I'm sure it killed him eventually. He built fences, working all day while drinking from his daily bottle. No wife or kids to object, and he hardly ever missed work. Still an alcoholic in my opinion, though.

If it did, as you surmise, kill him, wouldn't you say that's a "problem?"

Do you know if the reason he had no wife or kids was because he drank a bottle of jack a day?

Did you know him well enough to know everything about his life, and so from that can surmise that alcohol "didn't cause him problems?"

My ex hardly ever missed a day of work while he was drinking, either.
That didn't mean he wasn't alcoholic.

I'm rather thinking his drinking caused him more problems than you might think, or of which you were aware.
 
Does the use of the substance create substantial negative impacts on the individual's functioning?

Amount is no usable criteria

But isn't it the inability of someone to STOP using something without withdrawal symptoms the defining factor as to whether someone is physically addicted?

Emotional dependence is something quite different from addiction. And I think it is the emotionally dependent who respond best to Behaviour Modification therapies. :)


GB
 
You aren't? Really? That's odd. Did you not say:

Thus, it appears you know exactly what I mean when I say "the program," having used the phrase, yourself, as above.

You asked
"Membership requirements" for the program would be somewhat different from the program itself, wouldn't they?

I responded:
The "suggested" 12 steps you mean? (as in the 12 steps being "the program")

You said:
No. I said what I meant.

I remain confused.


Definition of SUPERFLUOUS

1a : exceeding what is sufficient or necessary : extra
b : not needed : unnecessary


If the 12 steps are "suggested," and not required within the program, then they exceed what is sufficient. They are superfluous.

They are optional. I would not go so far as to say superfluous, others might. A HP is optional too, not superfluous. A sponsor? Again optional, not superfluous. And on it goes.

[After all, you know someone who's been in the program for almost 5 decades, and he's never used them.

So we might say they are "superfluous" as far as he goes, but not others. I repeat, optional.

Funny, though, that AA's usually referred to as a "12-step program."
I'd have thought my meaning would be quite clear. You seem to me to be obfuscating just a bit.

I am going to give you the benefit of the doubt and say we are at cross purposes here. I asked you whether the (suggested) 12 steps were the program and asked you if that is what you meant? Like I said, confused as gto what you mean.

It would have been nice if you'd answered my original question about asking God to remove your shortcomings.

I believe I did.
 
Last edited:
Just wanted to throw this out there for public consumption:

If you toss out the 12 "suggested" religious 12 steps, and if you toss out the "suggested" religious Big Book, then what is left that qualifies as a "programme?"

Just asking. :)


GB
 
If it did, as you surmise, kill him, wouldn't you say that's a "problem?"

Do you know if the reason he had no wife or kids was because he drank a bottle of jack a day?

Did you know him well enough to know everything about his life, and so from that can surmise that alcohol "didn't cause him problems?"

My ex hardly ever missed a day of work while he was drinking, either.
That didn't mean he wasn't alcoholic.

I'm rather thinking his drinking caused him more problems than you might think, or of which you were aware.
I would think that death would be a problem, yes. I don't know what happened to him, I just assume that his health was impacted eventually.

I suppose you could look at being single as a problem, I rather enjoy it myself and I'm not an alcoholic.

My contention is that the man was an alcoholic based on the amount of his consumption alone, regardless of whether he had any problems. The question of whether he was unwilling to quit didn't come into it, since no one asked him to. It is unknown if he was unable to quit, since he never tried. He was an alcoholic anyway, IMO.
 
You asked
"Membership requirements" for the program would be somewhat different from the program itself, wouldn't they?

I responded:
The "suggested" 12 steps you mean? (as in the 12 steps being "the program")

You said:
No. I said what I meant.

I remain confused.

"Requirements for membership" can be "what we require to let you join our group," or they can be "what we expect you to do once you have joined our group."

For instance, in order to become a member of a particular group, I might be required to fill out an application. That would be a "requirement for membership."

But that says nothing about what the group expects of me after I've been accepted into it.



They are optional. I would not go so far as to say superfluous, others might. A HP is optional too, not superfluous. A sponsor? Again optional, not superfluous. And on it goes.

And if I ask you what the program does require of you, you will tell me it only requires a sincere desire to quit drinking.

But that's disingenuous. Lots of people sitting at home might have a sincere desire to quit drinking. That desire alone doesn't mean they suddenly joined AA while sitting alone in their living rooms.



So we might say they are "superfluous" as far as he goes, but not others. I repeat, optional.

"Optional" is the same as "not necessary," isn't it?

When I make oatmeal cookies, and the recipe says "1/2 cup raisins (optional)," it means the raisins are not necessary in order to make the recipe. The flour, on the other hand, is not optional. It is necessary.

If the 12 steps are not necessary, then why is AA called a 12-step program?



I am going to give you the benefit of the doubt and say we are at cross purposes here. I asked you whether the (suggested) 12 steps were the program and asked you if that is what you meant? Like I said, confused as to what you mean.

Then let me ask you: if the 12 steps are not the program, then what is the program?

Is there anything one must do as a member of AA, or is everything, including sobriety, optional?

What does it mean to "work the program?"

What is the program?
 
To assist answering the question Slingblade asked "What does it mean to "work the program?" and
"What is the program? " I rely on my 20+ years AA experience, and attendance at many thousands of meetings in the USA.

The Answer? The AA program is the 12 steps, or (for a smaller yet significant percentage of active members) the ABC's.

AAAlfie surely remembers the ABC's?

A. Admitted we were alcoholic
B. Admitted no human power could relieve us of our alcoholism
C. Admitted God could and would if He were sought.

Sounds faintly religious - xian even - to me . But what do I know?

:)
 
Just wanted to throw this out there for public consumption:

If you toss out the 12 "suggested" religious 12 steps, and if you toss out the "suggested" religious Big Book, then what is left that qualifies as a "programme?"

Just asking. :)


GB

We've been asking that since the beginning of the thread and never gotten an answer. Think you'll get one this time.
 
What makes believing in a power greater than oneself inherently religious?

Can groups achieve what individuals cannot?
 
To assist answering the question Slingblade asked "What does it mean to "work the program?" and
"What is the program? " I rely on my 20+ years AA experience, and attendance at many thousands of meetings in the USA.

The Answer? The AA program is the 12 steps, or (for a smaller yet significant percentage of active members) the ABC's.

AAAlfie surely remembers the ABC's?

A. Admitted we were alcoholic
B. Admitted no human power could relieve us of our alcoholism
C. Admitted God could and would if He were sought.

Sounds faintly religious - xian even - to me . But what do I know?

:)

Tinayal, thank you. Those are all the things I remember from my years of involvement with AA, as well.

Thus, I simply wasn't getting all this "suggested' and "optional" stuff. As far as I knew, if you worked the program, you did the steps.

Also as far as I know, human power is the only sort of "power" (of that nature) that we have. There isn't anything more than us, it's just us, and our power is all we have. If we can't do it, either on our own, or along with the help of other humans, it can't be done. I don't consider that a higher power. Just human power, which is prodigious in itself, and not to be sneered at, disregarded, or dismissed as inadequate.

To suggest anything else is to suggest sheer woo.
 
Last edited:
What makes believing in a power greater than oneself inherently religious?

Can groups achieve what individuals cannot?

Not without the individual's participation.

I don't see why group power would be considered a "higher" power. It's still just us people, doing what we do, singly or with a group.

If people power isn't enough, then tough luck. There isn't anything else.
 
AAAlfie surely remembers the ABC's?

A. Admitted we were alcoholic
B. Admitted no human power could relieve us of our alcoholism
C. Admitted God could and would if He were sought.

If you are going to try to paraphrase AA literature to demonstrate that AA is at all religious, you should do so with some eye toward accurately portraying what is said:

Our description of the alcoholic, the chapter to the agnostic, and our personal adventures before and after make clear ideas pertinent three

  • That we were alcoholic and could not manage our own lives
  • That probably no human power could relieve us of our alcoholism
  • That God could and would if He were sought.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom