Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Are you seriously not rembering what you said?



You said that something that was not human or was not animal was supernatural.

I know. I simply didn't think I'd need to mention plants and bacteria to be clear, or to make my point about the supernatural. It didn't occur to me that I'd have to exclude flora, too.



Yeah, first there is no "the program". Each person's program is individual to that person. Some people work the steps; some don't. Some understand "God" as a supernatural power; others don't. What seem to be going on here is that there is a fanatical focus on the word "God" and a complete inability to consider the following phrase: "as we understood (understand) Him".

To me, "God" (and I mean the word "God") is just a shorthand for "Higher Power" or "Power greater than oneself". There is nothing inherently supernatural about the latter two. In fact, there are numerous examples of atheists benefitting from AA and continuing not to believe in supernatural entities. If AA were inherently religious, how would this be possible?

I guess I can't explain what I mean in a clear manner. I have tried to. My apologies for failing at it.
 
I know. I simply didn't think I'd need to mention plants and bacteria to be clear, or to make my point about the supernatural. It didn't occur to me that I'd have to exclude flora, too.

Ooh, you got caught out there! Since bacteria was not part of your sentence, they are therefore supernatural to their nature and therefore your entire argument fails.

Lucky your opponent isn't obsessed with words, or anything, otherwise he/she might fail to get the gist of what you are saying.
 
There's a whole lot of this on both sides of this argument. Do you see both side's shortcomings or only one? Just curious.



Evidence?

I do not know of a program that has better than "appaling recovery rates." Do you, or are you just ranting here? There are no good programs that have proven, studied, published success. If you have a link to one I would like to have it. Not arguing here, I would like to have it and pass it on to others.

Also, there ARE studies that show AA is successful, which everyone in this thread seems to like to ignore. There are also studies showing it is not effective. I would like to see that argument broken off into its own thread to be honest, and see evidence from both sides instead of innuendo and ad hom attacks.

The only point to be addressed here is really not if it works, success or failure rates, how people choose to use AA, or any of that.

The point is whether or not AA is religious in nature. It is my opinion that it is. The Big Book and 12 Steps specifically mention upper-case God throughout. That makes AA a program with a religious bent, influence, overtone, etc.
 
The only point to be addressed here is really not if it works, success or failure rates, how people choose to use AA, or any of that.

The point is whether or not AA is religious in nature. It is my opinion that it is. The Big Book and 12 Steps specifically mention upper-case God throughout. That makes AA a program with a religious bent, influence, overtone, etc.

Sure, that's why I said another thread would be nice.

The actual original point of the OP was "Why do people insist AA is not religious?"

If you can get every one else back on topic, I'm all for it. Good luck. :D
 
The only point to be addressed here is really not if it works, success or failure rates, how people choose to use AA, or any of that.

The point is whether or not AA is religious in nature. It is my opinion that it is. The Big Book and 12 Steps specifically mention upper-case God throughout. That makes AA a program with a religious bent, influence, overtone, etc.

By the way, I quite like the way you worded your last sentence in this post and agree with it.

It has a religious bent, influence, overtone. I would say it is not a religion or a cult or worthless to athiests/agnostics, but that is only my personal anecdote of course.
 
By the way, I quite like the way you worded your last sentence in this post and agree with it.

It has a religious bent, influence, overtone. I would say it is not a religion or a cult or worthless to athiests/agnostics, but that is only my personal anecdote of course.

Thank you! I was trying to be as clear as possible, and not put more meaning on the word "religious" than I think it would bear in this matter.
 
But isn't it the inability of someone to STOP using something without withdrawal symptoms the defining factor as to whether someone is physically addicted?

Emotional dependence is something quite different from addiction. And I think it is the emotionally dependent who respond best to Behaviour Modification therapies. :)


GB

Not going to go there in this thread, the defintion of dependence does not require physical withdrawal syndroms.

There is no 'emotional dependance', there is either subsatance dependence or not.

:)

The defintions do not require physical withdrawal syndromes. (IE you can meet other criteria)
 
Last edited:
AA is very clearly a religious program. Even if the people within the program choose not to express or utilize religion, the program itself is of a religious bent and nature.

I would just add that while many are 'Big Book' bangers and insist on the doctrinaire approach, it does really vary a lot amongst groups and the individuals. I really found the DFD groups to be the least 'spiritual'.

I have seen groups that I attended change radically based upon the precense of a single person.

Overall however, the majority of groups and members seem to have a religious orientation.
 
Last edited:
Unless your local meetings accept only centaurs, I'm fairly certain "the group" is human in nature. You know, human, as in "could probably not help us". Its ability to affect your actions is no stronger than your susceptability to peer pressure. If all you need to get sober is to be susceptible to peer pressure, you would have quit because your spouse, kids, mother, father, co-workers, boss, siblings or friends wanted you to. To imbue "the group" with higher power than all those people who presumably meant something to you - how is that not supernatural, nay - religious - in its nature? Unless supernatural stuff is in play, the group is human.

Very well said, and something which I had never thought of before.

I suppose the oft-said response to that would be something along the lines of, "only another addict can *truly* understand me!"

Now, I do understand there can be some value in that sentiment, but it's really more of a barrier to treatment and health than anything else. I don't need my therapist to have been suffering from depression or megalomania to understand mental illness; I don't really care if my doctor suffers from extreme nerve damage or shingles to be able to successfully treat whatever I have come down with.
 
It has a religious bent, influence, overtone. I would say it is not a religion or a cult or worthless to athiests/agnostics, but that is only my personal anecdote of course.

Also by the way, I meant to tell you that I agree with how you expressed that. It's not a religion, and I don't think it's specifically a cult--though some members, some groups, could make it cultish--and it's not worthless to atheists or agnostics. Many of them get something good from it, and more power to them if they do. But yes, the religious tone is definitely there.

Thank you for that. It was well worth reading. :)
 
Very well said, and something which I had never thought of before.

I suppose the oft-said response to that would be something along the lines of, "only another addict can *truly* understand me!"

Now, I do understand there can be some value in that sentiment, but it's really more of a barrier to treatment and health than anything else. I don't need my therapist to have been suffering from depression or megalomania to understand mental illness; I don't really care if my doctor suffers from extreme nerve damage or shingles to be able to successfully treat whatever I have come down with.

Really? So talking to people who are experienced and are successful (in anything) is a waste of time 100%, always? I'm not trying to strawman you, I am asking for clarification. When is it a good idea to look to a successful group of people in any endeavor, and when is it not. What is the rule of thumb. Are we to never, ever take advice and strength from others? I'm not John Galt, I'm an alcoholic.

I know that this will lead back to the "does it work or not" derail, and I apologize for that.
 
I know. I simply didn't think I'd need to mention plants and bacteria to be clear, or to make my point about the supernatural. It didn't occur to me that I'd have to exclude flora, too.

But what you literally said was:

If it's not human, and it's surely not animal, then it's supernatural.

Quoting the material you quoted:

"That probably no human power could relieve us of our alcoholism."

I'm just holding you to the standard that you hold the Big Book to. If you are going hold to a literal interpretation of the Big Book, which, by the way you really are not as you have not addressed the words "as we understand Him", why should your word not be taken as literally?

Even strong emergence is human power. A high form of it, perhaps, but still human. "No human power" means supernatural. Twist it nine ways from Monday, it's still not human, and therefore is supernatural.

Uh...strong emergence is a property of ensemble (human and non-human) that cannot be decomposed into the properties of the the constituent systems. It is not necessarily human.

Also "not human" =/= "supernatural".

I guess I can't explain what I mean in a clear manner. I have tried to. My apologies for failing at it.

No, you've done an excellent job of explaining your position, but you have not explained how your position relates to the positions of those with whom you disagree.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
No, Mijo, I must disagree. I didn't have to include flora and fauna as agents which have the power to remove your shortcomings. I didn't need to include them in my definition of what is and isn't supernatural. Because they are nature, they are natural. Do you see the difference?

SUPERnatural is that which is beyond the natural. Life on earth in all its forms is natural, not supernatural. I thought that would be easily grasped without my having to spell it out.

God as you understand him is just...gah, the word I want is eluding me, sorry. It's just lipstick on a pig, essentially. But that still isn't the sense I want to convey. Hopefully, it's at least somewhat clear. Even if your concept of god is different, even if it is, as some have asserted, "whatever you want it to be," it's still god. So, it's still religious in essence.
 
You know, I was just looking for a good illustration of the meaning of "irony". Lo and behold: "Someone whose entire argument consists of sophistry and redefining words exclaiming that their opponent is too obsessed with words to get the gist of what is being said." (Of course, if you stay vague enough, you can say that about anything. You sir, for example, would do well to be less fleurvescent and try to engage more in docatinistry. It would really help your argument if you did. And if you want me to define those words, I will simply claim that you are too obsessed with words to get what I'm saying.)

So, by that, do you mean: "Someone called us on our bullcrap and I am solving that by throwing more of it on"?

<snip sophistic babble>

Look the issue is that my local AA community has emphasized the individual nature of the "Power greater than oneself"; it can literally be anything you want. For instance, it can be social support structure that simply does not exist in any person individually. This is most definitely not

  1. Supernatural-it exists completely within the confines of a group of individuals and does not transcend the group in such a way that it is ontologically real independent of the group
  2. A property of individuals independent of the group-it, by definition, does not exist within the individual in isolation

How is this an inherently religious idea?
 
By the way, I quite like the way you worded your last sentence in this post and agree with it.

It has a religious bent, influence, overtone. I would say it is not a religion or a cult or worthless to athiests/agnostics, but that is only my personal anecdote of course.

It was said months ago, in fact. Just lost in the noise.
 
No, Mijo, I must disagree. I didn't have to include flora and fauna as agents which have the power to remove your shortcomings. I didn't need to include them in my definition of what is and isn't supernatural. Because they are nature, they are natural. Do you see the difference?

Yes, I understand the difference, but, again, that is not literally what you said.

SUPERnatural is that which is beyond the natural. Life on earth in all its forms is natural, not supernatural. I thought that would be easily grasped without my having to spell it out.

The Steps do not spell out what is meant by "God". It is clear from the context, though, that Bill W did understand "God" to be a supernatural. However, there is no point in the Steps or in any of the literature that I have read that requires one to understand God as Bill W or anyone one else in AA understands God.

Why do you insist that "God" must be understood in the way that the Big Book implies that God should be understood?

God as you understand him is just...gah, the word I want is eluding me, sorry. It's just lipstick on a pig, essentially. But that still isn't the sense I want to convey. Hopefully, it's at least somewhat clear. Even if your concept of god is different, even if it is, as some have asserted, "whatever you want it to be," it's still god. So, it's still religious in essence.

Assertion, assertion, assertions.

If you choose a "Power greater that oneself" that is completely natural (as the emergent properties of groups are), how is your program inherently religious?
 
I'm not trying to strawman you

And yet you did. Funny how that works.

The point is, there is no need for a therapist to have lived through the problem, and although people who have may provide valuable insights, they may have no idea how to get others out of alcoholism. Indeed, if anything, AA's numbers show this quite conclusively.
 
Look the issue is that my local AA community has emphasized the individual nature of the "Power greater than oneself"; it can literally be anything you want. For instance, it can be social support structure that simply does not exist in any person individually. This is most definitely not

  1. Supernatural-it exists completely within the confines of a group of individuals and does not transcend the group in such a way that it is ontologically real independent of the group
  2. A property of individuals independent of the group-it, by definition, does not exist within the individual in isolation

How is this an inherently religious idea?

Because, as has been mentionned more than once, it can't be people. So it can't be anything you want.

We won't get into how rocks can't be higher powers, either.
 
And yet you did. Funny how that works.

The point is, there is no need for a therapist to have lived through the problem, and although people who have may provide valuable insights, they may have no idea how to get others out of alcoholism. Indeed, if anything, AA's numbers show this quite conclusively.

Bah. Seriously I was trying for a clarification. Not a strawman. I was not asking about therapists (strawman much yourself?) but about people who had success in an area I also wanted to have success in.

Also, again about "the numbers":

Evidence?

ETA: I'll take those "valuable insights" you mention and use them, if it is ok with you.
 
Last edited:
Because, as has been mentionned more than once, it can't be people. So it can't be anything you want.

We won't get into how rocks can't be higher powers, either.

No. The higher power thingy can be people, as has been mentioned more than once as well.

If you want to have a point about religion in AA, Slingblade had the best one:

"That probably no human power could relieve us of our alcoholism."

That one is hard to get around, period.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom