Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I know several towns where everything is AA and the government pays for AA and they have forced people into AA with no alternative in places? That's worse than a choke hold... It's about 80-90% 12-step in centers around the world. That's going to be changing.

Great! The more therapies we have on offer the better.

Now, I would be very interested to see the evidence that "the government pays for AA".

The practitioners of science/evidence-based medicine and evolutionary medicine who are taking over modern medicine. It will be the opposite of some dudes making stuff up.

Um.. ok ..
You make it sound like a violent revolution. :)

I would suggest a comprehensive approach, meaning an organization that applies the best of what we know and can prove while also spearheading the search for knowledge. The recovery movement needn't be fragmented. Every patient should have the opportunity to learn this knowledge and be encouraged to know it, not folk wisdom and memes (cult language - R.Lifton) Take just one example, the remarkable success of naltrexone and tailored talk therapy plus the 2008 result from NIH that taught us it works better on people with a certain gene variant. Screen everyone for that variant and for suitability for that intervention. Everyone. This will be inexpensive soon. Put everyone through standardized care just like any medical condition in a hospital. There are more examples obviously but I only need one good one to show something is drastically wrong and opportunities are being wasted. AA is notoriously anti-naltrexone. As long as they keep brainwashing people with their made up stupidity people with that gene variant aren't going to get the opportunity to have 20 sessions some pills and get their life back, they are going to spend the rest of their life going to meetings. The horror of this to me is just unspeakable. I cannot allow people to brainwash vulnerable victims of mental illness into a lifelong commitment to a faith healing cult when there are greener pastures mere clicks away on the internet.

OK. But what is available right now? Free? Readily available? Some of my clients take naltrexone, some do well on it some poorly. Naltrexone (like AA or anything else) will not suit everyone.

If you promote AA it is. I said it was controlled, you didn't read the study, they controlled against no treatment, yadda yadda, join the revolution while it's young Alfie. Just read the study Alfie. I know it's disturbing to you but they controlled against no treatment.

And this proves what? That is doesn't work or ot does? If someone thinks it works, they are happy and it improves their lives, I reckon that is just fine.

If you're defending AA as an organization which I think the world would be much better off if it ceased to exist,

That's nice. But I would (and do) disagree. So would millions of others; frankly, I think you are outvoted.

What? You honestly need data on the fact that there are many approaches and private companies that do alcoholism therapy? Or on the fact that 12-step dominates rehab centers?

I would like information on everything you claim. What evidence have you around all these opinions of yours? I am genuinely interested in the practices and results. You seem to have a lot of information to share with us, I am interested as to where it comes from..

I only need one so centers that offer naltrexone and talk therapy and possibly even screenings for that gene variant. Actually anyone can check themselves for that gene varient using various internet services. It's pretty cheap nowaways and rapidly getting chearper.

So have you got the evidence for this or not? I am genuinely interested in the results.

Well it certainly seems to have pissed a lot of people off for no good reason other than to maintain its cult blueprint.

Um, ok. Whatever.
I don't think this actually relates to anything that was said.

Also handed out billions of sentences of bad advice and lies about reality.

Are you saying that AA hands out court sentences?!? Are AA now part of the judiciary? Evidence please.

Also supported anti-psychiatry in a devastating way for a long time and still does in many places.

Evidence please.

Just because there is no other meetings in that small town of 40,000, doesn't win AA any points. There are only Christian churchses in lot of those towns too.

So in terms of economics, they have a solid market. Right?
So for someone to break into it, they would have to have a better product. Right?
What better products are available to them right now?
And why haven't they been successful do you think?

None of the proven science and treatment that you won't learn or receive in AA matters to my main argument,

Whar "proven science" are you talking about?

If we take AA claim by claim though, we can show that a great deal of it is wrong or counter to what we know. We can also show it fails to integrate anything modern because it has never changed. (well in a sense the old-timers are scarier)

What claim? You are really losing me in some places.

What about the delusion that you can never drink again.

Why is it "delusional"?

That's up for some people to decide and is undoubtedly true for some.

Oh! It's not?

But a lot of people get out of AA and just drink normally after. And thank their lucky stars they got out of a cult. Some people scared the bejesus out of them that they would die, end up in jail or worse.

Some do, I see them weekly in hospitals, ABI centres, prisons, rehabs etc etc.

You don't get it, we need to first get rid of all the ways AA is objectivly harmful,

There's that word again. How and why is it "harmful"?
 
Last edited:
Now, I would be very interested to see the evidence that "the government pays for AA".
The government subsidizes treatment centres where the group therapy is AA/NA and you go to a meeting every single day so, what's that?
Originally Posted by Joey McGee
The practitioners of science/evidence-based medicine and evolutionary medicine who are taking over modern medicine. It will be the opposite of some dudes making stuff up.
Um.. ok ..
What's there to be sarcastic about? Bill and Bob didn't just make the whole thing up off the top of their heads? Aren't they the storied founders? Is Gary Busey wrong when he says that God gave the program to us through them? Or you don't think evolutionary medicine is a good idea?
OK. But what is available right now? Free? Readily available?
Yes in every major city in the world there are secular meetings and support groups, the more people are educated the more small towns will be getting them.
Some of my clients take naltrexone, some do well on it some poorly. Naltrexone (like AA or anything else) will not suit everyone.
Yes, obviously I already said people should be scanned for that gene variant and the suitability for that treatment.
And this proves what? That is doesn't work or ot does? If someone thinks it works, they are happy and it improves their lives, I reckon that is just fine.
No, homeopathy is not just fine. AA is net harmful I have shown that in a variety of ways, it is a cult, it screws up marriages and families, it makes people stupider, it can even increase the death rate (Vaillant) It's not harmless, it's woo.
That's nice. But I would (and do) disagree. So would millions of others; frankly, I think you are outvoted.
Have fun with your toy that's what Christianity says too, whoopdie doo. Don't expect to be left alone people are basically learning how to rescue their family members from this cult. One day the numbers will start dropping.
Everything. What evidence have you around all these opinions of yours. I am genuinely interested in the practices and results. You seem to have a lot of information to share with us.
This is just common knowledge anyone can see for themselves I'm not running around getting links for you because you don't like what I'm saying. Where evidence is actually needed or warranted I have provided it in spades.
So have you got the evidence for this or not. I am genuinely interested in the results.
The gene variant study in 2008? I already linked to it. And anyone can find it. You don't have an argument against me so you complain that I haven't met your evidence standards. :rolleyes:
Um, ok, whatever. I don't think this actually relates to anything that was said.
You said "No, I think he is saying AA is readily available and forms one of a multitude of services on offer. You cannot place everyone in rehab." So I explained some reasons AA is a net harm and shouldn't be thought of as helpful just because it is exists. "Well, at least we exist"
"Are you saying that AA hands out sentenses?!? They are part of the judiciary? Evidence?
Don't go upstairs by yourself! Your best thinking got you here! Do what your sponsor tells you! All horrifically stupid sentences with devastating consequences. Cult.
Evidence please.
pfft you want me to provide evidence that people in AA tell their sponsees not to take their medications or that you don't need them or that it's a crutch and all that? Are you freaking kidding me Alfie? No, I refuse to accept you don't know about this. Anyone can do some quick googling and find out that it's common knowledge. Here's one person "I too have heard people tell others to go off their medications and I always stated in meetings that this is never addressed anywhere in the BB." No **** it's not in the big book, it's just part of the general culture of woo that exists in the program. People get up and speak about this in meetings until this day it's such a problem, and the evidence is all over the internet in personal testimonies, tons of stuff on it at the orange papers. So go "LA LA LA LA" all day long but the anti-psychiatry that is tolerated AA (not by the outraged person I quoted who makes it a point to say it's BS in meeings) is seriously hurting people.
So in terms of economics, they have a solid market right? So for someone to break into it, they would have to have a better product, right? What better products are available to them right now?
:rolleyes: All of the non-cult groups are better than the cult group. SMART is popping up everywhere. We don't need another franchise here, anyone can start up a meeting, invite some psychologists to volunteer and follow the methods of other groups. Here's a great meeting in Toronto. You just have to open your eyes, every major city has good secular meetings these days.
Whar "proven science"?
naltrexone and other drugs, counselling and personal change techniques, they don't even counsel you to eat and exercise properly to help you get over your withdrawal syndrome.
What claim?
How about the claim that AA works which I've shown is baloney.
You are really lsoing me in some places.
:D
Why is it "delusional"?
Because gajillions of people quit AA and discover they can control their drinking and do so successfully for many years while laughing at themselves for almost being so stupid. Some people probably can never drink again, but many people can! So people are being lied to by quacks!
Oh! It's not?
How do you know Alfie, let me guess, if you can control your drinking you weren't a "true alcoholic" :rolleyes: crank science.
Some do, I see them weekly in hospitals, ABI centres, prisons, rehabs etc etc.
So what their existence doesn't justify brainwashing people with that line with the pseudoscientific pronouncement that you can't quit without aa (it doesn't even work) or that without a support group an evil gremlin will control your brain.
There's that word again. How and why is it "harmful"?
:rolleyes: cults makes you stupid, and it's cult aspects do cause problems for families, so right there, that's too much harm. It's anti-psychiatry. It's controversial aspects are a waste of time look at this thread. Also, it's like homeopathy, doing it thinking it's helping is preventing you from spendng that time on something that actually is helpful, actually gets you where you want to go, actually works as a preventative for a relapse, not this delusion that the existence of the program creates. It's actually just institutionalized escapism.

It's ok, the history books and the Institute for Addiction Recovery have got their number.

Alcoholics Anonymous was, in fact, an anti-psychiatry movement. With characteristic magnanimity, Bill and Bob wrote the Big Book to avoid conflict with doctors. Make no mistake: A.A. was an attempt to re-inject spirituality into the picture, to re-introduce “free will” into the treatment of alcoholism so the alcoholic could take responsibility for his/her drinking, and to re-energize patients with the hope and optimism that is crucial for success. So in the beginning, psychiatry and A.A. were at odds. If you had a mental illness, you went to a psychiatrist, and if you were an alcoholic, you went to A.A.
But what if you had both a mental illness and alcoholism? The psychiatrists said, “Don’t go to those A.A. meetings – those people are a bunch of religious nuts. Here, take this Valium. You’ll be fine.” And in A.A. they said, “Don’t take that Lithium – those psychiatrists don’t know a damn thing about alcoholism. Here, just read Chapter Five. You’ll be fine.” They were both right - and they were both wrong. In the end, the patient with both a mental disorder and alcoholism – the patient we now call dually-diagnosed – fell through the cracks. These people died like alley-cats –miserable, alone, and afraid.
 
Last edited:
The government subsidizes treatment centres where the group therapy is AA/NA and you go to a meeting every single day so, what's that?

Does that mean they fund the whole thing?
At any rate, prove it.

Yes in every major city in the world there are secular meetings and support groups, the more people are educated the more small towns will be getting them.

Great!! The more types of treatment we have the better.

Yes, obviously I already said people should be scanned for that gene variant and the suitability for that treatment.

Good luck with that, how much money have you raised so far?

AA is net harmful I have shown that in a variety of ways, ...

Actually you have shown us virtually nothing; you have stated a lot of stuff, but actually proven zero.

This is just common knowledge anyone can see for themselves I'm not running around getting links for you because you don't like what I'm saying.

You may not be aware of it, but if you wish to make claims it falls to you to support them. You make the same mistake as others in this thread thinking that the more stentorious one is, the more truth there is in it. :rolleyes:

.. you want me to provide evidence that people in AA tell their sponsees not to take their medications or that you don't need them or that it's a crutch and all that? Are you freaking kidding me Alfie?

Just because some nutjobs suggest "pills are for dills" doesn't mean that the entire organisation believes it. I too think these people fools.

So, can you show me where AA says it; surely it is on their webpage?

All of the non-cult groups are better than the cult group.

In terms of success? Where are the stats for this comment?

SMART is popping up everywhere. We don't need another franchise here, anyone can start up a meeting, invite some psychologists to volunteer and follow the methods of other groups. Here's a great meeting in Toronto. You just have to open your eyes, every major city has good secular meetings these days.

Fantastic! Like I said, the more treatments we have the better.

By the way - what is the difference between doing a SMART program and an atheist doing AA?

naltrexone and other drugs, counselling and personal change techniques, they don't even counsel you to eat and exercise properly to help you get over your withdrawal syndrome. How about the claim that AA works which I've shown is baloney.

AA does work, you did show us that and I thank you for it
But have you provided somprehensive comparisons with other programs/therapies?

Because gajillions of people quit AA and discover they can control their drinking and do so successfully for many years while laughing at themselves for almost being so stupid. Some people probably can never drink again, but many people can! So people are being lied to by quacks!

And gajillions plus one stay and get better. You really do say some silly things.

cults makes you stupid,

I wouldn't know. You seem to know a lot about it though. :)

that's too much harm.

Evidence of "harm"please.
It seems to me that families and individuals are far more damaged by the practicing alcoholic than by the recovering one. That said, I am uncertain as to where you (and I mean"you" as in Joey McGee) define alcoholic. Perhaps you could enlighten us on both the definition and the general manifestations of the problem/disease/malady/insert word you find most appropriate here.

Sure people give up on their own, others don't. Some need rehab, some don't. All have to detox, not all need medical supervision (although for mine it is always preferred). Most alcoholics (in my experience) suffer from some mental disorders aswell (this is called comorbidity and my personal observations run at 70% plus); if they have them they should seek treatment outside AA for these afflications, some have no mental issues save (say) guilt, remorse and a poor self esteem.

In my experience, every person that turns up to AA is looking for assistance with their problem drinking. Similarly I find people turning up at detox and rehabs because of the same thing. Not everyone gets recovery, not everyone lives. You seem to be of the opinion that one size fits all; Naltrexone and a scan for an elusive gene with a treatment we might find in the future. The reality is that you are living in lala land.

You can prove AA has no better or worse success than anything else whether it be CBT, psychiatry for mental problems or simply stopping by yourself.

Where AA does have many others beaten is that it offers a wide range of opinions from people who share how they did it. How they got and stay sober.
I love AA, it is a multi faceted diamond; there is something in it for everyone of one looks. This may or may not include spirituality. It almost certainly will involve mixing with other people, learning new ways of thinking (CBT?) and finding new behaviours.
Some of my best friends are in AA, some are out of it. Those that are not in AA are glad I am. Why - they knew the man I was, and the man I am; without fail they prefer the clean and sober Alfie.

Take what you need, and leave the rest.

Tradition three: "The only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking".

Anything else anyone says is simply their opinion and they - as you, or I - are just as entitled to be ignored by others as anyone else. ;)
 
Last edited:
From your own source above (the negative you posed being in the past tense).
They sure do have AAs number: It seems to confirm AAs place as a serious therapy...

Medications will never be the answer, because addiction is a problem of a spiritual nature. For the patient who is “jittery or befogged,” medications can keep them coming back to A.A. until they can recognize the anti-depressive, anti-anxiety, mood-stabilizing effects of the twelve-steps. Today, a more complementary relationship is developing between psychiatry and the addiction treatment field. The good news is that people are getting sober today who died in the past.

It sounds to me like they are saying:

- Alcoholism is a spiritual problem.
- If they keep coming back, their depression will get better.
- People who used to die, live because of AA.

LOL!
Thanks dude!
 
Last edited:
Does that mean they fund the whole thing?
It doesn't matter, if the standard available level of care paid for the government includes AA most of the time that shows it has an undue amount of influence, and it's fact that people are forced into AA and have won court cases over it's religious nature.
At any rate, prove it.
Most rehab centres use a 12 step model. If you need proof and can't find it in Google, whatever, I'm not wasting my time with this anymore.
Good luck with that, how much money have you raised so far?
This is a hilarious comment. What are you trying to ridicule me for what the NIH has been pushing? :rolleyes:
Actually you have shown us virtually nothing; you have stated a lot of stuff, but actually proven zero.
In your bizarre world where you think asking me questions and naively trying to poke holes (small sample Alfie?) is an argument you're allowed to think whatever you want about my posts but you can't logically dispute a word of it.
You may not be aware of it, but if you wish to make claims it falls to you to support them. You make the same mistake as others in this thread thinking that the more stentorious one is, the more truth there is in it. :rolleyes:
Why don't you try backing this up.
Just because some nutjobs suggest "pills are for dills" doesn't mean that the entire organisation believes it. I too think these people fools.

So, can you show me where AA says it; surely it is on their webpage?
You fool, it's a common belief in AA, everyone knows it, Penn and Teller brought people on and proved it in their AA special, you can't call it a few bad apples, it goes right to the core of who they are and always were. The older incarnations were far worse anti-psychiatry, that's part of history, you can't just handwave it away like, it's still happening, people still talk about it at meetings and afterwards other people on medications will come and say "Thank you for saying that! AA makes me feel insecure for taking them!" So just saying that not every person in the program has that opinion, doesn't change the fact that it's a breeding ground for that belief.
In terms of success? Where are the stats for this comment?
pffft you want stats to show that being in a cult is worse than not being in a cult? This is getting ridiculous now.
By the way - what is the difference between doing a SMART program and an atheist doing AA?
AA is a cult that brainwashes vulnerable people and teaches people faith healing and a bunch of pseudoscientific crap whch I and many people have detailed in this thread, SMART doesn't have those problems.
AA does work, you did show us that and I thank you for it
lol, evidence? How did I do such a thing? Bizarre rhetoric...
And gajillions plus one stay and get better. You really do say some silly things.
Go ahead handwave the Cochrane review away, makes comments like this look stupid, but you can just keep on making them in your imaginary world where AA works compared to no treatment (those 8 studies were by far not the only ones who have shown that, but really, the best)
I wouldn't know. You seem to know a lot about it though. :)
You're an apologist for a cult, of course you're going to try and disrespect those who devote their lives to understanding and debunking them as well as rescuing people. Very low of you if you ask me.

Evidence of "harm"please.
Orange Papers dot org
It seems to me that families and individuals are far more damaged by the practicing alcoholic than by the recovering one.
non sequitur and appeal to emotion, we're talking about the harm the cult does, stay on that.
That said, I am uncertain as to where you (and I mean"you" as in Joey McGee) define alcoholic. Perhaps you could enlighten us on both the definition and the general manifestations of the problem/disease/malady/insert word you find most appropriate here.
It is a disorder the reward system where the body's natural craving for survival systems have been confused with alcohol. It is a pathology of biology and you need to rewire your brain and withdraw for several months to get rid of the craving and syndrome.
Sure people give up on their own, others don't. Some need rehab, some don't. All have to detox, not all need medical supervision (although for mine it is always preferred). Most alcoholics (in my experience) suffer from some mental disorders aswell (this is called comorbidity and my personal observations run at 70% plus); if they have them they should seek treatment outside AA for these afflications, some have no mental issues save (say) guilt, remorse and a poor self esteem.
The reality is that when people are introduced to the program they are given a "one size fits all" paradigm to fit into. You are an alcoholic, yadda yadda, rarely is the access to the "outside help" actually truly encouraged and supported. That this happens is only a result of decades and decades and battles and changes with the history of AA proves, many books and websites detail these battles it's history. So you can't hold up the ideal AA and wave away all of it's cult issues, that's been the defender's refuse for decades and it doesn't work anymore.
In my experience, every person that turns up to AA is looking for assistance with their problem drinking. Similarly I find people turning up at detox and rehabs because of the same thing. Not everyone gets recovery, not everyone lives. You seem to be of the opinion that one size fits all; Naltrexone and a scan for an elusive gene with a treatment we might find in the future. The reality is that you are living in lala land.
That's a ridiculous straw man and the worst attempt at you dismissing me so far. My point was a single example of what AA fails to integrate because it is a stupid cult. There are millions of possible bits of information that can help, there are dozens of different avenues that could be explored. The fact is that AA never tests it's own results and doesn't get involved with any of that kind of thing, never integrates it. WHY? Why is important, that would threaten their blueprint, which no cult will ever tolerate. What you want me to do is plan a recovery program how I would do it and all of what I would teach people. I'm not going to do that for you, you're not even being honest about what's wrong with AA first, why put that out for you to mangle in failed attempts to criticize. All I have to do is show what's wrong about AA and that's a new discussion.
You can prove AA has no better or worse success than anything else whether it be CBT, psychiatry for mental problems or simply stopping by yourself.
This is your lala land imaginary attempt at apologizing for AA's proven cult aspects?

Where AA does have many others beaten is that it offers a wide range of opinions from people who share how they did it. How they got and stay sober.
AA isn't a support group, those are great, this is a religious cult.
I love AA, it is a multi faceted diamond; there is something in it for everyone of one looks. This may or may not include spirituality. It almost certainly will involve mixing with other people, learning new ways of thinking (CBT?) and finding new behaviours.
Some of my best friends are in AA, some are out of it. Those that are not in AA are glad I am. Why - they knew the man I was, and the man I am; without fail they prefer the clean and sober Alfie.
I know but this is just your anecdotal experience, when we look at the big picture, it's not really helping alcoholics, and it's institutionalized religion that's foisted and forced onto vulnerable people.
Take what you need, and leave the rest.

Tradition three: "The only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking".
There's lots of cults that say their members are free to leave any time. The point is that there is dishonesty and pseudoscience and cult memetics that influences people to stay.

Anything else anyone says is simply their opinion and they - as you, or I - are just as entitled to be ignored by others as anyone else. ;)
Just like anyone is free to turn their browsers to The Orange Papers and Stinkin' Thinkin' ;)
 
Last edited:
From your own source above (the negative you posed being in the past tense).
They sure do have AAs number: It seems to confirm AAs place as a serious therapy...

Medications will never be the answer, because addiction is a problem of a spiritual nature.
Then I disagree with them, I quoted them because they got that part of history right, it was only to show it's common knowledge that they were always anti-psychiatry. This is you digging for any possible argument against me at all.


For the patient who is “jittery or befogged,” medications can keep them coming back to A.A. until they can recognize the anti-depressive, anti-anxiety, mood-stabilizing effects of the twelve-steps. Today, a more complementary relationship is developing between psychiatry and the addiction treatment field. The good news is that people are getting sober today who died in the past.

It sounds to me like they are saying:

- Alcoholism is a spiritual problem.
- If they keep coming back, their depression will get better.
- People who used to die, live because of AA.

LOL!
Thanks dude!
The people who I just quoted saying AA killed people are saying that the combination of psychiatry with the addiction recovery field is what is saving lives! So it still supports my argument, and besides, what these people have to say in no way disputes any of the arguments I have made here. More weak attempts to dismiss what I have to say.

AA hurts people Alfie, you're an AA denier. Maybe if you figured that out you'd realize how insulting you can be. I hope that lady doesn't bother trying to answer your two questions.
 
Last edited:
Then I disagree with them, I quoted them because they got that part of history right, it was only to show it's common knowledge that they were always anti-psychiatry. This is you digging for any possible argument against me at all.

Key word is "history" (my bold).


The people who I just quoted saying AA killed people are saying that the combination of psychiatry with the addiction recovery field is what is saving lives! So it still supports my argument, and besides, what these people have to say in no way disputes any of the arguments I have made here. More weak attempts to dismiss what I have to say.

Backpedal, backpedal, backpedal.
It also supports mine.

Thanks again.

AA hurts people Alfie, you're an AA denier.

If I am a denier, you are a dangerous alarmist zealot.

Like I said above, you make very little sense to me. I also said we were free to ignore each other. So onto ignore you go. I prefer not to feed your one trick troll pony any more, nor your ego.

Perhaps I should mention to others the pm you sent me, virtually pleading for me to respond to a post. Did you think I had left? Why did you want my opinion so desperately? Did you pm others, I wonder?

You prove nothing, provide little that actually supports your assertions and spout from the soapbox of opinion. Opinion that you claim is fact, yet you refuse to provide these "facts" saying it is "common knowledge". Ironic huh?

You rave on and on about cult, citing the orange papers, penn and teller etc - yet in the same breath demand scientific results. More irony.

I leave the last word to you, hopefully it has relevance this time. :)
 
If I am a denier, you are a dangerous alarmist zealot.
For saying what? Anything I say thousands of other people say on the internet and include their own experiences, I'm not making anything up, if you fail to search for these yourself that doesn't make me a zealot for talking about them.

Perhaps I should mention to others the pm you sent me, virtually pleading for me to respond to a post. Did you think I had left? Why did you want my opinion so desperately? Did you pm others, I wonder?
Any half nice thing I try and say is turned against me?

You prove nothing, provide little that actually supports your assertions and spout from the soapbox of opinion. Opinion that you claim is fact, yet you refuse to provide these "facts" saying it is "common knowledge". Ironic huh?
It's common knowledge AA dominates in the recovery field, this is the only thing I didn't bother to give evidence for because it was a ridiculous request, and now I gave no evidence. :rolleyes:

You rave on and on about cult, citing the orange papers, penn and teller etc - yet in the same breath demand scientific results. More irony.
What is there a double blind study that proves it's a cult that uses mind control? People can decide from themselves by reading this article "Is Alcoholics Anonymous a cult?" There are probably thousands of letters on Orange Papers, testimonies of experiences, and on Stinkin' Thinkin' decide for yourselves if those people make that stuff up or are the delusional ones.

I leave the last word to you, hopefully it has relevance this time. :)
The Cochrane review authors.
People considering attending AA or TSF programmes should be made aware that there is a lack of experimental evidence on the effectiveness of such programmes.
 
AA pretty much destroyed my marriage. We were cultural Jews when he started going to AA. (He did NOT do an inpatient program, but he DID have a drinking problem. Not a huge one, but a six pack a night one) He became a fundie Xtian and I just really.couldn't.take.it. The constant praying for sobriety and ****.

To say AA is not a religion in and of itself is, to me, ********. I am still a cultural Jew (meaning I am Jewish and love the culture, but not the religion) but he has since become some weird right wing Christian who married someone else like him.

I'm sorry you had to go through this. Thank you for sharing this with us.
 
AA pretty much destroyed my marriage. We were cultural Jews when he started going to AA. (He did NOT do an inpatient program, but he DID have a drinking problem. Not a huge one, but a six pack a night one) He became a fundie Xtian and I just really.couldn't.take.it. The constant praying for sobriety and ****.

To say AA is not a religion in and of itself is, to me, ********. I am still a cultural Jew (meaning I am Jewish and love the culture, but not the religion) but he has since become some weird right wing Christian who married someone else like him.
I really question the idea that six drinks a day could constitute alcoholism.

My observation would be that it is very PC in certain groups to assign the alcoholism label to moderate amounts. AFAIK, cessation of this level of consumption would not produce the well known withdrawal symptoms.
 
I really question the idea that six drinks a day could constitute alcoholism.

My observation would be that it is very PC in certain groups to assign the alcoholism label to moderate amounts. AFAIK, cessation of this level of consumption would not produce the well known withdrawal symptoms.

It sounds like the "problem" was that he drank them all in one sitting at the end of the day every day; which is frankly very common and I concur it doesn't necessarily add up to "alcoholism."

It's really sad that she had to go through all that pain to deal with something that wasn't necessarily a problem.

GB
 
I really question the idea that six drinks a day could constitute alcoholism.

My observation would be that it is very PC in certain groups to assign the alcoholism label to moderate amounts. AFAIK, cessation of this level of consumption would not produce the well known withdrawal symptoms.

I doubt it would produce withdrawal symptoms either. That said, I client of mine did have some moderate withdrawal symptoms after cessation from her daily glass of sherry. She had been drinking a glass for some 30 years. So who knows?

It is also true that not everyone in AA is an alcoholic, but I am also curious to ask how we determine what is an alcoholic. Generally, binge drinkers do not suffer the same withdrawal as a daily-top-up- drinker. Are they alcoholics or not? Where is this line drawn? It seems daily dependance is not an accurate measure.
 
Tradition three: "The only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking".

"Membership requirements" for the program would be somewhat different from the program itself, wouldn't they?

Does the tradition you quote then mean that the 12 steps are superfluous, and one needn't "work the steps" at all as a member of AA? Most especially steps 6 and 7?

6. Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character.

7. Humbly asked Him [god] to remove our shortcomings.

How does that work if one's higher power is not god, but merely an aspect of oneself, or something "spiritual?"
 
"Membership requirements" for the program would be somewhat different from the program itself, wouldn't they?

The "suggested" 12 steps you mean?

Does the tradition you quote then mean that the 12 steps are superfluous, and one needn't "work the steps" at all as a member of AA? Most especially steps 6 and 7?

The steps are not "superfluous" as you say, they are merely another option within the program. Nothing is compulsory and the steps are not a requirement for membership either long nor short term. One of my mentors is a man with 47 years sobriety. He has never done the steps yet he is held in some esteem by many.

How does that work if one's higher power is not god, but merely an aspect of oneself, or something "spiritual?"

It works just fine. Use whatever you want; no-one cares (or should care).
 
Last edited:
The "suggested" 12 steps you mean?

No. I said what I meant.



The steps are not "superfluous" as you say,

I did not say they are superfluous, Alfie. I asked if they are.



they are merely another option within the program. Nothing is compulsory and the steps are not a requirement for membership either long nor short term. One of my mentors is a man with 47 years sobriety. He has never done the steps yet he is held in some esteem by many.

Then they are superfluous. Thank you for the response.



It works just fine. Use whatever you want; no-one cares (or should care).

I needn't use anything. I don't drink alcohol.
 
No. I said what I meant.





I did not say they are superfluous, Alfie. I asked if they are.





Then they are superfluous. Thank you for the response.





I needn't use anything. I don't drink alcohol.

And therein lies the self-contradiction of AA Zealots.

AAer: "The 12 Steps are Suggested."

first timer: "Oh, so I don't need to follow them?:confused:"

AAer: "Well, if you want it to work you do....but it's just a suggestion."

GB
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom