Hallo Alfie
Banned
- Joined
- Oct 4, 2009
- Messages
- 10,691
I know several towns where everything is AA and the government pays for AA and they have forced people into AA with no alternative in places? That's worse than a choke hold... It's about 80-90% 12-step in centers around the world. That's going to be changing.
Great! The more therapies we have on offer the better.
Now, I would be very interested to see the evidence that "the government pays for AA".
The practitioners of science/evidence-based medicine and evolutionary medicine who are taking over modern medicine. It will be the opposite of some dudes making stuff up.
Um.. ok ..
You make it sound like a violent revolution.
I would suggest a comprehensive approach, meaning an organization that applies the best of what we know and can prove while also spearheading the search for knowledge. The recovery movement needn't be fragmented. Every patient should have the opportunity to learn this knowledge and be encouraged to know it, not folk wisdom and memes (cult language - R.Lifton) Take just one example, the remarkable success of naltrexone and tailored talk therapy plus the 2008 result from NIH that taught us it works better on people with a certain gene variant. Screen everyone for that variant and for suitability for that intervention. Everyone. This will be inexpensive soon. Put everyone through standardized care just like any medical condition in a hospital. There are more examples obviously but I only need one good one to show something is drastically wrong and opportunities are being wasted. AA is notoriously anti-naltrexone. As long as they keep brainwashing people with their made up stupidity people with that gene variant aren't going to get the opportunity to have 20 sessions some pills and get their life back, they are going to spend the rest of their life going to meetings. The horror of this to me is just unspeakable. I cannot allow people to brainwash vulnerable victims of mental illness into a lifelong commitment to a faith healing cult when there are greener pastures mere clicks away on the internet.
OK. But what is available right now? Free? Readily available? Some of my clients take naltrexone, some do well on it some poorly. Naltrexone (like AA or anything else) will not suit everyone.
If you promote AA it is. I said it was controlled, you didn't read the study, they controlled against no treatment, yadda yadda, join the revolution while it's young Alfie. Just read the study Alfie. I know it's disturbing to you but they controlled against no treatment.
And this proves what? That is doesn't work or ot does? If someone thinks it works, they are happy and it improves their lives, I reckon that is just fine.
If you're defending AA as an organization which I think the world would be much better off if it ceased to exist,
That's nice. But I would (and do) disagree. So would millions of others; frankly, I think you are outvoted.
What? You honestly need data on the fact that there are many approaches and private companies that do alcoholism therapy? Or on the fact that 12-step dominates rehab centers?
I would like information on everything you claim. What evidence have you around all these opinions of yours? I am genuinely interested in the practices and results. You seem to have a lot of information to share with us, I am interested as to where it comes from..
I only need one so centers that offer naltrexone and talk therapy and possibly even screenings for that gene variant. Actually anyone can check themselves for that gene varient using various internet services. It's pretty cheap nowaways and rapidly getting chearper.
So have you got the evidence for this or not? I am genuinely interested in the results.
Well it certainly seems to have pissed a lot of people off for no good reason other than to maintain its cult blueprint.
Um, ok. Whatever.
I don't think this actually relates to anything that was said.
Also handed out billions of sentences of bad advice and lies about reality.
Are you saying that AA hands out court sentences?!? Are AA now part of the judiciary? Evidence please.
Also supported anti-psychiatry in a devastating way for a long time and still does in many places.
Evidence please.
Just because there is no other meetings in that small town of 40,000, doesn't win AA any points. There are only Christian churchses in lot of those towns too.
So in terms of economics, they have a solid market. Right?
So for someone to break into it, they would have to have a better product. Right?
What better products are available to them right now?
And why haven't they been successful do you think?
None of the proven science and treatment that you won't learn or receive in AA matters to my main argument,
Whar "proven science" are you talking about?
If we take AA claim by claim though, we can show that a great deal of it is wrong or counter to what we know. We can also show it fails to integrate anything modern because it has never changed. (well in a sense the old-timers are scarier)
What claim? You are really losing me in some places.
What about the delusion that you can never drink again.
Why is it "delusional"?
That's up for some people to decide and is undoubtedly true for some.
Oh! It's not?
But a lot of people get out of AA and just drink normally after. And thank their lucky stars they got out of a cult. Some people scared the bejesus out of them that they would die, end up in jail or worse.
Some do, I see them weekly in hospitals, ABI centres, prisons, rehabs etc etc.
You don't get it, we need to first get rid of all the ways AA is objectivly harmful,
There's that word again. How and why is it "harmful"?
Last edited: