Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
This is the kind of thing I just don't get.

Is there a scoreboard somewhere, that you get points for that comment? Did you feel really cool after you typed it?

No, it was a response to the "anything can be your higher power" trope that is constantly said here.


ETA: You might want to watch personalizing your comments.
 
Last edited:
AS power greater than myself might in fact be my well self.

It seems to me you are trying to limit this power to your understanding only. Luckily for us, we can apply different measures.

Well, yes, lots of people include god and various paranormal beliefs in their understanding. Nothing wrong with that if it helps them and doesn't hurt others. Those are the people that it seems AA would be best targeted for, who have a natural inclination to believe in a higher power, as the phrase is usually used.

It seems mere semantics to think of one's well self as a separate entity from one's unwell self.

Explain please, I'm not sure what you are saying here.

My paragraph was meant to be a parallel to hud's paragraph.

Drunks say they're not abusing alcohol yet continue drinking. AA says it's not religious yet doesn't change the literature.
 
This is just wrong. "God" does not have to be a transcendent of ineffable entity. In fact, the February 2011 Grapevine has an article where one AA chooses a gingko tree as his or her PGTO.

All the PGTO need be is a symbol of the strength that one wasn't able to find within oneself.



I don't see how people admitting that the simply cannot stop after one drink and therefore need never take a drink again is an abrogation of personal responsibility.

There. If you cannot stop then you are not responsible.
 
No, it was a response to the "anything can be your higher power" trope that is constantly said here.

Oh I got that. I just couldn't understand why you would put it that way. Its the kind of comment that doesn't further the discussion, but only impresses the people who already agree with your point, that's all. Preaching to the choir and all that. :)
 
How hard is it to understand that alcoholics don't think rationally about their drinking, and that they need some outside help to change the way they think? Willpower alone is fine to a point, but why is it not allowed to seek help?

Join the Baptists, you'll get better preaching and a bigger community.
 
No, it was a response to the "anything can be your higher power" trope that is constantly said here.


ETA: You might want to watch personalizing your comments.

Didn't see your edit the first time.

I wasn't trying to personalize my comments, I was only trying to understand why you said what you did the way you did. I certainly wasn't going for a personal attack on you of any kind.

Apologize if I offended you somehow. :confused:
 
How hard is it to understand that alcoholics don't think rationally about their drinking, and that they need some outside help to change the way they think? Willpower alone is fine to a point, but why is it not allowed to seek help?

You seem to be caught in a duality: either a person changes alone through willpower, or seeks help.

I'm not saying that.

A person still must use their willpower to benefit from that help. A person who asks for help and then doesn't exert even the small amount of willpower necessary to attend meetings or therapy sessions, to apply the advice, etc., won't get much if any benefit.

Help is like a lever, if you need to raise something too heavy to lift alone. It's a tool to make the work easier, but you still have to exert some force on the one end, to raise the weight on the other end.
 
You seem to be caught in a duality: either a person changes alone through willpower, or seeks help.

I'm not saying that.
A person still must use their willpower to benefit from that help. A person who asks for help and then doesn't exert even the small amount of willpower necessary to attend meetings or therapy sessions, to apply the advice, etc., won't get much if any benefit.

Help is like a lever, if you need to raise something too heavy to lift alone. It's a tool to make the work easier, but you still have to exert some force on the one end, to raise the weight on the other end.

My bad, I thought you were saying that.

We seem to agree then. Willpower + some kind of outside help = better chance of not drinking.
 
Atheist ignores the importance of symbolism. News at 11.

Huh? To clarify, I'm an atheist, and if the tree is a symbol, I'm totally cool with that, as I said.

If the tree is supposed to be an actual higher power, well, then, no.

To Hud:

Sounds like we agree, then. :)
 
Oh I got that. I just couldn't understand why you would put it that way. Its the kind of comment that doesn't further the discussion, but only impresses the people who already agree with your point, that's all. Preaching to the choir and all that. :)


I put it that way so someone could see that saying "anything can be your higher power" is nonsense. If you can't accept crap in the toilet as a higher power then that statement is wrong.
 
I put it that way so someone could see that saying "anything can be your higher power" is nonsense. If you can't accept crap in the toilet as a higher power then that statement is wrong.

I got that. I didn't (and still don't) get why you put it that way. Probably just me.

My understanding - just mine - is basically like what I was saying a few posts ago to Pup. My higher power is the combination of myself and the help from others that I receive. Myself +outside help > just myself.
 
I got that. I didn't (and still don't) get why you put it that way. Probably just me.

My understanding - just mine - is basically like what I was saying a few posts ago to Pup. My higher power is the combination of myself and the help from others that I receive. Myself +outside help > just myself.

That is eminently logical.
 
It's a "Power greater than oneself", and it doesn't have to itself care about you or be able to literally intervene in your life.

It's still a god. You can call it anything you will but if you believe there's something invisible that's greater than yourself you're a believer in the turd in the toilet.


You see if anything can be a higher power then my "turd in a toilet" is as good as yours.
 
Last edited:
Nope. It can be secular. I have this really cool analogy about how it can be crap in the toilet, for example...:p

Thanks for following the argument out to it's logical conclusion.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom