Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
If you can't personally control it with your own mind, then the only thing which would stop it is physical restraint by a power literally greater than yourself, such as being confined against your will in a room with locks you can't break.

If you can control it by imagining or thinking about the influence of a power greater than yourself, then, well, you can control it with your own mind.

I don't see how one can get around that paradox, unless one considers that thinking about a power has a real effect that's external to one's own mind, which is usually the province of religion (such as the power of god, the power of prayer, etc.).

A power greater than myself could be education, knowledge, new tools, a different way of thinking etc.
If I don't have them already, I am in no position to use them. One cannot know what one doesn't know.

Your paradox isn't that paradoxical after all.
 
Last edited:
If you can't personally control it with your own mind, then the only thing which would stop it is physical restraint by a power literally greater than yourself, such as being confined against your will in a room with locks you can't break.

If you can control it by imagining or thinking about the influence of a power greater than yourself, then, well, you can control it with your own mind.

I don't see how one can get around that paradox, unless one considers that thinking about a power has a real effect that's external to one's own mind, which is usually the province of religion (such as the power of god, the power of prayer, etc.).

Don't get caught up in this seeming paradox. Admitting one has no control over alcohol is just that classic first step in solving your problem - admitting you have one.

The flip side is the feeling that you don't have a problem, the "I can handle it" thinking that most alcoholics have before seeking help.

A power greater than yourself can be the social group of AA, a therapist, a psychologist, a self-help book, anything. It doesn't have to be religious.

Of course, I was an atheist when I went in, and I still am. Others may see it differently.
 
A power greater than yourself can be the social group of AA, a therapist, a psychologist, a self-help book, anything. It doesn't have to be religious.

You know, that line really doesn't get less ridiculous the more often it is trotted out.

Seriously, who would associate the term "power" with books or other people? Nobody ever does that, and there is no reason to assume that AA was trying to go for an uterrly bizzar and atypical understanding of the language they used.
 
You know, that line really doesn't get less ridiculous the more often it is trotted out.

Seriously, who would associate the term "power" with books or other people? Nobody ever does that, and there is no reason to assume that AA was trying to go for an uterrly bizzar and atypical understanding of the language they used.

Except that it is exactly what is done in practice.

So much for your understanding. :)
 
You know, that line really doesn't get less ridiculous the more often it is trotted out.

Seriously, who would associate the term "power" with books or other people? Nobody ever does that, and there is no reason to assume that AA was trying to go for an uterrly bizzar and atypical understanding of the language they used.

Who? I did, and lots of others I knew. I guess that disproves your point about "nobody ever does that."

Its not ridiculous because you say so.

Ther is a larger point in there, and you are missing it by simply throwing around generalizations and insults. AA knows it has a problem with all the religious hogwash the founding members crammed into the program, and in practice (at the meetings I have been to personally) they bend over backwards trying to take it out or work around it. I wish they would rewrite the steps and the big book, leaving most of the god stuff out, or at least have atheist/agnostic doctrine printed and handed out at the same time. Also more atheist/agnostic/secular/whatever meetings, the only one I found near me was 2-3 hours away.
 
Who? I did, and lots of others I knew. I guess that disproves your point about "nobody ever does that."

Its not ridiculous because you say so.

Ther is a larger point in there, and you are missing it by simply throwing around generalizations and insults. AA knows it has a problem with all the religious hogwash the founding members crammed into the program, and in practice (at the meetings I have been to personally) they bend over backwards trying to take it out or work around it. I wish they would rewrite the steps and the big book, leaving most of the god stuff out, or at least have atheist/agnostic doctrine printed and handed out at the same time. Also more atheist/agnostic/secular/whatever meetings, the only one I found near me was 2-3 hours away.

Until "they" do AA will remain a religion.


Why do so many people deny personal responsibility?
 
A power greater than myself could be education, knowledge, new tools, a different way of thinking etc.
If I don't have them already, I am in no position to use them. One cannot know what one doesn't know.

Your paradox isn't that paradoxical after all.

No, the choice to acquire those powers, is still made by you. You can choose to seek more knowledge, gain more tools, etc.

I'm talking about a difference between "self" and "something outside of one's self." As long as a person is making voluntary choices, it's their "self" which is acting, and not a higher power acting on them.

As Rasmus said, if a person wanted to become an accountant and realized he needed to go to college to earn a degree in order to do so, he wouldn't say that a power greater than himself turned him into an accountant, unless he meant that an outside paranormal force not part of his self--a god, a guardian angel, etc.--inspired him to get the degree.
 
A power greater than myself could be education, knowledge, new tools, a different way of thinking etc.
If I don't have them already, I am in no position to use them. One cannot know what one doesn't know.

Your paradox isn't that paradoxical after all.

I have decided that a piece of crap in the toilet is my greater power since it represents what I have eaten and is a residue of that fact.

Or maybe I should worship my new lawn mower.
 
Until "they" do AA will remain a religion.


Why do so many people deny personal responsibility?

Not a religion in my opinion, but I can see how you (and others) think that. I would call it a recovery program with a whole lot of religious hogwash mixed in. I say that because you can go through the program without being indoctrinated, so to speak.

Personal responsibility is a hard subject for addicts to address, its part of the nature of the problem.

Look, a lot of these responses I am reading seem to be just about willpower, when you get down to it. If you want to quit, why don't you just quit? Correct me if I'm wrong, please, but that's how they sound. Substance abuse and addiction is a huge societal problem that can't be solve with a "Just Say No" campaign :p
 
AA knows it has a problem with all the religious hogwash the founding members crammed into the program, and in practice (at the meetings I have been to personally) they bend over backwards trying to take it out or work around it. I wish they would rewrite the steps and the big book, leaving most of the god stuff out, or at least have atheist/agnostic doctrine printed and handed out at the same time.

Drunks know on some level that they have a problem with alcohol, but in practice, they bend over backwards trying to deny it or hide it. I wish they'd be honest and just admit it, and then work to change.

There's a similarity, which is why I think that AA makes a mistake by encouraging the behavior of compensation and denial.
 
I have decided that a piece of crap in the toilet is my greater power since it represents what I have eaten and is a residue of that fact.

Or maybe I should worship my new lawn mower.

This is the kind of thing I just don't get.

Is there a scoreboard somewhere, that you get points for that comment? Did you feel really cool after you typed it?
 
Until "they" do AA will remain a religion.

This is just wrong. "God" does not have to be a transcendent of ineffable entity. In fact, the February 2011 Grapevine has an article where one AA chooses a gingko tree as his or her PGTO.

All the PGTO need be is a symbol of the strength that one wasn't able to find within oneself.

Why do so many people deny personal responsibility?

I don't see how people admitting that the simply cannot stop after one drink and therefore need never take a drink again is an abrogation of personal responsibility.
 
Last edited:
Look, a lot of these responses I am reading seem to be just about willpower, when you get down to it. If you want to quit, why don't you just quit? Correct me if I'm wrong, please, but that's how they sound. Substance abuse and addiction is a huge societal problem that can't be solve with a "Just Say No" campaign :p

Short of some drug that immediately and permanently rewires the brain, isn't it all about willpower? What other power does an individual have over his own actions, unless one believes in the paranormal influence of gods?

Whether an individual chooses a recovery program, an individual therapist, or some other technique to make accomplishing a goal easier, in the end, he or she still has to choose to take each individual step through his or her own will.

That's excluding, of course, involuntary confinement in a hospital or prison with no access to alcohol/drugs, where a person is unable to exercise their own will.
 
Drunks know on some level that they have a problem with alcohol, but in practice, they bend over backwards trying to deny it or hide it. I wish they'd be honest and just admit it, and then work to change.
There's a similarity, which is why I think that AA makes a mistake by encouraging the behavior of compensation and denial.

Well the way I saw it, that's what AA did, exactly what you are suggesting. Not compensation and denial, but more along the lines of admitting a problem and seeking help. And then providing a support group.
 
Short of some drug that immediately and permanently rewires the brain, isn't it all about willpower? What other power does an individual have over his own actions, unless one believes in the paranormal influence of gods?

Whether an individual chooses a recovery program, an individual therapist, or some other technique to make accomplishing a goal easier, in the end, he or she still has to choose to take each individual step through his or her own will.

That's excluding, of course, involuntary confinement in a hospital or prison with no access to alcohol/drugs, where a person is unable to exercise their own will.

How hard is it to understand that alcoholics don't think rationally about their drinking, and that they need some outside help to change the way they think? Willpower alone is fine to a point, but why is it not allowed to seek help?
 
No, the choice to acquire those powers, is still made by you. You can choose to seek more knowledge, gain more tools, etc.

And until I have them they are not mine and are (or can be) a power greater than myself.

I'm talking about a difference between "self" and "something outside of one's self." As long as a person is making voluntary choices, it's their "self" which is acting, and not a higher power acting on them.

I think you are conflating a number of points here.
That aside, where does it say that the "power greater than oneself" have to be external of me and acts upon me? A power greater than myself might in fact be my well or better self.

It seems to me you are trying to limit this power to your understanding only. Luckily for us, we can apply different measures.

I have decided that a piece of crap in the toilet is my greater power since it represents what I have eaten and is a residue of that fact.

Somehow this seems appropriate for you.

Drunks know on some level that they have a problem with alcohol, but in practice, they bend over backwards trying to deny it or hide it. I wish they'd be honest and just admit it, and then work to change.

And that is exactly what people in AA are doing. Thanks for the advise, but you are about 75 years too late.

There's a similarity, which is why I think that AA makes a mistake by encouraging the behavior of compensation and denial.

Explain please, I'm not sure what you are saying here.
 
Last edited:
This is just wrong. "God" does not have to be a transcendent of ineffable entity. In fact, the February 2011 Grapevine has an article where one AA chooses a gingko tree as his or her PGTO.

All the PGTO need be is a symbol of the strength that one wasn't able to find within oneself.

Do you think the gingko tree literally has an external, paranormal power over that person?

Or do you think the person is using his/her thoughts about the gingko tree as a tool to help strengthen his or her own will?

If the person is using his/her focus on the gingko tree as a tool, and nothing paranormal is involved, and everyone including the person knows it, that's cool.

If the person is supposed to actually, really, believe that the gingko tree is exerting an external paranormal power over him/her, that's where we're getting into religion.
 
Do you think the gingko tree literally has an external, paranormal power over that person?

Or do you think the person is using his/her thoughts about the gingko tree as a tool to help strengthen his or her own will?

If the person is using his/her focus on the gingko tree as a tool, and nothing paranormal is involved, and everyone including the person knows it, that's cool.

If the person is supposed to actually, really, believe that the gingko tree is exerting an external paranormal power over him/her, that's where we're getting into religion.

Atheist ignores the importance of symbolism. News at 11.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom