Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Don't pay much attention do you?

I do pay attention, but the issue here is that he is generalizing his experience to refer to all of AA and I am saying that my experience runs directly counter to his experience. Thus, it is rather arrogant to make the assertion that AA is a religious organization because its founders were religious and hostile to atheists.
 
Uh...no, he started with the assumption that "God" in the Steps means something other than it does and then asserted that AA must be religious.

It's truly a remarkable trait of many humans to project their own thought process onto others.

The Assumption that God (in AA) can mean anything that isn't a Supernatural Deity (and a male one at that) is flat out false. You can make all the internal intellectual logic pretzels to justify your assumptions all you want. But you'd still be wrong, and your justifications are unsupported by factual evidence.

I'm not going to waste my time creating new arguments, So I'll just link to my original posts one at a time.

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=6690235&postcount=3301

If you have any counter-evidence, please provide it. Personal Anecdotes about your internal justifications are not evidence.

GB
 
We seem to agree then. Willpower + some kind of outside help = better chance of not drinking.

Yep

I put it that way so someone could see that saying "anything can be your higher power" is nonsense. If you can't accept crap in the toilet as a higher power then that statement is wrong.

This Power greater than yourself is totally apt. There are a lot of things that are greater than you and this is a good starting point.

It's still a god. You can call it anything you will but if you believe there's something invisible that's greater than yourself you're a believer in the turd in the toilet.

You see if anything can be a higher power then my "turd in a toilet" is as good as yours.

A power greater than yourself is not a God. Your own PGTY is evidence of this.

If your "power greater than your self" is just your social network how are you different than a church?

Or a TAM network?

For the new posters in this thread who (apparently) either refuse to read through the previous posts,

.... big snip of useless information.....

Tinyal. Did AA help you get sober and stay sober even though you are an atheist?
If you are an atheist in this supposedly religious organisation, how did you get to such dizzying heights of the heirarchy (of which you were only a trusted servant btw)? Did you perhaps lie for all those years about your religious convictions? Or maybe it's simply because no-one gives a toss about religion or otherwise as the primary purpose is to simply get people sober?

You are a true paradox mate.

mijopaalmc, did you not read previous posts in this thread? If you did, you'll have known I've been in AA for over 20 years, have attended more than 8000 meetings, have been in positions of authority in AA just below Trustee level, have been invited to speak at meetings all across the western USA, and continue to attend at least 2 meetings per week. How much experience do you have at various meetings compared to this? Mind revising your suggestion about what I 'really' need to do??

Did AA get you sober and help to get you sober?

That's a far different position than the one you have fought tooth and nail for so far in this thread.

Bzzzz. Wrong!

As usual your closed mindedness only hears and sees what it wants to. I have consistently said that AA can have a religious element in there - if you want it to. Conversely, it doesn't have to, nor is it compulsory.

I knew you were one of those christian counsellors! :p

That would be difficult for someone who identifies as agnostic, now wouldn't it?
 
Asked and answered ad nauseum. Once again, for a guy who participated in this thread for so long you are very ignorant of what has been posted. . . of course, having witnessed your willfully ignorant arguing style, I am not surprised.

Still got nuthin' huh?

If you did you would have posted it (which you haven't because there is no such thing) or referred us to the relevant post (which you can't because it's not there).
 
Still got nuthin' huh?

If you did you would have posted it (which you haven't because there is no such thing) or referred us to the relevant post (which you can't because it's not there).

So you believe a turd in the toilet can be a higher power?
 
Still got nuthin' huh?

If you did you would have posted it (which you haven't because there is no such thing) or referred us to the relevant post (which you can't because it's not there).

Show me the posts or links.

Why not just admit you can't and stop the lies charade?

So you believe a turd in the toilet can be a higher power?

Theoretically it could be, in practice I don't see how; but whatever rocks your boat.

That said, your turd analogy would seem an a match made in heaven where you are concerned. :p

But once again you are making the mistake of thinking that a "power greater than yourself" (in step #2) must be a higher power, as in "God as we understood him" (in step #3); they can be completely different things.

I'm surprised you haven't picked up on that yet.
 
All I can say is that my experience is completely different than your experience and that your appeal to The Big Book to establish AA's hostility to atheism does not jibe with my face-to-face experience with AAs is meetings. Moreover, the personal nature of each individual's experience is what defies the over-arching assertion "AA is a religious organization".

Firstly, if you happen to be (or have) attending a particular group meeting that removes the ineffective & false god claims of AA's source material - that's great for you!! Such meetings is what I have been working towards for more than a decade.
However, this is a rare occurrence in the USA (and nearly unheard of in the southern states) - in my area, I know of 1 meeting out of hundreds that operate this way (that is, where the 2 claims I've notated above do not receive intensely negative & out-group responses).
Secondly, although I frequently mention my own anecdotal experience, all of the evidence I use is from AA's own core material (primarily the big book & the 12x12, occasionally the grapevine or various pamphlets) - this is evidence, not opinion.
Additionally, might I kindly suggest that until you gain at least a few years sober living experience, and attend meetings in more than 1 state - including District, Regional, & Area conferences, before you go concluding what AA is and what it is not.
For example, it is not a program to quit drinking. It is a program to strengthen christian religious beliefs (if not outright convert those who are at their weakest) who's primary side effect is claimed to be a cessation of drinking (as well as a host of other claims, see 'the promises' as well as other areas of the big book) - note that many of us in this thread alone have posted evidence that doing nothing at all - or simply having an honest chat with a medical professional - is at least as effective as going to AA.
Without the christian nonsense.

Specifically take note that what I am talking about is the AA program itself, not how some particular (perhaps rare) individual meeting may or may not be organized. I am talking about the program as a whole, as written by the founders and widely practiced in the USA, so you shouldn't take this as personal criticism of your particular meeting (which, of course, I have no idea if I've ever attended, as I don't know (nor do I want to) where you are.
 
.. big snip of stuff ...

I will ask this again. Each time you don't respond you look sillier and sillier.

Tinyal. Did AA help you get sober and stay sober even though you are an atheist?
If you are an atheist in this supposedly religious organisation, how did you get to such dizzying heights of the heirarchy (of which you were only a trusted servant btw)? Did you perhaps lie for all those years about your religious convictions? Or maybe it's simply because no-one gives a toss about religion or otherwise as the primary purpose is to simply get people sober?

You are a true paradox mate.
 
If you did you would have posted it (which you haven't because there is no such thing) or referred us to the relevant post (which you can't because it's not there).

So, back to your plea to ignorance fallacy are you?

If you were honest, argued honestly, or were even the professional you claim, you wouldn't ask me to waste my time and forum bandwidth, you would just go back and read the astounding number of posts you obviously missed on the first go around. But you are, you don't, and you won't.

The beauty of this is that everyone else participating in the thread can see your petulance so engaging you is infinitely worth while. :D
 
So, back to your plea to ignorance fallacy are you?

If you were honest, argued honestly, or were even the professional you claim, you wouldn't ask me to waste my time and forum bandwidth, you would just go back and read the astounding number of posts you obviously missed on the first go around. But you are, you don't, and you won't.

The beauty of this is that everyone else participating in the thread can see your petulance so engaging you is infinitely worth while. :D

LOL.

Actually, your avoidance is here for all to see, right now!

Let's give the newcomers the chance to see these posts, surely you remember too where you got them from.

It is not possible for me to trawl through the thread to find something THAT IS NOT THERE. :D

Your dishonesty knows no ends mate.

Put up or shut up.
 
LOL.

Actually, your avoidance is here for all to see, right now!

Let's give the newcomers the chance to see these posts, surely you remember too where you got them from.

It is not possible for me to trawl through the thread to find something THAT IS NOT THERE. :D

Your dishonesty knows no ends mate.

Put up or shut up.

Don't you think the newcomers are smart enough to just read the thread?

I think they are. And I think they are smart enough to know that even though you pretend it isn't, my telling you that all the information you look for is right here in this thread is a citation.

I think they are also smart enough to know that your unwillingness to do your own homework and read the posts of the thread is a plea to ignorance fallacy.

Not everyone is as lazy and dishonest as you.
 
Don't you think the newcomers are smart enough to just read the thread?

Sure they are, but being the honest poster you are (snigger), I thought you would be able to find it for them (snort). I have looked and looked and guess what? I can't find it.

Given my efforts, perhaps you would do us all a favour and provide this evidence you lie claim you have. :rolleyes:

The truth is, we both know it's not there and guess what else? It is customary for people in this forum to provide their own evidence rather than ask others to find it for them; the onus is on you to produce it mate. I can't find what is not there.

But the tuth is, we all know you can't provide it because it is NONEXISTANT.
There is a quick and simple way to make me go away on this, can you guess what it is?

Put up or shut up. :)
 
Last edited:
Show me the posts or links.

Why not just admit you can't and stop the lies charade?



Theoretically it could be, in practice I don't see how; but whatever rocks your boat.

That said, your turd analogy would seem an a match made in heaven where you are concerned. :p

But once again you are making the mistake of thinking that a "power greater than yourself" (in step #2) must be a higher power, as in "God as we understood him" (in step #3); they can be completely different things.

I'm surprised you haven't picked up on that yet.

So a power greater than myself is not a higher power?

It's really your turd in the toilet that you believe in.

I'm surprised you haven't picked up on that yet.
 
So a power greater than myself is not a higher power?

It's really your turd in the toilet that you believe in.

I'm surprised you haven't picked up on that yet.

Doesn't have to be. No.



It's your HP mate not mine. And a beautiful match by the sounds of things. Actually, I tend to think that you are aiming a bit high. :p

You're the one who said anything could be a higher power.
 
Last edited:
A.A. is a cult and screws people up. Just because it's possible to act like a normal person doesn't mean it's not a cult. Just because you can make apologies for it intellectually and philosophically doesn't change the fact that it acts like a cult. Just because you had a great experience doesn't change the fact that millions have horrible experiences. Just because they can't stand being called a cult and will freak out and try and make the argument about semantics doesn't mean you should refrain from calling them a cult.

It's hard to leave A.A. for a lot of people. Deprogramming can be a very disturbing, lonely, frightening experience. They need support, and find it on the internet with other people who are now out. These people are more important than this debate. This debate isn't about the facts anymore, the debate is over. This is about apologizing for a broken system that desperately does not want to be replaced. It will be replaced because it doesn't deserve it's place in the world.

And this change is happening as we speak...

Does religion belong at AA? Fight over 'God' splits Toronto AA groups
 
You're the one who said anything could be a higher power.
Individual matter of choice; a rather odd one on your part, but whatever floats your, er, boat.

"Are you staying sober?"is the real question.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom