Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I read through the whole thread and particpated a tiny bit the first time around. Had some of my ideas changed by the arguments presented, I have to admit. My question is why you take so much seeming glee from bashing AA. Were you, or someone you know, harmed by the organization at some point?

Serious question, and I'm not trying to flame here. But the way you like to dance around and proclaim victory is kind of off-putting. It detracts from your arguments, some of which I found sound. Its almost like you'd rather be right, than do right, if you know what I mean.

I don't take any glee at bashing AA. Nor do I suggest that people give it up if they like it there and feels it helps them somehow (which I'm guessing for non-theists is the support system).

And yes, i have had personal experiences with AA. But I prefer not to argue based on personal anecdotes, as they really don't have any value; in part because of the anonymous nature of forum debating, and also because one can't really extrapolate one's personal experience and apply it generally. If I do occasionally employ an anecdote, I don't use it as evidence; I use it to help people understand the viewpoint I'm coming from.

And this is a forum that lends itself to following the evidence. In the case of AA, this means not pretending that AA is not Religious.

This is also a forum that lends itself to Verbal Combat (i.e. Debate). The best and most well supported argument wins the day. I freely admit that I enjoy having solid evidence to support my arguments. :)

And it helps to have some Mental/Emotional armour. There's not much point debating here if you can't have some fun and insult each other a bit, it's more entertaining that way. It's kill or be killed on this forum.

GB

ETA: I should also mention, there are occasionally some debaters that use such dishonest arguments, that I do indeed relish destroying their arguments. In such cases, it has little to do with AA per se, but pointing out their fallacies.
 
Last edited:
Nice evasion! If you don't believe in the (Patently Religious) 12 steps, it still begs the question of why you attend the meetings. And why you deny that it is a Religious Organization.

If you're just going because you like the support of fellow alcoholics,,just admit it. But don't pretend it's not a Religious Organization. You're only fooling yourself, not to mention that you are violating the step to be honest with yourself.

This thread has a wealth of evidence that demonstrates that AA is a Religious Organization (not the least of which are the 12 Steps themselves). And at least one member I know of quit AA to find a Secular support group because of the evidence.


GB

Where did I deny it? It's religiously based but that was not an issue for me because I'm not religious.
 
. " Were you, or someone you know, harmed by the organization at some point?"

Of course, if AA as written & practiced in the USA (where I am most familiar with it, and have attended many thousands of meetings) was completely harmless, I'd not bother a whit.
But, just as in many other cases where holding fast to false ideas - illusionary, non-existent 'truths' - has caused much harm, so to has AA been shown in actual studies to cause more harm (and help less) than not going. For instance:

1. No more people are helped by AA than would get sober on their own.
2. Non-Theist individuals have been - and in many states continue to be - forced to attend what amounts to religious indoctrination by the justice system here in the US.
3. The incidents of binge drinking - and concurrent physical harm including death - has been demonstrated to increase with AA attendance.

My and GB's previous posts in this thread have links to studies - including one by an AA Trustee - that show these things to be true. I might also be persuaded to email links to these studies on polite request, given a bit of time - but they are in this thread for all to see and evaluate for themselves.
 
Where did I deny it? It's religiously based but that was not an issue for me because I'm not religious.

I owe you an apology. I was actually answering your post mistaking it for mijopaalmc's.

So, unless you share the views of mijopaalmc, that comment does not apply to you.

GB
 
. " Were you, or someone you know, harmed by the organization at some point?"

Of course, if AA as written & practiced in the USA (where I am most familiar with it, and have attended many thousands of meetings) was completely harmless, I'd not bother a whit.
But, just as in many other cases where holding fast to false ideas - illusionary, non-existent 'truths' - has caused much harm, so to has AA been shown in actual studies to cause more harm (and help less) than not going. For instance:

1. No more people are helped by AA than would get sober on their own.
2. Non-Theist individuals have been - and in many states continue to be - forced to attend what amounts to religious indoctrination by the justice system here in the US.
3. The incidents of binge drinking - and concurrent physical harm including death - has been demonstrated to increase with AA attendance.

My and GB's previous posts in this thread have links to studies - including one by an AA Trustee - that show these things to be true. I might also be persuaded to email links to these studies on polite request, given a bit of time - but they are in this thread for all to see and evaluate for themselves.

First time around, I also noted that there are quite a few studies showing AA to have a positive impact. One was recent, and done by someone associated with Harvard - as you said, the links are back in this thread somewhere.

My point being, I don't think its a settled issue. AA is hard to study scientifically, this seems to be all the science agrees on.
 
I don't take any glee at bashing AA. Nor do I suggest that people give it up if they like it there and feels it helps them somehow (which I'm guessing for non-theists is the support system).

And yes, i have had personal experiences with AA. But I prefer not to argue based on personal anecdotes, as they really don't have any value; in part because of the anonymous nature of forum debating, and also because one can't really extrapolate one's personal experience and apply it generally. If I do occasionally employ an anecdote, I don't use it as evidence; I use it to help people understand the viewpoint I'm coming from.

And this is a forum that lends itself to following the evidence. In the case of AA, this means not pretending that AA is not Religious.

This is also a forum that lends itself to Verbal Combat (i.e. Debate). The best and most well supported argument wins the day. I freely admit that I enjoy having solid evidence to support my arguments. :)

And it helps to have some Mental/Emotional armour. There's not much point debating here if you can't have some fun and insult each other a bit, it's more entertaining that way. It's kill or be killed on this forum.

GB

ETA: I should also mention, there are occasionally some debaters that use such dishonest arguments, that I do indeed relish destroying their arguments. In such cases, it has little to do with AA per se, but pointing out their fallacies.

Thanks for answering me. :)
 
But, just as in many other cases where holding fast to false ideas - illusionary, non-existent 'truths' - has caused much harm, so to has AA been shown in actual studies to cause more harm (and help less) than not going. For instance:


Hmmm. The word harm is an interesting one you use here, yet no actual harm is proven to be done by AA.

1. No more people are helped by AA than would get sober on their own.

And? Was there a claim somewhere that AA is the only way? We require as many different types of programs for recovery as society can muster. AA is just one.

2. Non-Theist individuals have been - and in many states continue to be - forced to attend what amounts to religious indoctrination by the justice system here in the US.

While I agree that the state should not be abdicating its responsibility towards the population. How is this "harmful", as you claim? For mine AA does, or can have a religious element - no question. But there are many other facets to the diamond and exposing some to those can surely not be "harmful".

3. The incidents of binge drinking - and concurrent physical harm including death - has been demonstrated to increase with AA attendance.

And you failed to prove this previously. It might also be of interest for you to know that this is true of any sort of therapy: It will usually get worse before it gets better. So one needs to look at recovery as a whole before making nonsensical and emotive claims such as yours.
 
Last edited:
Welcome to the thread.

Thank you.

It's nice to know that yet another Atheist has chosen to ignore the fact that AA is a Religious Organization.

This is in direct contradistinction to your previous comment. Insisting that it is I who "has chosen to ignore the fact that AA is a Religious Organization" does not seem to acknowledge that you could possibly be wrong and seems to express a veiled hostility toward anything, and possibly everything, I have to say.

This is, of course, my interpretation of what you are saying, and you are more than welcome to clarify what you are saying or even contradict what I have said, but your above statement of my ignorance (i.e., the fact that you think I am ignoring something) seems incongruous with your professed desire to welcome me.

So which of the twelve steps that explicitly require you to submit yourself to God, do you not agree with?

As I stated quite clearly and explicitly, Step Two refers to "a Power greater than ourselves". Therefore, all that Step Two, and the subsequent Steps that reference "God", absolutely require is a willingness to acknowledge that there exist entities that are more powerful than humans.

It is of paramount importance here to note that absolutely none of the Steps themselves actually imbue what they call "God" with any of the characteristics that, as far as I understand, can be explicitly associated with the expressly Christian, or even, Abrahamic concept, so following them, as they are laid out at the beginning of each meeting does not mean that the atheist alcoholic must accept that "God", as referenced in the Steps, is necessarily supernatural.

And if you don't agree with them, then why bother being in AA?

Because my experience with AA thus far (I am only 18 days sober) has been one in which the conception of a PGTO is an intensely personal, though not necessarily private, affair. Thus, I am completely free to pick how I conceive of my PGTO, and anyone who tells me otherwise can go procreate with themselves.

There are any number of secular alternatives to being Religiously Indoctrinated by AA.

On a more personal note, I turned to AA because I had desocialized myself through my drinking. I would go to bars and stand in the corner while I consumed large quantities of alcohol and waited for someone to talk to me. (Somehow no matter how much I drank my social anxiety would never go away.) Finally, closer to the end of my drinking, I would simply drinking at home, and, from the moment I cracked my first beer or uncorked the wine bottle, I felt more at ease (and keep in mind I was in a self-contained environment where I was physically by myself) if I had a bottle of a glass in my hand and wouldn't stop drinking until the six-pack was gone or the bottle was empty. Therefore, AA's ready-made social support system is particularly important to me.

I fully understand that I was using alcohol as a crutch, but there is some fairly good evidence that sustained substance abuse irrevocably changes the way the neural networks in the brain (particularly the nucleus accumbens) respond to the substance of abuse and possibly other substances not only in the amount that is required to achieve the desired effect, but also in the response of those networks responds to small amounts of the substance of abuse after prolonged periods of deprivation. Therefore, I am extremely loath what I like to call Bill's Challenge:

We do not like to pronounce any individual as alcoholic, but you can quickly diagnose yourself, Step over to the nearest barroom and try some controlled drinking. Try to drink and stop abruptly. Try it more than once. It will not take long for you to decide, if you are honest with yourself about it. It may be worth a bad case of jitters if you get a full knowledge of your condition.

Alcoholics Anonymous, pp 31-32

There may come a time when I realize that I do not need to have a social support system comprised of people with whom I fundamentally disagree, but of course that is contingent upon the fact that I actually perceive them to fundamentally disagree with me. Given my personal experience with living, breathing AA's and with the local organizational structure, I do not see any explicit conflict with the Steps, as read at the beginning of the meetings, and my atheism.

As far as I understand your position, the conflict you perceive is based on a rather facile reading of the Steps. In fact, your reading seems to stop whenever and wherever you see "God" in a Step and pick up at the beginning of the next Step. As such you appear to completely miss the most important words in Step Three and Step Eleven: as we understand Him. In fact, these very words are what allow atheists to work the Steps without compromising themselves because they emphasize a supremely individual approach to recovery. As long as one can acknowledge a PGTO (and, as far as I understand, there is nothing inherent to atheism that precludes such an acknowledgement), one can work the Steps and reap their rewards. Thus, I can place my trust in the emergent properties of communities, especially ones that are single-purpose-driven, and not have to submit to a supernatural power and therefore countermand my atheism.
 
Hmmm. The word harm is an interesting one you use here, yet no actual harm is proven to be done by AA.

Actually, the harm is self evident, it's the good you have been unable to prove.

And? Was there a claim somewhere that AA is the only way?

Actually, yes. AA has made that claim for years. The choice given to alcoholics was AA or death.


While I agree that the state should not be abdicating its responsibility towards the population. How is this "harmful", as you claim? For mine AA does, or can have a religious element - no question. But there are many other facets to the diamond and exposing some to those can surely not be "harmful".

Drop the god bothering and do some research into the effectiveness of AA and no one would have much of a problem with the program. Right now it's all god bothering and ************.

And you failed to prove this previously. It might also be of interest for you to know that this is true of any sort of therapy: It will usually get worse before it gets better.

False. I had a skin fungus on my elbow last week. I applied the salve the doctor prescribed and a week later it is gone. It never got worse with the therapy the doctor recommended.
 
Actually, the harm is self evident, it's the good you have been unable to prove.

Where is it evident?
btw, I made no such assertion; dishonesty noted.

Actually, yes. AA has made that claim for years. The choice given to alcoholics was AA or death.

Where does AA say that exactly?
Page and paragraph. Weblink page, show me the line.

Lies noted.

Drop the god bothering and do some research into the effectiveness of AA and no one would have much of a problem with the program. Right now it's all god bothering and ************.

Er.. whatever. This does not seem to answer anything.

Dodge noted

False. I had a skin fungus on my elbow last week. I applied the salve the doctor prescribed and a week later it is gone. It never got worse with the therapy the doctor recommended.

Hmm. I think you are being deliberately obtuse; no-one could be that stupid. I was remarking on recovery not your fungal problems.

Dodge noted.
 
Last edited:

That's what I ask every time you make the false claim that there is some good in AA. Still waiting.

Where does AA say that?

All over their literature. For an AA guy you sure are ignorant about AA stuff. Doesn't surprise me though, most zealots are unaware of what the upper eschelon is promoting.

Er.. whatever. This does not seem to answer anything.

It wasn't meant to.

Hmm. I think you are being deliberately obtuse; no-one could be that stupid. I was remarking on recovery not your fungal problems.

Well, duh! I recovered from the fungus infection. AA is only special as a recovery program because it doesn't work and yet so many zealots cling to the fallacy. Oh, wait. Maybe it's not special. CTM doesn't work either and millions of people believe it does. Oh, and touch therapy too. Oh, acupuncture and homeopathy. . .

Okay! You've convinced me! AA is just another in a long line of BS recovery methods.
 
Can you show me where GD has moved beyond bald-faced assertion?

READ THE BLOODY THREAD!!!!! :p

GB

ETA: If after you've read the thread you still want to make the same arguments, I will have no problem telling you that your arguments are ridiculous.
 
Last edited:
Not to control my use of my drug of choice, no. I am not.

If you can't personally control it with your own mind, then the only thing which would stop it is physical restraint by a power literally greater than yourself, such as being confined against your will in a room with locks you can't break.

If you can control it by imagining or thinking about the influence of a power greater than yourself, then, well, you can control it with your own mind.

I don't see how one can get around that paradox, unless one considers that thinking about a power has a real effect that's external to one's own mind, which is usually the province of religion (such as the power of god, the power of prayer, etc.).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom