Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's still a god. You can call it anything you will but if you believe there's something invisible that's greater than yourself you're a believer in the turd in the toilet.


You see if anything can be a higher power the my "turd in a toilet" is as good as yours.

No-one said that it wasn't. It seems only to be those who arguing that one can't be an atheist and an AA that AA is saying that you can't believe that anything can be your higher power. In fact, the very imagery seems to be designed to elicit hostility from AAs because it strives to diminish their experience by comparing it to something dirty. For people who seem not to understand the power of symbolism, those arguing that AA is inherently religious seem to be awfully adept at expressing their own disgust with AA through cultural simulacra.
 
Last edited:
Except to keep you sober?

Knowing that I have a social support network to reach out to when I feel overwhelmed by life and in a situation where I want to engage in self-destructive behavior is a powerful motivator to avoid engaging in the self-destructive behavior.
 
Thanks for following the argument out to it's logical conclusion.

You're welcome. :)

To some small extent I think we were talking about two different things. I don't really subscribe to the "anything" higher power myself. I think of it as just a "greater" power than myself. Unless I consider myself the most powerful entity on the planet, a "greater" power is easy to find.

I don't speak for AA, or even all AA members. And to the point of the thread, I basically quit going to meetings a while back because of all the God stuff. It does get old, after a while. I still feel that I got value out of the program.

Maybe my experience was atypical because I was an atheist going in, maybe there are people on the fence about religion who are "converted" in AA. I don't know, its possible. I don't have any evidence at all, just personal experiences and anecdote.
 
It's a "Power greater than oneself", and it doesn't have to itself care about you or be able to literally intervene in your life.

Knowing that I have a social support network to reach out to when I feel overwhelmed by life and in a situation where I want to engage in self-destructive behavior is a powerful motivator to avoid engaging in the self-destructive behavior.


If your "power greater than your self" is just your social network how are you different than a church?
 
You're welcome. :)

To some small extent I think we were talking about two different things. I don't really subscribe to the "anything" higher power myself. I think of it as just a "greater" power than myself. Unless I consider myself the most powerful entity on the planet, a "greater" power is easy to find.

I don't speak for AA, or even all AA members. And to the point of the thread, I basically quit going to meetings a while back because of all the God stuff. It does get old, after a while. I still feel that I got value out of the program.

Maybe my experience was atypical because I was an atheist going in, maybe there are people on the fence about religion who are "converted" in AA. I don't know, its possible. I don't have any evidence at all, just personal experiences and anecdote.

There is no greater power than you.
 
For the new posters in this thread who (apparently) either refuse to read through the previous posts, or having read them continue to persist in denying AA's religious nature, here's a quick test that I myself have performed many times.

Pick any AA meeting, anywhere in the US (where I'm most familiar and where most AA members are located). Sometime during the meeting, make one or both of the following statements:

"I choose to drink when I was abusing, today I choose not to drink. My Choice"

And

"I do not need a higher power of any kind to get - and stay - sober , happy, and a valued member of society. Living in fantasy is not something I choose to do".

I've said those two statements innumerable times at thousands of AA meetings across the US for more than 2 decades. I've said it at World Conferences in front of 10's of thousands of members - I've said it at Area Conferences, Workshops, meetings of hundreds of people or just 3. In nearly every case, heavy, heavy pressure was put on me to shut up, I was threatened, publicly ridiculed, ostracized, yelled and screamed at.
At first , many years ago, it was very difficult to handle - I was only speaking the truth, yet extreme negative reactions resulted. This last decade, however, such reactions bother me not in the slightest. Many have asked me - continue to ask - if such is my view, why remain in AA? The answer should be obvious - I remain to be a living demonstration that these statements are true, that fantasy isn't necessary or desirable to get and stay sober.
And I'll continue to do so until either AA changes by radically modifying the approach it uses, or I no longer think it's worth the effort.
 
If you can't personally control it with your own mind, then the only thing which would stop it is physical restraint by a power literally greater than yourself, such as being confined against your will in a room with locks you can't break.

If you can control it by imagining or thinking about the influence of a power greater than yourself, then, well, you can control it with your own mind.

I don't see how one can get around that paradox, unless one considers that thinking about a power has a real effect that's external to one's own mind, which is usually the province of religion (such as the power of god, the power of prayer, etc.).

Wow I don't know where alll that irrelevant stuff came from,
Did I mention a higher power?

I choose not to use, do you have *********** problem with that?
 
Wow I don't know where alll that irrelevant stuff came from,
Did I mention a higher power?

I choose not to use, do you have *********** problem with that?

In the previous post, which I was replying to, you said you weren't in control of your life when it came to using the drug of your choice. Now, apparently, you're saying you are in control of it, and can simply choose not to use it.

Don't know which is true, but when you change the statement like that, yes, of course, it does make what I wrote before irrelevant.
 
In other words, the harm isn't self evident and you have no proof.

Ditto above. Not there is it?

Can you back up these lies claims or not?

Asked and answered ad nauseum. Once again, for a guy who participated in this thread for so long you are very ignorant of what has been posted. . . of course, having witnessed your willfully ignorant arguing style, I am not surprised.

You have to read, not cover your eyes and pretend it wasn't posted.

But, carry on with your delusions.
 
For mine AA does, or can have a religious element - no question.

That's a far different position than the one you have fought tooth and nail for so far in this thread.

I knew you were one of those christian counsellors! :p
 
Some key quotes from AA literature/BB, which demonstrate both the

religious nature of AA (specifically xianity), as well as it's antagonistic nature to thinking, reasoning, & logic.
Most of us here will recognize the logical fallacies & simplistic errors Bill made in designing the AA program - see how many you can spot from these quote from AA's big book core 164 pages.

"When, however, the perfectly logical assumption is suggested that underneath the material world and life as we see it, there is an All Powerful, Guiding, Creative Intelligence, right there our perverse streak comes to the surface and we laboriously set out to convince ourselves it isn't so. We read wordy books and indulge in windy arguments, thinking we believe this universe needs no God to explain it. Were our contentions true, it would follow that life originated out of nothing, means nothing, and proceeds nowhere.
Instead of regarding ourselves as intelligent agents, spearheads of God's ever advancing Creation, we agnostics and atheists chose to believe that our human intelligence was the last word, the alpha and the omega, the beginning and end of all. Rather vain of us, wasn't it?
We, who have traveled this dubious path, beg you to lay aside prejudice, even against organized religion."

"When many hundreds of people are able to say that the consciousness of the Presence of God is today the most important fact of their lives, they present a powerful reason why one should have faith."

"Arrived at this point, we were squarely confronted with the question of faith. We couldn't duck the issue. Some of us had already walked far over the Bridge of Reason toward the desired shore of faith. The outlines and the promise of the New Land had brought lustre to tired eyes and fresh courage to flagging spirits. Friendly hands had stretched out in welcome. We were grateful that Reason had brought us so far. But somehow, we couldn't quite step ashore. Perhaps we had been leaning too heavily on reason that last mile and we did not like to lose our support.
That was natural, but let us think a little more closely. Without knowing it, had we not been brought to where we stood by a certain kind of faith?"

"Imagine life without faith! Were nothing left but pure reason, it wouldn't be life. But we believed in life-of course we did. We could not prove life in the sense that you can prove a straight line is the shortest distance between two points, yet, there it was. Could we still say the whole thing was nothing but a mass of electrons, created out of nothing, meaning nothing, whirling on to a destiny of nothingness? Or course we couldn't. The electrons themselves seemed more intelligent than that. At least, so the chemist said.
Hence, we saw that reason isn't everything. Neither is reason, as most of us use it, entirely dependable"

And this dozy of a quote from Dr. Bob Smith: “If you think you are an atheist, an agnostic, a skeptic, or have any other form of intellectual pride which keeps you from accepting what is in this book, I feel sorry for you.

I could (and have - and might continue to) go on and on - it's one big mess of stupidity and inane arguments.. For AA, the key is to remember it's not a program for quitting drinking - it's a program to develop a religious outlook on life of which a side effect is (according to AA) the stopping of drinking. For those who have no experience in AA, it gets alot worse.
 
If your "power greater than your self" is just your social network how are you different than a church?

I don't posit that said social network is anything supernatural, just that it does not proceed solely from me.
 
religious nature of AA (specifically xianity), as well as it's antagonistic nature to thinking, reasoning, & logic.
Most of us here will recognize the logical fallacies & simplistic errors Bill made in designing the AA program - see how many you can spot from these quote from AA's big book core 164 pages.

"When, however, the perfectly logical assumption is suggested that underneath the material world and life as we see it, there is an All Powerful, Guiding, Creative Intelligence, right there our perverse streak comes to the surface and we laboriously set out to convince ourselves it isn't so. We read wordy books and indulge in windy arguments, thinking we believe this universe needs no God to explain it. Were our contentions true, it would follow that life originated out of nothing, means nothing, and proceeds nowhere.
Instead of regarding ourselves as intelligent agents, spearheads of God's ever advancing Creation, we agnostics and atheists chose to believe that our human intelligence was the last word, the alpha and the omega, the beginning and end of all. Rather vain of us, wasn't it?
We, who have traveled this dubious path, beg you to lay aside prejudice, even against organized religion."

"When many hundreds of people are able to say that the consciousness of the Presence of God is today the most important fact of their lives, they present a powerful reason why one should have faith."

"Arrived at this point, we were squarely confronted with the question of faith. We couldn't duck the issue. Some of us had already walked far over the Bridge of Reason toward the desired shore of faith. The outlines and the promise of the New Land had brought lustre to tired eyes and fresh courage to flagging spirits. Friendly hands had stretched out in welcome. We were grateful that Reason had brought us so far. But somehow, we couldn't quite step ashore. Perhaps we had been leaning too heavily on reason that last mile and we did not like to lose our support.
That was natural, but let us think a little more closely. Without knowing it, had we not been brought to where we stood by a certain kind of faith?"

"Imagine life without faith! Were nothing left but pure reason, it wouldn't be life. But we believed in life-of course we did. We could not prove life in the sense that you can prove a straight line is the shortest distance between two points, yet, there it was. Could we still say the whole thing was nothing but a mass of electrons, created out of nothing, meaning nothing, whirling on to a destiny of nothingness? Or course we couldn't. The electrons themselves seemed more intelligent than that. At least, so the chemist said.
Hence, we saw that reason isn't everything. Neither is reason, as most of us use it, entirely dependable"

And this dozy of a quote from Dr. Bob Smith: “If you think you are an atheist, an agnostic, a skeptic, or have any other form of intellectual pride which keeps you from accepting what is in this book, I feel sorry for you.

I could (and have - and might continue to) go on and on - it's one big mess of stupidity and inane arguments.. For AA, the key is to remember it's not a program for quitting drinking - it's a program to develop a religious outlook on life of which a side effect is (according to AA) the stopping of drinking. For those who have no experience in AA, it gets alot worse.

You know, you really need to go to an open meeting and actually talk to AAs in person; the literature will only take you so far, especially since most AAs will readily admit that there are profound problems with, for instance, The Big Book and that they do not believe every word as revealed from on high.
 
You know, you really need to go to an open meeting and actually talk to AAs in person; the literature will only take you so far, especially since most AAs will readily admit that there are profound problems with, for instance, The Big Book and that they do not believe every word as revealed from on high.

For the new posters in this thread who (apparently) either refuse to read through the previous posts, or having read them continue to persist in denying AA's religious nature, here's a quick test that I myself have performed many times.

Pick any AA meeting, anywhere in the US (where I'm most familiar and where most AA members are located). Sometime during the meeting, make one or both of the following statements:

"I choose to drink when I was abusing, today I choose not to drink. My Choice"

And

"I do not need a higher power of any kind to get - and stay - sober , happy, and a valued member of society. Living in fantasy is not something I choose to do".

I've said those two statements innumerable times at thousands of AA meetings across the US for more than 2 decades. I've said it at World Conferences in front of 10's of thousands of members - I've said it at Area Conferences, Workshops, meetings of hundreds of people or just 3. In nearly every case, heavy, heavy pressure was put on me to shut up, I was threatened, publicly ridiculed, ostracized, yelled and screamed at.
At first , many years ago, it was very difficult to handle - I was only speaking the truth, yet extreme negative reactions resulted. This last decade, however, such reactions bother me not in the slightest. Many have asked me - continue to ask - if such is my view, why remain in AA? The answer should be obvious - I remain to be a living demonstration that these statements are true, that fantasy isn't necessary or desirable to get and stay sober.
And I'll continue to do so until either AA changes by radically modifying the approach it uses, or I no longer think it's worth the effort.


Don't pay much attention do you?
 
mijopaalmc, did you not read previous posts in this thread? If you did, you'll have known I've been in AA for over 20 years, have attended more than 8000 meetings, have been in positions of authority in AA just below Trustee level, have been invited to speak at meetings all across the western USA, and continue to attend at least 2 meetings per week. How much experience do you have at various meetings compared to this? Mind revising your suggestion about what I 'really' need to do??
 
mijopaalmc, did you not read previous posts in this thread? If you did, you'll have known I've been in AA for over 20 years, have attended more than 8000 meetings, have been in positions of authority in AA just below Trustee level, have been invited to speak at meetings all across the western USA, and continue to attend at least 2 meetings per week. How much experience do you have at various meetings compared to this? Mind revising your suggestion about what I 'really' need to do??

All I can say is that my experience is completely different than your experience and that your appeal to The Big Book to establish AA's hostility to atheism does not jibe with my face-to-face experience with AAs is meetings. Moreover, the personal nature of each individual's experience is what defies the over-arching assertion "AA is a religious organization".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom