Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Well, 85 pages later, and an OED-full of intelligent debate (on the most part, at least I think so) we have reached a moot point.

My husband, who is now in hospice, is allowed to have his glass of brandy before bedtime with no arguments whatsoever.

His brain tumor will eventually render his being able to ask for this, or even swallow, an impossibility.

I do appreciate all who participated in this discussion, on all sides. Please know that it is very important to create Living Wills, also called, "Durable Power of Attorney." Please know that spending a small amount of money to get this taken care of will help later on. Please know that a quiet discussion with your loved one while he is not ill and able to make choices will be of the utmost help later on.
Thank you.
 
Well, 85 pages later, and an OED-full of intelligent debate (on the most part, at least I think so) we have reached a moot point.

My husband, who is now in hospice, is allowed to have his glass of brandy before bedtime with no arguments whatsoever.

His brain tumor will eventually render his being able to ask for this, or even swallow, an impossibility.

I do appreciate all who participated in this discussion, on all sides. Please know that it is very important to create Living Wills, also called, "Durable Power of Attorney." Please know that spending a small amount of money to get this taken care of will help later on. Please know that a quiet discussion with your loved one while he is not ill and able to make choices will be of the utmost help later on.
Thank you.

Very sorry to hear this.

Take care,

Ian
 
Well, 85 pages later, and an OED-full of intelligent debate (on the most part, at least I think so) we have reached a moot point.

My husband, who is now in hospice, is allowed to have his glass of brandy before bedtime with no arguments whatsoever.

His brain tumor will eventually render his being able to ask for this, or even swallow, an impossibility.

I do appreciate all who participated in this discussion, on all sides. Please know that it is very important to create Living Wills, also called, "Durable Power of Attorney." Please know that spending a small amount of money to get this taken care of will help later on. Please know that a quiet discussion with your loved one while he is not ill and able to make choices will be of the utmost help later on.
Thank you.

Best Wishes from me too. I'm very sorry to hear how advanced your husband's brain tumor is.

GB
 
I know this is a zombie thread now three months after the most recent post, but I would like to point out the Step Two (yes, those are capital letters) clearly states:

We [c]ame to believe that a Power greater than ourselves could restore us to sanity

While the rest of the Steps (again, with a capital letter), when the make reference to an entity other than other humans, do use "God", there is no logical necessity to assume that "God" so referenced is anything other than the "Power grater than ourselves" or that "God" is necessarily supernatural. Members are free to interpret that phrase however they want, but there is no reason to require that the phrase be an invocation of a supernatural entity.
 
Last edited:
Correct. Here, a "power greater than ourselves" could be anything. Many simply use the fellowship of AA. Some use science and medicine. It matters not what it is.
The point here is to simply acknowledge we are not in control of everything and we need help from somewhere to get our heads back.
 
Correct. Here, a "power greater than ourselves" could be anything. Many simply use the fellowship of AA. Some use science and medicine. It matters not what it is.
The point here is to simply acknowledge we are not in control of everything and we need help from somewhere to get our heads back.

You're not in control of your own life?
 
At the same time, I think that it is necessary to recognize that there is a profound tension between the prima facie contemporary reading of Step Two and the exposition of "spiritual experience" in The Big Book and that such a tension may not be resolvable through attempts to reconcile the two.

However, what some of the "AA is religious" posters seem to be disregarding is that, while there are bodies that deal with intergroup issues within AA, there is very little of what couble be thought of a analogous to "religious orthodoxy" within AA. In my personal experience, some other members have told me that there are profound flaws in The Big Book ("profoundly f'ed-up" was the phrase that was used, if I recall correctly), and I have been told to disregard parts of The Big Book that I disagree with. Moreover, when I have discussed passages of The Big Book that upset me, the people I am talking to have often come up with reinterpretations of the passages that hold very loosely to the explicit words on the page, instead favoring personal meanings. In other words, my experience with AA has been one that almost completely arises from a profoundly personal and intimate connect with whatever power greater than myself I choose instead of blind and unbending adherence to the words of "The Great and Mighty Prophet Bill W".
 
At the same time, I think that it is necessary to recognize that there is a profound tension between the prima facie contemporary reading of Step Two and the exposition of "spiritual experience" in The Big Book and that such a tension may not be resolvable through attempts to reconcile the two.

However, what some of the "AA is religious" posters seem to be disregarding is that, while there are bodies that deal with intergroup issues within AA, there is very little of what couble be thought of a analogous to "religious orthodoxy" within AA. In my personal experience, some other members have told me that there are profound flaws in The Big Book ("profoundly f'ed-up" was the phrase that was used, if I recall correctly), and I have been told to disregard parts of The Big Book that I disagree with. Moreover, when I have discussed passages of The Big Book that upset me, the people I am talking to have often come up with reinterpretations of the passages that hold very loosely to the explicit words on the page, instead favoring personal meanings. In other words, my experience with AA has been one that almost completely arises from a profoundly personal and intimate connect with whatever power greater than myself I choose instead of blind and unbending adherence to the words of "The Great and Mighty Prophet Bill W".

Welcome to the thread. It's nice to know that yet another Atheist has chosen to ignore the fact that AA is a Religious Organization.

So which of the twelve steps that explicitly require you to submit yourself to God, do you not agree with? And if you don't agree with them, then why bother being in AA?

There are any number of secular alternatives to being Religiously Indoctrinated by AA.


GB
 
Welcome to the thread. It's nice to know that yet another Atheist has chosen to ignore the fact that AA is a Religious Organization.

So which of the twelve steps that explicitly require you to submit yourself to God, do you not agree with? And if you don't agree with them, then why bother being in AA?

There are any number of secular alternatives to being Religiously Indoctrinated by AA.


GB


One alternative is to go to AA and not be religiously indoctrinated. It's not that hard.
 
One alternative is to go to AA and not be religiously indoctrinated. It's not that hard.

Nice evasion! If you don't believe in the (Patently Religious) 12 steps, it still begs the question of why you attend the meetings. And why you deny that it is a Religious Organization.

If you're just going because you like the support of fellow alcoholics,,just admit it. But don't pretend it's not a Religious Organization. You're only fooling yourself, not to mention that you are violating the step to be honest with yourself.

This thread has a wealth of evidence that demonstrates that AA is a Religious Organization (not the least of which are the 12 Steps themselves). And at least one member I know of quit AA to find a Secular support group because of the evidence.


GB
 
Oh no, not this again! <hangs head>.....
GB, do ya think these 2 posters (2 so far, anyway) have read through the entire thread, including the debates, evidence, & inferences you, I, and others have posted here to support our view that AA is a solidly religious organization?, and that (specifically) Bill W, Bob, & AA as a whole are confident that the message as written in AA material is 'you cannot recover unless you submit your life to a higher power that's indistinguishable from the xian concept of god'.?
Guess the True Believers are out in force, again - one more time GB? <g>
 
This thread has a wealth of evidence that demonstrates that AA is a Religious Organization (not the least of which are the 12 Steps themselves). And at least one member I know of quit AA to find a Secular support group because of the evidence.


You may be referring to me; if not, it still applies.

When I started reading this thread last year, it took a while before I recognized that AA has nothing that I want as far as help in coping with addiction. Camaraderie -- sometimes, sure. That's about it.

Not speaking for anyone else here; I found that I prefer allowing myself the power of choice and making a life-affirming decision every day (if necessary) to continue to choose not to use, and to continue to employ the tools that I've learned in retraining my behavior and coping mechanisms.

I feel much more free and alive and confident than I did when I recited the mantra of being "powerless over drugs/alcohol" and a having a "power greater than myself".

I couldn't reconcile the idea of being powerless over [my drug of choice] yet accepting responsibility for my actions and behaviors. Still can't reconcile that, so I instead choose to choose and be powerful in my choice AS WELL AS accepting the responsibility for sometimes poor choices.
 
Oh no, not this again! <hangs head>.....
GB, do ya think these 2 posters (2 so far, anyway) have read through the entire thread, including the debates, evidence, & inferences you, I, and others have posted here to support our view that AA is a solidly religious organization?, and that (specifically) Bill W, Bob, & AA as a whole are confident that the message as written in AA material is 'you cannot recover unless you submit your life to a higher power that's indistinguishable from the xian concept of god'.?
Guess the True Believers are out in force, again - one more time GB? <g>

Clearly they haven't read through the entire thread, or they wouldn't have offered such tepid arguments.

I really don't want to repost every argument I've made. SO, newbies to this thread, are you going to make me and Tinyal repost every post we've made? Or are you going to read through the thread and come back with better arguments?

It's well worth reading through. I know it'll take some time. But Tinyal and I are patient. We'll wait for you to catch up.

GB
 
You're not in control of your own life?

Not when I'm drinking and/or drugging I'm not.

But I think you miss part of the point. There are many things in life that one has no control over.
But here we are talking about step #2. When drinking, it is not unreasonable to consider the alcoholic insane: Does a sane person feed their addiction before they feed their kids? Clearly not. We need to be restored to sanity and a "power greater than ourselves" will help one do that, whatever that power is.

For GB, Tinya et al; they obviously are blinded by religious hatred to see there is nothing religious in step #2.
 
Last edited:
Clearly they haven't read through the entire thread, or they wouldn't have offered such tepid arguments.

I really don't want to repost every argument I've made. SO, newbies to this thread, are you going to make me and Tinyal repost every post we've made? Or are you going to read through the thread and come back with better arguments?

It's well worth reading through. I know it'll take some time. But Tinyal and I are patient. We'll wait for you to catch up.

GB

Yup! :D

Welcome back to the fun. :)

GB

I read through the whole thread and particpated a tiny bit the first time around. Had some of my ideas changed by the arguments presented, I have to admit. My question is why you take so much seeming glee from bashing AA. Were you, or someone you know, harmed by the organization at some point?

Serious question, and I'm not trying to flame here. But the way you like to dance around and proclaim victory is kind of off-putting. It detracts from your arguments, some of which I found sound. Its almost like you'd rather be right, than do right, if you know what I mean.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom