Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
The thing about Alfie having us on ignore is that he has made himself completely irrelevent to the thread. He is reduced to cheering for the drive-by postings of his friends.

A self-fulfilling prophecy, if you will. If Alfie and AlBell no longer post relevant stuff, they can no longer be proven wrong, and they can continue to claim that they weren't, to their own satisfaction.

That fully encompasses everyone, religious or non-religious. Spiritual or . . . well, okay, they have to be spiritual.

Not sure I understand/agree there.
 
You should just be grateful that your arguments haven't borne the heaps of Mockery that other promoters of Woo have been deluged with on other threads.
Ah yes, the "promoting woo" strawman again. As is the case with qayak's "arguments", it's no longer just a parade of strawmen; it's a parade of zombie strawmen.

Questioning the claim that AA is religious equates to "defending" AA, which is the same as "promoting" it. Call it "proselytizing", and you're well on your way to "proving" that AA is religious, because proselytizing is something religions do. (The beauty part of affirming the consequent is in the symmetry and consistency; do it right and it can be hard to tell which is the consequent and which is the affirmation). If the accused pleads not guilty, say for example with statements like these:
I have made no attempt to defend AA in this thread. I made my position clear twenty pages ago:
I'll state for the record that I am not here advocating AA.
...you can take one of two approaches. The first is to simply ignore it. The other, of course, is to take the denial on board as further corroborating evidence. (For tips on perfecting this technique, consult a conspiracy theorist).
 
Not sure I understand/agree there.

I'm just saying that if one is going to use a concept like, the love of their wife, the betterment of their children, the memory of their mother, etc., as their "reason" to give up drinking, it has an aspect of spirituality to it.
 
Ah yes, the "promoting woo" strawman again. As is the case with qayak's "arguments", it's no longer just a parade of strawmen; it's a parade of zombie strawmen.

Questioning the claim that AA is religious equates to "defending" AA, which is the same as "promoting" it. Call it "proselytizing", and you're well on your way to "proving" that AA is religious, because proselytizing is something religions do. (The beauty part of affirming the consequent is in the symmetry and consistency; do it right and it can be hard to tell which is the consequent and which is the affirmation). If the accused pleads not guilty, say for example with statements like these:...you can take one of two approaches. The first is to simply ignore it. The other, of course, is to take the denial on board as further corroborating evidence. (For tips on perfecting this technique, consult a conspiracy theorist).

The evidence of your continuing to post in defense of the position that AA is not Religious is Incontrovertible. Trying to pretend that you are not thus defending AA is employing your favourite tactic--Sophistry.

And perhaps you forgot that YOU were the one some pages back trying to snare me with your "do you still beat your wife?" fallacies.

GB
 
The evidence of your continuing to post in defense of the position that AA is not Religious is Incontrovertible. Trying to pretend that you are not thus defending AA is employing your favourite tactic--Sophistry.
Got it. And pretending that I am not thus promoting AA (and hence "promoting woo") would be more of the same. I was already quite confident of the accuracy of my paraphrasing of your premise: Questioning the claim that AA is religious equates to "defending" AA, which is the same as "promoting" it -- but I appreciate you confirming it anyway.
 
Got it. And pretending that I am not thus promoting AA (and hence "promoting woo") would be more of the same. I was already quite confident of the accuracy of my paraphrasing of your premise: Questioning the claim that AA is religious equates to "defending" AA, which is the same as "promoting" it -- but I appreciate you confirming it anyway.

That's not what happened though.

First you questioned whether AA was religious and used a completely made up definition to support that claim.

Then you defended the people who say AA is not religious claiming they were only using their own definition.

When I demonstrated that your defense was baseless, you switched to claiming we are persecuting you and putting words in your mouth.

Your continued sophistry, dishonesty, and defence can easily be construed as promotion.

That's a far more accurate description of how this all played out.
 
Last edited:
Regarding your last point, I couldn't agree more. I live in Australia and have made some efforts to establish an alternative support group to AA. One that incorporates its helpful aspects such as a non-judgemental attitude to the alcoholic and group support. One that makes no mention of 'higher powers' and being 'powerless'. In other words, one that makes no allowance for magical thinking. However, I have not found it easy to establish such a group. Any comments?
 
Regarding your last point, I couldn't agree more. I live in Australia and have made some efforts to establish an alternative support group to AA. One that incorporates its helpful aspects such as a non-judgemental attitude to the alcoholic and group support. One that makes no mention of 'higher powers' and being 'powerless'. In other words, one that makes no allowance for magical thinking. However, I have not found it easy to establish such a group. Any comments?

Welcome to the forum!

I mean this in no snarky manner, but I'm mildly surprised to hear that you're having troubles in Oz finding a group such as you describe, mainly based on posts from AAAlfie and several others.

I've gotten great information from the folks at LifeRing for starting a similar group where I live here in the States. They have free pdf's of pamphlets and have regularly scheduled telephone meetings for the group leaders offering assistance, advice and so on.

SOS and Rational Recovery can also help provide a format for you. There are, I think, several other resources available; you'd have to search this thread for the links provided by others, however.
 
Regarding your last point, I couldn't agree more. I live in Australia and have made some efforts to establish an alternative support group to AA. One that incorporates its helpful aspects such as a non-judgemental attitude to the alcoholic and group support. One that makes no mention of 'higher powers' and being 'powerless'. In other words, one that makes no allowance for magical thinking. However, I have not found it easy to establish such a group. Any comments?

I am not being snarky either when I say, there are two reasons that strike me as to why you are having trouble getting things underway:
- there is no need as most AA groups in Australia (that I have been to anyway) couldn't give a toss whether you believe in "magic" or not. No one bats an eyelid when someone mentions they believe on god, nor when someone says they are an atheist. No-one cares.
- there are already groups that do similar to what you are suggesting:

http://smartrecoveryaustralia.com.au/

It seems to me you are reinventing the wheel somewhat here.

May I ask why you feel the need to start something else?
 
I'm just saying that if one is going to use a concept like, the love of their wife, the betterment of their children, the memory of their mother, etc., as their "reason" to give up drinking, it has an aspect of spirituality to it.

Again, not sure I understand/agree. What's spiritual about real things like that ?
 
Got it. And pretending that I am not thus promoting AA (and hence "promoting woo") would be more of the same. I was already quite confident of the accuracy of my paraphrasing of your premise: Questioning the claim that AA is religious equates to "defending" AA, which is the same as "promoting" it -- but I appreciate you confirming it anyway.

No. Defending and promoting are not the same thing. At all, in fact.
 
Again, not sure I understand/agree. What's spiritual about real things like that ?

Simply based on the definition in my dictionary where "spiritual" refers to "intangables."

Love definitely fits the definition of intangable in that one cannot touch it and also it exist only in connection with something else. In the cases I mentioned, either your spouse or children.

In my view, this is a valid position based on the definitions of the words.

On the other hand, I can see how some people see love as being something they can touch, or that touches them, so it is not intangable. Either is valid to me.

Also, a connection of souls or minds can also be seen as spiritual. One could argue that people with the same way of thinking, the same goals, or the same purpose fit the definition. This one is a little weaker but still valid in my view.

To me, taking the words God and Higher Power out of the AA literature wouldn't affect it being spiritual at all.
 
Simply based on the definition in my dictionary where "spiritual" refers to "intangables."

Love definitely fits the definition of intangable in that one cannot touch it and also it exist only in connection with something else. In the cases I mentioned, either your spouse or children.

Hard "G" in front of "A", though ;) Intangible.

Under that definition, sure. Considering that love is definitely a result of tangible things (hormones, specifically), I don't categorize it as "intangible", myself.
 
And I'm not surprised that you limit yourself to not actually answering me.
I've decided to limit myself to not walking you through the discussion. Having trouble following the conversation? It's your problem.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom