Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
You didn't ask me to support it, you asked me if I was able to cite the post. I replied "Yes."
If you are going to limit your reponses to this sort of evasive maneuver, I see no point in attempting to engage you further.
 
If you are going to limit your reponses to this sort of evasive maneuver, I see no point in attempting to engage you further.


Wait, what? Perhaps you had an exceptionally long blink and missed this:



You didn't ask me to support it, you asked me if I was able to cite the post. I replied "Yes."

Anywhere I have ever been that is an asked and answered question. Now, if the first question was not the one you meant to ask, you are free to ask another but please stop lying about what was said.

I knew you would be hung up on that because that's what you do when you have nothing else. Let me break this down for you:

The "same" part is that we both changed definitions to make them what we need them to be to support our argument. You changed "religion" and I changed "wife beater."

The "different" part is that you used your new definition to exclude AA members in your group and I used my change to include them in mine.

Hence, the same but different.

You are correct, it was and they were shown to you. You made some long, and irrelevent, apologetic posts for them but all your arguments were destroyed by Tinyal, GB and myself, along with others who have periodically dropped into the thread.

Logic would dictate that you should be re-examining your position but you seem to think that simply repeating something that has already been debunked, will eventually make it true. (It won't by the way.)

That's ironic coming from you. You often ask for a cite that was in the very section of your post that I responded to. Alfie uses the same tactic. I know the error both you and he are making. You both want the rest of us to be wrong so much that you don't actually read and understand our statements in context, you simply hit "quote" and start typing anything that comes into your mind.

Once again, just read through your posts after GB's very informative post and you will find the citation you want. By the way, you should read those posts by GB because as, as we have heard from some of the AAers who dropped in to give their opinion, those are the posts, along with Tinyal's, that made them aware of just how religious AA is.

It's on the previous page.

And as stated before, it is just a claim there is no evidence to support it. Claiming that I don't understand the facts because I have a different view of them than you do, is special pleading.

No, when I said violating Occam's Razor in that post I was specifically referring to your practice of argument where, when someone has shown your point to be wrong, you add a bunch more assumptions, variables and contingencies which you think support it. When that too is shown wrong, you add yet more.

That has already been proved false. Your argument here is simply an invincible ignorance fallacy.



Seems like a pretty comprehensive answer to you, but hey, if you wish to bow out of the conversation, I'm sure there are no hard feelings from anyone.
 
If you are going to limit your reponses to this sort of evasive maneuver, I see no point in attempting to engage you further.

The ignore button is handy for this bloke.
Questions are rarely answered or are answered with "I already told you", when the reality is nothing usually, has ever been provided.

Wait, what? Perhaps you had an exceptionally long blink and missed this:

Seems like a pretty comprehensive answer to you, ...

:jaw-dropp

You're kidding aren't you?
 
The ignore button is handy for this bloke.
Questions are rarely answered or are answered with "I already told you", when the reality is nothing usually, has ever been provided.

The ignore button is the last resort of someone whose arguments have been thoroughly debunked and utterly demolished.

GB
 
Seems like a pretty comprehensive answer to you
Perhaps things will be clearer if we do a little unbraiding of that multi-threaded exchange:

"...you keep bringing up obscure and minor points from long gone philosophers and claiming that AAers as a group know and understand them"
"Can you quote a post where you see me doing that?"
"Yes."
"Yet you decline to do so."
"You asked if I could, not if I would."
"You make a claim. I ask you to support it. You decline..."
"You didn't ask me to support it, you asked me if I was able to cite the post. I replied "Yes."

If that's the sort of thing that you consider "comprehensive", then you and I clearly have very different standards. I don't come here to play cat and mouse with posters who brashly put words in my mouth and then suddenly wax coy when called on it.
 
(sarcasm mode on) Ouch! My sides hurt from laughing so hard (sarcasm mode off)

And guess why you are (back) on ignore and Qayak stays there. :p
 
Last edited:
I hear someone knocking.
I wonder who it is?
A fool? A troll? Someone who is plain rude? Another?

Meh, like I care.:D
 
If you are going to limit your reponses to this sort of evasive maneuver, I see no point in attempting to engage you further.

I've thought about your post for a day now and although the urge is strong to simply blow you off I have decided to take this in a little different direction:

There are two reasons I don't buy your "their own meaning" argument. The first is that you yourself do not believe it and I have never seen anyone who really believes it. Here's why.

You stated that I misused the term Occam's Razor. In order to make that statement you need to believe that there is an accepted definition for it or else, 1) your claim is wrong, or 2) you are being dishonest.

The only times I have seen anyone use a different definition for a word is 1) when they are unaware of the proper definition, 2) when the proper definition isn't convenient to their argument.

The claim of misusing Occam's Razor was an honest one on your part, no dispute there but more importantly, it was 1) based on your knowledge of the accepted definition, and 2) convenient to your argument. On the other hand, you don't use the accepted definition of religion. Is that because you don't know what it is? I don't think so because it has been posted, you are a pretty intelligent person and you have at your fingertips dictionaries to inform you. That basically only leaves that having a different definition for religion is convenient to your argument and so you reject that particular standard but not others.

The second reason I don't buy your "own meaning" argument is that it doesn't stand up to reasoning. Let's accept that AA members have their own definition for "religion." You claim that whether AA is religious or not hinges on what that definition is. This doesn't stand to reason in that many of AA's members are religious and are fully aware of what the definition of "religious" is and yet still claim AA is not religious. We have at least one such person in this thread.

For some of these people, it isn't their "own meaning" that they base their claim on, it is something else. As well, many AA members are fully aware of what "religious" means and state flat out that AA is a religious organization. Your claim doesn't account for them in that you disregard their beliefs in deciding that AA is not religious based on the claim of AA members having their own meaning.

In other words, your claim only applies to a portion of some of all AA members. Those who don't know the definition of "religious" and claim AA isn't based on that ignorance. And just because it can apply, doesn't mean it does apply. It could just as well be another reason.

But, as is often the case, the issues in this thread have become muddled. As I stated before there are two real questions,

1) Is AA a religious organization.

2) If Yes to 1, why do some people say it isn't.

To me thay are entirely different questions because one or all members opinions cannot decide if AA is religious, only evidence from the organization it self can decide.

The second question, to me, is unanswerable in that generalizations do not apply to individuals and it is impossible to poll each individual to find out their specific reason for claim AA isn't religious if it, in fact, is.

And of course, if it can be shown that AA isn't religious, the question then becomes: "Why do people claim it is?" That is the point the Girl Guides of Canada got to. They were not a religious organization and yet, when asked, everyone thought they were because of the words in their literature. They removed the words.

Which leads be back to one of my first points, if everything hinges on "own meanings" what difference do the words make? Everyone is applying their own meaning anyway. To me, the answer is simple. Remove the words "God" and "Higher Power" and replace them with "a reason strong enough for you to change" or some such.

That fully encompasses everyone, religious or non-religious. Spiritual or . . . well, okay, they have to be spiritual. :D

That pretty much sums up my position and as nothing in this thread has provided any reason strong enough for me to change :p that position, I will be holdng onto it for at least awhile.

And, in closing, I would like to thank you for the discussion, productive and non-productive, that we have had in this thread. Even if I haven't changed my position too much, I have a better understanding of your position.

ETA: I think the reason many religious people think AA is spiritual but not religious is because of their religion. They believe they can see how AA can work even if one is not religious and so, for them, that means it isn't religious. Their mistake is an error of perspective. They do not realize that it is their religious beliefs that lead them to that conclusion and that it only applies to their very biased perspective.
 
Last edited:
Ouch! My feelings are so hurt! :)

GB

The thing about Alfie having us on ignore is that he has made himself completely irrelevent to the thread. He is reduced to cheering for the drive-by postings of his friends.

I know that really hurts my feelings. :D
 
Let's accept that AA members have their own definition for "religion."
You mean: let's accept that as if it really were what I'm arguing, and continue to ignore numerous posts like this one:
They are using commonly accepted definitions of those words to express the idea that AA is not a religious organization.
...in which I have argued precisely the opposite?

Here's what I can accept: That no matter how many times or how many ways I restate my position you'll continue to misconstrue it, and that no matter how many times I offer to provide clarification on something you think I said you'll continue to decline those offers by refusing to reference or quote specific posts. I can accept that you will continue to treat dictionary definitions as if they were intended not merely as basic guides to usage but comprehensive treatises on the meanings of words, prescriptively and exclusively authoritative -- and that you will continue to express this ignorance in posts like this:
On the other hand, you don't use the accepted definition of religion. Is that because you don't know what it is?
...in which you draw yet another mistaken conclusion from what I've been saying, oblivious to the fact that my claim that "religious" has specific, shared, supernatural beliefs as necessary and sufficient conditions is a claim regarding the commonly accepted meaning of that word.

I hope you can accept that the parade of strawmen has begun to bore me.
 
You mean: let's accept that as if it really were what I'm arguing, and continue to ignore numerous posts like this one:...in which I have argued precisely the opposite?

Here's what I can accept: That no matter how many times or how many ways I restate my position you'll continue to misconstrue it, and that no matter how many times I offer to provide clarification on something you think I said you'll continue to decline those offers by refusing to reference or quote specific posts. I can accept that you will continue to treat dictionary definitions as if they were intended not merely as basic guides to usage but comprehensive treatises on the meanings of words, prescriptively and exclusively authoritative -- and that you will continue to express this ignorance in posts like this:...in which you draw yet another mistaken conclusion from what I've been saying, oblivious to the fact that my claim that "religious" has specific, shared, supernatural beliefs as necessary and sufficient conditions is a claim regarding the commonly accepted meaning of that word.

I hope you can accept that the parade of strawmen has begun to bore me.

Thus spake the Master of Sophistry.

You've been all over the map redefining terms whenever they didn't suit your argument. You have created all your own straw men to tilt at while others have provided evidence.

You should just be grateful that your arguments haven't borne the heaps of Mockery that other promoters of Woo have been deluged with on other threads.

GB
 
You mean: let's accept that as if it really were what I'm arguing, and continue to ignore numerous posts like this one:...in which I have argued precisely the opposite?

Ummmm . . . No. I mean let's accept it for a moment, even though I don't agree with it, for the purpose of making a couple of points.

Here's what I can accept: That no matter how many times or how many ways I restate my position you'll continue to misconstrue it, and that no matter how many times I offer to provide clarification on something you think I said you'll continue to decline those offers by refusing to reference or quote specific posts. I can accept that you will continue to treat dictionary definitions as if they were intended not merely as basic guides to usage but comprehensive treatises on the meanings of words, prescriptively and exclusively authoritative -- and that you will continue to express this ignorance in posts like this:...in which you draw yet another mistaken conclusion from what I've been saying, oblivious to the fact that my claim that "religious" has specific, shared, supernatural beliefs as necessary and sufficient conditions is a claim regarding the commonly accepted meaning of that word.

I hope you can appreciate that from the very moment you have made the claim, which I have bolded, I rejected it with evidence and logic.

I hope you can accept that the parade of strawmen has begun to bore me.

Well, if I am that much mistaken about your position, we must be in complete agreement that AA is a religious organization and AAers have a miriad of reasons for claiming it isn't with only a very few being because they have their own definition of what religion means and the vast majority being because of indoctrination, group think, herd mentality, dishonesty, lack of knowledge of AA, etc.

Makes me wonder why you keep arguing instead of just admitting that Tinyal, GB, The Norseman, myself, et al, have been right all along.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom