Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why don't you start by showing "my own" semantic arguments ?
You mean like I JUST did, only a few posts up? Are you lost again, or just pretending to be? Here it is again, with bolding:
Though it does little to address that point, your response:
So in other words, "religious" is a subset of "spiritual".
is one that I do not necessarily disagree with; but my purpose in bringing it back up is to remind you that you yourself have been just as much a participant as I have in the exercises in semantics which constitute the bulk of this thread. And as I stated in an earlier response to qayak (post #3099), what I most object to is that you do it so badly.


As an added bonus, I'll offer the following quote because I believe it represents the first clear example of a purely semantic argument on your part (and not out of a desire to further the "disease model" derail). By my count, it is the eighth post you made to the thread since you first entered the discussion on page seven:
If Alcoholism is a disease then so is every hobby when it becomes addictive. The definition of disease becomes so vague as to be unusable and meaningless.


And, what the heck, here are some more, selected more or less at random:

"Self" is just a grammatical reference to "you" or whoever we're talking about.
When I tell someone "do it yourself", does that refer to some small part of his conscious mind, or some chimera of human belief systems, or simply to the bag of flesh I'm talking to ?
But I want to avoid having a term so vague as to be impossible to use in a conversation.
"Higher than yourself" in French would be quite different...
I noted that the first two definitions were clearer; but the third one does NOT contradict what I claimed.
Tell you what: why don't we simply NOT try to define "religious", go with the definitions from the dictionary, and explain why people insist that AA is not religious ?
Well, if it's not specific it's because of people who constantly redefine terms into uselessness.
AA is religious under ALL the definitions you've given.
You can't support a definition with logic and reason, because definitions are, by definition, arbitrary.

Whether you recognize them as such or not, all of these are semantic arguments. Is that enough to make the point? Because with a little more effort, I believe I could find a great many more. Like I said, it's the bulk of the thread.
 
You mean like I JUST did, only a few posts up? Are you lost again, or just pretending to be? Here it is again, with bolding:

You know, your petulant child attitude is getting quite amusing.

If by acknowledging that one is a subset of another by the definition already given by someone else is a semantics argument, then I guess sneezing is one, too.

As an added bonus, I'll offer the following quote because I believe it represents the first clear example of a purely semantic argument on your part

As I already said, then, even assuming we could call those semantics arguments, at least I'm trying to pinpoint a definition we can both use. You're trying to AVOID it.

Whether you recognize them as such or not, all of these are semantic arguments.

No, they're not. Not all of them, anyway. It's a shame you can't see it, but since you can't, there's no way in explaining all of the thread to you another time.
 
[Delurks]

Just wondering if Dymanic is ready to start discussing factual evidence yet.

Nope....still playing semantic, sophistic, fallacious word games I see.

[Relurks]

GB
 
If by acknowledging that one is a subset of another by the definition already given by someone else is a semantics argument, then I guess sneezing is one, too.
See, here's the very thing. When I discuss definitions (subsets of definitions, etc), it's "playing word games" -- but when you do that, it's legitimate. That IS what you're claiming, is it not? I'm challenging you to support this claim with some kind of reasoning.

As I already said, then, even assuming we could call those semantics arguments, at least I'm trying to pinpoint a definition we can both use. You're trying to AVOID it.
I'm glad to see that you might be willing to consider there to be at least some legitimate basis for examining the meanings of the words we're using; I simply question your implied claim to be somehow privileged in that regard.

As for definitions "we both" can use, I see a problem there, because our purposes here are clearly not the same. As I've stated several times, this discussion is one of two things (determined subjectively): Either it's an investigation, or it's a rant. The OP clearly had her mind made up at the outset: AA IS religious, and those who claim otherwise are lying. Along comes you, and qayak, and GB, and some others, and with that communal reinforcement, it quickly becomes a page right out of a pop-psych classic -- a stimulating round of "Ain't It Awful". Am I wrong? Have you ever had any sincere hope of gaining a better understanding of anything through participation in this discussion? What for, if you've already got it pegged, right?

So when you say you're trying to pinpoint definitions we both can use, that's not really true, is it? You're trying to pinpoint definitions YOU can use. Interestingly enough, that happens to be precisely what you are accusing me of doing, despite my having repeatedly pointed out that I am not trying to define any of these terms in any special way, but instead recommending that we defer to common usage.

And so, when I once again reiterate my position -- that the simplest explanation for the phenomenon observed by the OP is that these people who say that AA is not religious, or that it is "spiritual but not religious" are simply saying that their experience with AA does not fit the definition of the word "religious" as THEY understand the meaning of that word in common usage, but that it does fit the definition of "spiritual" as they understand THAT -- will you continue to claim that this is ME redefining terms?

No, they're not. Not all of them, anyway.
Which ones do you think are not? Is it possible that the irony here could extend to us not sharing the same understanding of the meaning of the word, "semantics"?
 
See, here's the very thing. When I discuss definitions (subsets of definitions, etc), it's "playing word games" -- but when you do that, it's legitimate. That IS what you're claiming, is it not? I'm challenging you to support this claim with some kind of reasoning.

I'm glad to see that you might be willing to consider there to be at least some legitimate basis for examining the meanings of the words we're using; I simply question your implied claim to be somehow privileged in that regard.

As for definitions "we both" can use, I see a problem there, because our purposes here are clearly not the same. As I've stated several times, this discussion is one of two things (determined subjectively): Either it's an investigation, or it's a rant. The OP clearly had her mind made up at the outset: AA IS religious, and those who claim otherwise are lying. Along comes you, and qayak, and GB, and some others, and with that communal reinforcement, it quickly becomes a page right out of a pop-psych classic -- a stimulating round of "Ain't It Awful". Am I wrong? Have you ever had any sincere hope of gaining a better understanding of anything through participation in this discussion? What for, if you've already got it pegged, right?

So when you say you're trying to pinpoint definitions we both can use, that's not really true, is it? You're trying to pinpoint definitions YOU can use. Interestingly enough, that happens to be precisely what you are accusing me of doing, despite my having repeatedly pointed out that I am not trying to define any of these terms in any special way, but instead recommending that we defer to common usage.

And so, when I once again reiterate my position -- that the simplest explanation for the phenomenon observed by the OP is that these people who say that AA is not religious, or that it is "spiritual but not religious" are simply saying that their experience with AA does not fit the definition of the word "religious" as THEY understand the meaning of that word in common usage, but that it does fit the definition of "spiritual" as they understand THAT -- will you continue to claim that this is ME redefining terms?

Which ones do you think are not? Is it possible that the irony here could extend to us not sharing the same understanding of the meaning of the word, "semantics"?

[Delurks]

The whole problem with nearly all of your posts, is that you are determined to avoid, obfuscate, conflate, or simply deny the definitions of words with the intent of denying the obvious.

Thus your efforts to obscure actual words with actual definitions like GOD (a Deity) and the clear admonitions in the Steps (and the Big Book) that to ask the Deity to remove one's "defects of character and Shortcomings" and subsume one's will to the Deity's Will as the way to achieve sobriety, are an exercise in denial because you simply don't like the fact that the primary definitions blow your arguments to smithereens.

It is clear to anyone reading the Steps that YOU, not Belz, nor Qayak, nor myself is engaging in redefining terms.

And just in case anyone newly browsing this thread wonders what you are attempting to redefine to suit your agenda, here again are the 12 Steps. Any non-theist who is not a devoted member of AA will recognize the clear Theistic statements that you are attempting to (and failing miserably at) redefine to suit YOUR own purposes.

Service Material from the General Service Office
THE TWELVE STEPS OF ALCOHOLICS ANONYMOUS

1. We admitted we were powerless over alcohol—that our lives had become
unmanageable.

2. Came to believe that a Power greater than ourselves could restore us to
sanity.

3. Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we
understood Him.

4. Made a searching and fearless moral inventory of ourselves.

5. Admitted to God, to ourselves, and to another human being the exact nature of our wrongs.

6. Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character.

7. Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings.

8. Made a list of all persons we had harmed, and became willing to make
amends to them all.

9. Made direct amends to such people wherever possible, except when to do
so would injure them or others.

10. Continued to take personal inventory and when we were wrong promptly
admitted it.

11. Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with God, as we understood Him, praying only for knowledge of His will for us
and the power to carry that out.

12. Having had a spiritual awakening as the result of these Steps, we tried to
carry this message to alcoholics, and to practice these principles in all our
affairs.

In context with the actual Steps, it is very clear that YOU are the one playing semantic word-games (and not very convincingly at that).


GB

[Relurks]
 
Last edited:
It is clear to anyone reading the Steps that YOU, not Belz, nor Qayak, nor myself is engaging in redefining terms.
It is clear that Belz is not capable of arguing this point without assistance, so your continued loyalty is admirable. Unfortunately, your effort is also inadequate, and here's why:

First, I'll ask you to have a quick look at this Wikipedia article and see if you agree that the phrase, "It is clear to anyone reading X" qualifies as one "aimed at creating an impression that something specific and meaningful has been said, when in fact only a vague or ambiguous claim has been communicated." Then read the rest of what you posted and ask yourself whether you think the authors of that article would find it to contain anything not vague and ambiguous.

Second, because it appears that you still don't grasp what I've been saying, I'll ask you to review yet again the following paragraph, paying particular attention to the bolded parts:
And so, when I once again reiterate my position -- that the simplest explanation for the phenomenon observed by the OP is that these people who say that AA is not religious, or that it is "spiritual but not religious" are simply saying that their experience with AA does not fit the definition of the word "religious" as THEY understand the meaning of that word in common usage, but that it does fit the definition of "spiritual" as THEY understand THAT -- will you continue to claim that this is ME redefining terms?
 
[Delurks]

The whole problem with nearly all of your posts, is that you are determined to avoid, obfuscate, conflate, or simply deny the definitions of words with the intent of denying the obvious.

Thus your efforts to obscure actual words with actual definitions like GOD (a Deity) and the clear admonitions in the Steps (and the Big Book) that to ask the Deity to remove one's "defects of character and Shortcomings" and subsume one's will to the Deity's Will as the way to achieve sobriety, are an exercise in denial because you simply don't like the fact that the primary definitions blow your arguments to smithereens.

It is clear to anyone reading the Steps that YOU, not Belz, nor Qayak, nor myself is engaging in redefining terms.

And just in case anyone newly browsing this thread wonders what you are attempting to redefine to suit your agenda, here again are the 12 Steps. Any non-theist who is not a devoted member of AA will recognize the clear Theistic statements that you are attempting to (and failing miserably at) redefine to suit YOUR own purposes.



In context with the actual Steps, it is very clear that YOU are the one playing semantic word-games (and not very convincingly at that).


GB

[Relurks]



I am new to the thread and see the theistic statements. But isn't Dymanic referring not to his understanding or reading of those words but to other people's way of understanding the steps?

Frankly, lots of folks simply don't pay attention to the literal meaning of words in their daily actions.

I haven't read much of this thread, but can I ask a simple question -- is this one of those "you aren't in AA unless you are an AA fundamentalist" type of arguments?
 
I am new to the thread and see the theistic statements. But isn't Dymanic referring not to his understanding or reading of those words but to other people's way of understanding the steps?

Frankly, lots of folks simply don't pay attention to the literal meaning of words in their daily actions.

I haven't read much of this thread, but can I ask a simple question -- is this one of those "you aren't in AA unless you are an AA fundamentalist" type of arguments?

No, this is a "Why can't you just admit it's Religious type of argument." Of course Atheists can go to AA meetings and create internal justifications to gloss over the religious language. That has never actually been in question.

What has been in question is whether those internal justifications can be used to invalidate the fact that AA is a religious organization; anymore than a Catholic or Baptist or Unitarian Universalist who attends Church every Sunday who does't take everything literally invalidates the fact that those Churches are Religious Organizations.

One cannot judge a Religious Organization by how many people do or do not take the texts literally. Thus one can only empirically determine the Religious nature of an Organization by it's Core Texts. The 12 Steps and the Big Book are the Core Texts of AA.

It is claimed that the Steps are only "Suggestions," yet that claim carries with it the "suggestion" that if you don't follow the Steps then you will not obtain the full "benefits" of AA, and it is clearly stated in the 12 Steps and the Big Book that only God can save the Alcoholic.

So no matter how many internal logical back-flips a non-theist AA member has to do to "make AA work for him or herself," AA will continue to be a Religious Organization until they adopt non-theistic language for the 12 Steps and Dump the Big Book as an Ancient Relic of no importance.

Dymanic's argument has thus been to deny, conflate, and obfuscate the meanings of words because that is the only way he can justify being a non-theist in a Religious Organization. And he also hopes that by doing so he will convince other non-theists that AA is not a Religious Organization, when in fact the opposite is true.

The arguments he uses are no doubt similar to the arguments lawyers in courts have used to defend the Judicial remanding of non-theist Alcoholics to AA. Yet a number of Circuit Courts of Appeals have determined, just as I have, that AA is indeed a Religious Organization. And the US Supreme Court has let stand these decisions.

If you bother to skim through this thread and read Tinyal's and my posts, you will find a wealth of Factual Historical Evidence to back up these claims.

The Doctor's Opinion in the Preamble to the Big Book was written by Dr Silkworth, a Christian who believed that only Christ, "The Great Physician" as he called Jesus, could save the Alcoholic. Bill W, a Protestant Christian, also picked up on this phraseology. The Reverend Shoemaker was also integral to the founding of AA. Dr Bob Smith, another founder of AA was also a Protestant Christian.

Many of these founders had connections and/or relationships with the Protestant Norman Vincent Peale, who also managed to mainstream and Semi-Universalize Protestant Christian Doctrines with books like "The Power of Positive Thinking"--now a staple in New Age circles.

AA grew out of--and borrowed many of the Religious Concepts from--the Oxford Group, which was a Religious Organization.

Passages in the 12 Steps and the Big Book were later slightly amended to attempt to Universalize the Religious Language (rather poorly I might add due to the retention of numerous references to a Supernatural Male Monotheistic Deity as Heavenly Father, Father, Father of Light, God of our Fathers, Almighty God, numerous references to God as Him (with a capitalized H) and God's Will, or His Will in the Big book and the 12 Steps; altogether about 400 references. These are all Christian references to God); however even a Semi-Universalized Male Deity to whom one must submit one's own will to is still a Supernatural Male Deity. Ergo AA is a Religious Organization.

Thus the claim that Dymanic makes above...
First, I'll ask you to have a quick look at this Wikipedia article and see if you agree that the phrase, "It is clear to anyone reading X" qualifies as one "aimed at creating an impression that something specific and meaningful has been said, when in fact only a vague or ambiguous claim has been communicated." Then read the rest of what you posted and ask yourself whether you think the authors of that article would find it to contain anything not vague and ambiguous.
...is an utter falsehood.

My claims have never been vague and ambiguous, but clear, to the point, and based on textual and historical evidence and the Primary Definitions of the terminology used. In fact it is Dymanic who is deliberately being vague and ambiguous. He is projecting his OWN Epistemological arguments on to me, in order to obfuscate, or conflate Ontological distinctions.

The argument that AA is "Spiritual but not Religious" is false. AA is Religious, and as Religious is clearly Spiritual, the correct phraseology should be "AA is Religious, thus it is also Spiritual."

Now there is nothing wrong with non-theists belonging to a Religious Organization. I have never claimed that. I have also never claimed that some non-theists could find ways to make it work for them (though they would also have to make similar internal logical pretzels, or ignore the Religious Language and Doctrines in order to do so).

What I HAVE stated (based on the evidence) is that claiming to others that AA is not Religious is sheer pretense.

Again, I recommend finding Tinyal's and my posts in this thread which actually provide numerous sources of evidence to back up my above statements.

GB
 
Last edited:
I haven't read much of this thread, but can I ask a simple question -- is this one of those "you aren't in AA unless you are an AA fundamentalist" type of arguments?


To be fair, this point has been brought up, but only tangentially.





No, this is a "Why can't you just admit it's Religious type of argument." Of course ...

*snip*


Nominated! Excellent summation, GB!
 
The Norseman said:
No, this is a "Why can't you just admit it's Religious type of argument." Of course ...

*snip*


Nominated! Excellent summation, GB!
Excellent talking point which has been beaten into small fragments of wrongness, anyway. :)

Someone should pray for several of you to eventually notice AA is not religious; either that or dump it into the same pot where you declare JREF to be atheist.
 
Dymanic;6671676[HILITE said:
]It is clear that Belz is not capable of arguing this point [/HILITE]without assistance, so your continued loyalty is admirable. Unfortunately, your effort is also inadequate, and here's why:

First, I'll ask you to have a quick look at this Wikipedia article and see if you agree that the phrase, "It is clear to anyone reading X" qualifies as one "aimed at creating an impression that something specific and meaningful has been said, when in fact only a vague or ambiguous claim has been communicated." Then read the rest of what you posted and ask yourself whether you think the authors of that article would find it to contain anything not vague and ambiguous.

Second, because it appears that you still don't grasp what I've been saying, I'll ask you to review yet again the following paragraph, paying particular attention to the bolded parts:

Continuing to accuse others of not understanding your posts would seem to indicate a lack of communication ability on your part.
 
Last edited:
Of course Atheists can go to AA meetings and create internal justifications to gloss over the religious language. That has never actually been in question.
It's been pretty clear all along that your own biased preconceptions have never been in question -- not by you.

What has been in question is whether those internal justifications can be used to invalidate the fact that AA is a religious organization; anymore than a Catholic or Baptist or Unitarian Universalist who attends Church every Sunday who does't take everything literally invalidates the fact that those Churches are Religious Organizations.
You never have grasped the argument, and still don't. A person saying that they do not take those religious doctrines literally is not the same thing as a person saying that the organizations are not religious. Is it often heard said that those churches are not religious? (Or "spiritual, but not religious"?) Oh, wait, I'll bet I know the answer: "Already addressed innmumerable times".

AA is Religious, and as Religious is clearly Spiritual, the correct phraseology should be "AA is Religious, thus it is also Spiritual."
Oh, so now we're back to "Religious is clearly Spiritual"? I don't see what good it does you to learn stuff if you're going to turn right around and forget it -- but then, you never really were here to learn anything, were you?

Let's review anyway. Who knows, maybe the lesson will stick a little longer this time:
I have previously stated in posts that the distinctions between Spiritual and Religious are too fuzzy to clearly distinguish between them.

Further investigation has demonstrated that I was wrong:

One CAN make certain Distinctions between Religious and Spiritual, insofar as Religious is a subset of Spiritual.
"Religious is a subset of Spiritual" is another way of saying that not everything that is spiritual is religious, correct? Just like: not all mammals are dogs, though all dogs are mammals? While we're at it, would you care to state whether you regard the above quoted material as constituting semantic arguments?
 
Continuing to accuse others of not understanding your posts would seem to indicate a lack of communication ability on your part.
Always the first thing I consider -- but I'm also aware that it is not the only possible explanation.

Are you by any chance familiar with the term "pragmatic competence" as it is used in linguistics?

And do YOU find that paragraph particularly difficult to parse?
 
Originally Posted by tsig View Post
Continuing to accuse others of not understanding your posts would seem to indicate a lack of communication ability on your part.


Always the first thing I consider -- but I'm also aware that it is not the only possible explanation.

Are you by any chance familiar with the term "pragmatic competence" as it is used in linguistics?

And do YOU find that paragraph particularly difficult to parse?

delete
 
Last edited:
No, this is a "Why can't you just admit it's Religious type of argument." Of course Atheists can go to AA meetings and create internal justifications to gloss over the religious language. That has never actually been in question.

What has been in question is whether those internal justifications can be used to invalidate the fact that AA is a religious organization; anymore than a Catholic or Baptist or Unitarian Universalist who attends Church every Sunday who does't take everything literally invalidates the fact that those Churches are Religious Organizations.

One cannot judge a Religious Organization by how many people do or do not take the texts literally. Thus one can only empirically determine the Religious nature of an Organization by it's Core Texts. The 12 Steps and the Big Book are the Core Texts of AA.

It is claimed that the Steps are only "Suggestions," yet that claim carries with it the "suggestion" that if you don't follow the Steps then you will not obtain the full "benefits" of AA, and it is clearly stated in the 12 Steps and the Big Book that only God can save the Alcoholic.

So no matter how many internal logical back-flips a non-theist AA member has to do to "make AA work for him or herself," AA will continue to be a Religious Organization until they adopt non-theistic language for the 12 Steps and Dump the Big Book as an Ancient Relic of no importance.

Dymanic's argument has thus been to deny, conflate, and obfuscate the meanings of words because that is the only way he can justify being a non-theist in a Religious Organization. And he also hopes that by doing so he will convince other non-theists that AA is not a Religious Organization, when in fact the opposite is true.

The arguments he uses are no doubt similar to the arguments lawyers in courts have used to defend the Judicial remanding of non-theist Alcoholics to AA. Yet a number of Circuit Courts of Appeals have determined, just as I have, that AA is indeed a Religious Organization. And the US Supreme Court has let stand these decisions.

If you bother to skim through this thread and read Tinyal's and my posts, you will find a wealth of Factual Historical Evidence to back up these claims.

The Doctor's Opinion in the Preamble to the Big Book was written by Dr Silkworth, a Christian who believed that only Christ, "The Great Physician" as he called Jesus, could save the Alcoholic. Bill W, a Protestant Christian, also picked up on this phraseology. The Reverend Shoemaker was also integral to the founding of AA. Dr Bob Smith, another founder of AA was also a Protestant Christian.

Many of these founders had connections and/or relationships with the Protestant Norman Vincent Peale, who also managed to mainstream and Semi-Universalize Protestant Christian Doctrines with books like "The Power of Positive Thinking"--now a staple in New Age circles.

AA grew out of--and borrowed many of the Religious Concepts from--the Oxford Group, which was a Religious Organization.

Passages in the 12 Steps and the Big Book were later slightly amended to attempt to Universalize the Religious Language (rather poorly I might add due to the retention of numerous references to a Supernatural Male Monotheistic Deity as Heavenly Father, Father, Father of Light, God of our Fathers, Almighty God, numerous references to God as Him (with a capitalized H) and God's Will, or His Will in the Big book and the 12 Steps; altogether about 400 references. These are all Christian references to God); however even a Semi-Universalized Male Deity to whom one must submit one's own will to is still a Supernatural Male Deity. Ergo AA is a Religious Organization.

Thus the claim that Dymanic makes above...

...is an utter falsehood.

My claims have never been vague and ambiguous, but clear, to the point, and based on textual and historical evidence and the Primary Definitions of the terminology used. In fact it is Dymanic who is deliberately being vague and ambiguous. He is projecting his OWN Epistemological arguments on to me, in order to obfuscate, or conflate Ontological distinctions.

The argument that AA is "Spiritual but not Religious" is false. AA is Religious, and as Religious is clearly Spiritual, the correct phraseology should be "AA is Religious, thus it is also Spiritual."

Now there is nothing wrong with non-theists belonging to a Religious Organization. I have never claimed that. I have also never claimed that some non-theists could find ways to make it work for them (though they would also have to make similar internal logical pretzels, or ignore the Religious Language and Doctrines in order to do so).

What I HAVE stated (based on the evidence) is that claiming to others that AA is not Religious is sheer pretense.

Again, I recommend finding Tinyal's and my posts in this thread which actually provide numerous sources of evidence to back up my above statements.

GB



I don't know. I know that AA was conceived within a particular religious context and is bathed in religious language, but I'm not in AA and hopefully will never need its services. I have no way to determine if it is currently a religious organization; things do change over time. I would assume, however, that any particular meeting group could be either religiously based or not depending on how it was run and what the members of that particularly meeting group might want, and that might sway any particular person's opinion of the group as a whole. I imagine the opposite probably occurs more often, however -- that group leaders use their religion as part of the process.

I will certainly read yours and Tinyal's posts since I have always held you in great respect. I don't know Tinyal but may feel the same about him or her.


ETA:

OK, I've looked through a bit of this thread, enough to see that it's largely a pissing match with people spending quite a bit of time commenting on others. I don't respond much to others in this forum when they start to show that behavior, so I think I'll just move along. Good luck to you all. Tinyal, if you are still reading this thread, your posts are heart felt and very moving. Keep on keepin' on and I wish you the best of luck.
 
Last edited:
See, here's the very thing. When I discuss definitions (subsets of definitions, etc), it's "playing word games" -- but when you do that, it's legitimate. That IS what you're claiming, is it not? I'm challenging you to support this claim with some kind of reasoning.

Dymanic, I can't believe you're not smart enough to understand what I've been saying for several posts, now: namely that we're NOT doing the same thing. Or perhaps you're ignoring what I'm posting because you choose to believe that we are.

Which ones do you think are not? Is it possible that the irony here could extend to us not sharing the same understanding of the meaning of the word, "semantics"?

:rolleyes:

I've been asking you to return to the topic for several pages, now, and here you are, creating an endless loop by suggesting we discuss the semantics of the word semantics. I wonder why we've drifted so far off course, but it seems to me like you don't want to go back there.
 
OK, I've looked through a bit of this thread, enough to see that it's largely a pissing match with people spending quite a bit of time commenting on others. I don't respond much to others in this forum when they start to show that behavior, so I think I'll just move along. Good luck to you all. Tinyal, if you are still reading this thread, your posts are heart felt and very moving. Keep on keepin' on and I wish you the best of luck.

I'd like to be the first to admit that Dymanic pisses way farther than I do. Unfortunately this is about AA's religiosity, so I won't feel to inadequate by his antics.

Now, if we could only get back on topic, somehow...
 
I'd like to be the first to admit that Dymanic pisses way farther than I do.
Actually, no. His is like a laser beam and on target; the rest are more like shotguns loaded with birdshot pointed in random directions.
 
I can't believe you're not smart enough to understand what I've been saying for several posts, now: namely that we're NOT doing the same thing.
I understand perfectly well that you've been saying that we're not doing the same thing. That was implicit in each of your repeated assertions that my arguments are based on twisting definitions, etc. I also understand that YOU understand that what I'm challenging you to do is to support that claim by showing why your arguments are different -- rather than continuing to do what you're doing, which is simply to repeat the assertion.

I've been asking you to return to the topic for several pages, now, and here you are, creating an endless loop by suggesting we discuss the semantics of the word semantics.
What I'm suggesting is that you answer the question: Which of the above quotes (taken from your earlier posts) are -- as you have claimed -- NOT semantic arguments? (And I'll be happy to repost the list of quotes if you can't find them).

It is true that in attempting to answer that question (in the unlikely event that you should actually choose to make that effort), it will be hard to avoid some consideration of the meaning of the word "semantics" -- and while there is, yes, a certain recursive quality to that, it's certainly not an endless loop.

In the sense you clearly have in mind, "semantics" is a bad thing. It refers only to a weak form of argument; either a foray into trivialities or a deliberate exploiting of ambiguities in the meanings of words. I wonder if you are even aware of the importance of semantics as a subfield of linguistics -- the scientific study of language -- or the tremendous amount of material that exists on the subject.

The OP's question goes directly to the specific uses of specific words in specific social contexts. That IS the topic, Belz, and it happens to be the very thing the study of semantics is concerned with.
 
I understand perfectly well that you've been saying that we're not doing the same thing. That was implicit in each of your repeated assertions that my arguments are based on twisting definitions, etc. I also understand that YOU understand that what I'm challenging you to do is to support that claim by showing why your arguments are different -- rather than continuing to do what you're doing, which is simply to repeat the assertion.

What I'm suggesting is that you answer the question: Which of the above quotes (taken from your earlier posts) are -- as you have claimed -- NOT semantic arguments? (And I'll be happy to repost the list of quotes if you can't find them).

It is true that in attempting to answer that question (in the unlikely event that you should actually choose to make that effort), it will be hard to avoid some consideration of the meaning of the word "semantics" -- and while there is, yes, a certain recursive quality to that, it's certainly not an endless loop.

In the sense you clearly have in mind, "semantics" is a bad thing. It refers only to a weak form of argument; either a foray into trivialities or a deliberate exploiting of ambiguities in the meanings of words. I wonder if you are even aware of the importance of semantics as a subfield of linguistics -- the scientific study of language -- or the tremendous amount of material that exists on the subject.

The OP's question goes directly to the specific uses of specific words in specific social contexts. That IS the topic, Belz, and it happens to be the very thing the study of semantics is concerned with.

So when we define the words why, do, people, insist, AA, is, not and religious we might start to discuss what they all mean when put together?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom