Gandalfs Beard
Graduate Poster
- Joined
- Feb 14, 2009
- Messages
- 1,548
I understand perfectly well that you've been saying that we're not doing the same thing. That was implicit in each of your repeated assertions that my arguments are based on twisting definitions, etc. I also understand that YOU understand that what I'm challenging you to do is to support that claim by showing why your arguments are different -- rather than continuing to do what you're doing, which is simply to repeat the assertion.
What I'm suggesting is that you answer the question: Which of the above quotes (taken from your earlier posts) are -- as you have claimed -- NOT semantic arguments? (And I'll be happy to repost the list of quotes if you can't find them).
It is true that in attempting to answer that question (in the unlikely event that you should actually choose to make that effort), it will be hard to avoid some consideration of the meaning of the word "semantics" -- and while there is, yes, a certain recursive quality to that, it's certainly not an endless loop.
In the sense you clearly have in mind, "semantics" is a bad thing. It refers only to a weak form of argument; either a foray into trivialities or a deliberate exploiting of ambiguities in the meanings of words. I wonder if you are even aware of the importance of semantics as a subfield of linguistics -- the scientific study of language -- or the tremendous amount of material that exists on the subject.
The OP's question goes directly to the specific uses of specific words in specific social contexts. That IS the topic, Belz, and it happens to be the very thing the study of semantics is concerned with.
Like your fiction based "volleyball" analogy, this is one of those points that undermines the very point you believe you are making. Thanks for scoring a goal for "my" team.
You are so right in the highlighted paragraph, that it demonstrates why your arguments are so wrong.
The Specific Use of Specific Words in a Specific Social Context is precisely what determines that AA is Religious. The Specific Words being used such as God, and His Will, and having Him remove "Defects of Character/Shortcomings" etc. have primary semantic definitions that contextualize the methodology of AA's programme to achieve sobriety as Religious.
GB