Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I understand perfectly well that you've been saying that we're not doing the same thing. That was implicit in each of your repeated assertions that my arguments are based on twisting definitions, etc. I also understand that YOU understand that what I'm challenging you to do is to support that claim by showing why your arguments are different -- rather than continuing to do what you're doing, which is simply to repeat the assertion.

What I'm suggesting is that you answer the question: Which of the above quotes (taken from your earlier posts) are -- as you have claimed -- NOT semantic arguments? (And I'll be happy to repost the list of quotes if you can't find them).

It is true that in attempting to answer that question (in the unlikely event that you should actually choose to make that effort), it will be hard to avoid some consideration of the meaning of the word "semantics" -- and while there is, yes, a certain recursive quality to that, it's certainly not an endless loop.

In the sense you clearly have in mind, "semantics" is a bad thing. It refers only to a weak form of argument; either a foray into trivialities or a deliberate exploiting of ambiguities in the meanings of words. I wonder if you are even aware of the importance of semantics as a subfield of linguistics -- the scientific study of language -- or the tremendous amount of material that exists on the subject.

The OP's question goes directly to the specific uses of specific words in specific social contexts. That IS the topic, Belz, and it happens to be the very thing the study of semantics is concerned with.

Like your fiction based "volleyball" analogy, this is one of those points that undermines the very point you believe you are making. Thanks for scoring a goal for "my" team. :rolleyes:

You are so right in the highlighted paragraph, that it demonstrates why your arguments are so wrong.

The Specific Use of Specific Words in a Specific Social Context is precisely what determines that AA is Religious. The Specific Words being used such as God, and His Will, and having Him remove "Defects of Character/Shortcomings" etc. have primary semantic definitions that contextualize the methodology of AA's programme to achieve sobriety as Religious.

GB
 
So when we define the words why, do, people, insist, AA, is, not and religious we might start to discuss what they all mean when put together?
Certainly we are not ready to discuss much of anything until we are able to define those words, and many more -- but language is much more than vocabulary. A person lacking pragmatic competence might, despite being in possession of a full vocabulary, be puzzled by the phrase: "Why don't you have a seat?" -- failing to understand that the speaker does not really desire an explanation, but is making a suggestion, or issuing an invitation, or perhaps even a command. So, sarcasm aside, even the meanings of simple words like "why" often do require considerable interpretation.

Our ability to perform these interpretive feats is so sophisticated (and so fast) that we usually are not even aware that we're doing it, just as most of us are not aware that no one really understands how we do it. Linguists, however, are very aware of that, as gaining a better understanding of that process is a lot of the reason for studying language. Those working in computational linguistics are particularly aware of the difficulty in creating a computer program capable of performing that feat which the average four-year-old does so effortlessly: parsing natural language.

It is pragmatic competence that enables me to infer that, like Belz, you also regard semantics as a bad thing (or at the very least, unnecessary) -- and to infer that the OP did not start this thread because she was sincerely interested in learning why people might say that AA is not religious. She was not asking; she was ranting -- just as is the case with several of the most frequent contributers to this thread. Do you disagree?
 
The Specific Use of Specific Words in a Specific Social Context is precisely what determines that AA is Religious.
Or not, as the case may be. But before I address the substance of that (by reiterating my position for the umpteenth time), I wonder if you'd mind stating clearly for the record what you have just implicitly acknowledged: that either way, it is an argument based in semantics.


(And, just a friendly tip: Don't you realize that around here the sort of non-standard use of capital letters you're applying is most often taken as a sign that the poster is a kook?)
 
Or not, as the case may be. But before I address the substance of that (by reiterating my position for the umpteenth time), I wonder if you'd mind stating clearly for the record what you have just implicitly acknowledged: that either way, it is an argument based in semantics.

No, YOUR argument is based on semantics. MY argument is based on facts, which just happen to have WORDS in them. :p


(And, just a friendly tip: Don't you realize that around here the sort of non-standard use of capital letters you're applying is most often taken as a sign that the poster is a kook?)

Unlike SOME PEOPLE, I'm not going to report you for your inane attempt to insult me because I can take it with a smile. :D

In any case, the alleged non-standard use of Capitalization is a Characteristic of British Writers, and I am British.


GB

(Speaking of friendly reminders, here's a tip: Don't you realize that around here the sort of non-standard use of semantics--which you employ--instead of the standard definitions and factual evidence is most often a sign that the poster has an invalid argument?)
 
Last edited:
I understand perfectly well that you've been saying that we're not doing the same thing. That was implicit in each of your repeated assertions that my arguments are based on twisting definitions, etc. I also understand that YOU understand that what I'm challenging you to do is to support that claim by showing why your arguments are different -- rather than continuing to do what you're doing, which is simply to repeat the assertion.

What I'm suggesting is that you answer the question: Which of the above quotes (taken from your earlier posts) are -- as you have claimed -- NOT semantic arguments? (And I'll be happy to repost the list of quotes if you can't find them).

It is true that in attempting to answer that question (in the unlikely event that you should actually choose to make that effort), it will be hard to avoid some consideration of the meaning of the word "semantics" -- and while there is, yes, a certain recursive quality to that, it's certainly not an endless loop.

In the sense you clearly have in mind, "semantics" is a bad thing. It refers only to a weak form of argument; either a foray into trivialities or a deliberate exploiting of ambiguities in the meanings of words. I wonder if you are even aware of the importance of semantics as a subfield of linguistics -- the scientific study of language -- or the tremendous amount of material that exists on the subject.

The OP's question goes directly to the specific uses of specific words in specific social contexts. That IS the topic, Belz, and it happens to be the very thing the study of semantics is concerned with.

No, I'm done with you as far as semantics are concerned. Let's get back on topic.
 
It's cool how you admit that you think it should be a pissing contest.
As all semantics discussions turn out to be ... like it or not. :)

Semantics is and has been the "topic" here for 1000's of posts now.
 
Last edited:
As all semantics discussions turn out to be ... like it or not. :)

Semantics is and has been the "topic" here for 1000's of posts now.

Only on the part of Dymanic (for the most part. The exceptions being those who are occasionally sucked (suckered) into his Semantic Black Hole--myself included ).

GB
 
No, YOUR argument is based on semantics. MY argument is based on facts, which just happen to have WORDS in them.
Is it not the case that the words ARE the facts? And does not your argument rest entirely on interpreting these words in the proper way -- a feat which you claim that you are able to perform while I am not?
 
No, I'm done with you as far as semantics are concerned.
And does that mean that you will make no further unsupported assertions that my arguments amount to "twisting definitions", etc -- and that you retract the accusations you've already made?

Thought not.
 
Thanks IC (may I call you IC? only, at least, until such a time as I get another cup of Joe - have been moving to a new house we bought, and not done yet - with my bad leg & back, the last week I've felt like another truck ran over me*)

*=(I do know what that feels like, as being hit by a truck was part of my life experience in a near-death auto accident 2 years ago)
 
Certainly we are not ready to discuss much of anything until we are able to define those words, and many more -- but language is much more than vocabulary. A person lacking pragmatic competence might, despite being in possession of a full vocabulary, be puzzled by the phrase: "Why don't you have a seat?" -- failing to understand that the speaker does not really desire an explanation, but is making a suggestion, or issuing an invitation, or perhaps even a command. So, sarcasm aside, even the meanings of simple words like "why" often do require considerable interpretation.

Our ability to perform these interpretive feats is so sophisticated (and so fast) that we usually are not even aware that we're doing it, just as most of us are not aware that no one really understands how we do it. Linguists, however, are very aware of that, as gaining a better understanding of that process is a lot of the reason for studying language. Those working in computational linguistics are particularly aware of the difficulty in creating a computer program capable of performing that feat which the average four-year-old does so effortlessly: parsing natural language.

It is pragmatic competence that enables me to infer that, like Belz, you also regard semantics as a bad thing (or at the very least, unnecessary) -- and to infer that the OP did not start this thread because she was sincerely interested in learning why people might say that AA is not religious. She was not asking; she was ranting -- just as is the case with several of the most frequent contributers to this thread. Do you disagree?


[P]ragmatic competence . . . is understood as the knowledge of the linguistic resources available in a given language for realising particular illocutions, knowledge of the sequential aspects of speech acts, and finally, knowledge of the appropriate contextual use of the particular language's linguistic resources."
(Anne Barron, Acquisition in Interlanguage Pragmatics: Learning How to Do Things With Words in a Study-Abroad Context. John Benjamins, 2003

How does this differ from just being competent?

Looks like Anne lacks a certain competence herself. I'd be wary of trusting a tainted fountain.
 
Only on the part of Dymanic (for the most part. The exceptions being those who are occasionally sucked (suckered) into his Semantic Black Hole--myself included ).

GB

Sometimes the only way to win is to not play the game.
 
And does that mean that you will make no further unsupported assertions that my arguments amount to "twisting definitions", etc -- and that you retract the accusations you've already made?

Thought not.

Don't try to derail this further. We've both already lost enough time and pages with this nonsense. Let's get back to the topic, shall we ?

Thought not.
 
Don't try to derail this further.
So when you accuse me of "twisting definitions", "playing with words", and "raising semantic arguments" -- that's on topic, but when I respond to those accusations, that's a derail? It seems to me that your blatant application of that double standard raises serious questions about your ability to formulate reasoned judgements on this topic or any topic.
 
So when you accuse me of "twisting definitions", "playing with words", and "raising semantic arguments" -- that's on topic, but when I respond to those accusations, that's a derail?

I'm not going to respond to this tu quoque of yours, either. You are consistently refusing the return to topic. Why ? The way I see it, there are two possibilities:

1- You genuinely feel that this is an important point in this thread, and that I'm trying to avoid adressing it by asking you to return to the topic. If this is the case, let me put it to rest right now: I actually want to continue debating this ridiculously endless chain of semantics points with you. I enjoy conversations that branch off in various directions and then return to the central point. In fact, I could probably go on for the next 25 years in this thread. There's just no end to me. But the problem is, I feel the actual reason you don't want to return to topic is because of the second possibility.

2- You have no argument, and you've been laying semantics traps all over the thread to avoid having to admit that. I mean, I'm sure the lurkers, if there are any left, can see that when one is left with arguing about the meaning of the very word "semantics", that person has his back to the wall. It seems clear to me that, aside from snide remarks and requests to redefine terms into vague blobs of uselessness, you have nothing to bring to this debate. But you have an emotional attachment to AA, and feel obligated to defend it even if you have no actual case. Personally, I don't see why it would bother you that AA is a religious organization. I don't think it would change the fact that you see it in a positive light, so why the perceived necessity to defend it at all costs ? I think you've simply lost all objectivity towards AA, and are incapable, due to this, to keep both its impact on your life, and its religiosity, in perspective. Hence the word-play on your part. That goes for AlBell and Alfie, too.
 
If I understand your question correctly, it was answered in the post you just quoted.

The question is how does pragmatic competence differ from competence. Since you had a hard time understanding my question I have to wonder about your "knowledge of the sequential aspects of speech acts and knowledge of the appropriate contextual use of the particular language's linguistic resources."
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom