The point of the matter is that we both work in opposite directions. I seek to use a word in the same way for everyone, you seek to use it differently for everyone.
I would say that the point of the matter is that neither one of us has the power to do either of those. We cannot speak
for everyone, and we cannot redefine words
for everyone. We either use the words we use in ways that follow common usage or we fail to communicate. When those words,
in common usage, have multiple context-dependent senses (like the word "self") or referents which are highly subjective (like "home", or "fun", or "God"), possibilities arise for exploiting these ambiguities for rhetorical purposes -- a practice which may be fairly characterized as "playing semantics games", etc. I'm happy to see that you are finally willing to at least
begin to try to explain why it is that I am guilty of doing this while you yourself are not, but I hope you're not thinking that the two sentences above accomplish that.
Far above (applying Occam's razor) I offered what I see as the simplest explanation for the phenomenon observed by the OP: that these people -- the ones who say that AA is not religious, or that it is "spiritual but not religious" -- are simply saying that their experience with AA does not fit the definition of the word "religious" as they understand the meaning of that word in common usage, but that it does fit the definition of "spiritual" as they understand THAT.
Though it does little to address that point, your response:
So in other words, "religious" is a subset of "spiritual".
is one that I do not necessarily disagree with; but my purpose in bringing it back up is to remind you that you yourself have been just as much a participant as I have in the exercises in semantics which constitute the bulk of this thread. And as I stated in an earlier response to qayak (post #3099), what I most object to is that you do it so
badly.