Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
But you do make arguments involving examination of the meanings of the words we're using. Correct?

If you instead say "but you DO stuff, don't you ?" it would further increase the chances of me agreeing with you, Dymanic.

The point of the matter is that we both work in opposite directions. I seek to use a word in the same way for everyone, you seek to use it differently for everyone. Which of the two do you think could be labeled as obfuscation ?
 
Unlike you, who doesn't know and has been taking it on faith; on other people's say so, that AA works.

The only difference is, Belz has some unbiased studies supporting their position and is honest enough to admit the evidence isn't conclusive, hence the "If" qualifier.

Ah, but don't you know ? Admitting that you don't know everything is a weakness.
 
No. Just like Dymanic's example -- creationists saying "evolution is just a theory" -- you have no idea what "faith" means.

Good try, no cigar.

Do you, or don't you know the figures, have you studied and found them or are you relying on what others tell you? Aren't you accepting in good faith what they say?

The land I have is primo, dude. ;)
 
Not sure what you're trying to say here, to be honest. Care to clarify for me, please?

Statistics: "Who is an alcoholic?" "What constitutes recovery?" are notoriously difficult to compile. The AA "anonymous" requirement makes AA stats even more suspect.



That AA, when compared to other methodologies that also provide help in achieving sobriety, is as successful as these other methodologies.
Based on gigo statistics, it's unknown, but from what I know, AA recovery rates are a very low percent.
 
Last edited:
The point of the matter is that we both work in opposite directions. I seek to use a word in the same way for everyone, you seek to use it differently for everyone.
I would say that the point of the matter is that neither one of us has the power to do either of those. We cannot speak for everyone, and we cannot redefine words for everyone. We either use the words we use in ways that follow common usage or we fail to communicate. When those words, in common usage, have multiple context-dependent senses (like the word "self") or referents which are highly subjective (like "home", or "fun", or "God"), possibilities arise for exploiting these ambiguities for rhetorical purposes -- a practice which may be fairly characterized as "playing semantics games", etc. I'm happy to see that you are finally willing to at least begin to try to explain why it is that I am guilty of doing this while you yourself are not, but I hope you're not thinking that the two sentences above accomplish that.

Far above (applying Occam's razor) I offered what I see as the simplest explanation for the phenomenon observed by the OP: that these people -- the ones who say that AA is not religious, or that it is "spiritual but not religious" -- are simply saying that their experience with AA does not fit the definition of the word "religious" as they understand the meaning of that word in common usage, but that it does fit the definition of "spiritual" as they understand THAT.

Though it does little to address that point, your response:
So in other words, "religious" is a subset of "spiritual".
is one that I do not necessarily disagree with; but my purpose in bringing it back up is to remind you that you yourself have been just as much a participant as I have in the exercises in semantics which constitute the bulk of this thread. And as I stated in an earlier response to qayak (post #3099), what I most object to is that you do it so badly.
 
Sadly long term recovery rates for every treatment are very low. That is why we need them all.
Imo, the best thing AA can offer to those who've actually managed to find bottom is a no-cost option.

I also suspect people with money and/or insurance usually try other options first, and most are damn far from knowing what bottom is.

And of course AA also was (and perhaps still is some places) getting stuck with the court-ordered who usually have no interest in quitting.
 
Imo, the best thing AA can offer to those who've actually managed to find bottom is a no-cost option.

I also suspect people with money and/or insurance usually try other options first, and most are damn far from knowing what bottom is.

And of course AA also was (and perhaps still is some places) getting stuck with the court-ordered who usually have no interest in quitting.

I have the court-ordered attend our addiction awareness courses in one of the places I work - these are mandated for things like drink driving, drunk in public places, drug use and possession, gambling etc. We facilitate a six week course of two hours pw.

The reality is that next to none of these will derive any short term gains - they may however have seeds planted that will see some growth down the track. This would be the same for the court mandated AA attendees, next to none will get anything, they are simply not ready to make change.

My favourite clients anywhere in the AOD field are those that are ready to take action - with these people we can actively explore all possibilities with a view to finding a number of possibilities that might work for them - this includes all the things that have been discussed here already: from "stopping on their own", to AA, to CBT, SMART recovery programs, detoxes, rehabs etc etc.. From there we (they) take action.
 
Last edited:
The point of the matter is that we both work in opposite directions. I seek to use a word in the same way for everyone, you seek to use it differently for everyone.

I would say that the point of the matter is that neither one of us has the power to do either of those.

That might have something to do with the fact that we both work in opposite directions.
 
I assume this means you know the meaning of "faith". So far you have not shown this.

The land is primo dude. Magnificent! You will love it.

Belz, instead of trying to deflect, how about just confirming you can't support the statements you have made and be done with it?
 
That might have something to do with the fact that we both work in opposite directions.
Nothing whatsoever to do with that.

I can continue to direct you back to the points I've raised, and you can continue to head off in any direction you think will help you avoid that -- but meanwhile, people will continue to use words in ways that are consistent with their understanding of what those words mean, with all the subjectivity and context-dependency that entails.
 
I can continue to direct you back to the points I've raised, and you can continue to head off in any direction you think will help you avoid that

The only point you've raised is that you like to muddle the issue by raising semantic arguments and twisting definitions. You'll forgive me if I head in a different direction, indeed.
 
The only point you've raised is that you like to muddle the issue by raising semantic arguments and twisting definitions.
The particular point I have in mind at present is that you have made exactly this same accusation quite a number of times now, and have repeatedly either dodged or outright refused to respond to my challenge that you explain why your own semantic arguments do not qualify as "twisting definitions", "playing word games", or any of the other dozen or so ways you have phrased it.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom