qayak
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Jul 31, 2006
- Messages
- 13,844
And once again you give unqualified nonsense as a response. AA leaves the door wide open, one needs merely to look at the innumerable higher powers available to see that in evidence.
Even without all the logical fallacies, that's nothing more than your own fabrication. AA is very specific about what qualifies. God is the only Higher Power AA accepts. The group is merely a substitute until God reveals himself to those who doubt, or don't believe in, Him. (You really need to be more rigorous.)
And all through the thread that has been shown there is no "insistance made". It does say thing like "suggestion", "as you understand him" etc.
That argument has been completely discredited, no need to return to it.
.... In your opinion.
And, without a countering argument, one can only assume you agree.
I have responded to this on numerous occasions already. I will not be so hypocritical as to not repeat myself
Repeating yourself doesn't make you a hypocrite, Alfie. Other behaviour does.
(maybe you could do the same at some stage).
As you can see from my last statement, I have already begun to do this.
On the other hand, the only time I repeat myself is when you ask for evidence that has already been given. It is your dishonesty that leads to my repeating.
The higher power is one of your understanding.
Well then, you've got a problem because I don't understand it at all.
It can be the universe, or the laws of natue. (Great Out Doors).
The universe or laws of nature have no control over my drinking and certainly no control over alcohol. They certainly can't hear me pray or take control of my life. That's not going to work for what AA wants me to do here.
It might be a better way of thinking, personal growth and a desire to improve ourselves (Good orderly direction).
That's not a higher power, that's a part of me. The fact that I want to improve myself is the reason I came to AA. Your position as a longtime member is the reason I ask you to clear this up for this poor, misguided atheist. But, AA says I can't be my own Higher Power so personal growth doesn't fit the bill . . . or in this case, the Bill W. (Get it?)
It might be the fellowship itself (group of Drunks).
Ummmmm . . . Nope! That definitely isn't a God or Higher Power and the Big Book states that the group is only temporary until God reveals Himself to me. Can you explain why it is that these drunks are too weak and pathetic to be their own higher power but they can manage to be mine? Your selling me a set of damaged goods here!
Maybe it is a combination/amalgam of some or all three.
AA sets very high standard for what constitutes a Higher Power and so far, all your "explanations have fallen far short of the mark. They just aren't. Three zeros still add up to zero no matter how you slice them.
Maybe you have a different idea of what spirituality is.
I do and it doesn't include a God and it doesn't fit in with anything AA claims.
Depending on the individual, we would explore their understanding of the word god and spiritual. I might say that spirituality may include one's purpose in life - so often men and women use their kids as an example of a spiritual connection; it is they that keeps them going (in part).
See, we are pretty close on the spiritual thing but it just doesn't fit with what AA says. They are all concepts and concepts don't have physical control over me or inanimate objects such as a bottle of booze. The concept is in my mind and only works when I make it work. So, I am the one with control over alcohol, I am the higher power but according to AA, I can't ever be and it is only my ego that says that which, apparently, makes me a dry drunk . . . or something like that.
(I might even suggest they do some reading around this). I heard Martin Scorcese say - and I paraphrase - that he liked making movies, it was a spiritual experience for the people viewing them, the spiritual aspect was the shared experience.
So, I could quit drinking just by watching Scorcese movies! Well, that's a hell of a lot more fun. Some of his movies make me want to drink, though.
So perhaps spirituality can be something starting with this type of concept.
Now you're getting it. Spirituality is a concept you create in your mind. It has no control over you or alcohol and it is a part of you, not a higher Power than you. That is why the AA idea only fits a supernatural being.
So Qayak; acting in good faith, in terms of this "conversation" and assuming you are a hard atheist and genuine in your question, where would you like to begin?
We don't need to do this in a conversation, you have laid out your arguments and I have responded. I just thought you might have preferred to do it as if I was the Newbee, you were the Old Salt and we were having a conversation at an AA meeting but this works just as well.
P.S.- Don't think I didn't notice that you moved the goal posts.