Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
And once again you give unqualified nonsense as a response. AA leaves the door wide open, one needs merely to look at the innumerable higher powers available to see that in evidence.

Even without all the logical fallacies, that's nothing more than your own fabrication. AA is very specific about what qualifies. God is the only Higher Power AA accepts. The group is merely a substitute until God reveals himself to those who doubt, or don't believe in, Him. (You really need to be more rigorous.)

And all through the thread that has been shown there is no "insistance made". It does say thing like "suggestion", "as you understand him" etc.

That argument has been completely discredited, no need to return to it.


.... In your opinion.

And, without a countering argument, one can only assume you agree.

I have responded to this on numerous occasions already. I will not be so hypocritical as to not repeat myself

Repeating yourself doesn't make you a hypocrite, Alfie. Other behaviour does.

(maybe you could do the same at some stage ;)).

As you can see from my last statement, I have already begun to do this.

On the other hand, the only time I repeat myself is when you ask for evidence that has already been given. It is your dishonesty that leads to my repeating.

The higher power is one of your understanding.

Well then, you've got a problem because I don't understand it at all.

It can be the universe, or the laws of natue. (Great Out Doors).

The universe or laws of nature have no control over my drinking and certainly no control over alcohol. They certainly can't hear me pray or take control of my life. That's not going to work for what AA wants me to do here.

It might be a better way of thinking, personal growth and a desire to improve ourselves (Good orderly direction).

That's not a higher power, that's a part of me. The fact that I want to improve myself is the reason I came to AA. Your position as a longtime member is the reason I ask you to clear this up for this poor, misguided atheist. But, AA says I can't be my own Higher Power so personal growth doesn't fit the bill . . . or in this case, the Bill W. (Get it?) :D

It might be the fellowship itself (group of Drunks).

Ummmmm . . . Nope! That definitely isn't a God or Higher Power and the Big Book states that the group is only temporary until God reveals Himself to me. Can you explain why it is that these drunks are too weak and pathetic to be their own higher power but they can manage to be mine? Your selling me a set of damaged goods here!

Maybe it is a combination/amalgam of some or all three.

AA sets very high standard for what constitutes a Higher Power and so far, all your "explanations have fallen far short of the mark. They just aren't. Three zeros still add up to zero no matter how you slice them.

Maybe you have a different idea of what spirituality is.

I do and it doesn't include a God and it doesn't fit in with anything AA claims.

Depending on the individual, we would explore their understanding of the word god and spiritual. I might say that spirituality may include one's purpose in life - so often men and women use their kids as an example of a spiritual connection; it is they that keeps them going (in part).

See, we are pretty close on the spiritual thing but it just doesn't fit with what AA says. They are all concepts and concepts don't have physical control over me or inanimate objects such as a bottle of booze. The concept is in my mind and only works when I make it work. So, I am the one with control over alcohol, I am the higher power but according to AA, I can't ever be and it is only my ego that says that which, apparently, makes me a dry drunk . . . or something like that. :rolleyes:

(I might even suggest they do some reading around this). I heard Martin Scorcese say - and I paraphrase - that he liked making movies, it was a spiritual experience for the people viewing them, the spiritual aspect was the shared experience.

So, I could quit drinking just by watching Scorcese movies! Well, that's a hell of a lot more fun. Some of his movies make me want to drink, though.

So perhaps spirituality can be something starting with this type of concept.

Now you're getting it. Spirituality is a concept you create in your mind. It has no control over you or alcohol and it is a part of you, not a higher Power than you. That is why the AA idea only fits a supernatural being.

So Qayak; acting in good faith, in terms of this "conversation" and assuming you are a hard atheist and genuine in your question, where would you like to begin?

We don't need to do this in a conversation, you have laid out your arguments and I have responded. I just thought you might have preferred to do it as if I was the Newbee, you were the Old Salt and we were having a conversation at an AA meeting but this works just as well.

P.S.- Don't think I didn't notice that you moved the goal posts. :) You went from trying to explain the AA concept of a Higher Power to merely looking for a spiritual connection. The spiritual connection part is easy but it isn't what AA is talking about in their literature. They talk about a "Higher Power" which they call "God," and whose attributes they list allow nothing but a supernatural being.
 
No, I must accept the responsibility. In indulging that impulse, I neglected to keep in mind that some things are hard to parody.

There is a particular brand of irrational thinking, exhibited by some posters here, that has skepticism as entailing nothing more than smugly demanding evidence at every turn, and regards logical interpretation of evidence as secondary in importance (when not completely unnecessary). It is, in itself, a form of unintentional parody; an imitation of skepticism; a sophomoric approach to skepticism under which regurgitation of facts represents the end of the investigative process rather than the starting point. It is a "feel good" skepticism whose adherents show little real interest in difficult questions or the often grueling process of obtaining answers; for them, these exercises mostly represent opportunities to reaffirm that they are part of an exciting social movement. They don't recognize genuine skepticism as a rigorous discipline; but then, they don't have the patience for it anyway. Rigidity in thinking is a cheap substitute for rigor in methodology, and the irony is that in taking that easy way out, these pseudoskeptics make themselves into mirror images of the religious fundamentalists they so thoroughly despise -- the ones who, on close examination, so often turn out to have only a passing aquaintance with the principles they so loudly proclaim as sacred. And, in so doing, they make themselves just as hard to parody.

Must be nice that all your opponents are pseudoskeptics, religious fundamentalists and have Rigidity in thinking because if they weren't you might have to actually answer their arguments instead of attacking their characters.
 
Must be nice that all your opponents are pseudoskeptics, religious fundamentalists and have Rigidity in thinking because if they weren't you might have to actually answer their arguments instead of attacking their characters.
Did you actually read the paragraph you quoted?
 
That aside, the main thrust of your arguments seem to be:
1. The "one god" will be revealed in time:-
Maybe, but that god will be one of your understanding - no if buts or maybe's.
2. You are hung up on this powerless thing.
The powerlessness relates to our drinking. I am completely powerless after I have the first drink and of that I have no qualms with whatsoever: You may be aware that (most?) alcoholics process alcohol differently in the brain causing chemical and physiological changes.


These things are taken from the AA text and related materials. The powerlessness relates to drinking, yes; and "...without help it is too much for us. But there is One who has all power-That One is God. May you find Him now!"

Where is it in any materials that say that NO Higher Power is fine?


The serenity prayer - heard at every meeting:

Grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change.
This relates to powerlessness and my "will". I cannot control what I cannot control. No matter how hard I apply my will, x or y will not happen just because I want it to.

Courage to change the things I can

Here we take on what is mine to own, what I can change, what is doable. Where I am not powerless.

And wisdom to know the difference

Self explanatory I would have thought.


So, do you want to have a conversation, or do you want to dismantle every point with the same old stuff? If the latter, you would prove yourself to be a hypocrite and a liar.


Yeah, yeah, the serenity prayer. A prayer that was co-opted by Bill W. in 1942 was it? Certainly not original to AA. I find it unfortunate that such a useful phrase is nowadays associated purely with Alcoholics Anonymous.
 
Some posts moved to AAH, mostly for bickering. There could be a lot more, plus some infractions handed out. So lets cut out the personalizing and sniping. Okay?
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Tricky
 

As I suspected, your desire to understand and have a "conversation" appears in no way genuine.

That aside, the main thrust of your arguments seem to be:
1. The "one god" will be revealed in time:-
Maybe, but that god will be one of your understanding - no if buts or maybe's. You suggest that AA sets a high standard; please shoe me where I have to call my HP "god".

2. You seem a bit hung up on this powerless thing - and have it rather wrong from where I sit.
The powerlessness relates to our drinking. I am completely powerless after I have the first drink and of that I have no qualms with whatsoever: You may be aware that (most?) alcoholics process alcohol differently in the brain causing chemical and physiological changes. Some say it is a physical allergy coupled with a mental obsession. If that isn't powerless, I'm not sure what is.

The serenity prayer - heard at every meeting - helps us understand how this powerlessness/self-will thing works:

Grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change.
This relates to powerlessness and my "will". I cannot control what I cannot control. No matter how hard I apply my will, x or y will not happen just because I want it to.

Courage to change the things I can

Here we take on what is mine to own, what I can change, what is doable. I am not powerless here.

And wisdom to know the difference

Self explanatory I would have thought.
 
As I suspected, your desire to understand and have a "conversation" appears in no way genuine.

Not at all. If you read my post, I said if you wanted to do it in a conversation form I was willing. The choice ws yours, answer in the manner we had been, which is getting us nowhere, or change it up and try it as a conversation.

To say my desire is not genuine because I responded to your post is hardly fair.

That aside, the main thrust of your arguments seem to be:
1. The "one god" will be revealed in time:-
Maybe, but that god will be one of your understanding - no if buts or maybe's.

I don't think you understand. I am an atheist and I am not waiting around for any god to reveal himself whenever he so desires. My understanding of gods, in any form, is they don't exist.

You suggest that AA sets a high standard; please shoe me where I have to call my HP "god".

2: Came to believe that a Power greater than ourselves could restore us to sanity.
3: Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we understood Him.

5: Admitted to God, to ourselves and to another human being the exact nature of our wrongs.
6: Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character.
7: Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings.

11: Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with God, as we understood Him, praying only for knowledge of His will for us and the power to carry that out.

You see, the AA God must be able to remove our short comings, hear our prayers, have a will for us and the ability to instill the power to carry out his will into us. Also, we have to humble ourselves before this God.

That said, this all rules out all other claims for what is meant by AA in reference to God. No "ideal" or "spiritual concept" except a supernatural deity fits the bill.

So, you don't have to call your HP anything (I notice you are now using the lower case letters for that. It's a start!) but then you are not doing Alcoholics Anonymous, you are doing Alcoholics Alfie.

And, don't get me wrong, that isn't a bad thing but that has no bearing on whether AA itself is a religious organization.

2. You seem a bit hung up on this powerless thing - and have it rather wrong from where I sit.
The powerlessness relates to our drinking. I am completely powerless after I have the first drink and of that I have no qualms with whatsoever:

Please show where it says that in the AA literature. I find this: 1. We admitted we were powerless over alcohol - that our lives had become unmanageable.

You may be aware that (most?) alcoholics process alcohol differently in the brain causing chemical and physiological changes. Some say it is a physical allergy coupled with a mental obsession. If that isn't powerless, I'm not sure what is.

Well, the evidence strongly suggests that alcoholics are not powerless, in fact, it is the ones who took charge of their lives who succeeded in stopping. Perhaps the claims about alcoholism are wrong.

The serenity prayer - heard at every meeting - helps us understand how this powerlessness/self-will thing works:

Grant me the serenity to accept the things I cannot change.
This relates to powerlessness and my "will". I cannot control what I cannot control. No matter how hard I apply my will, x or y will not happen just because I want it to.

Courage to change the things I can

Here we take on what is mine to own, what I can change, what is doable. I am not powerless here.

And wisdom to know the differenceSelf explanatory I would have thought.

It really is quite a beautiful thought but, as an atheist, who exactly am I asking to grant this all to me? The prayer as it exists in AA asks God. As an atheist, I reject all gods.

Now, if AA changed the wording to be more along the lines of, "I will work hard to . . . ", then I could agree that it was merely spiritual but as it stands, it is religious.
 
And I don't actually expect you to respond to my multiple earlier requests to explain why it is that when MY arguments involve examination of the meanings of the words we're using, that's me "playing semantics" (...) but when YOU do the same thing, it's something else. The last time we tried to discuss this, you ended up "lost", but I'll be happy to repeat the questions anyway.

I don't play semantics games. That's why it's something else.

I posted that question several times. The last time I did so, you finally gave up on claiming to be having trouble following the exchange, admitted that you HAD noticed the question after all

Dammit, Dymanic. YOU're the one having problems following the conversation. I DID spot the question, chose not to answer it, AND didn't get that you were refering to THAT question when you said I didn't answer it. This must be the fourth of fifth time that I have to explain this to you.

, and openly declared yourself a member of the "I refuse to answer" club

That seems to cause you a whole bunch of problems, because you've been running around in circles in that derail since forever, now.
 
You confirm my point. You have taken it on faith (ironic huh) something you have heard.

No, I don't. "If AA is not more useful than quitting on your own" starts with a very interesting word. It's only 2 letters long, though, so I'm not surprised you missed it.


What part of "AA is STILL religious even if the government doesn't send you there, however." didn't you understand ?
 
Where did I argue that?

Right here, actually:

And I don't actually expect you to respond to my multiple earlier requests to explain why it is that when MY arguments involve examination of the meanings of the words we're using, that's me "playing semantics" (or any of a number of other ways you have phrased the same objection: "playing around with words", "twisting the meaning around", "whining about definitions") -- but when YOU do the same thing, it's something else.

I don't do the same thing.
 
No, I don't. "If AA is not more useful than quitting on your own" starts with a very interesting word. It's only 2 letters long, though, so I'm not surprised you missed it.

Which, Brains - confirms what I have been saying: YOU DON'T KNOW! and are taking it on faith; on other peoples say so.
 
Last edited:
Which, Brains - confirms what I have been saying: YOU DON'T KNOW! and are taking it on faith; on other peoples say so.

Um. No, it's nothing to do with faith and it certainly isn't based on mere say-so. The studies that have been done, the numbers are there. You, Dymanic, and AlBell have yet to refute any of those claims.
 
Which, Brains - confirms what I have been saying: YOU DON'T KNOW! and are taking it on faith; on other peoples say so.

Unlike you, who doesn't know and has been taking it on faith; on other people's say so, that AA works.

The only difference is, Belz has some unbiased studies supporting their position and is honest enough to admit the evidence isn't conclusive, hence the "If" qualifier.
 
Um. No, it's nothing to do with faith and it certainly isn't based on mere say-so. The studies that have been done, the numbers are there.
And some people think oats are oats after they've been through the horse. Stats on AA recovery rates have been through the horse several times.


You, Dymanic, and AlBell have yet to refute any of those claims.
Which specific claims did you have in mind?
 
You, Dymanic, and AlBell have yet to refute any of those claims.
For my part, I stated quite early on in this discussion that I was not making any claims regarding the effectiveness of AA. It's got nothing to do with what the OP asks.
 
And some people think oats are oats after they've been through the horse. Stats on AA recovery rates have been through the horse several times.

Not sure what you're trying to say here, to be honest. Care to clarify for me, please?



Which specific claims did you have in mind?


That AA, when compared to other methodologies that also provide help in achieving sobriety, is as successful as these other methodologies.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom