Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
The question is how does pragmatic competence differ from competence.
Competence (that is, linguistic competence, re Chomsky) refers to knowledge about the language itself; how sounds are used to form words and the grammatical rules by which words are used to form meaningful sentences. Pragmatic competence involves consideration of such factors as context and speaker's intent. In this discussion, we've seen arguments made that essentially reduce to the absurd claim that linguistic meaning somehow trumps speaker's meaning.

Perhaps you'd like to add another absurd claim: that linguistic competence implies guaranteed total comprehension of every possible utterance.
 
So you completely ignored the rest of my post and focused on the six words that allowed you to reach the conclusion you wanted ?
I'm also not the least bit surprised that you consider it perfectly right and proper for you to choose which portions of my posts to respond to and which to ignore, but feel that I should not be extended the same privilege with regard to your posts.
 
I'm also not the least bit surprised that you consider it perfectly right and proper for you to choose which portions of my posts to respond to and which to ignore, but feel that I should not be extended the same privilege with regard to your posts.

Oh, I get it. So now you're in full tu quoque mode. You'll probably manage to do that to this post of mine, as well.
 
Competence (that is, linguistic competence, re Chomsky) refers to knowledge about the language itself; how sounds are used to form words and the grammatical rules by which words are used to form meaningful sentences. Pragmatic competence involves consideration of such factors as context and speaker's intent. In this discussion, we've seen arguments made that essentially reduce to the absurd claim that linguistic meaning somehow trumps speaker's meaning.


This is exactly the point being made, Dymanic. In context and with Bill W's intent, AA is a religious organization. He never intended it to be otherwise and only grudgingly made allowance that belief in something other than God to be temporary so that you will eventually come to Believe as he and the other founders did. We know this because he explicitly said so, in multiple times and places.

The AA World Organization has taken great pains to explain why they have not and will not change the basic texts of AA and they make no apologies whatsoever to the fact that AA is religious/spiritual in its core structure.

The steps are explained by way of "suggestions" yet then go on to say -- over and over again -- that you will not succeed unless you follow all the steps. Every single example given is just to reinforce this idea.
 
In context and with Bill W's intent, AA is a religious organization. He never intended it to be otherwise and only grudgingly made allowance that belief in something other than God to be temporary so that you will eventually come to Believe as he and the other founders did. We know this because he explicitly said so, in multiple times and places.
As Bill Wilson died in 1971, it seems safe to assume that he is not among the above-mentioned "people" who insist that AA is not religious. What reason is there for disregarding the context and intent of others -- for instance, the authors of the foreword to the second edition of the Big Book, who stated it as explicitly as this: "Alcoholics Anonymous is not a religious organization"?
 
What reason is there for disregarding the context and intent of others -- for instance, the authors of the foreword to the second edition of the Big Book, who stated it as explicitly as this: "Alcoholics Anonymous is not a religious organization"?

The fact that it is not true. :p

That would be like the Catholic Church claiming (in a foreword to the revised KJV Bible) that they are not a Religious Organization.

GB
 
Competence (that is, linguistic competence, re Chomsky) refers to knowledge about the language itself; how sounds are used to form words and the grammatical rules by which words are used to form meaningful sentences. Pragmatic competence involves consideration of such factors as context and speaker's intent. In this discussion, we've seen arguments made that essentially reduce to the absurd claim that linguistic meaning somehow trumps speaker's meaning.

Perhaps you'd like to add another absurd claim: that linguistic competence implies guaranteed total comprehension of every possible utterance.

I'm sure that with your linguistic competence you can understand what a strawman is.

If that fails you refer to the hilited sentence.
 
That would be like the Catholic Church claiming (in a foreword to the revised KJV Bible) that they are not a Religious Organization.
If one accepts the premise: that AA, like the Catholic Church, is a religious organization, then yes, it would be like that. Of course, that happens to be the very thing you are using the analogy to prove. Do you understand why this is flawed reasoning?

Is it often heard said that the Catholic Church is not a religious organization? Is that explicitly stated in Catholic literature? Because either of those might also help to make it a valid analogy. As things stand, I'd say it's a complete flop.
 
I'm sure that with your linguistic competence you can understand what a strawman is.
Unless you'd like to provide some additional context, or state some intent not easily gleaned from the content, I have to stand by my interpretation as an appropriate response to what you appeared to be implying here:
Since you had a hard time understanding my question I have to wonder about your "knowledge of the sequential aspects of speech acts and knowledge of the appropriate contextual use of the particular language's linguistic resources."
 
As Bill Wilson died in 1971, it seems safe to assume that he is not among the above-mentioned "people" who insist that AA is not religious.

Which above-mentioned people? I'm not sure to whom you are referring.



What reason is there for disregarding the context and intent of others -- for instance, the authors of the foreword to the second edition of the Big Book, who stated it as explicitly as this: "Alcoholics Anonymous is not a religious organization"?

I dunno; I don't think I'm completely disregarding it. Just when it's weighed against the rest of the book, most of the 12 steps and some of the 12 traditions, what Bill W. and many of the founders said in letters, papers, talks, speeches, and other writings -- it's not that convincing.

Anyway, also from the Forward to the 2nd Edition (since you mentioned it):


"Six months earlier, the broker had been relieved of his drink obsession by a sudden spiritual experience, following a meeting with an alcoholic friend who had been in contact with the Oxford Groups of that day."
"Though [Bill Wilson] could not accept all the tenets of the Oxford Groups, he was convinced of the need for moral inventory, confession of personality defects, restitution to those harmed, helpfulness to others, and the necessity of belief in and dependence upon God." (emphasis mine)

Just like I said.

But the disclaimer ("this book isn't religious") is a continuation on the same principle that Bill laid out -- most notably the Chapter to the Agnostic -- that he didn't ultimately care what you started your belief with because he 'knew' that you'd have to end up where he was eventually on the road to sobriety.

A point which I've raised several times which I guess is not important enough to address, but which is that any spiritual belief is good belief, but you can't have no belief at all.

Nowhere does it say that no belief is okay. AA is a spiritual/religious program and without it, it collapses.
 
But the disclaimer ("this book isn't religious") is a continuation on the same principle that Bill laid out -- most notably the Chapter to the Agnostic -- that he didn't ultimately care what you started your belief with because he 'knew' that you'd have to end up where he was eventually on the road to sobriety.

Yes, doesn't matter what you believe in at first as long as you believe in the Christian God at last.
 
Which above-mentioned people? I'm not sure to whom you are referring.
The ones to whom the OP is referring. She actually made specific mention of only two such persons, but implied that "spiritual but not religious" is a phrase very often used to describe AA. Though its value as evidence is limited, I have confirmed this with my personal observation that this is in fact one of the most populous members of the AA meme pool, and it also seems logical to assume that participation in this thread may be taken as implicit acceptance of the proposition that people really do say this.


A point which I've raised several times which I guess is not important enough to address, but which is that any spiritual belief is good belief, but you can't have no belief at all.
I agree that this roughly characterizes what is perhaps AA's most central premise: that successful recovery from alcoholism requires "what are called vital spiritual experiences" which appear to be "in the nature of huge emotional displacements and rearrangements" with the result that "ideas, emotions, and attitudes which were once the guiding forces of the lives of these men are suddenly cast to one side, and a completely new set of conceptions and motives begin to dominate them."
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=6637720&postcount=3155
(And I wonder if anyone -- I have a couple of particular people in mind -- will notice or appreciate the fact that rather than just tossing out a quick "Already been addressed innumerable times", I took the trouble to actually direct the poster's attention to one of those instances).

Perhaps it is true that Bill Wilson and others possessed no non-supernatural conceptual framework to apply to such experiences. Why should that act as a limitation on anyone today? Are YOU ready to dismiss "huge emotional displacements and rearrangements" as not possible without the intervention of a supernatural power? If the phrase "spiritual experience" were used to describe such mental/emotional displacements/rearrangements, would you consider that an improper use of the word "spiritual"? Does being an atheist, or a critical thinker, or a skeptic, mean being exempt from such experiences? Or does not all of that imply an increased willingness to have one's ideas and attitudes rearranged in the face of strong evidence and logic (accepting whatever emotional rearrangements might go along with that)? Would it be completely unreasonable to describe de-conversion from some form of religious fundamentalism as a "spiritual experience"?
 
The ones to whom the OP is referring. She actually made specific mention of only two such persons, but implied that "spiritual but not religious" is a phrase very often used to describe AA. Though its value as evidence is limited, I have confirmed this with my personal observation that this is in fact one of the most populous members of the AA meme pool, and it also seems logical to assume that participation in this thread may be taken as implicit acceptance of the proposition that people really do say this.


I agree that this roughly characterizes what is perhaps AA's most central premise: that successful recovery from alcoholism requires "what are called vital spiritual experiences" which appear to be "in the nature of huge emotional displacements and rearrangements" with the result that "ideas, emotions, and attitudes which were once the guiding forces of the lives of these men are suddenly cast to one side, and a completely new set of conceptions and motives begin to dominate them."
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showpost.php?p=6637720&postcount=3155
(And I wonder if anyone -- I have a couple of particular people in mind -- will notice or appreciate the fact that rather than just tossing out a quick "Already been addressed innumerable times", I took the trouble to actually direct the poster's attention to one of those instances).

Perhaps it is true that Bill Wilson and others possessed no non-supernatural conceptual framework to apply to such experiences. Why should that act as a limitation on anyone today? Are YOU ready to dismiss "huge emotional displacements and rearrangements" as not possible without the intervention of a supernatural power? If the phrase "spiritual experience" were used to describe such mental/emotional displacements/rearrangements, would you consider that an improper use of the word "spiritual"? Does being an atheist, or a critical thinker, or a skeptic, mean being exempt from such experiences? Or does not all of that imply an increased willingness to have one's ideas and attitudes rearranged in the face of strong evidence and logic (accepting whatever emotional rearrangements might go along with that)? Would it be completely unreasonable to describe de-conversion from some form of religious fundamentalism as a "spiritual experience"?

Well, this HAS been addressed innumerable times. In fact, when we last discussed this, it was clear from the definitions that Religious was a Subset of Spiritual. Which of course implies that non-theists can still have Spiritual experiences.

And again, if all references to a Male Supernatural Deity were stricken from the 12 Steps, and the Big Book (with all its references to a Male Supernatural Deity) was relegated to the status of Historical Artifact instead of continuing to be used as a Central Text, then you would be able to claim that AA is "Spiritual, but not Religious."

But until the GSO takes these steps, AA will remain a Religious Organization.

GB
 
In fact, when we last discussed this, it was clear from the definitions that Religious was a Subset of Spiritual.
It may have been clear enough to you when you last asserted that, but I cannot help but notice that you STILL have made no attempt to respond in any way to this:
I cannot help but notice that you have made no attempt to respond in any way to this:
But I would conjecture that a vanishingly small percentage of people ("religious" or otherwise) would regard the activities of the Westboro Baptist Church as "spiritual" in nature, yet it's hard to deny that they are inspired by (justified by is probably a better choice of words) a system of "religious" beliefs -- in other words, religious, but not spiritual. There are other possible examples with which we are all familiar: the Spanish Inquisition, the Crusades, etc.
Will you not make any effort at all to refute this argument that "religious" and "spiritual" are intersecting sets, or are you just going to continue to stand on your assertion that "religious" is a subset of "spiritual" as if I had never presented that argument?



Which of course implies that non-theists can still have Spiritual experiences.
In other words, it's not a question of whether "spiritual but not religious" represents an internally logically consistent proposition, but one of whether what AA is (not was) is fully represented by what is written in its literature, or if much of that is, as you say, historical artifact -- or even one of whether its historical artifacts are mere historical artifacts (that is, the personal views and beliefs of certain long-dead members, their associations, etc).
 
It may have been clear enough to you when you last asserted that

Yes, an assertion backed up by FACT. I'm still waiting for you to come up with an assertion backed up by a Fact.


but I cannot help but notice that you STILL have made no attempt to respond in any way to this:
I cannot help but notice that you have made no attempt to respond in any way to this:
But I would conjecture that a vanishingly small percentage of people ("religious" or otherwise) would regard the activities of the Westboro Baptist Church as "spiritual" in nature, yet it's hard to deny that they are inspired by (justified by is probably a better choice of words) a system of "religious" beliefs -- in other words, religious, but not spiritual. There are other possible examples with which we are all familiar: the Spanish Inquisition, the Crusades, etc.
Will you not make any effort at all to refute this argument that "religious" and "spiritual" are intersecting sets, or are you just going to continue to stand on your assertion that "religious" is a subset of "spiritual" as if I had never presented that argument?

I have responded indirectly by pointing out that Religious is a subset of Spiritual by Definition.

Many Religious Organizations have participated or instigated all manner of atrocities in the name of their Religion. They believe they are Justified by their Religious Beliefs, which by definition are also Spiritual Beliefs.

A lot of people don't think Islamic Jihadists are "Spiritual" either. Those people would be wrong, by definition.

It doesn't make any difference how "vanishingly small" the percentage of people who do not regard the abhorrent activities of many Religious Organizations as Spiritual is. Human Sacrifice, and the Slaughter of Heathens is considered to be among the HIGHEST of Spiritual Activities by those that commit such acts in the name of their God (or Gods).

In fact, the argument you employ is the very argument that many Theists (liberal and fundamentalist alike) employ in an attempt to deny that atrocities committed by their Religious Organizations and Members should ever be attributed to their Religious Beliefs while simultaneously stating that all "Good" Deeds committed by their Religious Organizations and Members be ONLY attributed to their Religious Beliefs.

When they employ this fallacy, they are employing Sophistry (I think by now you are familiar with this word).

Which of course implies that non-theists can still have Spiritual experiences.

In other words, it's not a question of whether "spiritual but not religious" represents an internally logically consistent proposition, but one of whether what AA is (not was) is fully represented by what is written in its literature, or if much of that is, as you say, historical artifact -- or even one of whether its historical artifacts are mere historical artifacts (that is, the personal views and beliefs of certain long-dead members, their associations, etc).

AA IS represented by what is written in its literature. To be an AA affiliated 12 Step Programme, local groups must subscribe to, and distribute AA's Literature. The Religious Literature is not designated as an Historical Artifact, but as the Central Texts of the AA programme. Therefore my assertions stand as backed up by Factual Evidence.

Groups which use the Secular 12 Steps text (and related materials) are unaffiliated with AA.

GB
 
Last edited:
I have responded indirectly by pointing out that Religious is a subset of Spiritual by Definition.
And ignoring the counterargument that by definition both words have multiple meanings, and that the truth or falsehood of the above statement depends entirely on which specific meanings are applied.

It doesn't make any difference how "vanishingly small" the percentage of people who do not regard the abhorrent activities of many Religious Organizations as Spiritual is.
It does, actually -- if you regard meaning as a property which resides with common usage rather than one which is determined prescriptively by publishers of dictionaries.

AA IS represented by what is written in its literature.
But not FULLY represented by what is written in its literature -- a detail we are obligated to overlook by the streetlight fallacy principle.

To be an AA affiliated 12 Step Programme, local groups must subscribe to, and distribute AA's Literature.
According to which of AA's 12 traditions?
 
And ignoring the counterargument that by definition both words have multiple meanings, and that the truth or falsehood of the above statement depends entirely on which specific meanings are applied.

That was addressed on several occasions. Religious is always spiritual but spiritual is not always religious.

In AA's case, as it stands, the spiritual is definitely religious. There are ways it could be made to not be, but that hasn't happened and doesn't appear that it will anytime soon.

An individual AAer could be spiritual without being religious but that has nothing to do with AA as an organization, only on how much the individual is willing to ignore.

It does, actually -- if you regard meaning as a property which resides with common usage rather than one which is determined prescriptively by publishers of dictionaries.

What you say here doesn't support your claim of AA being spiritual but not religious. There are three things you need to ask:

1) Can an organization be spiritual without being religious?

2) If yes to 1, what would constitute an organization being spiritual but not religious?

3) Does AA operate in the manner of an organization that fits being spiritual but not religious?

Your claim relies on the answer to the first question being "yes" but you never go further. No one here has denied that the answer to 1 is "yes." We have only said that when you answer 2 and then ask 3, AA falls way short.

But not FULLY represented by what is written in its literature -- a detail we are obligated to overlook by the streetlight fallacy principle.

No, not true. Your claim seems to be that if we take the claim that "AA is spiritual and not religious, as is claimed once in the literature, we are not allowing "full" representation of the literature.

The problem here is that if we allow that AA is spiritual but not religious because of that one statement we have to overlook hundreds, if not thousands, of statements that make it religious.

Which is more "fully" representative of AA literature, that one statement or the hundreds/thousands that contradict it?

In my view, your cognative dissonnance trumps my "not fully representative" fallacy. :D
 
Religious is always spiritual but spiritual is not always religious.
I have made the counterargument that the two are intersecting sets, and have supported that with examples. Here you are merely restating the premise, as if that somehow constituted a valuable contribution to the discussion. What are you doing, voting?

In AA's case, as it stands, the spiritual is definitely religious.
Already asserted innumerable times.

what would constitute an organization being spiritual but not religious?
Being dedicated to, say, an inner path enabling a person to discover the essence of their being; or the "deepest values and meanings by which people live" -- yet lacking the qualities essential to religiousity (which, I have posited, are specific, shared, supernatural beliefs, and which you are certainly free to challenge).

Your claim relies on the answer to the first question being "yes" but you never go further.
Strange, the objection I have most often encountered seems to have more to do with my having gone too much further.

We have only said that when you answer 2 and then ask 3, AA falls way short.
And I have not only disagreed, but explained why.

What you say here doesn't support your claim of AA being spiritual but not religious.
I have reported having very frequently encountered that meme, but it isn't my claim. My argument continues to be that the simplest explanation for the phenomenon observed by the OP is that these people who say that AA is not religious, or that it is "spiritual but not religious" are simply saying that their experience with AA does not fit the definition of the word "religious" as THEY understand the meaning of that word in common usage, but that it does fit the definition of "spiritual" as THEY understand that.

Your claim seems to be that if we take the claim that "AA is spiritual and not religious, as is claimed once in the literature, we are not allowing "full" representation of the literature.
No, you misunderstand. I know of no place in AA literature where the "spiritual but not religious" meme appears. That's simply something AA people often say (as the OP noted). What I am challenging is the notion that what AA is is fully represented in its literature. AA is more than a book. GB has asserted that because AA's literature is the only available source of empirical evidence, we must disregard as unreliable what is expressed verbally by AA members -- hence my reference to the streetlight fallacy. You on the page now?
 
My argument continues to be that the simplest explanation for the phenomenon observed by the OP is that these people who say that AA is not religious, or that it is "spiritual but not religious" are simply saying that their experience with AA does not fit the definition of the word "religious" as THEY understand the meaning of that word in common usage, but that it does fit the definition of "spiritual" as THEY understand that.

Your claim about AA members is probably true. Most of the ones who claim AA is "spiritual but not religious" probably don't know what those words mean. However, it is just a claim you make with no evidence. Another possiblity is that AA members, as a group, are especially gullible and easily led through propaganda and never give a thought to whether it is true or not.

No, you misunderstand. I know of no place in AA literature where the "spiritual but not religious" meme appears. That's simply something AA people often say (as the OP noted). What I am challenging is the notion that what AA is is fully represented in its literature. AA is more than a book. GB has asserted that because AA's literature is the only available source of empirical evidence, we must disregard as unreliable what is expressed verbally by AA members -- hence my reference to the streetlight fallacy. You on the page now?

Okay, so you feel that AA members claiming/believing it is not religious counters the literature. Fair enough except if you are going to open it up like that, you can't limit it to just AA members.

As with the Girl Guides of Canada, it wasn't what the members believed, or wanted to believe, it was the general public's perception of the organization that led to the removal of all religious references.

Girl Guide Promise (pre-1994)

I promise, on my honour, to do my best:
To do my duty to God, the Queen, and my country,
To help other people at all times,
And to obey the Guide Law.

Promise (1994-2010)

I promise to do my best,
To be true to myself, my God/faith* and Canada;
I will help others,
And accept the Guiding Law.
*The word God or the word faith is chosen according to each girl's own personal convictions.

Promise (current)
I promise to do my best,
To be true to myself, my beliefs and Canada.
I will take action for a better world
And respect the Guiding Law

In the GGoC Promise of 1994 - 2010 the words "God/faith" were a compromise exactly like AA's claim of "God as we know him" is a compromise. Both compromises don't change anything except in the minds of those who really want to believe that they change things. for anyone new, looking at the organizations for the first time, they are both still religious organizations. The GGoC identified the problem, addressed it, and can now honestly claim they are inclusive of all girls. AA cannot in all honesty make the claim that they are inclusive of all alcoholics.

In essence, AA started off as a religious organization and hasn't changed enough to throw off that label. That has been made clear on every occasion that it arises.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom