Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
It's my claim that people claim ? You mean I actually have to quote people saying they claim what I claim they claim ? Aren't you taking this goalpost-moving thing a little too far ?

Do you seriously not see the poroblem here?? :confused:
If you are going to stand steadfastly to what other people claim you need to investigate and confirm their claim.
It is an appeal to, or argument to authority of the worst kind: The authority is "people say". FFS! :rolleyes:

No, I don't. I very clearly said that I didn't see any studies on this matter. It's you who's beating up a strawman, here.

You confirm my point. You have taken it on faith (ironic huh) something you have heard. BTW, I have some primo real estate you will be interested in. ;)

Investigate and get the evidence that supports your beliefs, in the meantime you are arguing from ignorance.

No. But we wouldn't be having that part of the discussion if it wasn't for the mandatory, state-sanctioned membership issue. AA is STILL religious even if the government doesn't send you there, however.

Umm??? Whatever.
 
This entire thread is one long investigation into the semantics of a few key words -- beginning with "religious".

I notice that this is a semantic argument. Why is it that when I do that, it's me "being stuck" ("playing with words", etc), but when you do it, or when Belz does it (as in the examples above), it's something else? And what is that something else? Or are you stuck too? What's different about what you're doing and what I'm doing?

Now that I've made these inquiries into the nature of the argument you've just made, I'll address the argument itself. Not surprisingly, I disagree completely. What you have provided is a good example of an observation which initially had no explanation and which later came to be treated as evidence -- after an attempt was made to explain it.

You know, the only reason we ever got started on this is that one of the most prolific posters in this thread likes to take the familiar strategy of simply pounding the table demanding evidence, as if the presentation of new evidence is the only means by which an argument can be refuted. I have argued, and will continue to argue, that evidence is worthless (and potentially worse than worthless) if the logic used in interpreting it is flawed, and that valid counterarguments can take the form of simply examining the logic. In criminal trials, the prosecution and the defense typically both take the same evidence, and from that develop different theories. No piece of evidence may be presented which is exempt from examination and interpretation by both sides, and very rarely (outside of Hollywood) is a case settled by the dramatic introduction of some new and devastating piece of evidence. The theory that wins is (ideally) the one that best explains the facts already in evidence. That's exactly what's been happening here: we're all looking at the same evidence and reaching different conclusions, and the incessant and repetitive demands for additional evidence suggest that somebody doesn't get that.


Wasn't addressed to you anyway. Of course, now that I have just asked you basically the same question, maybe I do need to ask: Will you join the "I refuse to answer" club as well?

It was intended as parody. I can only hope that your response, with its absurd mischaracterization of my position, was offered in the same spirit (but I have a bad feeling it wasn't).

And I really hope this was intended as a joke, but I'm getting that bad feeling again.

So the post quoted was intended as a parody?
 
It was intended as parody. I can only hope that your response, with its absurd mischaracterization of my position, was offered in the same spirit (but I have a bad feeling it wasn't).

And I really hope this was intended as a joke, but I'm getting that bad feeling again.

You might want to take something for that bad feeling.
 
So the post quoted was intended as a parody?
I really don't understand why some of you seem to have so much trouble following the conversation. You do know about the little red arrow thingy right after the poster's name in a quoted post, right?

You said: "This seems to be a form of Scholasticism where logical syllogisms take the place of evidence."
I responded: "Do you have any evidence to back up that claim?"

If you didn't recognize that as parody, it's probably for approximately the same reason that so many first time visitors to Landover Baptist Church don't immediately grasp what's going on there.
 
I really don't understand why some of you seem to have so much trouble following the conversation. You do know about the little red arrow thingy right after the poster's name in a quoted post, right?

You said: "This seems to be a form of Scholasticism where logical syllogisms take the place of evidence."
I responded: "Do you have any evidence to back up that claim?"

If you didn't recognize that as parody, it's probably for approximately the same reason that so many first time visitors to Landover Baptist Church don't immediately grasp what's going on there.

So if I fail don't spot your cleverly concealed parody it's my lack of understanding and not your lack of clarity that is at fault?

Or could it be that it wasn't parody?

parody
- 4 dictionary results
par·o·dy
   /ˈpærədi/ Show Spelled [par-uh-dee] Show IPA noun, plural -dies, verb, -died, -dy·ing.
–noun
1.
a humorous or satirical imitation of a serious piece of literature or writing: his hilarious parody of Hamlet's soliloquy.
2.
the genre of literary composition represented by such imitations.
3.
a burlesque imitation of a musical composition.
4.
any humorous, satirical, or burlesque imitation, as of a person, event, etc.
5.
the use in the 16th century of borrowed material in a musical setting of the Mass (parody Mass).
6.
a poor or feeble imitation or semblance; travesty: His acting is a parody of his past greatness
 
So if I fail don't spot your cleverly concealed parody it's my lack of understanding and not your lack of clarity that is at fault?
No, I must accept the responsibility. In indulging that impulse, I neglected to keep in mind that some things are hard to parody.

There is a particular brand of irrational thinking, exhibited by some posters here, that has skepticism as entailing nothing more than smugly demanding evidence at every turn, and regards logical interpretation of evidence as secondary in importance (when not completely unnecessary). It is, in itself, a form of unintentional parody; an imitation of skepticism; a sophomoric approach to skepticism under which regurgitation of facts represents the end of the investigative process rather than the starting point. It is a "feel good" skepticism whose adherents show little real interest in difficult questions or the often grueling process of obtaining answers; for them, these exercises mostly represent opportunities to reaffirm that they are part of an exciting social movement. They don't recognize genuine skepticism as a rigorous discipline; but then, they don't have the patience for it anyway. Rigidity in thinking is a cheap substitute for rigor in methodology, and the irony is that in taking that easy way out, these pseudoskeptics make themselves into mirror images of the religious fundamentalists they so thoroughly despise -- the ones who, on close examination, so often turn out to have only a passing aquaintance with the principles they so loudly proclaim as sacred. And, in so doing, they make themselves just as hard to parody.
 
No, I must accept the responsibility. In indulging that impulse, I neglected to keep in mind that some things are hard to parody.

There is a particular brand of irrational thinking, exhibited by some posters here, that has skepticism as entailing nothing more than smugly demanding evidence at every turn, and regards logical interpretation of evidence as secondary in importance (when not completely unnecessary).


You may be frustrated by the process, but I think that this is a gross mischaracterization of the position "in opposition" to you. As a lurker and participant, I think that your points have been addressed; but perhaps not to your satisfaction. There were long derails which you enthusiastically took part in, discussing points which YOU raised. Dictionaries were consulted, evidence presented, philosophers mentioned (moreso than just in passing), and points raised and discussed.

I'm failing sincerely to see what it is you think you're not getting responses to.

The last exchange between you and I for example -- I haven't replied because I see it as a point that you and I will not reach consensus on. I'm failing to understand how AA does not have some, specific, shared beliefs, the core of which is spiritual and deific. As I've brought up time and again, a higher power is necessary to the AA philosophy and program and cannot be defined as certain things -- like "self" and "nothing" (or "no higher power at all"). This conclusion has been arrived at through the texts, writings, letters, experiences shared, official AA World opinion and direction; the founders and the beliefs expressed by the majority of people in the majority of meetings that we anecdotally have seen.

As Alfie has pointed out, ad nauseum, the phrases "God as we understand Him", "these are only suggestions" will flatly negate ALL the other combined experiences, writings, texts, and wishes of what the founders intended.

I disagree with that position; I find it untenable and faintly ridiculous. Many of us have personal success stories within AA and I don't wish to take anything away from that experience, but I just can't seem to recommend the program to anyone who might be uncomfortable with a purely spiritual approach to sobriety.
 
Last edited:
I'm failing to understand how AA does not have some, specific, shared beliefs, the core of which is spiritual and deific. As I've brought up time and again, a higher power is necessary to the AA philosophy and program and cannot be defined as certain things -- like "self" and "nothing" (or "no higher power at all").
And as you've been repeatedly told by AA members; you are wrong.

This conclusion has been arrived at through the texts, writings, letters, experiences shared, official AA World opinion and direction; the founders and the beliefs expressed by the majority of people in the majority of meetings that we anecdotally have seen.
Majorities do not rule AA meetings, as you as an attendee should well know, nor do texts and writings.

As Alfie has pointed out, ad nauseum, the phrases "God as we understand Him", "these are only suggestions" will flatly negate ALL the other combined experiences, writings, texts, and wishes of what the founders intended.
Indeed so.

I disagree with that position; I find it untenable and faintly ridiculous.
Your choice. So what? Other do agree.

Many of us have personal success stories within AA and I don't wish to take anything away from that experience, but I just can't seem to recommend the program to anyone who might be uncomfortable with a purely spiritual approach to sobriety.
As has been mentioned more than once, define "spiritual". And as soon as you do, others will have different definitions.

Of course if you have better alternatives to AA meetings, I'd certainly agree that's where you and people who think like you do should be.
 
As Alfie has pointed out, ad nauseum, the phrases "God as we understand Him", "these are only suggestions" will flatly negate ALL the other combined experiences, writings, texts, and wishes of what the founders intended.

I disagree with that position; I find it untenable and faintly ridiculous. Many of us have personal success stories within AA and I don't wish to take anything away from that experience, but I just can't seem to recommend the program to anyone who might be uncomfortable with a purely spiritual approach to sobriety.

I agree. I can see how Alfie can come to a conclusion that works for him but I can also see, very easily, how that conclusion would not work for everybody and, specifically, how it would not work for people who don't agree that "good morals" can be had by picking and choosing out of a 3000 year old book and its 2000 year old addendum.

Picking and choosing which parts of AA overide all the other parts is no different than picking and choosing which moral lessons from the bible overide all other moral lessons contained within it.

I further disagree with the perception that people who can perform such mental gymnastics are somehow more worthy of recovery. That they are "ready" while the people who see the obvious contradiction, are not.

For me, that is what this entire discussion boils down to. The religious references in AA make it a religious organization just like they did with the Girl Guides of Canada organization. Remove the references, as the Girl Guides did, and the organization is no longer religious and everyone gets to benefit from the services of the organization regardless of their religious beliefs.

Thanks for putting a little bit of sanity back in this thread. :)
 
And as you've been repeatedly told by AA members; you are wrong.

And yet, many AA members have specifically stated, in this thread, that you are wrong.

Majorities do not rule AA meetings, as you as an attendee should well know, nor do texts and writings.

"Group conscience" is simple majority rule? The worst, most intolerant kind.

As has been mentioned more than once, define "spiritual". And as soon as you do, others will have different definitions.

One can be spiritual without being religious, too bad AA insists on religion instead of just spirituality.

Of course if you have better alternatives to AA meetings, I'd certainly agree that's where you and people who think like you do should be.

Just like all those immigrants should go back where they came from. And all those blacks should ride at the back of the bus and drink from their own fountains. And all those gays should get back in the closet.

Does AA foster this type of intolerance or did you bring it with you when you joined? :rolleyes:
 
One can be spiritual without being religious, too bad AA insists on religion instead of just spirituality.

The bolded party is what I have been saying since day one of this thread, now you see it the same way. I'm glad; it didn't seem to be your view earlier.

The second part, I just can't let go unchallenged.
Can you please provide evidence (anywhere), that "AA insists on religion instead of just spirituality".

As is oft heard in meetings: "It is a spiritual program, not religious"
 
And as you've been repeatedly told by AA members; you are wrong.


Oh? The big book specifically says we are powerless over alcohol. How can we be powerless over alcohol and yet be our own higher power? And I've seen no evidence that any AAer believes that no higher power is acceptable. Any higher power you decide to make up is fine, but it has to be something. Without this, the spiritual program of AA falls apart.

Remove spirituality, and you're not doing AA -- you're doing Rational Recovery.



Majorities do not rule AA meetings, as you as an attendee should well know, nor do texts and writings.

Qayak already responded partially to this; "group conscience" is precisely rule by majority.


As has been mentioned more than once, define "spiritual". And as soon as you do, others will have different definitions.

Your point? You might be surprised at the fact that others with whom you disagree, can actually arrive at a consensus on the meanings of words and still disagree with the premise of the discussion.


Of course if you have better alternatives to AA meetings, I'd certainly agree that's where you and people who think like you do should be.


More and more, I'm thinking of showing up to even more AA meetings than I did before in the interests of getting new members to a LifeRing group I'm wanting to get started. We may not be many where I live, but non-theists and non-spiritualists need support groups too. :)



Thanks for putting a little bit of sanity back in this thread. :)


Well, now I'm kind of embarrassed; I had thought that I needed to give more input considering that you and GB and a few others have really carried the message and frankly, had changed my viewpoint since I started reading the thread and thinking more critically about the organization I was attending.



Just like all those immigrants should go back where they came from. And all those blacks should ride at the back of the bus and drink from their own fountains. And all those gays should get back in the closet.

Good call, sir! (ETA: I meant, "well said" and not that I was actually agreeing with it! heh.)



As is oft heard in meetings: "It is a spiritual program, not religious"

It's going to become my new mantra: "difference without distinction."
 
Last edited:
The bolded party is what I have been saying since day one of this thread, now you see it the same way. I'm glad; it didn't seem to be your view earlier.

I have never denied it is possible, in fact, I stated it several times in the thread. Unfortunately, as I stated earlier, AA doesn't leave that option open.

The second part, I just can't let go unchallenged.
Can you please provide evidence (anywhere), that "AA insists on religion instead of just spirituality".

That has been done throughout this thread. All the references to God and a Higher Power are the religious part. Being merely spiritual would simply be telling people that they do have power over alcohol and they have to find a reason to quit if doing it for themselves isn't enough. For instance, doing it for your kids, your wife, your door knob. (Sorry, couldn't resist.)

As is oft heard in meetings: "It is a spiritual program, not religious"

I was tempted to make a smart remark off this but that would just return us to where we were.

So, let me ask you this. If I were an alcoholic and an atheist, I was looking into AA because I truly wanted to quit, how would you convince me that the God/Higher Power references are not contrary to my atheistic beliefs? (In other words, perhaps I am completely misunderstanding what goes on at an AA meeting and so would like to see a member in action addressing the issue.)

We could do it as a conversation if you would like.
 
I have never denied it is possible, in fact, I stated it several times in the thread. Unfortunately, as I stated earlier, AA doesn't leave that option open.

And once again you give unqualified nonsense as a response. AA leaves the door wide open, one needs merely to look at the innumerable higher powers available to see that in evidence.

That has been done throughout this thread. All the references to God and a Higher Power are the religious part.

And all through the thread that has been shown there is no "insistance made". It does say thing like "suggestion", "as you understand him" etc. So yet again I note the fail and dodge to show where this is said:

One can be spiritual without being religious, too bad AA insists on religion instead of just spirituality.

Being merely spiritual would simply be telling people that they do have power over alcohol and they have to find a reason to quit if doing it for themselves isn't enough.

.... In your opinion.

So, let me ask you this. If I were an alcoholic and an atheist, I was looking into AA because I truly wanted to quit, how would you convince me that the God/Higher Power references are not contrary to my atheistic beliefs? (In other words, perhaps I am completely misunderstanding what goes on at an AA meeting and so would like to see a member in action addressing the issue.)

We could do it as a conversation if you would like.

I have responded to this on numerous occasions already. I will not be so hypocritical as to not repeat myself (maybe you could do the same at some stage ;)).

The higher power is one of your understanding.

It can be the universe, or the laws of natue. (Great Out Doors).
It might be a better way of thinking, personal growth and a desire to improve ourselves (Good orderly direction).
It might be the fellowship itself (group of Drunks).
Maybe it is a combination/amalgam of some or all three.
Maybe you have a different idea of what spirituality is.

Depending on the individual, we would explore their understanding of the word god and spiritual. I might say that spirituality may include one's purpose in life - so often men and women use their kids as an example of a spiritual connection; it is they that keeps them going (in part).

(I might even suggest they do some reading around this). I heard Martin Scorcese say - and I paraphrase - that he liked making movies, it was a spiritual experience for the people viewing them, the spiritual aspect was the shared experience.

So perhaps spirituality can be something starting with this type of concept.

So Qayak; acting in good faith, in terms of this "conversation" and assuming you are a hard atheist and genuine in your question, where would you like to begin?
 
Last edited:
No, I must accept the responsibility. In indulging that impulse, I neglected to keep in mind that some things are hard to parody.

There is a particular brand of irrational thinking, exhibited by some posters here, that has skepticism as entailing nothing more than smugly demanding evidence at every turn, and regards logical interpretation of evidence as secondary in importance (when not completely unnecessary). It is, in itself, a form of unintentional parody; an imitation of skepticism; a sophomoric approach to skepticism under which regurgitation of facts represents the end of the investigative process rather than the starting point. It is a "feel good" skepticism whose adherents show little real interest in difficult questions or the often grueling process of obtaining answers; for them, these exercises mostly represent opportunities to reaffirm that they are part of an exciting social movement. They don't recognize genuine skepticism as a rigorous discipline; but then, they don't have the patience for it anyway. Rigidity in thinking is a cheap substitute for rigor in methodology, and the irony is that in taking that easy way out, these pseudoskeptics make themselves into mirror images of the religious fundamentalists they so thoroughly despise -- the ones who, on close examination, so often turn out to have only a passing aquaintance with the principles they so loudly proclaim as sacred. And, in so doing, they make themselves just as hard to parody.


Talking about yourself in the third person again?

Edited by jhunter1163: 
Edited for civility.


GB
 
Last edited by a moderator:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom