Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Don't you think it's disingenuous to ask for evidence when you have already declared that logic trumps facts?
It was intended as parody. I can only hope that your response, with its absurd mischaracterization of my position, was offered in the same spirit (but I have a bad feeling it wasn't).

Seems to me that any power higher than human power would be superhuman and therefore supernatural since humans are part of nature
And I really hope this was intended as a joke, but I'm getting that bad feeling again.
 
That might have something to do with the fact that gods are supernatural by definition.
Unless one chooses to define "God" some other way. Of course, if you're unwilling to do that, or if you see it as somehow "not allowed", it naturally follows that you'd expect others to be just as bound by your rigidity in thinking as you are yourself.

And don't you just love weasel words ?
I described that word as more than a qualifier in that context. You may have overlooked that argument, or you may have chosen to ignore it, but you haven't answered it.

"Ultimate or immaterial reality" doesn't refer to the supernatural ?
I guess that depends on whether you consider modern science to be adequate as a "Theory of Everything".
 
Unless one chooses to define "God" some other way. Of course, if you're unwilling to do that, or if you see it as somehow "not allowed", it naturally follows that you'd expect others to be just as bound by your rigidity in thinking as you are yourself.

I really love you, man. Few people manage to stretch definitions to galactic proportions while making it appear as though it's their opponents who are using definitions that are too narrow.

I described that word as more than a qualifier in that context. You may have overlooked that argument, or you may have chosen to ignore it, but you haven't answered it.

AA's inclusion of the word is just for weasel purposes, just in case someone points it out.

I guess that depends on whether you consider modern science to be adequate as a "Theory of Everything".

Here's you with your philosopher's hat, again.
 
Few people manage to stretch definitions to galactic proportions while making it appear as though it's their opponents who are using definitions that are too narrow.
A couple of pages back I introduced an important concept: the difference between linguistic meaning and speaker's meaning. Here, the phrase: "As WE understood" indicates that we're not even talking about speaker's meaning. We're talking about thinker's meaning: an individual's private understanding, possibly useful only to him in managing his own internal affairs, and independent of any need to communicate the details of that process. Words like "home", and "fun" have commonly understood meanings, but most of us (beyond about the age of five or six) are able to comprehend that the personal referents for these words vary considerably from one individual to another; that our idea of "home" (the public version of that concept) need not be limited to my idea of "home".

A person who had lived most of his life in an RV, or a prison, might announce: "I'm going home", knowing full well that "home" to him means something so much different from what it does to the people he was speaking to that they might not even consider him to have a home at all. Even a homeless person might say he was "going home", meaning back to his cardboard box under the bridge. If he felt a need to be particularly fussy, he might qualify his statement by saying something like: "I'm going to that place I choose to call home", or "I'm going home as I understand it" -- but most of the time he'd probably just say "home", and let it default to the public version of that concept. And any (adult) person who rigidly insisted that he could only mean that he was going to a place that closely matched their own personal, private understanding of that concept I would have to regard as suffering from a mental deficiency.

Here's you with your philosopher's hat, again.
My linguist's hat works just as well here. Donning it, I can note that "supernatural" may be taken to refer simply to "that which is beyond the realm of current scientific understanding". I can then don my physicist's hat, and note that "ultimate or immaterial reality" (the "ultimate" part in particular) might be taken to refer to a Unified Field Theory (often loosely referred to as a "Theory of Everything"), and then add the observation that the realm of current scientific understanding does not include any such theory. But "supernatural" might also be taken to refer to something that violates the fundamental laws of physics -- known or unknown -- in which case, I would say no, "ultimate and immaterial reality" cannot meaningfully refer to the supernatural.
 
I'm not arguing from ignorance. Sheesh those fallacies elude you. I'm saying that people claim that AA is no better than quitting on your own. You seem to have no argument to disprove that claim other than silly games.

And yet here you contradict yourself.
"People claim" is your claim, the onus of proof here is on who? Guess what - you.

So you are not only arguing from a place of ignorance, you display that ignorance with pride.

And what YOU fail to understand, is that those 5% would STILL quit if they didn't go to AA. But at least the other 95% wouldn't have felt pressured.

Virtually every alcoholic trying to, or considering making change is under pressure. Alcoholics have a great ability for finding reasons not to quit - if this were not the case there would be no relapses with other treatments. I assume the pressure you mean is that of these religious undertones; if so, you would need to prove to me (show me) that 95% leave AA because of same.

The other thing you need to prove is that the 5% would "STILL quit if they didn't go to AA". You stand steadfastly to this claim - again, with nothing but your gut and a number (of coincidence) as evidence.

If it were voluntary we wouldn't be having this discussion.

I have stated a number of times in this thread that I do not believe that 'the state' should be sending people to AA: It is abdicating its' responsibility.

So, I find it very hard to believe you
a. missed that
b. have based every argument you put forward around this "voluntary" requirement.


My claims of you arguing from ignorance not only stand, they are enhanced further by your latest posts. Prove what you claim - or at least support them with something more than coincidences.
 
Last edited:
Never have said anything more than that there must be some specific shared beliefs. It's amusing to watch you try to dispute it, as even your precious dictionary says exactly that: "A specific fundamental set of beliefs and practices generally agreed upon by a number of persons or sects. No wonder you dodged it for so long.

Indeed not, since religious texts simply reflect the oral traditions that preceded them.

You know, GB, there is a very old joke about a drunk who went looking for his lost car keys under a street lamp because that's where the light was best. The meme is invoked quite often as an example of flawed reasoning. Google it. You'll see.

What you're saying is that the lack of any reliable means of examining the subjective element justifies declaring the matter to be objectively resolveable on the only evidence available: the writings. Adding to the comic value of this already laughable attempt at logic is the fact that the writings themselves immediately refer us right back to the subjective experience of the individual -- don't they? You have asserted -- scores of times in this thread, if not hundreds -- that AA is based on Protestant Christian doctrines. And what is that religion's most central and indispensible premise? It's all about what? Faith, did you say? And what is faith, if not a subjective experience?

I see that you do sense what's happening here. Internal contradiction is precisely your problem.

Not only have I NOT DODGED THE ISSUE, I have REPEATEDLY ADDRESSED IT (another lie on your part).

I have REPEATEDLY pointed out that it is NOT NECESSARY for all members of a Religious Organization to share the "same specific beliefs" to make the determination that said Organization is a Religious Organization.

The one with an Internal Contradiction is the Non-theist attempting to justify his/her belonging to a Theistic Organization.

Your continued lies, epistemological obfuscations, and sophistry are the only straws you can grasp at with your failed arguments.

GB
 
Last edited:
Not only have I NOT DODGED THE ISSUE, I have REPEATEDLY ADDRESSED IT (another lie on your part).
It's funny how every time I ask you to provide a specific post in which you have addressed an argument I've made, I always get the same answer: "Already addressed that repeatedly" -- yet, when I go looking myself, I never am able to find any post in which you actually did that. Seems like you'd be quite eager to wave those posts in my face, if they actually existed. Let me demonstrate how a thing like that might work:

Almost twenty pages ago, I asked you this:
I've postulated that beliefs are not "religious" if they lack any of three qualities: specific, shared, supernatural. Before this is all over, will you ever once attempt to address that directly?
Your response?
Dymanic said:
<blah, blah, babble, usual crap, sophistry and lies snipped>
Got any evidence that AA is not religious?
I guess we can assume then that the times you REPEATEDLY ADDRESSED that argument must have come after that post, or you would have claimed then to have already addressed it. Follow my logic there? But wait... your very next post was the one in which you openly stated that you would not attempt to address arguments of that nature:
I have little to no patience for this kind of crap. I made a HUGE mistake by allowing Dymanic to goad me into a thread derail with HIS Pseudo-Philosophical Crap. Well screw that. It's back to Brass Tacks and Evidence for me.
So it couldn't very well have been after that, either. Right? Follow my logic there? Where oh where could those posts be, I wonder?

Something here stinks real bad, GB, and if you don't like having your face rubbed in it, all you have to do is drop the low-rent tactics and step up.


I have REPEATEDLY pointed out that it is NOT NECESSARY for all members of a Religious Organization to share the "same specific beliefs" to make the determination that said Organization is a Religious Organization.
The "repeatedly" business aside, you appear not to have noticed (or chose to ignore) that I have just stated that I never said any such thing. Create as many straw versions as you like, just as you did here:
You're the one saying that everyone has to share all the beliefs of a religious organization for the religious organization to be religious.
and then claim to have "addressed" my argument. I think I actually prefer that to open refusal to address it at all. But no matter how you try to skew it with absolutes like "everyone" and "all", my argument remains the same.
 
It's funny how every time I ask you to provide a specific post in which you have addressed an argument I've made, I always get the same answer: "Already addressed that repeatedly" . . .

I am trying to figure this out . . . didn't you read the post you responded to? In that post GB states that he has responded to the question several times AND THEN HE RESPONDS AGAIN!

Also, the shared beliefs you so desperately desire have been pointed out by many other people, GB and myself included. If you need a recap, start with the 12 Steps.

Now, I am trying to stay within the guidelines of the MA but you make it pretty difficult. If I ran into someone in person who exhibited this behaviour I would know right away if they were drunk, stoned, or just plain obstinate. On the internet one does not have that luxury so could you please explain why you are being so blatantly dishonest?
 
It's funny how every time I ask you to provide a specific post in which you have addressed an argument I've made, I always get the same answer: "Already addressed that repeatedly" -- yet, when I go looking myself, I never am able to find any post in which you actually did that. Seems like you'd be quite eager to wave those posts in my face, if they actually existed. Let me demonstrate how a thing like that might work:

Almost twenty pages ago, I asked you this:
Your response?
I guess we can assume then that the times you REPEATEDLY ADDRESSED that argument must have come after that post, or you would have claimed then to have already addressed it. Follow my logic there? But wait... your very next post was the one in which you openly stated that you would not attempt to address arguments of that nature:
So it couldn't very well have been after that, either. Right? Follow my logic there? Where oh where could those posts be, I wonder?

Something here stinks real bad, GB, and if you don't like having your face rubbed in it, all you have to do is drop the low-rent tactics and step up.


The "repeatedly" business aside, you appear not to have noticed (or chose to ignore) that I have just stated that I never said any such thing. Create as many straw versions as you like, just as you did here: and then claim to have "addressed" my argument. I think I actually prefer that to open refusal to address it at all. But no matter how you try to skew it with absolutes like "everyone" and "all", my argument remains the same.

What stinks are your repeated lies.

In the case of your statement whether YOU say all or some doesn't significantly alter your point. You are still making the point that a Religious Organization can ONLY be determined if one includes the shared aspects of belief. Thus the claims I am "Straw Manning" you is a false assertion:

Never have said anything more than that there must be some specific shared beliefs.

I have REPEATEDLY pointed out that it is NOT NECESSARY for all members of a Religious Organization to share the "same specific beliefs" to make the determination that said Organization is a Religious Organization.

There is no functional difference. Again you are clutching at straws. And I EXPLICITLY (AND REPEATEDLY) stated that not all members of a Religious Organization must have "SOME specific shared beliefs" for an organization to be religious. Thus DIRECTLY responding to your assertions. What follows are just a FEW of the posts in which I addressed your claims (which you are now PRETENDING don't exist:

Is the religiousity of AA a falsifiable proposition?
YES!

What would accomplish that? Evidence of people not praying? How many would it take? And how could we know for sure that they weren't praying? A person whose lips weren't moving might be praying silently, and, conversely, a person might be mouthing words without actually meaning any of it -- is that still praying? If I happen to mention God once or twice immediately after having dropped a hammer on my toe, does that constitute adequate evidence that I am a theist?

Your Honour, I am NOT attempting to convict Dymanic of being a Theist. But I WILL prove beyond a reasonable doubt that he belongs to a Religious Organization known by the name of Alcoholics Anonymous.

How will I do that you ask? The same way I can prove beyond a Reasonable Doubt that many non-praying/praying silently/word-mouthing/God mentioning once or twice (especially after dropping hammers on their toes) people belong to other Religious Organizations such as The Catholic Church, The Nation of Islam, Vedic sects of Tantric Hinduism, The Southern Baptist Church, The Anglican Communion/ The Unitarian Universalists and many others far too numerous to mention. Your Honour, I cannot rely on the word of individual adherents, as their own personal views vary widely from those who merely attend to demonstrate propriety without actually believing in either the doctrines and/or the Deity of their chosen Religious Organization, to those that Fundamentally believe that every word of their sacred texts must be taken as Literal Truth.
Thus, as with any religious organization, I must rely on the words of their Sacred Texts, and the Historical Record of the Organization, the Biographies of the founders and the texts of the Founders Letters and Ancillary Writings, and Legal Precedence including the upholding of the Second Circuit's decision by the US Supreme Court establishing the the Religiosity of AA.

Your Honour, I have submitted to you numerous briefs over the course of 61 pages of this thread containing this evidence, as has Tinyal and other members of our legal team.

In the Case of AA, the Evidence truly does Speak for Itself.
Glad to also have confirmation that I have not misrepresented your position with the above analogy:

"Ladies and Gentlemen of the jury, the defendant's fingerprints are all over the murder weapon, therefore you have no choice but to find him guilty".

Finally your Honour, the opposition attorney has deliberately misrepresented our case using specious analogies, and has deliberately discounted all the relevant evidence.

He claims that all we have are Fingerprints.

Yet as the submitted briefs have shown, our legal team also has DNA evidence, Ancillary Forensic Evidence, the Testimony of the Founders, the Historical Record, and Legal precedence.

GB

I have offered a definition for "religious" which still remains unchallenged here -- in fact, I don't recall one person having even "seen fit" to clarify whether they were rejecting that definition or accepting it but arguing that AA members DO adhere to a system of specific, shared, supernatural beliefs.

Love how you tamper with the definitions. And ya gotta love it when you claim that no-one's challenged your tampered definitions.

I seem to recall a very recent post that pointed out that the "shared" aspect of those that attend a religious organization is not necessarily "shared" at all.

Your Honour, I am NOT attempting to convict Dymanic of being a Theist. But I WILL prove beyond a reasonable doubt that he belongs to a Religious Organization known by the name of Alcoholics Anonymous.

How will I do that you ask? The same way I can prove beyond a Reasonable Doubt that many non-praying/praying silently/word-mouthing/God mentioning once or twice (especially after dropping hammers on their toes) people belong to other Religious Organizations such as The Catholic Church, The Nation of Islam, Vedic sects of Tantric Hinduism, The Southern Baptist Church, The Anglican Communion/ The Unitarian Universalists and many others far too numerous to mention.

Your Honour, I cannot rely on the word of individual adherents, as their own personal views vary widely from those who merely attend to demonstrate propriety without actually believing in either the doctrines and/or the Deity of their chosen Religious Organization, to those that Fundamentally believe that every word of their sacred texts must be taken as Literal Truth.


Thus, as with any religious organization, I must rely on the words of their Sacred Texts, and the Historical Record of the Organization, the Biographies of the founders and the texts of the Founders Letters and Ancillary Writings, and Legal Precedence including the upholding of the Second Circuit's decision by the US Supreme Court establishing the the Religiosity of AA.

Maybe you were hoping no-one would remember that such a clear refutation of your tampered definitions was on the previous page. Or maybe you hoped that I was just resting on my laurels gloating, never to return to rub it in your face. But there it is, in black and white (actually red and white now, in a font large enough for you to see). :D

GB



Insofar as all the major denominations of Christianity adhere to a core set of doctrines and a belief in the same Deity, we can refer to Christianity as a whole. The key doctrines of Original Sin, being covered by the blood of Christ (Absolution/Grace), and the Trinity are the tenets that define the majority of Christianity as a whole. These are the central doctrines that Catholic, Reformation, and "Eastern" Orthodox churches all adhere too.

Are their minority sects with "heretical" views of Christianity? Of course.

But we don't determine what is Christianity simply by the views its minority sects, any more than we determine what is Christianity by the individual views of its practitioners. We determine Christianity and its offshoots by their Sacred Texts and the ancillary writings of the founders of the splinter groups. GB

I don't know why you continue to LIE about this. I have categorically demonstrated that the "shared" aspect is not something that is empirically demonstrable...except insofar as adherents actually belong to said religious organization. I have made this point time and again as have others.

If you are a member of AA you belong to a religious organization. Your private beliefs have nothing to do with it.
GB

AA is a Religious Organization. The fact that you don't believe in its religious aspects (nearly all of it) doesn't make it any less a Religious Organization.
Now if you could only demonstrate YOUR assertions with Evidence and Logic.

GB

I could invent a New Religion tomorrow, build a Church (religious organization) and gather a few adherents. Some of those adherents may share only Some of the Specific "Shared" Beliefs of my New Church. Yet CLEARLY my Religious Organization would still be a Religious Organization.

Your arguments are built on distortions and lies.

GB
 
Last edited:
You are still making the point that a Religious Organization can ONLY be determined if one includes the shared aspects of belief.
Yes. No specific shared supernatural beliefs, no religious organization. Not all that complicated, really.

Thus the claims I am "Straw Manning" you is a false assertion:
I was quite specific in identifying the straw man. Here it is yet again:
You're the one saying that everyone has to share all the beliefs of a religious organization for the religious organization to be religious.
That WAS you who posted that, correct? And you DO understand that that is NOT my position? Can you possibly be stuck on an absurd overinterpretation of the word "shared"? Are you supposing that by that I mean necessarily shared by every single member?

And I EXPLICITLY (AND REPEATEDLY) stated that not all members of a Religious Organization must have "SOME specific shared beliefs" for an organization to be religious. Thus DIRECTLY responding to your assertions.
No, that was you restating your earlier premise, one which I do not dispute: that inclusion of some non-adherents is not enough to disqualify an organization as religious. That is not at all the same thing as addressing the question of whether the essential elements of religiousity reside in specific, shared, supernatural beliefs.

What follows are just a FEW of the posts...
What follows is an ugly mess that looks like the ravings of a loon. Most of it I couldn't make heads or tails out of when you first posted it, and I can't make heads or tails of it now, but I have endured the assault on my eyeballs long enough to identify at least a couple of sentences which are marginally coherent despite the excesses in text formatting:

We determine Christianity and its offshoots by their Sacred Texts and the ancillary writings of the founders of the splinter groups.
Texts in which the specific supernatural beliefs are innumerated in detail -- such as the ones you had listed a couple of sentences earlier: "The key doctrines of Original Sin, being covered by the blood of Christ (Absolution/Grace), and the Trinity" -- the very sort of thing which is utterly lacking in AA literature, a fact which serves as the basis for my contention that AA does not teach any specific supernatural beliefs.

I have categorically demonstrated that the "shared" aspect is not something that is empirically demonstrable...except insofar as adherents actually belong to said religious organization.
Well, like I said: marginally coherent. It certainly was not a rational answer to the question I had asked, which was whether the shared aspect is indispensible. It looks like your answer was that it cannot be indispensible because it is not empirically demonstrable, which is the "streetlight fallacy" again (as well as inconsistent with your stance that it's all about empirical evidence: the texts) -- but I can't quite tell if you were actually trying to answer the question at all (or if you even understand it, for that matter).

I could invent a New Religion tomorrow, build a Church (religious organization) and gather a few adherents. Some of those adherents may share only Some of the Specific "Shared" Beliefs of my New Church. Yet CLEARLY my Religious Organization would still be a Religious Organization.
So, if I have this straight: your church would have (and would teach) specific supernatural beliefs, correct? Presumably presented (one might say "shared") in some form of scripture?
 
Yes. No specific shared supernatural beliefs, no religious organization. Not all that complicated, really.

Which is complete BS of course. MY point is/was that YOU are claiming PRECISELY that which you JUST stated above. I even went into great ******* detail that not every member of had to share the same specific Supernatural beliefs to yet still be a member of a Religious Organization. Therefore NO STRAW MAN occurred.

Really, I'm sick of your fallacies and lies and YOUR LOONY OFF THE WALL ARGUMENTS. You are raving sir...because you don't have a supportable argument at all.

GB
 
A couple of pages back I introduced an important concept: the difference between linguistic meaning and speaker's meaning. Here, the phrase: "As WE understood" indicates that we're not even talking about speaker's meaning. We're talking about thinker's meaning: an individual's private understanding, possibly useful only to him in managing his own internal affairs, and independent of any need to communicate the details of that process. Words like "home", and "fun" have commonly understood meanings, but most of us (beyond about the age of five or six) are able to comprehend that the personal referents for these words vary considerably from one individual to another; that our idea of "home" (the public version of that concept) need not be limited to my idea of "home".

I didn't actually expect you to defend the fact that you're playing semantics games. But there you have it.
 
"People claim" is your claim, the onus of proof here is on who? Guess what - you.

It's my claim that people claim ? You mean I actually have to quote people saying they claim what I claim they claim ? Aren't you taking this goalpost-moving thing a little too far ?

So you are not only arguing from a place of ignorance, you display that ignorance with pride.

No, I don't. I very clearly said that I didn't see any studies on this matter. It's you who's beating up a strawman, here.

Virtually every alcoholic trying to, or considering making change is under pressure.

And now you're taking a page from the Dymanic "Twisting words" school of debating. Since I assume you know what I meant, I won't bother explaining it to you.

The other thing you need to prove is that the 5% would "STILL quit if they didn't go to AA".

Assuming they tried at all ?

I have stated a number of times in this thread that I do not believe that 'the state' should be sending people to AA: It is abdicating its' responsibility.

So, I find it very hard to believe you
a. missed that

I didn't miss that. I remember it quite clearly, in fact.

b. have based every argument you put forward around this "voluntary" requirement.

No. But we wouldn't be having that part of the discussion if it wasn't for the mandatory, state-sanctioned membership issue. AA is STILL religious even if the government doesn't send you there, however.
 
Which is complete BS of course.
Because....?

I even went into great ******* detail that not every member of had to share the same specific Supernatural beliefs to yet still be a member of a Religious Organization.
Yes you did. And you continue to rave about it even after I've pointed out several times that it never has been my position that for an organization to be religious every member must embrace the shared beliefs. You apparently need it pointed out to you that attacking a misrepresented version of an argument while avoiding dealing the actual argument is the definition of a "straw man".

I'm willing to extend the benefit of the doubt and allow that this may not be entirely deliberate on your part, but based on a failure to understand my position. I just asked a couple of questions regarding your hypothetical church which I believe will help to clarify this, but I cannot help noticing that you ignored them completely. In referring to "the specific shared beliefs" of your new church, you seemed to me to be implicitly acknowledging that for it to be a "church", there must be some such specific shared beliefs. I'll now ask you again: is that correct?
 
I didn't actually expect you to defend the fact that you're playing semantics games.
And I don't actually expect you to respond to my multiple earlier requests to explain why it is that when MY arguments involve examination of the meanings of the words we're using, that's me "playing semantics" (or any of a number of other ways you have phrased the same objection: "playing around with words", "twisting the meaning around", "whining about definitions") -- but when YOU do the same thing, it's something else. The last time we tried to discuss this, you ended up "lost", but I'll be happy to repeat the questions anyway.

Is it important to use words in a commonly agreed-upon way, or is it okay to just use them in whatever way best suits your purposes?
That one got me chirping crickets.

Dymanic said:
Have you never encountered the creationist argument that "Evolution is only a theory"? Do you understand that the reason that is such a pathetically weak argument is that it is based on the arguer's own ignorance of what the word, "theory" means in science? Is it "whining about definitions" to point out that ignorance?
I posted that question several times. The last time I did so, you finally gave up on claiming to be having trouble following the exchange, admitted that you HAD noticed the question after all, and openly declared yourself a member of the "I refuse to answer" club:
Yes. But since it's still you playing semantics, and I'm sick of it, I choose to skip it a third time.
So I will not be the least bit surprised should you choose to skip it again.
 
And I don't actually expect you to respond to my multiple earlier requests to explain why it is that when MY arguments involve examination of the meanings of the words we're using, that's me "playing semantics" (or any of a number of other ways you have phrased the same objection: "playing around with words", "twisting the meaning around", "whining about definitions") -- but when YOU do the same thing, it's something else. The last time we tried to discuss this, you ended up "lost", but I'll be happy to repeat the questions anyway.

Repeatedly asking the same question in hopes of getting the answer you want is not winning and argument. That question has been answered innumerable times in the thread. Move on, Dymanic.

That one got me chirping crickets.

Because it was answered many times before you asked it. Reading what others write is part of this whole exercise we call a discussion, Dymanic.

I posted that question several times. The last time I did so, you finally gave up on claiming to be having trouble following the exchange, admitted that you HAD noticed the question after all, and openly declared yourself a member of the "I refuse to answer" club:So I will not be the least bit surprised should you choose to skip it again.

Wow! You are definitely responding to the wrong thread if you think that question hasn't been answered here, Dymanic.

But let's talk refusals. Dymanic has refused to:

-Provide evidence.
-Read responses.
-Answer pointed questions.
-Examine evidence when provided.
-Provide evidence.
-Look up dictionary definitions.
-Read dictionary definitions when provided.
-Provide evidence.
-Etc., etc., ad nauseum.

It is no wonder you can't get past these irrelevent points, Dymanic. What do your pet philosophers have to say about that? :rolleyes:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom