God as you understand Him. Sounds supernatural to me.
I will not deny that it probably sounds supernatural to a lot of people -- in or out of AA. But it has been asserted here that it
cannot possibly refer to anything that is
not supernatural, and I can't agree with that. There's no accounting for people's understanding, and few limits to imagination (with some obvious exceptions, represented by certain posters here). The meme "God is other people" (an inversion of Sartre's "Hell is other people") is also familiar both in and out of AA, and represents only one among an infinite number of possible counterexamples.
Power greater than ourselves. Wishy-washy phrasing but, taken in context, clearly implies a supernatural power, especially when accompanied by phrases like "no human power could [help us recover from alcoholism]."
The phrase is from page 60 of the Big Book, and actually reads: "...
probably no human power could have relieved our alcoholism". The qualifier you omitted: "probably" is important -- and not
just as a qualifier. It helps to establish the context. It is a reference to lengthy discussion in a previous chapter, There is a Solution, which describes the resistence of alcoholism to the known treatment modalities of the day. A brief snippet: "
He begged the doctor to tell him the whole truth, and he got it. In the doctor's judgement he was utterly hopeless; he would never regain his position in society and he would have to place himself under lock and key or hire a bodyguard if he expected to live long. That was a great physician's opinion." (- page 26).
On the next page, the same doctor is quoted as saying, "
Exceptions to cases such as yours have been occurring since early times. [...] Alcoholics have had what are called vital spiritual experiences. To me these occurrences are phenomena. They appear to be in the nature of huge emotional displacements and rearrangements. Ideas, emotions, and attitudes which were once the guiding forces of the lives of thse men are suddenly cast to one side, and a completely new set of conceptions and motives begin to dominate them."
Are you ready to dismiss "huge emotional displacements and rearrangements" as not possible without the intervention of a supernatural power, real or imagined? I'm not.
I have trouble coming up with some other definition of "spiritual" other than supernatural.
Then if the description immediately above does not suffice, I'll repeat a recommendation I made much earlier: try the Wikipedia article titled: "Spirituality".
"
Spirituality can refer to an ultimate or immaterial reality; an inner path enabling a person to discover the essence of their being; or the deepest values and meanings by which people live."
Fuzzy as all get-out, to be sure; a possible departure point for dubious pseudo-philosophical adventures, perhaps; -- but supernatural? Not necessarily, in my view.
As I've stated before, the belief is that there is some Other, some unknown thing you make up so you're all warm and fuzzy that you can turn your life over to, that can listen to you, that can guide you in your new life of sobriety.
Reminds me of a song:
"It's the note that you leave on the breakfast table
With a list of things to help me plan my day
It's the way you say we could have
If you'd done the things you should have..."
Sorry. Got a little distracted there.
How can these things not fit precisely under your definition?
By not being specific, shared, or necessarily supernatural.
Bill W. and the others made it into something far more than just one alcoholic's opinion.
Alcoholics Anonymous certainly is something far more than just one alcoholic's opinion. That was precisely my point. AA now represents the opinions and experiences of millions of alcoholics worldwide -- and it shouldn't take more than ten or fifteen minutes of sitting in one of their meetings to confirm that they don't all agree on much of anything. Evidently, quite a few of them find their experiences with AA to be a poor fit to their understanding of what the word "religious" means -- or this thread would never have been started in the first place.