Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I'm going to also say that AA requires a belief in a higher power of some kind. The entire program falls apart without this belief. No higher power equals no AA.

There.

Another Specific Shared Belief. (With God thrown in for good measure.)

And around and around we go.

The higher power can be anything - a new way of life/thinking, a group of drunks, the universe, as well as any traditional deity one chooses to opt for.

Also, it is not a "requirement" it is a suggestion - that said, I personally believe it is a very important suggestion.
 
You claim that the 5% AA success is the same 5% that just stop. You then state that you have never seen any figures.

The dodges are yours and lead to the abject failures; you fail to answer anything and admit to not having information yet make statements from total ignorance. :boggled:
 
There. I posit that these three steps are the minimum that every AA'er believes in. Some. Specific. Shared. Beliefs.
The specific shared beliefs I was referring to there are part of an argument I've been making for some tens of pages. It's nice to finally see at least some attempts being made to address that, but you appear to have missed most of that non-discussion, so I'll clarify. My argument is that religiousity is dependent on beliefs with three essential qualities: specific, shared, supernatural.

The first item on your list fails on the observation that it does not refer to a supernatural belief. The other two serve to bolster the argument I've made all along: that in AA, the belief aspect is not merely non-specific, but explicity so, as the language you quoted demonstrates.

I'm going to also say that AA requires a belief in a higher power of some kind.
For your benefit, I will repost for the umpteenth time some of what GB would call "textual evidence" -- the sort that his entire case rests upon, and which he repeatedly states that I have not provided:

"First, Alcoholics Anonymous does not demand that you believe anything."
12&12, page 26.
 
The higher power can be anything . . .

Round, round he goes, where he'll stop, nobody knows!

It has already been shown that a Higher Power (I notice you use lower case H and P, unlike AA which uses upper case letters there) cannot be anything.

You change the spelling, change the meanings, ignore a large portion of AA literature, deceive yourself about AA, make statements directly contrary to what AA states, all to "prove" to us that anyone can fit in at AA.

No, Alfie, not just anyone can fit in. It takes a special kind of person to be that dishonest with themselves.
 
The specific shared beliefs I was referring to there are part of an argument I've been making for some tens of pages. It's nice to finally see at least some attempts being made to address that, but you appear to have missed most of that non-discussion, so I'll clarify. My argument is that religiousity is dependent on beliefs with three essential qualities: specific, shared, supernatural.


To be honest, I nearly dropped out of this thread on several occasions due to what I felt to be all of the in-depth yet off-topic discussions, so I very well could have missed your main point.



The first item on your list fails on the observation that it does not refer to a supernatural belief. The other two serve to bolster the argument I've made all along: that in AA, the belief aspect is not merely non-specific, but explicity so, as the language you quoted demonstrates.

For your benefit, I will repost for the umpteenth time some of what GB would call "textual evidence" -- the sort that his entire case rests upon, and which he repeatedly states that I have not provided:

"First, Alcoholics Anonymous does not demand that you believe anything."
12&12, page 26.


I didn't realize that every single shared belief must be supernatural in nature.

And as I've said from fairly recently on, there must be some sort of Higher Power belief -- there is absolutely no contextual or evidential acceptance of NO HIGER POWER WHATSOEVER. Bill W. grudgingly accepted the concepts of the vague Higher Power and a God of your Imagination, a God of your Choice -- but a God nonetheless.

It is stated over and over again, by Bill and others in the big book and personal letter, speeches, and so on, that AA is a spiritual program. That's why I put forth the argument that without some sort of spirituality, you are not doing AA.

[Dymanic mode]
And I never said that AA "demands" anything -- I said it was a requirement.
[/Dymanic mode]

Okay, sorry, just having a little fun with you. :)

But I think this is perhaps trying to address how one is considered a part of a larger group or organization. I will think more on this and come up with a comprehensive answer later on.
 
Do I ?

I said I didn't see the STUDIES, not the that I never saw the figures.

Reading comprehension failure, there.

Oops, sorry: FAIL!

Sigh... (or should I laugh)

How can you be certain of the figures if you have never seen the studies.
You are arguing from ignorance and can't see it. But this is a little side tangent of yours that moves away from the main point I was making.

But the abject failures I largely refer to is the fact that you still do not accept that we need every single opportunity for the alcoholic to get well. If we have a success rate of 5% at AA, that is 5% (I have heard as high as 13% btw). And in the context of recovery that is another opportunity for recovery. As I said, nothing is foolproof and until we have something that is, we need every resource.
As an aside, how much more might that be if the courts didn't order people there in the USA - i.e. they were all voluntary? They don't want to stop drinking and guess what, they wont. People have to be in a state of mind to want to change (and I again ask you to educate yourself about the stages of change).
 
Last edited:
http://www.behaviortherapy.com/whatworks.htm

Google LifeRing. SOS. Go to local library: borrow books from Rational Recovery.

Without having read (purchased) the book, I must admit to being rather confused here.
E.g."Brief interventions" has been ranked #1 with a (seemingly) 53% excellence rate (are they trying to say success rate?). Why? Because they went to a doctor?:confused:
These figures do not appear to reflect actual recovery/abstinence, and surely that must be the measure of any success.

This is what they say about brief interventions

Brief interventions are usually given by healthcare providers. If you have a good working relationship with your personal physician, this is a good starting point. He or she can screen you for possible alcohol problems and assess whether your drinking or drug use is putting your health at risk or causing problems of which you might not be aware. Your physician may also suggest a more comprehensive assessment of your drinking and/or drug use and suggest other resources in your community.

If you don't have a good working relationship with a physician, consider one of the Motivational enhancement options in the next section.


It sounds like they are talking about diagnosis here. As I say, confused.
 
I didn't realize that every single shared belief must be supernatural in nature.
Religions typically do include some specific, shared beliefs that are not supernatural in nature. My argument is that these are neither necessary nor sufficient when it comes to meeting the definition of "religious"; that the essence of religiousity -- the quality that distinguishes the religious from the secular -- resides in there being a core of specific shared beliefs which are supernatural in nature.

And as I've said from fairly recently on, there must be some sort of Higher Power belief -- there is absolutely no contextual or evidential acceptance of NO HIGER POWER WHATSOEVER.
Then surely it all turns on whether this MUST be a supernatural power. And even then, not just any old one. Bona fide religous systems place a very great deal of importance on this.

Bill W. grudgingly accepted the concepts of the vague Higher Power and a God of your Imagination, a God of your Choice -- but a God nonetheless.
To the extent that it is possible to generalize, it may be said that those things alcoholics do accept, they tend to accept grudgingly. You can see that grudge working there. In religious organizations, the word of a particular individual is often regarded as sacrosanct, so it's not surprising that those who are unable to find their way past their own biased assumptions simply refuse to accept that this is not the way it works in AA. In the final analysis, Bill's was just another alcoholic's opinion. Here's another piece of "textual evidence" from AA literature which has been provided a number of times before, despite continued claims to the contrary:

"You can, if you wish, make AA itself your higher power".
-12&12, page 27
 
Without having read (purchased) the book, I must admit to being rather confused here.
E.g."Brief interventions" has been ranked #1 with a (seemingly) 53% excellence rate (are they trying to say success rate?). Why? Because they went to a doctor?:confused:
These figures do not appear to reflect actual recovery/abstinence, and surely that must be the measure of any success.

This is what they say about brief interventions

Brief interventions are usually given by healthcare providers. If you have a good working relationship with your personal physician, this is a good starting point. He or she can screen you for possible alcohol problems and assess whether your drinking or drug use is putting your health at risk or causing problems of which you might not be aware. Your physician may also suggest a more comprehensive assessment of your drinking and/or drug use and suggest other resources in your community.

If you don't have a good working relationship with a physician, consider one of the Motivational enhancement options in the next section.


It sounds like they are talking about diagnosis here. As I say, confused.


Actually, you bring up a good point.

It would be interesting to know what percentage of AAers are self-diagnosed and how many are professionally diagnosed.

One of the lines that I've heard over the past decade or more has been, "if you think you're an alcoholic, you probably are." Well, I disagree and I now wonder what kind of an impact that would have on what we could reasonably see as affecting different treatment modalities.
 
One of the lines that I've heard over the past decade or more has been, "if you think you're an alcoholic, you probably are." Well, I disagree and I now wonder what kind of an impact that would have on what we could reasonably see as affecting different treatment modalities.

I'm pretty much on the same page as you on both counts here.
 
Last edited:
Religions typically do include some specific, shared beliefs that are not supernatural in nature. My argument is that these are neither necessary nor sufficient when it comes to meeting the definition of "religious"; that the essence of religiousity -- the quality that distinguishes the religious from the secular -- resides in there being a core of specific shared beliefs which are supernatural in nature.

God as you understand Him. Sounds supernatural to me.

Power greater than ourselves. Wishy-washy phrasing but, taken in context, clearly implies a supernatural power, especially when accompanied by phrases like "no human power could [help us recover from alcoholism]."

These are core concepts to the AA program. I know of no meeting that does not read the 12 steps at every meeting and/or have the poster of the 12 steps and 12 traditions (short form) up on the walls along with all the other pithy (and trite) sayings developed over the past seventy years.

The central doctrine of AA is that it's a spiritual program. I have trouble coming up with some other definition of "spiritual" other than supernatural. As I've stated before, the belief is that there is some Other, some unknown thing you make up so you're all warm and fuzzy that you can turn your life over to, that can listen to you, that can guide you in your new life of sobriety.

How can these things not fit precisely under your definition?



Then surely it all turns on whether this MUST be a supernatural power. And even then, not just any old one. Bona fide religous systems place a very great deal of importance on this.

According to the beliefs laid out in the texts, papers, letters and rituals that grew up surrounding those core beliefs, it's nothing but supernatural. Geez -- Higher Power? God? Really? Those core beliefs have nothing to do with the supernatural in your mind?



To the extent that it is possible to generalize, it may be said that those things alcoholics do accept, they tend to accept grudgingly. You can see that grudge working there. In religious organizations, the word of a particular individual is often regarded as sacrosanct, so it's not surprising that those who are unable to find their way past their own biased assumptions simply refuse to accept that this is not the way it works in AA. In the final analysis, Bill's was just another alcoholic's opinion. Here's another piece of "textual evidence" from AA literature which has been provided a number of times before, despite continued claims to the contrary:

"You can, if you wish, make AA itself your higher power".
-12&12, page 27

Bill W. and the others made it into something far more than just one alcoholic's opinion. That's what the OpEd column of the newspapers were for back in the day. See, he not only said this was his experience, but that he took the success (which much may have been exaggerated) of others and used the power of the group to impress the lone, struggling alcoholic. "This is the way to your salvation and deliverance from the evils of alcohol!" is what he, in essence, said. Only in the chapter Bill's Story does he use the first person, by the way. All other chapters, he speaks from the third person, "we", "us". "Many of us thought the way you do." "We too suffered as you, but we found peace and serenity through God."

The thing is, Bill W. and AA were never ashamed of this stance. They are not apologizing for their essentially thinly-hid proselytization.
 
God as you understand Him. Sounds supernatural to me.
I will not deny that it probably sounds supernatural to a lot of people -- in or out of AA. But it has been asserted here that it cannot possibly refer to anything that is not supernatural, and I can't agree with that. There's no accounting for people's understanding, and few limits to imagination (with some obvious exceptions, represented by certain posters here). The meme "God is other people" (an inversion of Sartre's "Hell is other people") is also familiar both in and out of AA, and represents only one among an infinite number of possible counterexamples.

Power greater than ourselves. Wishy-washy phrasing but, taken in context, clearly implies a supernatural power, especially when accompanied by phrases like "no human power could [help us recover from alcoholism]."
The phrase is from page 60 of the Big Book, and actually reads: "...probably no human power could have relieved our alcoholism". The qualifier you omitted: "probably" is important -- and not just as a qualifier. It helps to establish the context. It is a reference to lengthy discussion in a previous chapter, There is a Solution, which describes the resistence of alcoholism to the known treatment modalities of the day. A brief snippet: "He begged the doctor to tell him the whole truth, and he got it. In the doctor's judgement he was utterly hopeless; he would never regain his position in society and he would have to place himself under lock and key or hire a bodyguard if he expected to live long. That was a great physician's opinion." (- page 26).

On the next page, the same doctor is quoted as saying, "Exceptions to cases such as yours have been occurring since early times. [...] Alcoholics have had what are called vital spiritual experiences. To me these occurrences are phenomena. They appear to be in the nature of huge emotional displacements and rearrangements. Ideas, emotions, and attitudes which were once the guiding forces of the lives of thse men are suddenly cast to one side, and a completely new set of conceptions and motives begin to dominate them."

Are you ready to dismiss "huge emotional displacements and rearrangements" as not possible without the intervention of a supernatural power, real or imagined? I'm not.

I have trouble coming up with some other definition of "spiritual" other than supernatural.
Then if the description immediately above does not suffice, I'll repeat a recommendation I made much earlier: try the Wikipedia article titled: "Spirituality".

"Spirituality can refer to an ultimate or immaterial reality; an inner path enabling a person to discover the essence of their being; or the deepest values and meanings by which people live."

Fuzzy as all get-out, to be sure; a possible departure point for dubious pseudo-philosophical adventures, perhaps; -- but supernatural? Not necessarily, in my view.

As I've stated before, the belief is that there is some Other, some unknown thing you make up so you're all warm and fuzzy that you can turn your life over to, that can listen to you, that can guide you in your new life of sobriety.
Reminds me of a song:

"It's the note that you leave on the breakfast table
With a list of things to help me plan my day
It's the way you say we could have
If you'd done the things you should have..."

Sorry. Got a little distracted there.

How can these things not fit precisely under your definition?
By not being specific, shared, or necessarily supernatural.

Bill W. and the others made it into something far more than just one alcoholic's opinion.
Alcoholics Anonymous certainly is something far more than just one alcoholic's opinion. That was precisely my point. AA now represents the opinions and experiences of millions of alcoholics worldwide -- and it shouldn't take more than ten or fifteen minutes of sitting in one of their meetings to confirm that they don't all agree on much of anything. Evidently, quite a few of them find their experiences with AA to be a poor fit to their understanding of what the word "religious" means -- or this thread would never have been started in the first place.
 
Do you have any evidence to back up that claim?

Your own statement:

I have argued, and will continue to argue, that evidence is worthless (and potentially worse than worthless) if the logic used in interpreting it is flawed, and that valid counterarguments can take the form of simply examining the logic.

Don't you think it's disingenuous to ask for evidence when you have already declared that logic trumps facts?
 
Religions typically do include some specific, shared beliefs that are not supernatural in nature. My argument is that these are neither necessary nor sufficient when it comes to meeting the definition of "religious"; that the essence of religiousity -- the quality that distinguishes the religious from the secular -- resides in there being a core of specific shared beliefs which are supernatural in nature.

Then surely it all turns on whether this MUST be a supernatural power. And even then, not just any old one. Bona fide religous systems place a very great deal of importance on this.

To the extent that it is possible to generalize, it may be said that those things alcoholics do accept, they tend to accept grudgingly. You can see that grudge working there. In religious organizations, the word of a particular individual is often regarded as sacrosanct, so it's not surprising that those who are unable to find their way past their own biased assumptions simply refuse to accept that this is not the way it works in AA. In the final analysis, Bill's was just another alcoholic's opinion. Here's another piece of "textual evidence" from AA literature which has been provided a number of times before, despite continued claims to the contrary:

"You can, if you wish, make AA itself your higher power".
-12&12, page 27


Seems to me that any power higher than human power would be superhuman and therefore supernatural since humans are part of nature
 
How can you be certain of the figures if you have never seen the studies.

Gosh, Alfie. You really should take the time to read. When did I say I was certain, exactly ? Can you quote me on that ?

You are arguing from ignorance and can't see it.

I'm not arguing from ignorance. Sheesh those fallacies elude you. I'm saying that people claim that AA is no better than quitting on your own. You seem to have no argument to disprove that claim other than silly games.

But the abject failures I largely refer to is the fact that you still do not accept that we need every single opportunity for the alcoholic to get well. If we have a success rate of 5% at AA, that is 5% (I have heard as high as 13% btw).

And what YOU fail to understand, is that those 5% would STILL quit if they didn't go to AA. But at least the other 95% wouldn't have felt pressured.

As an aside, how much more might that be if the courts didn't order people there in the USA - i.e. they were all voluntary?

If it were voluntary we wouldn't be having this discussion.
 
I will not deny that it probably sounds supernatural to a lot of people

That might have something to do with the fact that gods are supernatural by definition.

The phrase is from page 60 of the Big Book, and actually reads: "...probably no human power could have relieved our alcoholism".

And don't you just love weasel words ?

"Spirituality can refer to an ultimate or immaterial reality; an inner path enabling a person to discover the essence of their being; or the deepest values and meanings by which people live."

"Ultimate or immaterial reality" doesn't refer to the supernatural ?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom