Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Only for those who wish to obfuscate them. Do you have this same difficulty with other words in the English language?

Actually it s the oversimplification of the usage that is causing you trouble. Often curiosity, reading, research and empathy is used to broaden minds.

It's quite telling that both you and Dynamic are attempting to rewrite the OP.

One can imagine why you see it that way - it would depend on your starting position.
So, what do you think it is asking exactly?
 
Actually it s the oversimplification of the usage that is causing you trouble. Often curiosity, reading, research and empathy is used to broaden minds.


One can imagine why you see it that way - it would depend on your starting position.
So, what do you think it is asking exactly?

Calling someone stupid is offensive no matter how many words you use.

Lacking empathy one often does things that abrade on others.
 
Which bit of "don't hold me to them", they were for "illustration" purposes only was hard to understand?

So YOU can use them as an argument but I can't turn them around on you because then they become fictional ? Hopefully, even you can see how utterly ridiculous that is.

Can you provide these numbers please? Do they group everything under the 'stopping on your own' heading too?

I've seen the 5% number cited in a number of places, but I've honestly never seen the studies. It would help if AA gave use THEIR numbers, though. But it's oft-repeated that 95% of AA members stop showing up after a year.

I would also like you to clarify what you mean when you say "they'd all be better off quitting in their own".

If no method is better than quitting on your own, keep your money and quit on your own.

And again you misinterpret; that was not what I said nor intended. Attempted deflection noted.;)

I'm having trouble understanding how you manage to state that it was a mistake on my part, and simultaneously call me dishonest in the same breath.
 
You lost the debate in objective terms.
That you think a question framed in terms of the subjective can be won or lost in terms of the objective is evidence of a flawed reasoning process.

Why do people insist that Bob Dylan's singing voice is not beautiful? We need only consult the dictionary to obtain a definition of the word "beautiful" and observe whether Bob Dylan's singing exhibits the listed properties. If we find that we are unable to make this determination ourselves we may defer to the expertise of individuals whose profession it is to deliver authoritative opinions on such matters, but to inqure further into the meaning of the word is to invoke a semantic argument, and that cannot be allowed, because purely objective questions like this one can only be determined on evidence.
 
If no method is better than quitting on your own, keep your money and quit on your own.


Unless they strap you down on a gurney, I fail to see why you're distinguishing "quitting on [one's] own" vs. treatment methodologies.

One ALWAYS quits on one's own. The argument that I see is which method one chooses is most effective -- and by extension, which method is most effective for the most number of people.

And of the studies done and presented at this point, AA is clearly ineffectual.

So I personally will from here on, not argue for any changes to be made to AA; I will simply choose a more effective (and FREE) alternative and tell others of these more effective (and FREE) alternatives.

Of course, nearly all of the people I've met in recovery seem quite satisfied with their "spiritual not religious" AA revivals, so, more power to them and their Sober Bretheren!
 
So YOU can use them as an argument but I can't turn them around on you because then they become fictional ? Hopefully, even you can see how utterly ridiculous that is.

I've seen the 5% number cited in a number of places, but I've honestly never seen the studies. It would help if AA gave use THEIR numbers, though. But it's oft-repeated that 95% of AA members stop showing up after a year.

If no method is better than quitting on your own, keep your money and quit on your own.

I'm having trouble understanding how you manage to state that it was a mistake on my part, and simultaneously call me dishonest in the same breath.

Abject FAILS noted. :D

Unless they strap you down on a gurney, I fail to see why you're distinguishing "quitting on [one's] own" vs. treatment methodologies.

Yep a completely ridiculous standpoint.

One ALWAYS quits on one's own. The argument that I see is which method one chooses is most effective -- and by extension, which method is most effective for the most number of people.

One size does not fit all.

So I personally will from here on, not argue for any changes to be made to AA; I will simply choose a more effective (and FREE) alternative and tell others of these more effective (and FREE) alternatives.

Could you provide me with a list please?

Of course, nearly all of the people I've met in recovery seem quite satisfied with their "spiritual not religious" AA revivals, so, more power to them and their Sober Bretheren!

Live and let live.
 
That you think a question framed in terms of the subjective can be won or lost in terms of the objective is evidence of a flawed reasoning process.

Why do people insist that Bob Dylan's singing voice is not beautiful? We need only consult the dictionary to obtain a definition of the word "beautiful" and observe whether Bob Dylan's singing exhibits the listed properties. If we find that we are unable to make this determination ourselves we may defer to the expertise of individuals whose profession it is to deliver authoritative opinions on such matters, but to inqure further into the meaning of the word is to invoke a semantic argument, and that cannot be allowed, because purely objective questions like this one can only be determined on evidence.

We aren't discussing something subjective like Beauty. We are addressing something concrete, with objective concrete definitions. Religion and Religious have the primary definitions already discussed. AA's God and His Doctrines fulfill the objective primary definition of religious.

It also happens that it fulfills all the other objective definitions of religious (and Spiritual) too, given the zealotry with which people defend it.

GB
 
We're discussing religiousity, which just happens to be centered around belief, a concept which explicitly refers to an internal state -- the very definition of "subjective".

Wrong, religiosity isn't necessarily centered around individual belief, it centers around the written expression of belief in God or Gods and the attendant Doctrines.

Whether or not people chose to strictly adhere to the doctrines as written is up to them. This is why religiosity cannot be determined by the varying beliefs of all members of a religious organization. Objectively, Empirically Determining the Religiosity of an Organization is to examine the Central Texts and Practices of the Organization.

This is how AA can be objectively determined to be a Religious Organization.

Thus you are committing a fallacy of conflating internal states with empirical data like textual and historical evidence.

GB
 
Wrong, religiosity isn't necessarily centered around individual belief, it centers around the written expression of belief in God or Gods and the attendant Doctrines.
It almost sounds like you're talking about shared beliefs there. Oh, I see: it's just a matter of what is written, regardless of whether anyone (other than the one(s) who wrote it) actually believes it or not. I think you need to pick one or the other, because you can't have it both ways.

Whether or not people chose to strictly adhere to the doctrines as written is up to them.
And now it looks like you're just making stuff up. If that's part of the definition of "religious", what dictionary did you get it from? Is it not possible for a totally illiterate person to be religious? If so, how do they know if they're adhering to what is written?

This is why religiosity cannot be determined by the varying beliefs of all members of a religious organization.
No, religiousity is determined by the specific, shared beliefs of the members of a religious organization.
 
No, religiousity is determined by the specific, shared beliefs of the members of a religious organization.

No, GB had it right.

You don't know which belief/s are shared by all members. In fact, most likely, none are in a large organization. That doens't mean the organization is not a religious one.
 
It almost sounds like you're talking about shared beliefs there. Oh, I see: it's just a matter of what is written, regardless of whether anyone (other than the one(s) who wrote it) actually believes it or not. I think you need to pick one or the other, because you can't have it both ways.

I'm not having it both ways. You're the one saying that everyone has to share all the beliefs of a religious organization for the religious organization to be religious. That is a fallacy.

And now it looks like you're just making stuff up. If that's part of the definition of "religious", what dictionary did you get it from? Is it not possible for a totally illiterate person to be religious? If so, how do they know if they're adhering to what is written?

No, but we've been over this ground before. The written aspect of religion isn't all there is to religion, but it's perhaps the only aspect (other than accoutremental artifacts and ancillary writings of founders or key leaders in certain traditions) that can provide us with reliable empirical data.

No, religiousity is determined by the specific, shared beliefs of the members of a religious organization.

It doesn't make any difference whatsoever whether an individual shares the beliefs of the specific doctrines and deities of the religious organization that they are a member of (as you are allegedly a Non-theist member of a religious organization you are living proof of that).

Indeed MANY members of religious organizations don't even know or understand all the Doctrines of their particular denomination--in Christianity many just have a cursory knowledge that Jesus died for their sins, and that He and His Father are One, that's it.

Ask a group of self-described Church-going Christians if they know the difference between Arminian, Pelagian, or Calvinist Doctrines, and a high percentage will not even have heard of those specific doctrines.

No, the only reliable evidence for the religiosity of an organization are the Textual (and Oral) Traditions and the Historical Evidence of such, that posits the existence of a deity or deities, and the associated doctrines of the deity/deities.

AA has plenty of that in its core texts and traditions, ergo it is as religious as any church or adjunctive organization (like the Salvation Army).

But as I said, I've been all over this before. Your feeble attempt to snare me in some sort of internal contradiction has failed.

GB
 
Last edited:
You're the one saying that everyone has to share all the beliefs of a religious organization for the religious organization to be religious.
Never have said anything more than that there must be some specific shared beliefs. It's amusing to watch you try to dispute it, as even your precious dictionary says exactly that: "A specific fundamental set of beliefs and practices generally agreed upon by a number of persons or sects. No wonder you dodged it for so long.

The written aspect of religion isn't all there is to religion
Indeed not, since religious texts simply reflect the oral traditions that preceded them.

...but it's perhaps the only aspect that can provide us with reliable empirical data.
You know, GB, there is a very old joke about a drunk who went looking for his lost car keys under a street lamp because that's where the light was best. The meme is invoked quite often as an example of flawed reasoning. Google it. You'll see.

What you're saying is that the lack of any reliable means of examining the subjective element justifies declaring the matter to be objectively resolveable on the only evidence available: the writings. Adding to the comic value of this already laughable attempt at logic is the fact that the writings themselves immediately refer us right back to the subjective experience of the individual -- don't they? You have asserted -- scores of times in this thread, if not hundreds -- that AA is based on Protestant Christian doctrines. And what is that religion's most central and indispensible premise? It's all about what? Faith, did you say? And what is faith, if not a subjective experience?

Your feeble attempt to snare me in some sort of internal contradiction has failed.
I see that you do sense what's happening here. Internal contradiction is precisely your problem.
 
Could you provide me with a list please?

http://www.behaviortherapy.com/whatworks.htm

Google LifeRing. SOS. Go to local library: borrow books from Rational Recovery.



No, religiousity is determined by the specific, shared beliefs of the members of a religious organization.
Never have said anything more than that there must be some specific shared beliefs.


"We admitted we were powerless over alcohol--that our lives had become unmanageable."

"Came to believe that a Power greater than ourselves could restore us to sanity."

"Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we understood Him"

There. I posit that these three steps are the minimum that every AA'er believes in. Some. Specific. Shared. Beliefs. (With God thrown in for good measure.)
 
I'm going to also say that AA requires a belief in a higher power of some kind. The entire program falls apart without this belief. No higher power equals no AA.

There.

Another Specific Shared Belief. (With God thrown in for good measure.)
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom