Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Google the phrase "argument by definition" and you may find that I am not the only one who disagrees with that. For example:

"A common method of argumentation is to argue that some particular thing belongs to a particular class of things because it fits the definition for that class.

If only that were what you were doing. It isn't. You are trying to change a definition so that some particular pet thing is excluded from a particular class of things.

That would be known as "Argument for Exclusion by Changing the Definition."
 
Maybe they need to stop being so religious about meaning?

Maybe you just need to stop being so illogically religious. Your tendency to sugar coat your christian beliefs only weakens your already debunked arguments.

Why is it, as a religious fundamentalist, you feel you have anything to say in regard to atheists' beliefs?
 
If only that were what you were doing. It isn't. You are trying to change a definition so that some particular pet thing is excluded from a particular class of things.

That would be known as "Argument for Exclusion by Changing the Definition."

Nominated. Because Dymanic has had two wholly undeserved nominations for his piles of steaming BS and Qayak succinctly called him on it. (I wouldn't want people reading the nominations thread to think that we were letting Dymanic's sophistry, epistemological arguments, fallacies and lies go unanswered).

GB
 
If only that were what you were doing.
"If only"? As in: "If only that were what you were doing, I'd accept it as a valid argument"? Is it really possible that you could have missed the point of what I posted so completely that you don't even understand that I'm arguing against that practice on the basis of it being fundamentally weak, for reasons that are clearly stated? I know it was a rather long post, and one which referenced quite a bit of material. Did you actually bother to read any of it?

You are trying to change a definition so that some particular pet thing is excluded from a particular class of things.
And how am I doing that again? Is it where I single out from a list of dictionary definitions the one(s) that apply in this context (the way the author I quoted above did with the word "mean"?) Is it where I list three criteria I see as necessary and sufficient to meet the definition of "religious"? If so, can you specify how this constitutes a deviation from the standard definition? Do you not agree that ANY attempt to define ANY thing constitutes an implicit exclusion of all other things? Isn't that precisely the whole point of a definition?
 
Hmm. No action here on Sunday.

Did everyone go to church to try to figure out what religion is and what religious means?
 
Is it really possible that you could have missed the point of what I posted so completely that you don't even understand that I'm arguing against that practice on the basis of it being fundamentally weak, for reasons that are clearly stated?

So, you posted a long diatribe countering what I said just to prove that the long diatribe you posted and the point you were making was a fundamentally weak one for obvious reasons? Alrightythen!!

Interesting way to say you agree with me but thanks, I am glad we can move on.

And how am I doing that again?

Asked and answered so many times but what does it matter? You have admitted it is weak and you reject it.

Why can't you just say, "Qayak, you're right?" :D
 
Hmm. No action here on Sunday.

Did everyone go to church to try to figure out what religion is and what religious means?

No, I was re-reading the AA literature to try and figure out why you and Dymanic don't know what Religious means. ;)

GB
 
Simple maths (I am not surprised you don't get it though). Some rough numbers (don't hold me to them) purely to illustrate the point.

5% stop on their own.
5% stop using expensive psychiatry.
5% stop using expensive CBT and psychology.
5% stop using a church.
5% stop using AA.
5% stop using other self help groups.

Guess what? We have a total of 30% and without AA it might be 25%.

You're assuming that the 5% that quit using AA wouldn't be part of the 5% that quit on their own. That's rather odd. Let's keep doing mathematics, shall we ?

Out of 10000 people:

500 stop on their own.
500 stop using expensive psychiatry.
500 stop using expensive CBT and psychology.
500 stop using a church.
500 stop using AA.
500 stop using other self help groups.

Now, let's remove AA and let these people quit on their own:

1000 stop on their own.
500 stop using expensive psychiatry.
500 stop using expensive CBT and psychology.
500 stop using a church.
500 stop using other self help groups.

I guess removing AA wasn't all that bad :rolleyes:
 
LOL
So according to your logic, why wouldn't we put those that use (say) psychiatry under the same banner of those that quit on their own.

picture.php


Maths isn't your strong suit, huh?
 
Last edited:
So, you posted a long diatribe countering what I said just to prove that the long diatribe you posted and the point you were making was a fundamentally weak one for obvious reasons?
Either that, or one (or more) of your premises is flawed. You might start with a dictionary definition of the word, "diatribe". Is every long post a diatribe, or are there some other essential elements that must be present as well?

Asked and answered so many times
It has been alleged many times that I am changing the definition of the word "religious", but no actual arguments have been presented in support of that allegation.

...but what does it matter? You have admitted it is weak and you reject it.
Does it matter to YOU? Do you agree that argument by definition is a weak practice? That dictionaries are not means by which substantial conceptual disputes can be settled? Do you think that means that substantial conceptual disputes cannot be settled at all?

Interesting way to say you agree with me but thanks, I am glad we can move on.
Looks like you need another reading assignment:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evasion_(ethics)

Why can't you just say, "Qayak, you're right?"
Considering the amount of time I've dedicated to your training as a critical thinker, it would bring me great pleasure to be able to say that and mean it. As it is, I'm afraid the closest I can come is: Qayak, you're lost.
 
Either that, or one (or more) of your premises is flawed. You might start with a dictionary definition of the word, "diatribe". Is every long post a diatribe, or are there some other essential elements that must be present as well?

You can be quite sure I meant to use the word.

It has been alleged many times that I am changing the definition of the word "religious", but no actual arguments have been presented in support of that allegation.

Asked and answered on one less occasion that the previous question.

Does it matter to YOU? Do you agree that argument by definition is a weak practice? That dictionaries are not means by which substantial conceptual disputes can be settled? Do you think that means that substantial conceptual disputes cannot be settled at all?

You think this hasn't been settled? You think that all the people that looked at this issue and came to the obvious conclusion are wrong? You think the courts were wrong when they found AA to be religious? You think atheists don't know when they are being asked to believe in a deity? You think the word "God" and "Higher Power" in AA literature means "a door knob?" :eye-poppi

I do not need to argue by definition. The definition is there, the evidence in AA is there, AA is a religious organization. You need to. You need to argue that the definition isn't what it is, and you need to show that the evidence in AA itself isn't what it is, doesn't mean what it says and, therefore, AA isn't a religious organization.

It isn't even that AA is sitting in a grey area in all this. AA was set up in, and continues to maintain, a postion that is clearly, beyond any reasonable doubt, religious.

You are making every possible mistake in your investigation. Making claims the evidence doesn't support, cherry picking evidence, violating Occam's Razor, etc., et., etc.

You are the Deepak Chopra of AA apologists. :D

Looks like you need another reading assignment:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evasion_(ethics)

Considering the amount of time I've dedicated to your training as a critical thinker, it would bring me great pleasure to be able to say that and mean it. As it is, I'm afraid the closest I can come is: Qayak, you're lost.

Interesting! If it were just me arguing that what you are saying is wrong, if the others arguing weren't providing compelling evidence and reasoned responses to counter points, if you could show where AA doesn't fit the definition of "religious organization" and/or you could provide any evidence at all to support your claims, I would completely agree that I am the lost one here. But, that isn't the case. You avoid all that and just keep spinning long posts that mean the opposite of what you think they do. Yours is a case of sophistry over substance.
 
LOL
So according to your logic, why wouldn't we put those that use (say) psychiatry under the same banner of those that quit on their own.

[qimg]http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/picture.php?albumid=329&pictureid=1976[/qimg]

Maths isn't your strong suit, huh?

Those are YOUR numbers, Alfie. Assuming you're correct, YES, they'd ALL be better off quitting on their own. But the only numbers I DO have are those comparing AA to no treatment at all.

What's worth the laughing dog is the fact that you're using numbers you pulled from your own behind as some kind of evidence.

Mind you, that you think that the logic behind grouping one with the other stems from poor math skills is baffling.
 
You can be quite sure I meant to use the word.
And here I was thinking you placed great emphasis on the importance of using words in a way that is consistent with their commonly accepted meanings.

Asked and answered on one less occasion that the previous question.
Should be easy to point to a specific post then.

You think this hasn't been settled? You think that all the people that looked at this issue and came to the obvious conclusion are wrong?
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Argumentum_ad_populum

I do not need to argue by definition. The definition is there, the evidence in AA is there, AA is a religious organization.
"I don't need to argue by definition, but here's me doing exactly that anyway".

You are making every possible mistake in your investigation. Making claims the evidence doesn't support, cherry picking evidence, violating Occam's Razor, etc.
All of which assertions, I cannot help but notice, are unsupported by any specifics. (And by the way, treating Occam's Razor as though it were an immutable law rather than a mere heuristic is exactly the sort of error I'd expect from a "skeptic" of your caliber).

Interesting! If it were just me arguing that what you are saying is wrong, if the others arguing weren't providing compelling evidence and reasoned responses to counter points, if you could show where AA doesn't fit the definition of "religious organization" and/or you could provide any evidence at all to support your claims, I would completely agree that I am the lost one here. But, that isn't the case. You avoid all that and just keep spinning long posts that mean the opposite of what you think they do. Yours is a case of sophistry over substance.
As a response to what I posted, the irony value of this is rich indeed. Can it be that you never actually found your way to the article, due to the link I provided being broken? (the auto url bot is quite insistent that the closing parens belongs after the closing tag, it seems). Here, try it again:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evasion_(ethics)
 
Those are YOUR numbers, Alfie.

Which bit of "don't hold me to them", they were for "illustration" purposes only was hard to understand?

Assuming you're correct, YES, they'd ALL be better off quitting on their own. But the only numbers I DO have are those comparing AA to no treatment at all.

Can you provide these numbers please? Do they group everything under the 'stopping on your own' heading too?

I would also like you to clarify what you mean when you say "they'd all be better off quitting in their own".

What's worth the laughing dog is the fact that you're using numbers you pulled from your own behind as some kind of evidence.

Um... so perhaps you did note they were for illustration only. :confused::boggled:

Mind you, that you think that the logic behind grouping one with the other stems from poor math skills is baffling.

And again you misinterpret; that was not what I said nor intended. Attempted deflection noted.;)

Look, my whole point is that we need as many treatments as we can find to help treat alcoholics. If AA scores 5% or more (or less); Fantastic! That is 5% more treated/assisted.
If slapping two fish together at 10,000 feet helped 1%. Then we have another 1% treated.

The more the better, and until there is a 100% cure-all, foolproof treatment, we need every one of them.

Your 5% "just stopped" is the same 5% that is AA is disingenious at best; you have no evidence that they are the same, and I would suggest that even your numbers that you refer to above would group them separately. So again, I ask for your numbers.
 
Last edited:
The OP may be rephrased as: "What do people mean when they insist that AA is not religious?" -- in which case it goes directly to the meaning of the word "religious". It may also be rephrased as: "Why do people insist on lying about AA being religious?" -- in which case it goes to motive.

It could also be rephrased as "Why do AA people always lie about AA being religion"?

Isn't making stuff up fun?
 
This entire thread is one long investigation into the semantics of a few key words -- beginning with "religious".

I notice that this is a semantic argument. Why is it that when I do that, it's me "being stuck" ("playing with words", etc), but when you do it, or when Belz does it (as in the examples above), it's something else? And what is that something else? Or are you stuck too? What's different about what you're doing and what I'm doing?

Now that I've made these inquiries into the nature of the argument you've just made, I'll address the argument itself. Not surprisingly, I disagree completely. What you have provided is a good example of an observation which initially had no explanation and which later came to be treated as evidence -- after an attempt was made to explain it.

You know, the only reason we ever got started on this is that one of the most prolific posters in this thread likes to take the familiar strategy of simply pounding the table demanding evidence, as if the presentation of new evidence is the only means by which an argument can be refuted. I have argued, and will continue to argue, that evidence is worthless (and potentially worse than worthless) if the logic used in interpreting it is flawed, and that valid counterarguments can take the form of simply examining the logic. In criminal trials, the prosecution and the defense typically both take the same evidence, and from that develop different theories. No piece of evidence may be presented which is exempt from examination and interpretation by both sides, and very rarely (outside of Hollywood) is a case settled by the dramatic introduction of some new and devastating piece of evidence. The theory that wins is (ideally) the one that best explains the facts already in evidence. That's exactly what's been happening here: we're all looking at the same evidence and reaching different conclusions, and the incessant and repetitive demands for additional evidence suggest that somebody doesn't get that.


Wasn't addressed to you anyway. Of course, now that I have just asked you basically the same question, maybe I do need to ask: Will you join the "I refuse to answer" club as well?

This seems to be a form of Scholasticism where logical syllogisms take the place of evidence.
 
I never said it wasn't but you are playing fast and loose with the claims again. How did we get from "argument of semantics" to "exercise in semantics?"

Typing is an exercise in semantics, so is reading, speaking, listening. It isn't exercises in semantics we have an issue with, it is allowing you, Alfie and AlBell to change the discussion from one of ideas to one of definitions.

It was made very clear that all the words in the discussion were meant to have a standard dictionary meaning specifically so that you couldn't just make up crap as you went along. You all tried and you were rejected at every turn.

It would be nice if you guys would get honest and actually try to make your arguments using those standard definitions. Or, you could make up some new words and give them any definition you want and we wouldn't be able to argue against you then, as long as the definitions remained consistent, I mean, you're making stuff up anyway. :D

Oh! And a little evidence to back up your claims would be nice too.

Evidence? We don't need no stinkin' evidence!!


Dynamic
I have argued, and will continue to argue, that evidence is worthless (and potentially worse than worthless) if the logic used in interpreting it is flawed, and that valid counterarguments can take the form of simply examining the logic.
 
It could also be rephrased as "Why do AA people always lie about AA being religion"?

I think Dynamic has a point and it has been evident since we first started here. i.e. what was the OP saying? That AA is religious and members are in denial, or was it a genuine question as to why members say it isn't religious when clearly she believes it is.

The words "religious" and "spiritual" remain unresolved (or perhaps inflexible is more accurate) in the minds of its detractors (and others possibly). However - speaking for myself, this difference is why and how members do not classify AA as religious and is the answer to the OP.

I notice with some humour that AAs detractors are not just trying to show that it is religious, they also assert it doesn't work and is harmful and damaging. All of which are unsupportable in any real or non-speculative terms and drfit a long way from the OP which has been answered many times.
 
Last edited:
I think Dynamic has a point and it has been evident since we first started here. i.e. what was the OP saying? That AA is religious and members are in denial, or was it a genuine question as to why members say it isn't religious when clearly she believes it is.

The words "religious" and "spiritual" remain unresolved (or perhaps inflexible is more accurate) in the minds of its detractors (and others possibly). However - speaking for myself, this difference is why and how members do not classify AA as religious and is the answer to the OP.

Only for those who wish to obfuscate them. Do you have this same difficulty with other words in the English language?

It's quite telling that both you and Dynamic are attempting to rewrite the OP.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom