I would point you to a dictionary to look up the meaning of argument. Posting the standard deefinition of a word and saying that is the one being used, doesn't fit the definition of an argument.
Google the phrase "argument by definition" and you may find that I am not the only one who disagrees with that. For example:
"A common method of argumentation is to argue that some particular thing belongs to a particular class of things because it fits the definition for that class. For example, someone might argue that a human embryo is a person because it meets the definition of “person.” The goal of this method is to show that the thing in question adequately meets the definition. Definitions are often set within theories. This method is most often used as part of an extended argument. For example, someone might use this method to argue that a human embryo is a person and then use this to argue against stem cell research involving embryos."
"Since dictionaries conveniently provide a plethora of definitions it is tempting to use them as the basis for an argument from definition. However, such arguments tend to be rather weak in regards to addressing matters of substantive dispute. For example, referring to the dictionary cannot resolve the debate over what it is to be a person. This is because dictionaries just provide the definition that the editors regard as the correct, acceptable, or as the generally used definition. Dictionaries also generally do not back up their definitions with arguments -- the definitions are simply provided and not defended. Obviously dictionaries are very useful in terms of learning the meanings of words. But they are not means by which substantial conceptual disputes can be settled."
http://aphilosopher.wordpress.com/2008/01/04/argument-by-definition/
No, that's not what that means. It means that there is a group of us who have all done the same in not allowing people to deviate from the standard definitions whenever it suits their purposes.
It may give Belz fits, but you have just provided an excellent example with your use of the phrase "what that
means".
---------------------
In everyday English, the word
means has a number of different uses, many of which are not relevant to the study of language [I'm typing this from a linguistics textbook]:
a. That was no mean (insignificant) accomplishment.
b. They are so mean (cruel) to me.
c. This will mean (result in) the end of our regime.
d. This means so much (is so important) to me.
e. I mean (intend) to help if I can.
f. Keep Off the Grass! This means (refers to) you.
g. His losing his job means (implies) that he will have to look again.
h. Lucky Strike means (indicates) fine tobacco.
i. Those clouds mean (are a sign of) rain.
j. She doesn't mean (believe) what she said.
These uses of the word
mean can all be paraphrased by other expressions (indicated in parentheses above). None of them is appropriate for our discussion of word meaning. Rather, we will use the terms
mean and
meaning as they are used in the following examples:
a.
Procrastinate means "to put things off".
b. In saying that, she meant that we should leave.
These two uses of the word
mean exemplify two important types of meaning:
linguistic meaning and
speaker's meaning.
---------------------
Changing the definition of a word hasn't addressed the issue under discussion. That you, Alfie, or AlBell have made up a new definition for yourself means nothing unless you can show that EVERYONE uses the same one and not the standard one that has been in use for ages.
I don't disagree with that, but you're missing something important: I (and I'm speaking only for myself) have not made any attempt to
change any definition. The one word which is surely most important to the OP's question (
pretending that it really was a sincere inquiry initiated in the hope of gaining better understanding) is the word, "religious". Among the various commonly accepted definitions for that word are some which do not apply, just as is the case with the list above for the word, "mean". The absurdity of Belz's argument above that the word "self" refers to "a bag of flesh" is a fallacy of equivocation, one which arises out of rigidly insisting that
linguistic meaning trumps
speaker's meaning:
"Equivocation is classified as both a formal and informal logical fallacy. It is the misleading use of a term with more than one meaning or sense (by glossing over which meaning is intended at a particular time). It generally occurs with polysemic words."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equivocation
George Carlin did this deliberately to exploit the comedic value of phrases like "jumbo shrimp". Belz does it unknowingly, and then steadfastly refuses to acknowledge the error even when it is pointed out repeatedly (and if there is comedic value in that, it's lost on Belz).
The main difference I see between your approach and mine is that you want to treat dictionary definitions as an end point, while I see them as a starting point. The first step should be easy: identify which one among a number of defintions is the one that applies in the given context. The next step is more challenging: to pick up where the dictionary leaves off, and examine the
meanings underlying the
definitions. I have argued that the commonly agreed upon definition of the word "religious" which applies here includes three essential elements:
specific, shared, supernatural beliefs. In a brief discussion that took place here a little over seven years ago, The Mad Linguist describe this as: "an approach based on necessary and sufficient conditions". It's worth a quick read.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=204957
Of course, as soon as I begin doing that I immediately begin to face charges of "playing with words" -- and my accusers
refuse to respond to my countersuit:
that they are doing exactly the same thing. But what I most object to is not
just that they are doing the same thing, or even that they are so completely oblivious of that fact; it's that they are doing it so
badly. The linguistics textbook I was copying from above goes on to present an introduction into various
theories of meaning: the Referential Theory of Meaning, the Mentalist Theory of Meaning, the Use Theory of Meaning -- but I won't reproduce more of that material here. A more in-depth examination of the various categories of theories of meaning are available here:
http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/meaning/
What you are attempting to do (and it's quite obvious that you're doing it completely blind) is to invoke what I hereby dub the "Lexicographical Theory of Meaning". It's just too bad that there is not a single member of your "group" who is capable of getting the joke.