Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Again, if you knew me personally you would never even consider such a possibility.
But I don't. That's just the thing. All I have to go by is what has appeared here, and if you were capable of anything remotely resembling logical thinking, you wouldn't even bother with the "if you knew me" bit, because you would recognize that it has zero value here, and you'd understand why. If you had not so often demonstrated -- in this thread -- an inability to grasp how a post I've made relates to something I've quoted when it is as drop-dead obvious as it was in the case above (or even if you just had not done it over and over again) I would have had no reason to cast about for explanations.

So basically, no matter what I do it proves your theory.
Right. I think the best way to determine whether a person has done something is to accuse them of it, and if they deny it, you know they're guilty -- and if they admit it, then you also know they're guilty, so you've got them either way. It's called "trial by accusation", and it's all the rage these days. (With anyone else I'd probably skip this, but my familiarity with you as a poster tells me that it is necessary in this case to spell out the disclaimer: that was pure sarcasm).

No, and no. In fact the answer to that is IN THE VERY POST you answered: I didn't know you were refering to THAT question because you were replying to a part of my post that had NOTHING to do with it, hence my confusion.
It's all moot now, isn't it? Doesn't really matter how or why you became "confused" about the question, or whether you really were at all, now that you've decided to just go with "I refuse". Might have saved us some time if you'd done so sooner.

Serves me right for not including myself for fear of sounding pretentious.
That would hardly have helped to make it a less idiotic conclusion on your part. I mean, come on -- "you've chased every able-minded skeptic from this thread"??? At this point it must be rather obvious even to you that you pulled that one right out of the ol' nether orifice. It would be rather easier to overlook if you yourself were not so hard on others for doing what you perceive to be the very same thing when it comes to "higher powers" and whatnot.
 
You and a couple of your buddies tried to make it into a semantics argument but the rest of us have pretty much kept it on topic.
The OP may be rephrased as: "What do people mean when they insist that AA is not religious?" -- in which case it goes directly to the meaning of the word "religious". It may also be rephrased as: "Why do people insist on lying about AA being religious?" -- in which case it goes to motive.
 
Right. I think the best way to determine whether a person has done something is to accuse them of it, and if they deny it, you know they're guilty -- and if they admit it, then you also know they're guilty, so you've got them either way. It's called "trial by accusation"...

Actually it's called sophistry, loaded questions, and lying. And you've been doing it nearly this whole thread.

GB
 
You know, the only reason we ever got started on this is that one of the most prolific posters in this thread likes to take the familiar strategy of simply pounding the table demanding evidence, as if the presentation of new evidence is the only means by which an argument can be refuted. I have argued, and will continue to argue, that evidence is worthless (and potentially worse than worthless) if the logic used in interpreting it is flawed, and that valid counterarguments can take the form of simply examining the logic. In criminal trials, the prosecution and the defense typically both take the same evidence, and from that develop different theories. No piece of evidence may be presented which is exempt from examination and interpretation by both sides, and very rarely (outside of Hollywood) is a case settled by the dramatic introduction of some new and devastating piece of evidence. The theory that wins is (ideally) the one that best explains the facts already in evidence. That's exactly what's been happening here: we're all looking at the same evidence and reaching different conclusions, and the incessant and repetitive demands for additional evidence suggest that somebody doesn't get that.

Since you have demonstrated neither logic nor the ability to interpret the evidence in it's historical and textual contexts, you lost your case, just like all the many lawyers who have lost their cases in Federal Circuit Courts of Appeal whose Judgments (regarding the Religious nature of AA and the violations of the Establishment Clause by Judicially requiring Alcoholics to attend AA) the US Supreme Court have allowed to stand.

You haven't "examined" any evidence at all actually. Instead you've offered epistemological arguments, sophistry, loaded questions, any number of fallacies, and outright lies,

GB
 
Last edited:
Yep.... until there is such a thing as a one-size-fits-all, failsafe, the one way, gold plated guaranteed, way to recover from alcoholism we need every means possible available for the recovering addict/alcoholic.

That's not what I asked.

Would you rob people of all these opportunities because they do not have higher success rates too?

Thanks for trying to transform this into an emotional issue. Evil Belz... trying to prevent people from quitting alcohol.

No. But if AA's success rates are NO BETTER than quitting on your own, then it serves no purpose and removing it would not actually rob people of anything (except of a ticket to the nearest church, that is).
 
But I don't. That's just the thing. All I have to go by is what has appeared here, and if you were capable of anything remotely resembling logical thinking, you wouldn't even bother with the "if you knew me" bit, because you would recognize that it has zero value here, and you'd understand why.

Well, if we follow your logic, then, I am incapable of anything remotely resembling logical thinking. Boy, it must be awesome being you and being able to decree things like that about reality.

Right. I think the best way to determine whether a person has done something is to accuse them of it, and if they deny it, you know they're guilty -- and if they admit it, then you also know they're guilty, so you've got them either way. It's called "trial by accusation", and it's all the rage these days. (With anyone else I'd probably skip this, but my familiarity with you as a poster tells me that it is necessary in this case to spell out the disclaimer: that was pure sarcasm).

"Hey. Now that I've been a little insulting, it might be fun if I added ANOTHER insult on top of it."

Seriously, the only thing you've been doing in this thread, aside from word games, is to insult your correspondants. Don't you think you should find something better to do ?

It's all moot now, isn't it? Doesn't really matter how or why you became "confused" about the question, or whether you really were at all, now that you've decided to just go with "I refuse". Might have saved us some time if you'd done so sooner.

Wow. You simultaneously understand what I said and forget it in the very next sentence. That has to be a record for attention deficit, right there.

How the hell could I have done it sooner if I didn't understand you were refering to that question ? :rolleyes:

That would hardly have helped to make it a less idiotic conclusion on your part. I mean, come on -- "you've chased every able-minded skeptic from this thread"???

Well, I didn't expect GB and Qayak to return.
 
How the hell could I have done it sooner if I didn't understand you were refering to that question ?
Indeed, how can you hope to participate at all in this discussion or any discussion if you can't understand what people are saying? If you are unable to parse a short paragraph like this one:

Have you never encountered the creationist argument that "Evolution is only a theory"? Do you understand that the reason that is such a pathetically weak argument is that it is based on the arguer's own ignorance of what the word, "theory" means in science? Is it "playing semantics" to point out that ignorance?

...and identify the question it poses, then YOU have a comprehension problem. It is clear that your struggles with this problem are going to continue to be a problem for the other participants here. I expect you to continue to express confusion about what is being said, regardless of how obvious that is, in nearly every post you make -- and to attempt to place the blame for this on others, just as you have done in post after post -- but I intend to give this no further attention. It's obvious that there is nothing I can do to help you with this. I'm just going to start treating it as noise in the channel.

Well, I didn't expect GB and Qayak to return.
Yes, I realize that, Belz. You made an observation: Neither GB nor qayak had posted for a while. You developed a theory: Dymanic had chased them from the thread. Once you had done that, your observation became evidence supporting your theory. I was considering asking whether you are interested in understanding the nature of the logical fallacy you committed there, but thought better of it when I realized that you either wouldn't notice the question or wouldn't understand it -- so I'm just going to offer what I find to be a very pertinent illustration of that fallacy and leave it up to you to do with it what you will:

Lisa Simpson’s Tiger-Repellant Rock
 
How the hell could I have done it sooner if I didn't understand you were refering to that question ?

Indeed, how can you hope to participate at all in this discussion or any discussion if you can't understand what people are saying? If you are unable to parse a short paragraph like this one:

Have you never encountered the creationist argument that "Evolution is only a theory"? Do you understand that the reason that is such a pathetically weak argument is that it is based on the arguer's own ignorance of what the word, "theory" means in science? Is it "playing semantics" to point out that ignorance?

You fail at basic reading comprehension, Dymanic. I can't help you. And since you refuse to get back on topic, I'll have to leave you to your word salad, now.
 
The OP may be rephrased as: "What do people mean when they insist that AA is not religious?" -- in which case it goes directly to the meaning of the word "religious". It may also be rephrased as: "Why do people insist on lying about AA being religious?" -- in which case it goes to motive.

Your claim is not substantiated. The OP cannot be rephrased in the manner you suggest. They are two completley different questions. The OP asks for reasons/motivations as why people insist AA is not religious.

Your first rewrite asks what they mean when they say it. That is not what the OP is asking.

Your second rewrite assumes the people who say this are lying and then asks for the motivation for those lies.

The closest you get is that an answer to the OP might be that some of the people who claim AA isn't religious are lying but that isn't what the rewrite asks.

You and Alfie led this down the path of semantics while others of us have only gone so far as to say we are using dictionary definitions of the words and posting those definitions.
 
I was considering asking whether you are interested in understanding the nature of the logical fallacy you committed there, but thought better of it when I realized that you either wouldn't notice the question or wouldn't understand it -- so I'm just going to offer what I find to be a very pertinent illustration of that fallacy and leave it up to you to do with it what you will:

Lisa Simpson’s Tiger-Repellant Rock

Your arguments are so full of fallacies you wouldn't recognize one if it bit you on the Arse.

So, come up with any empirical evidence yet? Or are you just going to continue playing off-topic epistemological and semantic games?

And by the way, Belz wasn't entirely off the mark. I got hammered over Thanksgiving and decided to take few EXTRA days off from this thread so I wouldn't have to read all of your ridiculous posts.

Frankly, I'm not sure I WOULD have come back at all, except when Belz wrote that post I realized that I couldn't leave him to suffer alone. ;)

GB
 
That's not what I asked.

Really!?!?
What did you ask then exactly? :confused::rolleyes:

Thanks for trying to transform this into an emotional issue. Evil Belz... trying to prevent people from quitting alcohol.

Well alcoholism, death etc is an emotional issue - especially for those affected and afflicted. Moreover, you you take it there when you ask/say things like AA "serves no purpose" (my bold below).

No. But if AA's success rates are NO BETTER than quitting on your own, then it serves no purpose and removing it would not actually rob people of anything (except of a ticket to the nearest church, that is).

Simple maths (I am not surprised you don't get it though). Some rough numbers (don't hold me to them) purely to illustrate the point.

5% stop on their own.
5% stop using expensive psychiatry.
5% stop using expensive CBT and psychology.
5% stop using a church.
5% stop using AA.
5% stop using other self help groups.

Guess what? We have a total of 30% and without AA it might be 25%.
Yet you would (seem to want to) remove AA as source of recovery because you object to the God word, spirituality or religion. Frankly I still don't know what your actual objection to AA is.
OK, let's now take away the 5% that find abstinence through church because of your dislike of God (or whatever).

You would have just robbed 10% the opportunity of affordable and available recovery.

That is what I mean when I talk about needing "every means possible available for the recovering addict/alcoholic" until we have a foolproof method.
 
Last edited:
Your first rewrite asks what they mean when they say it. That is not what the OP is asking.
I tend to agree. I never saw it as a sincere inquiry to begin with. What it was was a rant. As evidence to support this theory, I present the last sentence in the OP, which begins with the phrase "I feel so angry...". The OP apparently came here looking for a little communal reinforcement. But that's really not what we do here... is it? An organization with "Educational Foundation" in its title might be reasonably be expected to be devoted to increasing understanding -- but it's rather obvious that neither the OP nor many of the posters here ever had any genuine interest in understanding what a person might mean by a statement such as "AA is spiritual, but not religious". You're one of them.

Your second rewrite assumes the people who say this are lying and then asks for the motivation for those lies.
Yes, I know.

The closest you get is that an answer to the OP might be that some of the people who claim AA isn't religious are lying but that isn't what the rewrite asks.
That's right. It asks why anyone would be motivated to do that. It's as important an element in the typical murder trial as forensic evidence like fingerprints and footprints. Unless the prosecution can establish some logical reason why the accused would have committed the crime, it's tough to make the case. Shall we review the efforts that have been made toward establishing motive here? Shouldn't take long.

You and Alfie led this down the path of semantics while others of us have only gone so far as to say we are using dictionary definitions of the words and posting those definitions.
Which is NOT an exercise in semantics because...?
 
And by the way, Belz wasn't entirely off the mark. I got hammered over Thanksgiving and decided to take few EXTRA days off from this thread so I wouldn't have to read all of your ridiculous posts.
I understand.

Frankly, I'm not sure I WOULD have come back at all, except when Belz wrote that post I realized that I couldn't leave him to suffer alone.
You are a true and loyal virtual friend.
 
Which is NOT an exercise in semantics because...?

I never said it wasn't but you are playing fast and loose with the claims again. How did we get from "argument of semantics" to "exercise in semantics?"

Typing is an exercise in semantics, so is reading, speaking, listening. It isn't exercises in semantics we have an issue with, it is allowing you, Alfie and AlBell to change the discussion from one of ideas to one of definitions.

It was made very clear that all the words in the discussion were meant to have a standard dictionary meaning specifically so that you couldn't just make up crap as you went along. You all tried and you were rejected at every turn.

It would be nice if you guys would get honest and actually try to make your arguments using those standard definitions. Or, you could make up some new words and give them any definition you want and we wouldn't be able to argue against you then, as long as the definitions remained consistent, I mean, you're making stuff up anyway. :D

Oh! And a little evidence to back up your claims would be nice too.
 
I never said it wasn't
Just to be clear: you never said that posting dictionary definitions is not an exercise in semantics. And will you state it affirmatively: that posting dictionary definitions IS an exercise in semantics?

How did we get from "argument of semantics" to "exercise in semantics?"
Is there a difference there that you regard as important? If you prefer, I'd be happy to rephrase that as: "Which is NOT an argument in semantics because...?" Would it change your answer?

but you are playing fast and loose with the claims again.
Can you be more specific? Which claims?

It isn't exercises in semantics we have an issue with
Your use of the pronoun "we" suggests that you feel entitled to speak for some others present. Do you need me to refer you to some previous posts in which arguments against me have focused entirely on charges that I am "playing with words" -- or can you find them on your own?

..it is allowing you, Alfie and AlBell to change the discussion from one of ideas to one of definitions.
Can you clarify the distinction you're making there? Are definitions not ideas?

It would be nice if you guys would get honest and actually try to make your arguments using those standard definitions.
Where do you see that not being done? Can you provide an example?

And a little evidence to back up your claims would be nice too.
Do you feel that you understand the point I've been making that consideration of the facts already in evidence may lead to different conclusions when interpreted differently? Do you agree that the very same facts which may be claimed as evidence to support one position may also be used as evidence to support another -- or do you believe that facts can never be interpreted more than one way?
 
Holy smokes! 78 pages!

Show up to a meeting and realize the religion. 99% say god saved them but none say god screwed them while they were drunk or screwed their drunk friends that failed. god is only mentioned positively.

Once you are involved you are taught to deny the religious aspects to prospects. It's in the literature. Deny what is obvious. The Lords Prayer at the end was what tipped me off and I'm slow.
 
Just to be clear: you never said that posting dictionary definitions is not an exercise in semantics.

There are a lot of things I haven't said in this thread which makes me wonder why you aregue about something I didn't say?

And will you state it affirmatively: that posting dictionary definitions IS an exercise in semantics?

Akin to typing, reading, speaking, yes.

Is there a difference there that you regard as important? If you prefer, I'd be happy to rephrase that as: "Which is NOT an argument in semantics because...?" Would it change your answer?

I would point you to a dictionary to look up the meaning of argument. Posting the standard deefinition of a word and saying that is the one being used, doesn't fit the definition of an argument.

Can you be more specific? Which claims?

You have changed the claim that I made about not allowing this thread to deteriorate into a argument over semantics and claim that I said it was about a semantics exercise.

Your use of the pronoun "we" suggests that you feel entitled to speak for some others present.

No, that's not what that means. It means that there is a group of us who have all done the same in not allowing people to deviate from the standard definitions whenever it suits their purposes. I don't speak for anyone, I simply include myself in a group of people doing the same thing.

Can you clarify the distinction you're making there? Are definitions not ideas?

In one sense yes, but not in the sense that makes them the subject of this discussion. The definitions are already decided and posted, the idea being discussed is "Why do people insist AA is not religious?"

This is the exact point Richard Feynman made about philosophy. That it has degenerated into meaningless arguments over the definitions of words and nothing gets accomplished. You think you have won something if you change a definition but it means nothing. Changing the definition of a word hasn't addressed the issue under discussion. That you, Alfie, or AlBell have made up a new definition for yourself means nothing unless you can show that EVERYONE uses the same one and not the standard one that has been in use for ages.

Where do you see that not being done? Can you provide an example?

All through the thread. As for an example, how about I assume you can read, are halfway intelligent and aren't being a twat, in which case you can find them on your own?

Do you feel that you understand the point I've been making that consideration of the facts already in evidence may lead to different conclusions when interpreted differently? Do you agree that the very same facts which may be claimed as evidence to support one position may also be used as evidence to support another -- or do you believe that facts can never be interpreted more than one way?

I do agree with that but I don't see that happening here. I don't understand why anyone would feel AA isn't religious just because they themself have a different meaning for the word "religious." It makes no sense that one doesn't look at AA and its literature to decide if the organization is religious. Once one does that it is completely obvious that it is a religious organization. That then leads right back to the question posed in the OP which is why, with the evidence being so obvious, do people insist AA isn't religious?

So, there can be different interpretations to evidence but that really isn't possible in this case.
 
I would point you to a dictionary to look up the meaning of argument. Posting the standard deefinition of a word and saying that is the one being used, doesn't fit the definition of an argument.
Google the phrase "argument by definition" and you may find that I am not the only one who disagrees with that. For example:

"A common method of argumentation is to argue that some particular thing belongs to a particular class of things because it fits the definition for that class. For example, someone might argue that a human embryo is a person because it meets the definition of “person.” The goal of this method is to show that the thing in question adequately meets the definition. Definitions are often set within theories. This method is most often used as part of an extended argument. For example, someone might use this method to argue that a human embryo is a person and then use this to argue against stem cell research involving embryos."

"Since dictionaries conveniently provide a plethora of definitions it is tempting to use them as the basis for an argument from definition. However, such arguments tend to be rather weak in regards to addressing matters of substantive dispute. For example, referring to the dictionary cannot resolve the debate over what it is to be a person. This is because dictionaries just provide the definition that the editors regard as the correct, acceptable, or as the generally used definition. Dictionaries also generally do not back up their definitions with arguments -- the definitions are simply provided and not defended. Obviously dictionaries are very useful in terms of learning the meanings of words. But they are not means by which substantial conceptual disputes can be settled."
http://aphilosopher.wordpress.com/2008/01/04/argument-by-definition/


No, that's not what that means. It means that there is a group of us who have all done the same in not allowing people to deviate from the standard definitions whenever it suits their purposes.
It may give Belz fits, but you have just provided an excellent example with your use of the phrase "what that means".

---------------------
In everyday English, the word means has a number of different uses, many of which are not relevant to the study of language [I'm typing this from a linguistics textbook]:

a. That was no mean (insignificant) accomplishment.
b. They are so mean (cruel) to me.
c. This will mean (result in) the end of our regime.
d. This means so much (is so important) to me.
e. I mean (intend) to help if I can.
f. Keep Off the Grass! This means (refers to) you.
g. His losing his job means (implies) that he will have to look again.
h. Lucky Strike means (indicates) fine tobacco.
i. Those clouds mean (are a sign of) rain.
j. She doesn't mean (believe) what she said.

These uses of the word mean can all be paraphrased by other expressions (indicated in parentheses above). None of them is appropriate for our discussion of word meaning. Rather, we will use the terms mean and meaning as they are used in the following examples:

a. Procrastinate means "to put things off".
b. In saying that, she meant that we should leave.

These two uses of the word mean exemplify two important types of meaning: linguistic meaning and speaker's meaning.
---------------------


Changing the definition of a word hasn't addressed the issue under discussion. That you, Alfie, or AlBell have made up a new definition for yourself means nothing unless you can show that EVERYONE uses the same one and not the standard one that has been in use for ages.
I don't disagree with that, but you're missing something important: I (and I'm speaking only for myself) have not made any attempt to change any definition. The one word which is surely most important to the OP's question (pretending that it really was a sincere inquiry initiated in the hope of gaining better understanding) is the word, "religious". Among the various commonly accepted definitions for that word are some which do not apply, just as is the case with the list above for the word, "mean". The absurdity of Belz's argument above that the word "self" refers to "a bag of flesh" is a fallacy of equivocation, one which arises out of rigidly insisting that linguistic meaning trumps speaker's meaning:

"Equivocation is classified as both a formal and informal logical fallacy. It is the misleading use of a term with more than one meaning or sense (by glossing over which meaning is intended at a particular time). It generally occurs with polysemic words."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Equivocation

George Carlin did this deliberately to exploit the comedic value of phrases like "jumbo shrimp". Belz does it unknowingly, and then steadfastly refuses to acknowledge the error even when it is pointed out repeatedly (and if there is comedic value in that, it's lost on Belz).

The main difference I see between your approach and mine is that you want to treat dictionary definitions as an end point, while I see them as a starting point. The first step should be easy: identify which one among a number of defintions is the one that applies in the given context. The next step is more challenging: to pick up where the dictionary leaves off, and examine the meanings underlying the definitions. I have argued that the commonly agreed upon definition of the word "religious" which applies here includes three essential elements: specific, shared, supernatural beliefs. In a brief discussion that took place here a little over seven years ago, The Mad Linguist describe this as: "an approach based on necessary and sufficient conditions". It's worth a quick read.
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=204957

Of course, as soon as I begin doing that I immediately begin to face charges of "playing with words" -- and my accusers refuse to respond to my countersuit: that they are doing exactly the same thing. But what I most object to is not just that they are doing the same thing, or even that they are so completely oblivious of that fact; it's that they are doing it so badly. The linguistics textbook I was copying from above goes on to present an introduction into various theories of meaning: the Referential Theory of Meaning, the Mentalist Theory of Meaning, the Use Theory of Meaning -- but I won't reproduce more of that material here. A more in-depth examination of the various categories of theories of meaning are available here: http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/meaning/

What you are attempting to do (and it's quite obvious that you're doing it completely blind) is to invoke what I hereby dub the "Lexicographical Theory of Meaning". It's just too bad that there is not a single member of your "group" who is capable of getting the joke.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom