Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
But we also have proof from AA members in this very thread that they can practice their atheism within AA. They choose no God (except the fellowship, the laws of nature, their better self or whatever), can attend the steps etc.

You have no such thing. You have a few people claiming to practice their AA and then stating they believe in a higher power/god. That's not atheism, Alfred.

In other words, it has been necessary for them to twist, bend, and deny their beliefs to fit into the AA model. You need to read what they are actually saying and not what you need to hear to appease your AA mind.

The one person who stated they, and their meeting, lived their atheistic beliefs had a very difficult time being accepted into AA and, in fact, are still not fully accepted.
 
Ah, my mistake. You were refering to a question that had nothing to do with the comment you quoted. Gotcha. In the future I'll have to guess that you're refering to questions that are not related to the part of the post you're quoting.
I continue to find the evidence insufficient to determine which of two competing theories best explains your apparent inabililty to follow the thread of a discussion that spans more than about two posts. There is the "dumb act" theory, which posits that you actually understand perfectly well how my questions relate to what I quoted and that your feigned confusion is part of an effort to deflect attention away from a point which is devastating to your argument. You vehemently deny this, but then, that's just what I'd expect you to do if that were the case. And then there is the "cognitive impairment/time constraint" theory, which posits that you really are having trouble following along, due to some factor not in evidence; perhaps your short term memory is affected by heavy marijuana use, or a stroke or some other pathology, or perhaps it is simply that you are too busy with other things to give this discussion more than a few second's thought per post.

The possibility that your problem is due to you having a pathology that affects your memory makes things a bit awkward, because it might be considered unkind to point out how pronounced your impairment is -- but it's something that has been affecting the continuity of this discussion ever since we first began engaging, and I'm not sure it would even be doing you any favor to pretend that it's not a problem. If that were the explanation I were leaning toward, I probably wouldn't even mention it, though. What I would do is proceed directly with what I'm about to do, which is to gather together the posts that comprise this particular line of discussion in the hope that it will make it easier to follow.

I'm not going to try to identify the point at which we first started talking about the nature of EVIDENCE. I recall mentioning (T.I.C.) that for GB, that abstract principle might serve as a "higher power", and pointing out that the logic and reason used in interpreting the evidence is as important as the evidence itself, etc. We've been kicking this around since very early in the thread. I'm going to focus just on the part you have most recently had trouble following. That began with this, the bolded portion of which I'm going to modify for a fourth time (I think it is) so as to accomodate yet another rephrasing of the same objection you've continued to raise over and over while ignoring every counterargument.

Have you never encountered the creationist argument that "Evolution is only a theory"? Do you understand that the reason that is such a pathetically weak argument is that it is based on the arguer's own ignorance of what the word, "theory" means in science? Is it "playing semantics" to point out that ignorance?

Dymanic said:
Have you never encountered the creationist argument that "Evolution is only a theory"?
Twice in two posts. You can't even remember the last thing you said, Dymanic.

Belz said:
Twice in two posts.
And twice in two posts, you dodge the question. Are you ready to do a GB and openly state that you refuse to answer?

Dymanic said:
And twice in two posts, you dodge the question. Are you ready to do a GB and openly state that you refuse to answer?
Answer what ? There was no question.

Belz said:
Answer what ? There was no question.
You noticed that I posted it "twice in two posts"...
...and you didn't notice that it contained a question?

Which brings us to your last response:
Yes. But since it's still you playing semantics, and I'm sick of it, I choose to skip it a third time.
So: Yes, you DID notice that there was a question, but you chose to deny that ("Answer what ? There was no question") -- and now that that has failed to fly, here you are doing exactly what I suggested, by doing a GB and openly stating that you refuse to answer. What a fine example of able-minded skepticism you are, Belz... but wait! You said I had already "chased every able-minded skeptic from this thread", yet here YOU still are! It's self-validating in a way I find rather enjoyable, actually: you didn't follow that conclusion to the next logical conclusion, which serves to further confirm your premise.
 
You're still playing with words.
To help me better understand why it is that a statement like this one:
Observations do not become evidence until after they have been incorporated into a reasoned theory.
is "playing with words" -- while a statement like this one:
Observation is evidence. It's usually evidence for something, but it's still evidence even if you don't know for what.
is not, can you explain just what you see as the... what? methodological difference between those two? While we're at it, maybe we should include DD's slight variant:
sometimes observations are evidence of phenomena that have no theory to explain them.
Is DD also "playing with words" here, or is he doing... whatever it is that you'd call it; the alternative to playing with words that you implicitly claim to be doing? I'm genuinely interested in seeing your answer.
 
In other words (if I take your meaning correctly), an observation that cannot be used as evidence within the framework of any theory might be considered evidence under an epistemological theory: we don't know everything. That has the flavor of a clever loophole, but I don't think it quite works, because it is still necessary to state the premise first.

You are stuck in the semantic arguments, say when Bequerel noticed the foggy of teh photographic plates by uranium, he made the observation that the plates were fogged, despite teh fact that they were unexposed to light. That is evidence , period.

It is evidence of a process, regardless of any theory.
 
To help me better understand why it is that a statement like this one:
is "playing with words" -- while a statement like this one:is not, can you explain just what you see as the... what? methodological difference between those two? While we're at it, maybe we should include DD's slight variant:Is DD also "playing with words" here, or is he doing... whatever it is that you'd call it; the alternative to playing with words that you implicitly claim to be doing? I'm genuinely interested in seeing your answer.

Sorry Dynamic, I will not respond to this.

You are stuck.
 
Dancing David said:
In other words (if I take your meaning correctly), an observation that cannot be used as evidence within the framework of any theory might be considered evidence under an epistemological theory: we don't know everything. That has the flavor of a clever loophole, but I don't think it quite works, because it is still necessary to state the premise first.

You are stuck in the semantic arguments, say when Bequerel noticed the foggy of teh photographic plates by uranium, he made the observation that the plates were fogged, despite teh fact that they were unexposed to light. That is evidence , period.

It is evidence of a process, regardless of any theory.
Congratulations. You managed to repeat what Dymanic already said.
 
I continue to find the evidence insufficient to determine which of two competing theories best explains your apparent inabililty to follow the thread of a discussion that spans more than about two posts.

False dichotomy. There is another possibility: that you're not being very coherent in your arguments.

There is the "dumb act" theory, which posits that you actually understand perfectly well how my questions relate to what I quoted and that your feigned confusion is part of an effort to deflect attention away from a point which is devastating to your argument.

Of course... I could just as well simply quit the thread and do something more worthwhile with my time. Again, if you knew me personally you would never even consider such a possibility.

You vehemently deny this, but then, that's just what I'd expect you to do if that were the case.

Sounds fun. So basically, no matter what I do it proves your theory. :rolleyes:

Which brings us to your last response:
So: Yes, you DID notice that there was a question, but you chose to deny that ("Answer what ? There was no question")

No, and no. In fact the answer to that is IN THE VERY POST you answered: I didn't know you were refering to THAT question because you were replying to a part of my post that had NOTHING to do with it, hence my confusion.

and now that that has failed to fly, here you are doing exactly what I suggested, by doing a GB and openly stating that you refuse to answer. What a fine example of able-minded skepticism you are, Belz...

Yes, I am. Why would I waste time chasing down phantoms ? Yes, theists use their ignorance as an argument. That's nothing new. If you state your point perhaps we can, you know, debate the actual thread topic, something you've been evading for long enough.

You said I had already "chased every able-minded skeptic from this thread", yet here YOU still are! It's self-validating in a way I find rather enjoyable, actually: you didn't follow that conclusion to the next logical conclusion, which serves to further confirm your premise.

If there was a competition for word-play and dodging, you'd get a platinum medal. Serves me right for not including myself for fear of sounding pretentious.
 
Thank you! I have a little over a year of sobriety - it took awhile to make A.A work for me (as I do believe that it is a tad harder for atheists and agnostics and I've gotten flak from believers along the way), but I've found a way that's good for me. I use the collective wisdom of my A.A. groups and nature as my higher power. While I can't wrap my mind around a supreme being knowing what's best for me, I CAN wrap my head around other people who have been through the same thing knowing (or giving advice on) what's best for me because going completely with my own thinking was what got me into trouble in the first place.

I am glad to hear brave people like you have taken it upon themselves to make it work inside your beliefs.

Just to show you there is more than one. There are others too - you just refuse not to believe them. :rolleyes:

You have no such thing. You have a few people claiming to practice their AA and then stating they believe in a higher power/god. That's not atheism, Alfred.

They state they believe in a higher power llike nature, or the group collective etc sure? Why isn't that atheism?

In other words, it has been necessary for them to twist, bend, and deny their beliefs to fit into the AA model. You need to read what they are actually saying and not what you need to hear to appease your AA mind.

Straight back at you.
Evidence please.

The one person who stated they, and their meeting, lived their atheistic beliefs had a very difficult time being accepted into AA and, in fact, are still not fully accepted.

There is a lot more than one (as per above), and the one I think you are talking about has not been rejected because of his atheism, but his intolerance to the beliefs of others. Ironic huh?

So, on all counts just plain wrong Qayak.
 
I seem to remember reading upthread, and elsewhere, that AA is just as helpful as quitting on your own. Any comment on that ?

Yep.... until there is such a thing as a one-size-fits-all, failsafe, the one way, gold plated guaranteed, way to recover from alcoholism we need every means possible available for the recovering addict/alcoholic.

Sadly most don't obtain recovery, the numbers are heartbreaking. That said, succesful recovery methods include:

Some people just quit.
Some people use AA.
Some use Psychiatrists/psychologists/counsellors
Doctors, pharmacotherapies
Churches, religions and philosophies
Some quit living
Some are gaoled or
institutionalised (do we count these in your quitting on your own?).

Apart from the last three (provisions on the institutionalised) we need every one of them to help.

AA works for many, not every (and it has never said it is the only way and will work for every). Same with the others.
Would you rob people of all these opportunities because they do not have higher success rates too?
 
Last edited:
You are stuck in the semantic arguments
This entire thread is one long investigation into the semantics of a few key words -- beginning with "religious".

say when Bequerel noticed the foggy of teh photographic plates by uranium, he made the observation that the plates were fogged, despite teh fact that they were unexposed to light. That is evidence, period.
I notice that this is a semantic argument. Why is it that when I do that, it's me "being stuck" ("playing with words", etc), but when you do it, or when Belz does it (as in the examples above), it's something else? And what is that something else? Or are you stuck too? What's different about what you're doing and what I'm doing?

Now that I've made these inquiries into the nature of the argument you've just made, I'll address the argument itself. Not surprisingly, I disagree completely. What you have provided is a good example of an observation which initially had no explanation and which later came to be treated as evidence -- after an attempt was made to explain it.

You know, the only reason we ever got started on this is that one of the most prolific posters in this thread likes to take the familiar strategy of simply pounding the table demanding evidence, as if the presentation of new evidence is the only means by which an argument can be refuted. I have argued, and will continue to argue, that evidence is worthless (and potentially worse than worthless) if the logic used in interpreting it is flawed, and that valid counterarguments can take the form of simply examining the logic. In criminal trials, the prosecution and the defense typically both take the same evidence, and from that develop different theories. No piece of evidence may be presented which is exempt from examination and interpretation by both sides, and very rarely (outside of Hollywood) is a case settled by the dramatic introduction of some new and devastating piece of evidence. The theory that wins is (ideally) the one that best explains the facts already in evidence. That's exactly what's been happening here: we're all looking at the same evidence and reaching different conclusions, and the incessant and repetitive demands for additional evidence suggest that somebody doesn't get that.


Sorry Dynamic, I will not respond to this.
Wasn't addressed to you anyway. Of course, now that I have just asked you basically the same question, maybe I do need to ask: Will you join the "I refuse to answer" club as well?
 
This entire thread is one long investigation into the semantics of a few key words -- beginning with "religious".

Ummmm . . . no. You and a couple of your buddies tried to make it into a semantics argument but the rest of us have pretty much kept it on topic.

Which is why you and your buddies are sucking wind in this one.
 
Don't hold your breath waiting ... :D

It's kind of ironic that a christian like you, who thinks non-AA members shouldn't have an opinion on AA, would bother to make claims about the atheists' experience in AA.

Of course, with the quality of your posts, it isn't surprising, just ironic.
 
Just to show you there is more than one. There are others too - you just refuse not to believe them. :rolleyes:

Yeah, that makes sense. :rolleyes:

They state they believe in a higher power llike nature, or the group collective etc sure? Why isn't that atheism?

Figure it out, Alfred.

Straight back at you.
Evidence please.

Translation: "Alfred's got nothing!" You'll have to do better, I merely look at what is written in the literature and what goes on at the meetings. You need to disregard all evidence except the unsubstantiated claims you pull out of thin air. That's why you haven't been able to convince anyone in this thread.

There is a lot more than one (as per above), and the one I think you are talking about has not been rejected because of his atheism, but his intolerance to the beliefs of others. Ironic huh?

Unsubstantiated claim! You love making this **** up, don't you? :D

So, on all counts just plain wrong Qayak.

Unsubstantiated claim.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom