Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I get back from holiday...
And what did you think of Belz's stellar reasoning that had me chasing you from the thread along with all the others Belz (applying more of the same stellar reasoning) includes among "able-minded skeptics"?

You really shouldn't bring up the "Creationist" argument, as YOU are the one employing the Creationist tactic of deploying an Epistemological Argument to undermine or conflate Ontological Distinctions.
You may of course want to take a stab at answering the question yourself.


....pppffftttt!! Riiiiight. Like THAT'S gonna happen!
 
And what did you think of Belz's stellar reasoning that had me chasing you from the thread along with all the others Belz (applying more of the same stellar reasoning) includes among "able-minded skeptics"?

You may of course want to take a stab at answering the question yourself.


....pppffftttt!! Riiiiight. Like THAT'S gonna happen!

You might want to take a stab at providing evidence that the 12 Steps and The Big Book are not religious. Be sure to explain how the over 400 references to God, Heavenly Father, Creator, Him, His Will, etc are not religious (with EVIDENCE, not word twisting).

Explain how chapter 4 telling agnostics and atheists that they need to find God to make the programme work is not religious. Again, please provide evidence, not your made up re-definitions.

Be sure to demonstrate how the Historical Record of the Protestant Christian History of AA and it's semi-evolution to semi-Universalism is unfactual and--according to you--irrelevant and unrelated to the Doctrines of AA, with corroborating evidence please.

If you can't do it without word twisting, sophistry, loaded questions, logical fallacies, or lying, then you have no argument.

You should just admit you're wrong, and put your intellect to better use--like starting a support group for non-theist alcoholics without the Big Book and without AA's 12 Steps.

You can always use the Secular 12 Steps. But then of course you lose the cozy affiliation with AA that goes with adopting AA's 12 Steps and Big Book.

GB

PS: I extended my holiday particularly from posting on this thread because I'm tired of arguing with someone who doesn't have a topical, or an evidence based rational argument. I don't plan on wasting any more time on this thread than I have to. If Belz wants to continue arguing about epistemology and philology with you, that's up to him.
 
Last edited:
And what did you think of Belz's stellar reasoning that had me chasing you from the thread along with all the others Belz (applying more of the same stellar reasoning) includes among "able-minded skeptics"?

You actually think you chased people from this thread with your reasoning ability? :dl:
 
I think most following along are laughing, but with Dymanic, not at him.
 
You actually think you chased people from this thread with your reasoning ability?
Actually, no. I thought that was just as idiotic a conclusion as you apparently do. Had you been capable of following the conversation well enough to figure out whose conclusion it was, you might have realized that. A nice example of different people applying different logic to the same evidence and reaching different conclusions, I'd say.
 
Last edited:
I think most following along are laughing, but with Dymanic, not at him.

I'd have thought that too.

And I was disappointed to see GB post again, I thought he had left. Too bad. ;)

In other news; we bury my friend (Lisa) tomorrow.

Alcoholism is serious stuff - we need as many resourses and chances for recovery as we can find. AA needs to be a part of the mix, whether you agree with the supposed religious component or not.
 
You might want to take a stab at providing evidence that the 12 Steps and The Big Book are not religious. Be sure to explain how the over 400 references to God, Heavenly Father, Creator, Him, His Will, etc are not religious (with EVIDENCE, not word twisting).

Explain how chapter 4 telling agnostics and atheists that they need to find God to make the programme work is not religious. Again, please provide evidence, not your made up re-definitions.

Be sure to demonstrate how the Historical Record of the Protestant Christian History of AA and it's semi-evolution to semi-Universalism is unfactual and--according to you--irrelevant and unrelated to the Doctrines of AA, with corroborating evidence please.

If you can't do it without word twisting, sophistry, loaded questions, logical fallacies, or lying, then you have no argument.

You should just admit you're wrong, and put your intellect to better use--like starting a support group for non-theist alcoholics without the Big Book and without AA's 12 Steps.

You can always use the Secular 12 Steps. But then of course you lose the cozy affiliation with AA that goes with adopting AA's 12 Steps and Big Book.

GB

PS: I extended my holiday particularly from posting on this thread because I'm tired of arguing with someone who doesn't have a topical, or an evidence based rational argument. I don't plan on wasting any more time on this thread than I have to. If Belz wants to continue arguing about epistemology and philology with you, that's up to him.


GB, you know by now the only response has been the Get Out Of Jail Free card of "God as you understand Him" and "steps are only suggestions" that Alfie has been banging on about for the past thousand-odd posts.


Oh, and I almost forgot the classic "it's spiritual, not religious."
 
GB, you know by now the only response has been the Get Out Of Jail Free card of "God as you understand Him" and "steps are only suggestions" that Alfie has been banging on about for the past thousand-odd posts.


Oh, and I almost forgot the classic "it's spiritual, not religious."

And the funniest things about all three of these (and more) is:
1/. They are true.
2/. They are used in practice.
3/. They are used by millions.
4/. They help alcoholics recover.

Who'd have thought huh? :rolleyes:
 
And the funniest things about all three of these (and more) is:
1/. They are true.
2/. They are used in practice.
3/. They are used by millions.
4/. They help alcoholics recover.

Who'd have thought huh? :rolleyes:



Thousand-odd-plus-one posts.


Those still don't excuse the overwhelming evidence supporting the argument that AA is a religious organization.
 
Those still don't excuse the overwhelming evidence supporting the argument that AA is a religious organization.

Sure they do.:)
Not only do they "excuse" it, they explain it, and prove that it is a support group for alcoholics who can choose a god of their own understanding if they want to.
 
Sure they do.:)
Not only do they "excuse" it, they explain it, and prove that it is a support group for alcoholics who can choose a god of their own understanding if they want to.



Perhaps, but as I've also said, there is no provision made for those who choose no god whatsoever.

The "proof" that an addict can choose no god or spirituality is by not attending AA.
 
Perhaps, but as I've also said, there is no provision made for those who choose no god whatsoever.

The "proof" that an addict can choose no god or spirituality is by not attending AA.

I agree with that too.
But we also have proof from AA members in this very thread that they can practice their atheism within AA. They choose no God (except the fellowship, the laws of nature, their better self or whatever), can attend the steps etc.

As I have said time and again, the roots of AA, the literature etc give some guidance and have some grounding in religion. However the practical application and practice of the steps and recovery in reality are far different for many millions.

The proof of the pudding is in the the eating, as they say. Recipes are given as a guide but the best results come with practice and personal changes to suit one's own palate.
AA is the same.
 
You noticed that I posted it "twice in two posts"......

Ah, my mistake. You were refering to a question that had nothing to do with the comment you quoted. Gotcha. In the future I'll have to guess that you're refering to questions that are not related to the part of the post you're quoting. :rolleyes:

and you didn't notice that it contained a question?

Yes. But since it's still you playing semantics, and I'm sick of it, I choose to skip it a third time.
 
In other words (if I take your meaning correctly), an observation that cannot be used as evidence within the framework of any theory might be considered evidence under an epistemological theory: we don't know everything. That has the flavor of a clever loophole, but I don't think it quite works, because it is still necessary to state the premise first.

You're still playing with words.

Observation is evidence. It's usually evidence for something, but it's still evidence even if you don't know for what.
 
I'd have thought that too.

And I was disappointed to see GB post again, I thought he had left. Too bad. ;)

In other news; we bury my friend (Lisa) tomorrow.

Alcoholism is serious stuff - we need as many resourses and chances for recovery as we can find. AA needs to be a part of the mix, whether you agree with the supposed religious component or not.
It's time again for conclusions from the peanut gallery:

1) AA is religious based.

2) AA can help people anyway.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom