Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
1. that which tends to prove or disprove something;
And guess what the "something" in that sentence refers to, qayak.

"Evidence in its broadest sense includes everything that is used to determine or demonstrate the truth of an assertion. Giving or procuring evidence is the process of using those things that are either (a) presumed to be true, or (b) were themselves proven via evidence, to demonstrate an assertion's truth. Evidence is the currency by which one fulfills the burden of proof."
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Evidence

It begins with observation. We may observe things we cannot explain. We dig up some bones, they obviously don't belong to any earthly creature we've ever seen. The bones cannot serve as evidence to prove or disprove any assertion about their origins, because we can't make any such assertions; we simply do not know where they came from. Once we develop an explanation (a theory), we use that to make assertions. Dragons once roamed the earth. Now the bones are evidence -- that dragons once roamed the earth. Somebody else comes along later and provides a better explanation. Now those very same bones are evidence that may be used to support that theory. Absent theory there is no burden of proof; hence, no evidence -- just observations.
 
Absent theory there is no burden of proof; hence, no evidence -- just observations.

Funny, without the evidence of observation, (your dragon bones) one wouldn't know a theory was necessary. :boxedin:
 
Exactly wrong. In modern science, the reasoning comes first.

Michelson–Morley is a perfect example. The hypothesis was pure reasoning: if light

Observation.

is a wave phenomenon

Observation.

You are just flatass wrong here, Belz. Spectacularly wrong. Embarassingly wrong.

No, I'm not. In fact, even if I WERE wrong, we're so far off course that it wouldn't matter one bit.

No. I'm not objecting just to that specific absurdity. I am objecting in a very general sense to the absurdity in saying that what most people think is not important when it comes to the commonly accepted meaning of any word. It is the very definition of the word, "definition".

This is where the knee-jerk reactions you're having right now are hurting your case. You can't seem to remember how the previous posts played out in the discussion, presumably because you put so little thought into them.
 
Michelson–Morley is a perfect example. The hypothesis was pure reasoning: if light is a wave phenomenon
Observation
No, Belz, that was not observation. It was theory. Mechanical waves may be observed as oscillations propagating through a medium such as a taught string, or a body of water, but light waves are a bit too small for that; their existence must be inferred. A weakness in the theory was that it demanded a medium (an exercise in pure reasoning), and the search for that hypothesized medium provided the starting point for Michelson and Morley.

Observation of evidence.
Evidence of what? The "of what" part is not merely important, it's absolutely vital. How about the oatmeal in the cupboard? Is that evidence? The sky is blue. Is that evidence? If I tell you that I have in my possession some evidence, but you have no way of knowing what that evidence might be related to, have I made a meaningful statement? Have you become better informed for having heard it?

Gee, can we get back on topic, now ?
You don't see EVIDENCE as an important concept in the context of this discussion? What would be your guess as to how many times that word has appeared (ALL CAPS or not) in this thread? Three hundred times? Five hundred?
 
No, Belz, that was not observation. It was theory.

Thanks for altering my post to make it appear as though I was saying something different. Light and waves are observations.

Evidence of what? The "of what" part is not merely important, it's absolutely vital.

Here you are, playing with words again.

Next thing you know, you'll be arguing about the definition of "word", and it will become entirely impossible to have any kind of discussion.
 
Thanks for altering my post to make it appear as though I was saying something different.
You chopped up one of my posts in mid-statement, posted the same response ("observation") to each piece, and the result was incoherency; I patched my portion back together in order to permit a coherent response. That's not me altering one of your posts, that's me undoing a clumsy alteration you made to one of mine.

Light and waves are observations.
They're not, actually. Light is observed, but no one has ever seen a light wave and no one ever will, for fundamental reasons. Modern theory postulates a wave/particle duality to the nature of light, but in the context of this example what is most pertinent is the state of the science in 1887.

Here you are, playing with words again.
I'm not playing; I consider the meanings of words to be important. It's hard to have any kind of a discussion involving the use of words like "observation", "evidence", and "theory" with participants who do not even recognize what these words mean. Have you never encountered the creationist argument that "Evolution is only a theory"? Do you understand that the reason that is such a pathetically weak argument is that it is based on the arguer's own ignorance of what the word, "theory" means in science? Is it "playing around with words" to point out that ignorance?
 
You chopped up one of my posts in mid-statement, posted the same response ("observation") to each piece, and the result was incoherency; I patched my portion back together in order to permit a coherent response.

And in so doing you missed my point entirely. Ironic, no ?

They're not, actually. Light is observed, but no one has ever seen a light wave and no one ever will, for fundamental reasons.

You know, when I talked about knee-jerk reactions, I meant that you should take time to actually READ what's being said. I didn't say "light waves".

I'm not playing; I consider the meanings of words to be important.[/QUOTE]

So do I, which is why I try to refrain from twisting that meaning around.
 
And in so doing you missed my point entirely.
I'm willing to accept about half of the responsibility for our failure to communicate there, and I consider that generous.

You know, when I talked about knee-jerk reactions, I meant that you should take time to actually READ what's being said. I didn't say "light waves".
You also didn't say "light is observed" and "waves are observed", so there wasn't anything more to READ. You simply said "observed" and left it up to me to provide the context. I had already provided the context: light waves, and had already noted that "mechanical waves may be observed". It was not clear that you were wanting to shift the context back to waves as a generalized concept, but now that we've cleared that up, are you willing to concede that light waves are not "observed"?

So do I, which is why I try to refrain from twisting that meaning around.
This is simply a restating of your objection: "Here you are, playing with words again." Did you notice that I already responded to that? What is your reason for completely ignoring that response? Here it is again, rephrased to accomodate your rephrasing of the objection:

Have you never encountered the creationist argument that "Evolution is only a theory"? Do you understand that the reason that is such a pathetically weak argument is that it is based on the arguer's own ignorance of what the word, "theory" means in science? Is it "twisting the meaning around" to point out that ignorance?
 
You also didn't say "light is observed" and "waves are observed", so there wasn't anything more to READ. You simply said "observed" and left it up to me to provide the context.

Negative. I said "light AND waves are observations". You fail.

Have you never encountered the creationist argument that "Evolution is only a theory"?

Twice in two posts. You can't even remember the last thing you said, Dymanic. Time to take a deep breath...

...and get back on topic. Not that anybody cares, anymore.
 
Twice in two posts.
And twice in two posts, you dodge the question. Are you ready to do a GB and openly state that you refuse to answer?

...and get back on topic.
And here, you continue to dodge another question:

You don't see EVIDENCE as an important concept in the context of this discussion? What would be your guess as to how many times that word has appeared (ALL CAPS or not) in this thread? Three hundred times? Five hundred?
After thinking it over a little more, I suspect that is a considerable underestimate. Somewhere between one and two thousand times is probably more like it. Examination of what is meant by the word "EVIDENCE" is hardly tangential to this discussion, considering the amount of importance that has been placed on that, and it's an issue that has been raised many times before. Here, for example:
Evidence doesn't really do much of anything but sit there waiting to be interpreted -- and within different interpretive frameworks, the same evidence may lead to very different conclusions (an insight I obtained at about age thirteen, largely through watching "Perry Mason" while having my after school snack). Again, it is the very reason for peer review and all that. You seem to think that evidence really does speak for itself, and you simply could not be more wrong.


Not that anybody cares, anymore.
Perhaps the most pertinent question is: Do you care? Is it important to use words in a commonly agreed-upon way, or is it okay to just use them in whatever way best suits your purposes?
 
And twice in two posts, you dodge the question. Are you ready to do a GB and openly state that you refuse to answer?

Answer what ? There was no question.

Perhaps the most pertinent question is: Do you care?

Yes, that's why I asked you to get back on topic and stop whining about definitions. You won't, of course, and it seems you've chased every able-minded skeptic from this thread. Hence the comment about nobody caring.
 
Answer what ? There was no question.
You noticed that I posted it "twice in two posts"...
Have you never encountered the creationist argument that "Evolution is only a theory"? Do you understand that the reason that is such a pathetically weak argument is that it is based on the arguer's own ignorance of what the word, "theory" means in science? Is it "playing around with words" to point out that ignorance?
Have you never encountered the creationist argument that "Evolution is only a theory"? Do you understand that the reason that is such a pathetically weak argument is that it is based on the arguer's own ignorance of what the word, "theory" means in science? Is it "twisting the meaning around" to point out that ignorance?
...and you didn't notice that it contained a question? I'm supposed to believe that this is the reason you didn't answer? I wonder if you'll notice now that I've bolded the question -- and I'll do better than that; I'll rephrase it one more time, so as to accomodate this latest version of your objection, once again bolding the question you're dodging:

Have you never encountered the creationist argument that "Evolution is only a theory"? Do you understand that the reason that is such a pathetically weak argument is that it is based on the arguer's own ignorance of what the word, "theory" means in science? Is it "whining about definitions" to point out that ignorance?
 
Dancing David said:
Observations do not become evidence until after they have been incorporated into a reasoned theory.

[\delurk]
Um, no, sometimes observations are evidence of phenomena that have no theory to explain them.
[relurk]
What non-reasoning entity do you suggest "observes" them?
 
Have you never encountered the creationist argument that "Evolution is only a theory"? Do you understand that the reason that is such a pathetically weak argument is that it is based on the arguer's own ignorance of what the word, "theory" means in science? Is it "whining about definitions" to point out that ignorance?

I get back from holiday, and you're still off-topic; and you're still not providing any evidence for your assertions that AA is not religious.

You really shouldn't bring up the "Creationist" argument, as YOU are the one employing the Creationist tactic of deploying an Epistemological Argument to undermine or conflate Ontological Distinctions.

GB
 
Um, no, sometimes observations are evidence of phenomena that have no theory to explain them.
In other words (if I take your meaning correctly), an observation that cannot be used as evidence within the framework of any theory might be considered evidence under an epistemological theory: we don't know everything. That has the flavor of a clever loophole, but I don't think it quite works, because it is still necessary to state the premise first.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom