Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
So quotes from AA literature are now regarded as speculation? I thought they were EVIDENCE. Did you get permission from your mentor to issue this declaration?

The quote itself is not speculation; the conclusions you drew from it are. Qayak stated as such in the lines you snipped -- he said it was speculation and why he thought it was speculation.

Care to actually address his points now that it's been clarified?
 
The quote itself is not speculation; the conclusions you drew from it are. Qayak stated as such in the lines you snipped -- he said it was speculation and why he thought it was speculation.

Care to actually address his points now that it's been clarified?
I'm afraid your attempt to clarify has succeeded only in confusing me. I see qayak claiming that what I posted was "speculation", where all I did was adhere to the established standard in this thread: quote from AA literature and offer my interpretation -- and I'm quite prepared to stand by it.
 
I'm afraid your attempt to clarify has succeeded only in confusing me. I see qayak claiming that what I posted was "speculation", where all I did was adhere to the established standard in this thread: quote from AA literature and offer my interpretation -- and I'm quite prepared to stand by it.



"You have no evidence that the meeting called itself anything other than an AA meeting, or that it was affiliated with any other group, and you completely ignore the fact that Atheism is not a group one can affiliate with."
 
I'm afraid your attempt to clarify has succeeded only in confusing me. I see qayak claiming that what I posted was "speculation", where all I did was adhere to the established standard in this thread: quote from AA literature and offer my interpretation -- and I'm quite prepared to stand by it.

Epic failure of comprehension there Dymanic.

There is no evidence to support that the AA quotes you provided apply, that you think they do, is mere speculation on your part.
 
Last edited:
ALL religions are cults, and are best to be avoided.

Former addicts often turn to religion as a crutch- get your spouse of AA if they are pushing the Christ cult on him
 
ALL religions are cults, and are best to be avoided.

Former addicts often turn to religion as a crutch- get your spouse of AA if they are pushing the Christ cult on him

I agree with that - to a point.
Addicts also turn to people for help, therapists etc for help and suicide. Sadly, I lost one of my closest friends to suicide yesterday. She picked up a drink again a few months ago after a few years sobriety and decades struggling with it. She confided in me recently she doubted she could do another recovery - guess she was right (sad).

But to see Christ being pushed by AA itself is not evident (anywhere) from where I sit, except with the individual (or group, by agreement). There is no mention of Christ within the prescribed literature and he is as relevant to my recovery as is atheism. i.e. NOT!

I say for the umteenth time. If AA is Christian, where is he mentioned?
 
Last edited:
Where reasoning is flawed, evidence is worthless -- potentially, worse than worthless.

Again, that's just rhetoric. Without evidence, reasoning is worthless, too.

Because in a context where psychological aspects of human nature are the central focus -- such as this one -- the relevant meaning of the word self, as determined by common usage, defaults to intuitive notions involving some form of Cartesian dualism

No, it doesn't. You choose to pick that definition simply because it allows AlBell to choose his unconscious as a higher power.

That you refuse to acknowledge this is precisely the basis of my objection.

Well, object no more, because I never refused to acknowledge this.

Yes, it is almost painfully clear to me that you don't see that. But let's take it one step at a time. Self first; greater than self afterward.

I suspect even if I were to find a suitable definition of "self" you'd ask me to define an even lower term. Turtles all the way down.

The first definition on that list is the one most relevant here. Do you find "bag of flesh" to be a human being's most essential quality?

You really didn't appreciate my hyperbole. Perhaps you don't like to be reminded that you're just a bunch of atoms.

Do you think most people would consider that to be a human being's most essential quality?

Actually, I don't care what people think. This isn't a popularity contest.
 
Without evidence, reasoning is worthless, too.
Without evidence, reasoning is all you've got. Can you really be completely ignorant of such exercises in pure reasoning as Einstein's light beam, Maxwell's demon, Schrödinger's cat, Borel's monkeys, Hawking's turtles? I see that you do not hesitate to invoke that last one. Does this constitute an endorsement on your part of the value of that particular exercise in pure reasoning, or is "turtles all the way down" just a catchy phrase for you? Are you thinking that that metaphor was based on some kind of empirical evidence?


Belz said:
Dymanic said:
Because in a context where psychological aspects of human nature are the central focus -- such as this one -- the relevant meaning of the word self, as determined by common usage, defaults to intuitive notions involving some form of Cartesian dualism.
No, it doesn't. You choose to pick that definition simply because it allows AlBell to choose his unconscious as a higher power.
Quoted (and bolded) to provide the context for your response to my next sentence in that paragraph:
Belz said:
dymanic said:
That you refuse to acknowledge this is precisely the basis of my objection.
Well, object no more, because I never refused to acknowledge this.
One of us is very confused. Did you or did you not JUST do precisely that when you said, "No, it doesn't"?


Actually, I don't care what people think. This isn't a popularity contest.
Where the commonly accepted meanings of words are concerned, that's exactly what it is.
 
Without evidence, reasoning is all you've got.

And it STILL leads nowhere without evidence. Of course, we DO have evidence, so we can reason appropriately.

One of us is very confused.

Both of us, it seems.

Where the commonly accepted meanings of words are concerned, that's exactly what it is.

You're just objecting to my calling a human a "bag of flesh". It doesn't have anything to do with any of the definitions I posted.
 
And it STILL leads nowhere without evidence.
Exactly wrong. In modern science, the reasoning comes first.

Michelson–Morley is a perfect example. The hypothesis was pure reasoning: if light is a wave phenomenon, there must be a medium to support it, and a properly designed experiment should detect this medium. As the Earth moves through this "luminiferous aether" (so it was reasoned), its speed relative to this aether must vary with changes in Earth's direction of travel as it orbits the Sun, and this should produce at least very small differences in the speed of the light as it moves through the aether. The results, quite startling to the theorists of the day, are now familiar to anyone who was paying attention in science class in about the about seventh grade. The same can be said of Einstein's Gedankenexperiments. The corroborating evidence for Uncle Al's logic came long after the reasoning itself was widely accepted on its own merits. You are just flatass wrong here, Belz. Spectacularly wrong. Embarassingly wrong.

You're just objecting to my calling a human a "bag of flesh".
No. I'm not objecting just to that specific absurdity. I am objecting in a very general sense to the absurdity in saying that what most people think is not important when it comes to the commonly accepted meaning of any word. It is the very definition of the word, "definition".
 
Exactly wrong. In modern science, the reasoning comes first.

That's not true. Often there are observations and evidence that leads to a reasoned theory, not the other way around. As well, the evidence often requires that the theory be changed, or discarded, for a different one. That is a case where the evidence came first.
 
That's not true. Often there are observations and evidence that leads to a reasoned theory, not the other way around. As well, the evidence often requires that the theory be changed, or discarded, for a different one. That is a case where the evidence came first.

Observations do not become evidence until after they have been incorporated into a reasoned theory.
 
Observations do not become evidence until after they have been incorporated into a reasoned theory.

No, observations are evidence whether they fit into a theory or not. You are suggesting that the observations that gravity did not work as Newton predicted were not evidence until after Einstein came up with his theory. That's not correct. They were evidence that Newton was wrong.

Einstein's theory explained the evidence that existed prior to it and then more evidence was gathered to check the predictions made by his theory.
 
Last edited:
No, observations are evidence whether they fit into a theory or not.
A dead body lies on the floor in the front room of an apartment. There are potentially an infinite number of observations we might make. There are no signs of forced entry. It was not raining the day before the body was discovered. There is oatmeal in the cupboard but no beer in the refrigerator. The couch is yellow, and dingy. The carpet is blue, and though it has been recently cleaned there are traces of muddy footprints. The kitchen tile is damp, and there are cockroaches under the sink. There is a small hole in the bedroom wall that appears to be several years old and to have been made by a screwdriver, as well as a large hole in the forehead of the deceased that appears to be just a few hours old and to have been made by a 38 caliber slug. There is a receipt in a drawer for a large quantity of dry ice. There are no dwarves or unicorns in the apartment...

Some of these observations may turn out to be important in explaining what caused the deceased's untimely death, and during the earliest stages of an investigation into the matter they must be treated as such. But until someone comes up with a theory as to what happened, they are, at best, potential evidence. Most will remain merely observations -- and while any one of them might be used as evidence to support some theory (say, one having to do with the feeding habits of cockroaches, or why humans see light at a wavelength of 450-495 nm as "blue"), most of the possible observations will be as completely irrelevant to those theories as they are to theories about the murder (suicide? accident?). Until they are put to work within the framework of some theory, they aren't evidence of anything. It's just a sloppy way of using that word.

They were evidence that Newton was wrong.
I have a theory under which that statement is evidence that you don't know what you're talking about. Newton's description of gravity still works just fine for most practical applications.

You are suggesting that the observations that gravity did not work as Newton predicted were not evidence until after Einstein came up with his theory.
Not at all. The same observations that became evidence under Newton's also became evidence under Einstein's. And the observations that aren't part of either theory, or any theory, are still just observations.
 
I have a theory under which that statement is evidence that you don't know what you're talking about. Newton's description of gravity still works just fine for most practical applications.

Even if it works well and is simple to use, it is still wrong. Based on that observation/evidence, your theory is wrong. :p

Not at all. The same observations that became evidence under Newton's also became evidence under Einstein's. And the observations that aren't part of either theory, or any theory, are still just observations.

Me thinks you are in la la land.

Ob·ser·va·tion
 
1. an act or instance of noticing or perceiving.
2. an act or instance of regarding attentively or watching.
3. the faculty or habit of observing or noticing.
4. notice: to escape a person's observation.
5. an act or instance of viewing or noting a fact or occurrence for some scientific or other special purpose: the observation of blood pressure under stress.
6. the information or record secured by such an act.
7. something that is learned in the course of observing things: My observation is that such clouds mean a storm.
8. a remark, comment, or statement based on what one has noticed or observed.
9. the condition of being observed.
10. Navigation .
a. the measurement of the altitude or azimuth of a heavenly body for navigational purposes.
b. the information obtained by such a measurement.

ev·i·dence 

1. that which tends to prove or disprove something; ground for belief; proof.
2. something that makes plain or clear; an indication or sign: His flushed look was visible evidence of his fever.
3. Law . data presented to a court or jury in proof of the facts in issue and which may include the testimony of witnesses, records, documents, or objects.
4. to make evident or clear; show clearly; manifest: He evidenced his approval by promising his full support.
5. to support by evidence: He evidenced his accusation with incriminating letters.
6. in evidence, plainly visible; conspicuous: The first signs of spring are in evidence.

As you can see, the first definition of evidence makes it clear that an observation (especially as in definition 6) is indeed evidence.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom