Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
"There is only one "self" IS a philosophical claim.

No, it's not. You'd LIKE it to be, because once something becomes philosophical you can pretty much reach any conclusion you want about it.

Sounds more like a "soul" to me. By definition, each individual can only have one of those, too, you know.

I already told you that you're wrong about this.

The "bag of flesh", that is. And you're assuming that others always take it the same way?

Some people don't think we landed on the moon. What people believe doesn't impact reality.

That you have a rather itchy "report" button finger suggests otherwise.

I didn't say I didn't mind, Dymanic. I said I'd rather. Please learn to read, because having to explain to you the meaning of words over and over is tiresome.

"A unified being which is the source of consciousness", or "The agent responsible for the thoughts and actions of an individual to which they are ascribed".

And what is it made of, pray tell ?

When people talk about "aspects of self" (in any of the myriad ways in which they do that -- and they do so quite often), they are NOT talking about themselves as bags of freaking flesh, Belz.

That's odd. I do. Am I not part of the set of "people" ? When you say "me", don't you include all of that stuff ?

"Further, each word may have multiple meanings. Some dictionaries include each separate meaning in the order of most common usage while others list definitions in historical order, with the oldest usage first."

That has so nothing to do with what I said...
 
Yes, I believe I said that. But the point of the matter is the validity of one's argument should be universal. "Self" is just a grammatical reference to "you" or whoever we're talking about. Dymanic is trying to make it appear as though it means something else, so I'm pointing out that in other languages the word doesn't necessarily appear as loader, or indeed appear at all.

And......?
Because the French language has no word for self (what does the French "me" mean? - just curious), that suddenly invalidates an entire line of argument because you think "it should be universal".


Well, that went entirely over your head, it seems. You can't tu quoque a tu quoque.

That would depend on the language one is using, I guess. :p

So... the fact that I haven't read Descartes somehow invalidates the fact that there is no word I know of for "self" in French.....,

Nothing to do with whether you have read him or not, more that he was able to explore a whole subject of self without having a word for it - seems odd, that's all.


...and that the sentence "power higher than yourself" would be entirely different in that language ? How do you figure that ?

If you say so, I really wouldn't know how they do the steps in France, I have never visited there and am unfamiliar with the language (save the odd phrase and word). I assume they, like us, do it the way they interpret it. :rolleyes:

What is French for suggested?

I already told you that you're wrong about this.

I suppose we should pack up our balls and bats, and leave. Clearly you understanding and insight here surpasses everyone elses. :rolleyes:


That's odd. I do. Am I not part of the set of "people" ? When you say "me", don't you include all of that stuff ?

So you are nothing but a bag of flesh?
There is no conscience? - because that's not flesh.
How do things like love, other emotions figure?
How do things like experience figure, they are not flesh?
Good and bad?
Morality? Habits?
How does family, a sense of belonging and desires fit with a simple "bag of flesh".

Your description reminds me of a sausage.
Are you a sausage? :D
I think you are a silly sausage. :)

I think the point here is that there is far more to a person than simply the sausage. If this is how you really see yourself, then I truly feel sorry for you.

Suddenly I'm a bit peckish.
 
Last edited:
And......?
Because the French language has no word for self (what does the French "me" mean? - just curious), that suddenly invalidates an entire line of argument because you think "it should be universal".

Phew! It's a good thing that this isn't what I think, then.

Nothing to do with whether you have read him or not, more that he was able to explore a whole subject of self without having a word for it - seems odd, that's all.

I know nothing about the subject because I haven't read outdated Descartes ? Fascinating.

I suppose we should pack up our balls and bats, and leave. Clearly you understanding and insight here surpasses everyone elses. :rolleyes:

Ah, so now having proven you wrong doesn't mean a thing. No wonder you still think AA isn't religious.

So you are nothing but a bag of flesh?
There is no conscience? - because that's not flesh.

Yes, it is. It may not be "made of" flesh, like bones aren't made of flesh, but it is OF the flesh, as I know you already understood. Admitting it, of course, would mean that we could move on and, you know, actually adress the topic.

I think the point here is that there is far more to a person than simply the sausage. If this is how you really see yourself, then I truly feel sorry for you.

If you truly need to see yourself as more than you really are, then you're the one you need to feel sorry for.

That would depend on the language one is using, I guess. :p

And with this, you've clearly shown that you have nothing to bring to this discussion aside from insults and irrelevancies.
 
Which "self" you mean?;)

Confused Alfie, then.

ETA: It is much easier to understand you, and your participation in this thread, Alfie, once I realized you think each aspect of your personality is a different person.
 
Last edited:
Evidence of what? That you are lying?
It is you that needs to provide evidence of your claims. i.e.

The proof of my claim has been cited innumerable times and you have never addressed it. That is an admission of truth in any honest person's book books.

Do you think that claiming they are lies at this late date means anything except "Alfie's got nothing?". It is easy to prove someone is lying. The citations were made, my reason was given, fill your boots. We both know you can't.

You were asked (as you point out) to provide evidence of this...

No, Alfie, that's not what you asked. You asked for evidence and an explanation. The evidence has been cited, there was no need to do it again. The explanation was given.

Ignoring citations you asked for and then claiming someone else is a liar, although not surprising from you, is the epitome of dishonest.
 
No, it's not. You'd LIKE it to be, because once something becomes philosophical you can pretty much reach any conclusion you want about it.
Exactly wrong. One hundred and eighty degrees wrong (for you, this little geometry lesson is a review; let's see if you've finally got it right).

One may reach any conclusion one likes as long as it is not necessary to justify one's conclusions with logic and reason. Philosophy is the process of examining the logic and reason used in reaching conclusions. Its objective is to clarify, not to obfuscate. If it often appears to have the opposite effect, it is usually because those who find themselves confused by the process were confused to begin with --so confused that they didn't even know they were confused. In Dennett's words, they had "taken their philosophical baggage onboard unexamined". This thread stands as a monument to unexamined assumptions. For one particular poster here, it is a celebration of unexamined assumptions. He wears his refusal to examine his assumptions as proudly as the moron who struts around the baseball stadium wearing one of these: http://crujonessociety.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2009/03/double-beer-hat.jpg -- an attitude which runs counter to everything the JREF stands for.

I don't know how things are where you live, but in my neck of the woods, illogical and irrational conclusions are absolutely rampant. Experts in economics and political science expound from barstools tidbits of wisdom they gleaned from Professors Limbaugh and Beck, while armchair psychologists continue their studies at the University of Daytime Talkshow Sleaze ("Lesbian Nazi hookers abducted by UFOs and forced into weight loss programs, all this week, on Town Talk"). Truthers, Birthers, and Denialists of every imaginable flavor dedicate uncountable hours to communal reinforcement of their pet beliefs, with technology at their fingertips that would make the computer systems used to put the first man on the moon look like an abacus. Evidence speaks for itself, the accused are assumed to be guilty, and gut instinct rules the day. Adrift in a sea of woo, I come here partly looking for some reassurance that the entire world has not yet quite become a global idiocracy. Instead of bringing me cause for hope, your obstinence serves only to reinforce my fears. This may be the reason that I find myself losing patience with you.

What people believe doesn't impact reality.
I do not entirely disagree; that is, what people believe does not always directly impact any reality but their own -- but one public aspect of reality that IS impacted by what people believe is the way words are commonly used in a language. English (I have to assume that you've found some way to deal with a bit of linguistic anglo-centrism) is absolutely filthy with metaphors and assumptions which reduce to some form of dualism, teleology, etc. It is virtually impossible to use the language at all in a way that avoids them entirely.

"A unified being which is the source of consciousness", or "The agent responsible for the thoughts and actions of an individual to which they are ascribed".
And what is it made of, pray tell ?
You do understand that this is precisely the objection I was raising when I clipped those quotes from the link qayak posted? It's not necessary to have read every word Descartes ever wrote; for our purposes here, we can focus on the one quote for which he is best known: "cogito ergo sum" -- "I think, therefore I am". Do you see how this is an exercise in affirming the consequent? Wait. Maybe we should back up a little. Do you see how this has nothing whatsoever to do with the nature of a human being as a "bag of flesh"? Probably not. Perhaps it would help if you had a little more background; one of the things that can make philosophy a challenging area of study is that it is often necessary (just as is the case in geometry) to understand how one idea is built upon another. Descartes was conducting a thought experiment here, one which is expressed in modern terms as the "brain in a vat".

Imbedded in that article you will find a link to Descartes' original phrase, "evil daemon", a concept more accessible to a person of his (pre-Frankenstein movie) time. There, you will find this:
In his Meditations on First Philosophy, René Descartes hypothesises the existence of an evil daemon, a personification who is "as clever and deceitful as he is powerful, who has directed his entire effort to misleading me." The evil daemon presents a complete illusion of an external world, including other people, to Descartes' senses, where in fact there is no such external world in existence. The evil genius also presents to Descartes' senses a complete illusion of his own body, including all bodily sensations, where in fact Descartes has no body."
In other words, no "bag of flesh" at all. Your posts suggest that you are completely unfamiliar with any of this, but this seems so incredible to me that I continue to entertain alternative explanations for your stubbornness on this point.

Belz said:
That's odd. I do. Am I not part of the set of "people"?
"Meanings about the words people use, the objects we produce, and the activities in which we engage, are negotiated through social interaction with others in multiple, overlapping, and often contesting communities."
http://www.citejournal.org/vol4/iss3/languagearts/article1.cfm

You may of course use words any way you want, but in order to address the OP's question we must look to current, common usage -- and it's a "one man, one vote" system.
 
Exactly wrong. One hundred and eighty degrees wrong

I wasn't aware that one could be wrong in angles about a subject, but ok ! :p

One may reach any conclusion one likes as long as it is not necessary to justify one's conclusions with logic and reason. Philosophy is the process of examining the logic and reason used in reaching conclusions.

How does that change what I said ? We're getting so far off topic at this point I can barely see the solar system from here.

Its objective is to clarify, not to obfuscate.

Explain solipsism, please. The point is that philosophy is not concerned with evidence, merely the process of reasoning. But you can reason anything if you ignore evidence, which is why philosophy is useless in a debate such as this one.

This may be the reason that I find myself losing patience with you.

The feeling's mutual.

English (I have to assume that you've found some way to deal with a bit of linguistic anglo-centrism) is absolutely filthy with metaphors and assumptions which reduce to some form of dualism, teleology, etc. It is virtually impossible to use the language at all in a way that avoids them entirely.

And yet we both know that I wasn't talking about homunculi or souls when I said "you" or "self", so why even bring that into the discussion if not to obsfuscate ?

n other words, no "bag of flesh" at all. Your posts suggest that you are completely unfamiliar with any of this

I'm very familiar with that kind of nonsense but I don't see how it relates to the phrase "power higher than yourself" other than by trying to make it impossible to analyse and thus grind the discussion to a halt.

You may of course use words any way you want, but in order to address the OP's question we must look to current, common usage -- and it's a "one man, one vote" system.

Again, what's your point ? Wouldn't it be JUST simpler to use the definitions found in the dictionary rather than make them up as we go ? Of course, we all know the true purpose behind the latter behaviour...
 
The point is that philosophy is not concerned with evidence, merely the process of reasoning.
Where reasoning is flawed, evidence is worthless -- potentially, worse than worthless. Using flawed reasoning to extrapolate from sparse data is the basis for every conspiracy theory that ever gained traction, every execution of a person wrongly convicted for murder, every brand of lunacy from Bigfoot to the Bermuda Triangle.

And yet we both know that I wasn't talking about homunculi or souls when I said "you" or "self", so why even bring that into the discussion if not to obsfuscate ?
Because in a context where psychological aspects of human nature are the central focus -- such as this one -- the relevant meaning of the word self, as determined by common usage, defaults to intuitive notions involving some form of Cartesian dualism -- notions which are indeed largely indistinguishable from the concept, "soul". That you refuse to acknowledge this is precisely the basis of my objection. I hope you do understand that I am not advocating those notions as logically defensible; quite the opposite. I'm just saying that regardless of whether it's what YOU mean, that is what most people mean when they use that word in a context such as this one. It defaults to the way it feels.

I'm very familiar with that kind of nonsense but I don't see how it relates to the phrase "power higher than yourself" other than by trying to make it impossible to analyse and thus grind the discussion to a halt.
Yes, it is almost painfully clear to me that you don't see that. But let's take it one step at a time. Self first; greater than self afterward.

Wouldn't it be JUST simpler to use the definitions found in the dictionary rather than make them up as we go ?
Yes it would. Is it still not clear to you that I'm not suggesting that we make up a new definition for the word "self"? How many different ways are there to say it? We must look to current, common usage. That is what was provided in the dictionary definition you posted above:
1.the identity, character, or essential qualities of any person or thing
2.one's own person as distinct from all others
3.one's own welfare, interest, or advantage; selfishness: obsessed with self

The first definition on that list is the one most relevant here. Do you find "bag of flesh" to be a human being's most essential quality? No, wait. Considering who it is I'm talking to, perhaps I should rephrase that. Do you think most people would consider that to be a human being's most essential quality?
 
I initially stayed the hell away from AA because of all of the godspeak. However, in my city, someone started an AA group for atheists and agnostics. It's wonderful to get the program without all of the god talk (and it still is the program...at least to me). When it comes to addiction, I say do what works for you and makes you a better person.
 
I initially stayed the hell away from AA because of all of the godspeak. However, in my city, someone started an AA group for atheists and agnostics. It's wonderful to get the program without all of the god talk (and it still is the program...at least to me). When it comes to addiction, I say do what works for you and makes you a better person.

How is it different? Does it use a de-godded version of the Big Book and AA literature or does it use the standard ones with the meetings consisting of atheists who don't mention god?

Did you see the secular 12 Steps listed earlier? Might be an idea to give those a try. Atheists having a program that fits their beliefs is a great idea.
 
I initially stayed the hell away from AA because of all of the godspeak. However, in my city, someone started an AA group for atheists and agnostics. It's wonderful to get the program without all of the god talk (and it still is the program...at least to me). When it comes to addiction, I say do what works for you and makes you a better person.

Welcome aboard Carolynf1.

I wish you all the best in recovery and AA.
I am not surprised to learn that recovery does work with a higher power that is not God.;)

Don't take the inevitable flogging you will get from Belz, Qayak and GB et al personally - sadly they have no clue and would try and pull down AA from afar.

Your recovery encompasses all I have been saying about doing the steps any way you like.

Well done you.
 
How is it different? Does it use a de-godded version of the Big Book and AA literature or does it use the standard ones with the meetings consisting of atheists who don't mention god?

Did you see the secular 12 Steps listed earlier? Might be an idea to give those a try. Atheists having a program that fits their beliefs is a great idea.

Yup! We read a list of secular 12 steps, and we also sometimes read a Humanist interpretation of the steps written by Skinner. I'd post the URL, but I don't have 15 posts yet.

We almost never read the Big Book (unless if someone wants to quote something then we'll dig it out), since this particular meeting is a topic meeting. They had a HELL of a time getting it acknowledged by my city's intergroup. The only way that the person in charge of intergroup would approve it is if the meeting was named "We Agnostics" since that's a chapter in the big book. It's just nice to be around people who share my beliefs and are also in recovery.
 
Welcome aboard Carolynf1.

I wish you all the best in recovery and AA.
I am not surprised to learn that recovery does work with a higher power that is not God.;)

Don't take the inevitable flogging you will get from Belz, Qayak and GB et al personally - sadly they have no clue and would try and pull down AA from afar.

Your recovery encompasses all I have been saying about doing the steps any way you like.

Well done you.

Thank you! I have a little over a year of sobriety - it took awhile to make A.A work for me (as I do believe that it is a tad harder for atheists and agnostics and I've gotten flak from believers along the way), but I've found a way that's good for me. I use the collective wisdom of my A.A. groups and nature as my higher power. While I can't wrap my mind around a supreme being knowing what's best for me, I CAN wrap my head around other people who have been through the same thing knowing (or giving advice on) what's best for me because going completely with my own thinking was what got me into trouble in the first place.
 
Thank you! I have a little over a year of sobriety - it took awhile to make A.A work for me (as I do believe that it is a tad harder for atheists and agnostics and I've gotten flak from believers along the way), but I've found a way that's good for me. I use the collective wisdom of my A.A. groups and nature as my higher power. While I can't wrap my mind around a supreme being knowing what's best for me, I CAN wrap my head around other people who have been through the same thing knowing (or giving advice on) what's best for me because going completely with my own thinking was what got me into trouble in the first place.

That sounds a lot like me.
I also applied the 'live and let live' motto to my theist friends (and they me). After 11 years it is a real non-issue - and was only an issue for me early on; save for some well intentioned theists, no-one else seemed to care that much.

My HP is the fellowship, nature and a different application of my thinking. I identify as agnostic because I can't say for certain what is and isn't out there.
 
Yup! We read a list of secular 12 steps, and we also sometimes read a Humanist interpretation of the steps written by Skinner. I'd post the URL, but I don't have 15 posts yet.

That's okay, I've seen it.

We almost never read the Big Book (unless if someone wants to quote something then we'll dig it out), since this particular meeting is a topic meeting. They had a HELL of a time getting it acknowledged by my city's intergroup. The only way that the person in charge of intergroup would approve it is if the meeting was named "We Agnostics" since that's a chapter in the big book. It's just nice to be around people who share my beliefs and are also in recovery.

I am glad to hear brave people like you have taken it upon themselves to make it work inside your beliefs. It is a little disheartening to hear the larger group was resistant to the changes. Hopefully that will change over time in more areas. Change doesn't come easy.

Congratulations on your sobriety. Don't forget to take some of the credit for yourself. None of the changes happen without you making them happen. :)
 
Yeah imagine that - flexibility within AA.

Seems Quayak has 'converted'. :D

Why do you think evidence that supports my claim would convert me to your viewpoint? :confused:

There doesn't seem to be much flexability at all. The Atheist group can't even call themselves an AA meeting. They have to use a name of a chapter in the Big Book that is disrespectful, condescending, and ignorant of, everything an Atheist believes.

I guess it takes more than just the desire to quit drinking to belong and more than just two people to call yourself a meeting. One asshat in the intergroup can overrule the collective conscious of the Atheist's meeting. That it is allowed to happen in AA is proof that AA gives nothing more than lip service to its claims of inclusion.

The proof stares you in the face, Alfie, and yet you still apologize for AA's anti-Atheist bigotry.
 
Why do you think evidence that supports my claim would convert me to your viewpoint?
Pulling your chain he was, I think. Worked, too, looks like.

One asshat in the intergroup can overrule the collective conscious of the Atheist's meeting.
"Any two or three alcoholics gathered together for sobriety may call themselves an AA group provided that as a group they have no other affiliation."
- 12&12, page 146

The rule that disallows a group from calling themselves the "Saturday Night AA Atheists" is the same one that would disallow another bunch from calling themselves the "Sunday Morning AA Jesus Freaks".

Asshats in intergroup (and we have evidence that they do exist) have nothing to do with it.
 
Pulling your chain he was, I think. Worked, too, looks like.

No, I already stated that once I realized Alfie was several different people it became easy to deal with him. That was "I Want to Believe" Alfie talking. Asking him a simple question isn't evidence of his pulling my chain. :rolleyes:

"Any two or three alcoholics gathered together for sobriety may call themselves an AA group provided that as a group they have no other affiliation."
- 12&12, page 146

The rule that disallows a group from calling themselves the "Saturday Night AA Atheists" is the same one that would disallow another bunch from calling themselves the "Sunday Morning AA Jesus Freaks".

Asshats in intergroup (and we have evidence that they do exist) have nothing to do with it.

This is all speculation on your part. You have no evidence that the meeting called itself anything other than an AA meeting, or that it was affiliated with any other group, and you completely ignore the fact that Atheism is not a group one can affiliate with.

AA indoctrinated asshats have everything to do with it and is further evidence that AA talks the talk but doesn't walk the walk.

If you were a boxer, you would be down for the count despite all your bobbing and weaving. :p
 
Why do you think evidence that supports my claim would convert me to your viewpoint? :confused:

There doesn't seem to be much flexability at all. The Atheist group can't even call themselves an AA meeting. They have to use a name of a chapter in the Big Book that is disrespectful, condescending, and ignorant of, everything an Atheist believes.

I guess it takes more than just the desire to quit drinking to belong and more than just two people to call yourself a meeting. One asshat in the intergroup can overrule the collective conscious of the Atheist's meeting. That it is allowed to happen in AA is proof that AA gives nothing more than lip service to its claims of inclusion.

The proof stares you in the face, Alfie, and yet you still apologize for AA's anti-Atheist bigotry.

American society in general has a negative attitude when it comes to atheists and agnostics, not just some people in A.A. You'll get anti-atheist bigotry anywhere, especially where I'm located (a heavy lutheran population).

Congratulations on your sobriety. Don't forget to take some of the credit for yourself. None of the changes happen without you making them happen

And, thank you.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom