No, it's not. You'd LIKE it to be, because once something becomes philosophical you can pretty much reach any conclusion you want about it.
Exactly wrong.
One hundred and eighty degrees wrong (for you, this little geometry lesson is a review; let's see if you've finally got it right).
One may reach any conclusion one likes
as long as it is not necessary to justify one's conclusions with logic and reason. Philosophy is the process of examining the logic and reason used in reaching conclusions. Its objective is to clarify, not to obfuscate. If it often appears to have the opposite effect, it is usually because those who find themselves confused by the process were confused to begin with --
so confused that they didn't even know they were confused. In Dennett's words, they had "taken their philosophical baggage onboard unexamined". This thread stands as a monument to unexamined assumptions. For one particular poster here, it is a
celebration of unexamined assumptions. He wears his refusal to examine his assumptions as proudly as the moron who struts around the baseball stadium wearing one of these:
http://crujonessociety.com/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2009/03/double-beer-hat.jpg -- an attitude which runs counter to everything the JREF stands for.
I don't know how things are where you live, but in my neck of the woods, illogical and irrational conclusions are absolutely
rampant. Experts in economics and political science expound from barstools tidbits of wisdom they gleaned from Professors Limbaugh and Beck, while armchair psychologists continue their studies at the University of Daytime Talkshow Sleaze ("Lesbian Nazi hookers abducted by UFOs and forced into weight loss programs, all this week, on Town Talk"). Truthers, Birthers, and Denialists of every imaginable flavor dedicate uncountable hours to communal reinforcement of their pet beliefs, with technology at their fingertips that would make the computer systems used to put the first man on the moon look like an abacus. Evidence speaks for itself, the accused are assumed to be guilty, and gut instinct rules the day. Adrift in a sea of woo, I come here partly looking for some reassurance that the entire world has not yet quite become a global idiocracy. Instead of bringing me cause for hope, your obstinence serves only to reinforce my fears. This may be the reason that I find myself losing patience with you.
What people believe doesn't impact reality.
I do not entirely disagree; that is, what people believe does not always directly impact any reality but their own -- but one public aspect of reality that IS impacted by what people believe is
the way words are commonly used in a language. English (I have to assume that you've found some way to deal with a bit of linguistic anglo-centrism) is absolutely filthy with metaphors and assumptions which reduce to some form of dualism, teleology, etc. It is virtually impossible to use the language at all in a way that avoids them entirely.
"A unified being which is the source of consciousness", or "The agent responsible for the thoughts and actions of an individual to which they are ascribed".
And what is it made of, pray tell ?
You
do understand that this is precisely the objection I was raising when I clipped those quotes from the link qayak posted? It's not necessary to have read every word Descartes ever wrote; for our purposes here, we can focus on the one quote for which he is best known: "
cogito ergo sum" -- "I think, therefore I am". Do you see how this is an exercise in affirming the consequent? Wait. Maybe we should back up a little. Do you see how this has nothing whatsoever to do with the nature of a human being as a "bag of flesh"? Probably not. Perhaps it would help if you had a little more background; one of the things that can make philosophy a challenging area of study is that it is often necessary (just as is the case in geometry) to understand how one idea is built upon another. Descartes was conducting a thought experiment here, one which is expressed in modern terms as the
"brain in a vat".
Imbedded in that article you will find a link to Descartes' original phrase, "evil daemon", a concept more accessible to a person of his (pre-Frankenstein movie) time. There, you will find this:
In his Meditations on First Philosophy, René Descartes hypothesises the existence of an evil daemon, a personification who is "as clever and deceitful as he is powerful, who has directed his entire effort to misleading me." The evil daemon presents a complete illusion of an external world, including other people, to Descartes' senses, where in fact there is no such external world in existence. The evil genius also presents to Descartes' senses a complete illusion of his own body, including all bodily sensations, where in fact Descartes has no body."
In other words, no "bag of flesh"
at all. Your posts suggest that you are completely unfamiliar with any of this, but this seems so incredible to me that I continue to entertain alternative explanations for your stubbornness on this point.
Belz said:
That's odd. I do. Am I not part of the set of "people"?
"
Meanings about the words people use, the objects we produce, and the activities in which we engage, are negotiated through social interaction with others in multiple, overlapping, and often contesting communities."
http://www.citejournal.org/vol4/iss3/languagearts/article1.cfm
You may of course use words any way you want, but in order to address the OP's question we must look to
current, common usage -- and it's a "one man, one vote" system.