Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
So when the self changes, we have the old self and the new self? :confused:;)

That's the danger of trying to redefine things in non-pragmatic terms.

"Self" is you, in this example. There is only one you at any given time.

Again, this is simply an example of how language is used on a day-to-day basis.

In English, perhaps. "Higher than yourself" in French would be quite different, and two-bit philosophical nonsense as offered by Dymanic wouldn't have a leg to stand on.

You (and others) want to nail down usage to mean just one thing; and that is your interpretation only.

False. But I want to avoid having a term so vague as to be impossible to use in a conversation. For instance, would you agree to the definitions of "self" I quoted earlier on ?

We have already seen numerous discussions around the word "suggested", "self", "religious" and "spiritual".

You'll notice that the one asking to define these terms over and over isn't me.

I am assuming that you and others are in the latter category; clearly you are not idiots and clearly you can read. Why is it you don't see the fuller picture?

You mean, why don't I see things as YOU do ?
 
Dictionary definitions provide meanings that have already been agreed upon. The dictionary is saying: "Here is one of the things a person may mean when they use this word; and here's another; and here is yet another, though it is seldom seen in common usage these days..." etc.

And we usually take those words to mean something along those lines.

As I said to Alfie above, "Self" is not really a word that exists in French, my first language. So the whole "power higher than yourself" question would never have gotten this far into sophistry were we discussing in that tongue.

beyond stupid.

Why do you insist in using such extreme superlatives ? Does it make you feel better to belittle people who disagree with you ?

We're not loading an elevator here.

And it's a good thing. Otherwise before we even started loading it you'd ask me to define what I mean by "pounds" just to ensure we're not overloading the elevator.

(And by the way, Belz, pointing out ignorance, and even stupidity, is not only allowed around here, and not merely encouraged; it's the whole reason this forum exists -- so report away; the mods probably don't have anything better to do than listen to you whine about how somebody hurt your feelings by pointing out how mind-bogglingly stupid one of your arguments was).

Again with the presumption that my feelings were hurt. You seem incapable of detaching yourself from my intentions or thoughts. Can't we simply discuss the subject at hand ? If not, two can play that game.

Evidently, the quality of some of the discussions I've seen around here over the years has allowed me to develop an unrealistically high level of expectation.

Me too, and I'm usually very dissapointed when a subject that should be decided by evidence descends into a rhetoric about semantics.

Actually, I found the second one to be the one that best expresses the meaning you want to use here: a simple description of the boundaries of "you" or "me".

Hopefully you at least agree that your fingers are part of "you". Otherwise I submit that "you" is undefinable, or perhaps even non-existent, and that the whole question of "power higher than yourself" is nonsensical.

If I recall correctly, the way you phrased it earlier in the thread was: "YOU is the sum of things that are your body".

Yes, excluding clothes, imagined souls or other irrelevant entities seemed reasonable at the time. Little did I know how important it was for you to deny this thread any progress at all.

Are you aware that ninety percent of the cells in and on a human body are not actually human cells, but cells belonging to bacteria and other mircroflora?

Yes, actually. And that reminds me that about 70 billion of them owe me some rent for that space I gave them in my colon.

Does that make ME part human and part microbe?

Will answering "yes" or "no" make a difference ? Whether one considers gut flora to be part of "you" or just parasites, does it really change anything to the question at hand ? No, it doesn't. But it allows you to continue to dodge the whole point of the thread.
 
Since I actually attend AA meetings, I actually know what is entailed, and don't need to guess.
 
And we usually take those words to mean something along those lines.
It's necessary to specify which line when there is more than one, as here.

As I said to Alfie above, "Self" is not really a word that exists in French, my first language. So the whole "power higher than yourself" question would never have gotten this far into sophistry were we discussing in that tongue.
That's somewhat puzzling considering that the philosopher who is most often credited with first formulating the idea of the "solitary self" is the French Philosopher Rene Descartes. How ever did he manage?

Does it make you feel better to belittle people who disagree with you ?
I'd just like to be sure I'm not wasting my time with somebody who is just pulling my leg, and I find your argument on this point so idiotic that I feel compelled to consider that possibility.

...I'm usually very dissapointed when a subject that should be decided by evidence descends into a rhetoric about semantics.
Review the OP and you may see that this discussion began as an exercise in semantics -- either that, or as an inquiry into motives (and as such, one which, by its very nature, cannot be decoupled from consideration of the intentions of the posters involved). Of course, there is another way of looking at it, which is that it did not begin with a sincere effort to conduct an inquiry of any sort -- but that itself involves making certain unproveable assumptions regarding motive, doesn't it?

Hopefully you at least agree that your fingers are part of "you". Otherwise I submit that "you" is undefinable, or perhaps even non-existent, and that the whole question of "power higher than yourself" is nonsensical.
I do not agree that my fingers are an important part of "me" under the commonly accepted definition of "self" that is most relevant to the context of this discussion. I do agree that in that context, "you" cannot be crisply defined or empirically tested, and that the same goes for "higher power". That doesn't necessarily mean that it cannot be helpful to apply these concepts, if only somewhat metaphorically, in managing one's own internal states or in communicating to others about matters related to that. To paraphrase Dennett, just because it's a fiction does not necessarily mean it's not useful.
 
Thanks for confirming that you have no sincere interest in a public examination of the biased assumptions used in reaching your conclusions. Can't say that I blame you.

Your arguments have no sincerity in the least. THEY cannot stand public scrutiny.

I don't disagree -- but then, it wasn't my premise. The question here is not whether AA's premises are all logically sound; it's whether they are inherently religious.

BS, you're the one defending AA against charges of religiosity, and you're the one that chose to set up the premise as a set of fallacies

"Sharing pain and suffering" were your words -- words which reflect a lack of understanding of AA's Step Five, which is about sharing "the exact nature of our wrongs". Doesn't say a word about pain and suffering. It's about coming out of hiding. That can be painful (as well as scary), but the assumption is that not to do so results in even more pain. You've posted those steps more times than I'd care to count, but it doesn't look like you've ever really read them even once. You certainly are nowhere near understanding them.

What is clear is that YOU don't understand the difference between sharing one's own pain and suffering with a sympathetic ear and admitting (confessing) one's WRONGS to GOD with the expectation of receiving AA's version of Grace/Absolution--Sobriety. I wasn't claiming that AA's Step 5 said ANYTHING about "sharing pain and suffering,"

It is also clear that you never really read the 12 Steps. You once confessed in a post that you didn't know much about Christianity. So it is no surprise to me that you don't understand the Historical Context of the Christian Tenets the Steps are based on. Given that you have never conceded that AA's Steps are based on these Christian Tenets, you lack any credibility to speak at all on this subject.

And here you are doing the very thing you just accused me of doing: conflating the 4th/5th with the 6th/7th. Now that you've decided to rejoin the actual discussion, then once we're done with this part I'll be more than happy to move on to a more detailed examination of the process you're referring to as "Seeking Absolution".

The Conflation was yours; in your premise it was clear you were referring to Steps 6 and 7 in your proposition in which you are questioning whether the character flaws/shortcomings were equivalent to Sin:

There is an obvious implication of viewing "character defects" as an integral aspect of alcoholism (which the steps clearly do): not every person is alcoholic; therefore not every person (apparently) suffers from these flaws. Is this consistent with what Christianity teaches about "sin"?

Then you bait and switch (substitute) Steps 4 & 5 in which the Steps refer to Inventory and Admission (Confession):

I see two logical alternatives here. One is that the process of identifying and admitting one's wrongdoings is itself inherently religious. The other is that it is not inherently religious, but becomes religious if performed in accordance with some formalized system of religious beliefs.

So, not only was your original post disingenuous (dishonest), you are now lying about what you posted.


The statement of yours I quoted is from page 16 -- long before I ever asked any of these questions, ALL of which you have left unanswered:

"Would you agree that possession of an internalized set of moral principles presupposes a capacity for experiencing guilt?"

"Is there something inherently religious about considering where you may have made mistakes and trying to understand what caused you to make them?"

"Do you agree with those Christians who regard atheists as immoral (the more sophisticated ones might say "amoral") due to a lack of any possible basis for judging right from wrong?"

"You don't think it's important to consider whether there exists outside the framework of Christianity a legitimate basis for judging right from wrong? I find that hard to believe. Do you not judge ME for having committed what you perceive to be moral transgressions right here in this very thread?"

"You evidently do have some basis for judging right from wrong. Is that basis inherently religious in nature and origin? If not, what is its nature, and where did it originate?"

"Within a belief system based on the concept of "Original Sin", what possible value can there be in a personal inventory? Why bother listing the wrongs you may have committed, or making direct amends to those you've harmed, or considering whether you're willing to have your character defects removed -- when none of that counts for squat anyway because you're still filthy with Sin you inherited?"

Sorry Dymanic. I'm not playing the game by your rules of sophistry anymore.

Your case has been utterly lost, just like the lawyers who no doubt used your same arguments before the Supreme Court. Your responses to my pointing out all your fallacies demonstrate that you are not willing have an honest debate on the evidence.

Therefore I will treat you the way we skeptics treat any other person trolling on the forums posting fallacies and lies, and simply demand you provide evidence for your assertions every time you post.


GB
 
Last edited:
What is clear is that YOU don't understand the difference between sharing one's own pain and suffering with a sympathetic ear and admitting (confessing) one's WRONGS to GOD with the expectation of receiving AA's version of Grace/Absolution--Sobriety.
That must be the GB version of some recovery program.

It isn't AA's.
 
That's somewhat puzzling considering that the philosopher who is most often credited with first formulating the idea of the "solitary self" is the French Philosopher Rene Descartes. How ever did he manage?

Here you are, again, using antiquated, philosophical notions of the "soul". I don't know how Descartes did it, because I don't know which terms he used. Do you ? Does it matter ? When I tell someone "do it yourself", does that refer to some small part of his conscious mind, or some chimera of human belief systems, or simply to the bag of flesh I'm talking to ?

When someone says "power higher than yourself", I take "self" to simply be a grammatical reference to the "you" that came right before it. Of course, that'd be too simple to accept because then you'd have to actually debate the topic of the thread.

I'd just like to be sure I'm not wasting my time with somebody who is just pulling my leg, and I find your argument on this point so idiotic that I feel compelled to consider that possibility.

It's unfortunate that we're all strangers, here. Someone who knows me personally would never even consider that I'm being dishonest. I prefer being called stupid.

Review the OP and you may see that this discussion began as an exercise in semantics -- either that, or as an inquiry into motives (and as such, one which, by its very nature, cannot be decoupled from consideration of the intentions of the posters involved).

You're correct. However in order to even begin to answer the question I think we have to determine whether AA _is_ religious. I think it's been a dead horse for a while.

I do not agree that my fingers are an important part of "me" under the commonly accepted definition of "self" that is most relevant to the context of this discussion.

Who said anything about being an "important" part of your self ? It's part of you, plain and simple. The rest, "commonly accepted", "most relevant" and "context" are just exit doors you constructed for your own benefit later on, methinks.
 
On the AA claims that:

1) the only two options for alcoholics are recovery or death.

2) that AA is the only cure for alcoholism.

Outright lies or at best total misrepresentations.

I asked for evidence and you come up with this. :mad::rolleyes:

In day to day terms we talk about the duality of good and evil being embodied in one person on occasion but you have expanded this to the point where every aspect of a personality is itself a completely new personality. That's psychobabble as someone said earlier.

So I ask you the same thing I ask the other. Is CBT psychobabble too?

I understand what you are saying but I think it is wrong.

Then that's fine. We will have to agree to disagree.
 
In English, perhaps. "Higher than yourself" in French would be quite different, and two-bit philosophical nonsense as offered by Dymanic wouldn't have a leg to stand on.

Last time I checked, we were conversing in English.

You mean, why don't I see things as YOU do ?

Right back at you.

I do see where you are coming from and see there could be application in the sense you suggest.
You fail to see that application could be applied in more than the sense you see, and that in reality/practice it is applied liberally.

Pretend it's an AA meeting; take what you like, leave the rest.

lol :D

Here you are, again, using antiquated, philosophical notions of the "soul". I don't know how Descartes did it, because I don't know which terms he used. Do you ? Does it matter ?

Backpedal noted.
It was you who brought up the completely irrelevant topic of your first language. And when challenged you have no defense.

Goal posts! Over there. :D
 
Last edited:
Outright lies or at best total misrepresentations.

Evidence?

I asked for evidence and you come up with this. :mad::rolleyes:

No, you asked: "On what do you base this ("do or die")?"

So I ask you the same thing I ask the other. Is CBT psychobabble too?

Before I answer this question, it is time for you to answer the one I asked you.

Then that's fine. We will have to agree to disagree.

Exactly which Alfie am I talking to here? :D
 
Here you are, again, using antiquated, philosophical notions of the "soul".
Oh, that's ME doing that? Could you have missed this post?:
Perhaps you did not recognize it as such, but your statement: "There is only one "self" IS a philosophical claim. I asked to see the evidence, and qayak tossed out a Wiki link, one which contained a couple of definitions for "self" that I actually find pretty comical. I mean, come on: "A unified being which is the source of consciousness"? Sounds more like a "soul" to me. By definition, each individual can only have one of those, too, you know.


Belz said:
When someone says "power higher than yourself", I take "self" to simply be a grammatical reference to the "you" that came right before it.
The "bag of flesh", that is. And you're assuming that others always take it the same way?

I prefer being called stupid.
That you have a rather itchy "report" button finger suggests otherwise.

You're correct. However in order to even begin to answer the question I think we have to determine whether AA _is_ religious. I think it's been a dead horse for a while.
For some of the participants here (starting with the OP) that horse was clearly dead at the starting gate.

Who said anything about being an "important" part of your self ? It's part of you, plain and simple.
I'll state my position more strongly: the fingers are not any part of the "self" under the commonly accepted definition of "self" that is most relevant to the context of this discussion. In common usage -- in contexts concerned with psychological aspects of human nature -- that word defaults to something very much along the lines of the definition contained in qayak's link above: "A unified being which is the source of consciousness", or "The agent responsible for the thoughts and actions of an individual to which they are ascribed". In short, a homunculus; the "ghost in the machine". When people talk about "aspects of self" (in any of the myriad ways in which they do that -- and they do so quite often), they are NOT talking about themselves as bags of freaking flesh, Belz.

The rest, "commonly accepted", "most relevant" and "context" are just exit doors you constructed for your own benefit later on, methinks.
Methinks you could learn much by reading the Wikipedia article titled: "Dictionary", where you may find such deep and penetrating insights as this one:

"Further, each word may have multiple meanings. Some dictionaries include each separate meaning in the order of most common usage while others list definitions in historical order, with the oldest usage first."
 
Evidence?

Evidence of what? That you are lying?
It is you that needs to provide evidence of your claims. i.e.

On the AA claims that:
1) the only two options for alcoholics are recovery or death.
2) that AA is the only cure for alcoholism.

please provide the evidence of this (which you can't as it isn't there)

You were asked (as you point out) to provide evidence of this...

The religion practiced in AA suggests that "suggestions" are just a euphamism for "Do it or die!"

And you provided lies as evidence?!?! :boggled:
 
Last edited:
Last time I checked, we were conversing in English.

Yes, I believe I said that. But the point of the matter is the validity of one's argument should be universal. "Self" is just a grammatical reference to "you" or whoever we're talking about. Dymanic is trying to make it appear as though it means something else, so I'm pointing out that in other languages the word doesn't necessarily appear as loader, or indeed appear at all.

Right back at you.

Well, that went entirely over your head, it seems. You can't tu quoque a tu quoque.

Backpedal noted.
It was you who brought up the completely irrelevant topic of your first language. And when challenged you have no defense.

Goal posts! Over there. :D

So... the fact that I haven't read Descartes somehow invalidates the fact that there is no word I know of for "self" in French, and that the sentence "power higher than yourself" would be entirely different in that language ? How do you figure that ? And how is it that me backing away from my original claim ?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom