In both cases you can use dictionary definitions to reach an agreement as to what words mean.
Dictionary definitions provide meanings that have
already been agreed upon. The dictionary is saying:
"Here is one of the things a person may mean when they use this word; and here's another; and here is yet another, though it is seldom seen in common usage these days..." etc.
The only thing WE need to agree on is the proper context. I don't see there being any question that the definitions of "self" that interest us most are those used in psychology and philosophy, and to insist that the one we should be using is the naive "every
body is a
self" just strikes me as beyond stupid. We're not loading an elevator here. (And by the way, Belz, pointing out ignorance, and even stupidity, is not only
allowed around here, and not merely
encouraged; it's the whole reason this forum exists -- so report away; the mods probably don't have anything better to do than listen to you whine about how somebody hurt your feelings by pointing out how mind-bogglingly stupid one of
your arguments was).
What's amazing is the knee-jerk reaction that led you to think that this is what I thought.
I am somewhat prone to knee-jerk reaction on this particular issue, I'll admit. I see dictionary-thumping like this all the time around here, and it bothers me. It
wouldn't if I were chatting with some toothless hayseed down at the local bowling alley, but to see it from seasoned members of a skeptics forum is unsettling. Evidently, the quality of some of the discussions I've seen around here over the years has allowed me to develop an unrealistically high level of expectation.
I noted that the first two definitions were clearer; but the third one does NOT contradict what I claimed.
Actually, I found the second one to be the one that best expresses the meaning you want to use here:
a simple description of the boundaries of "you" or "me". If I recall correctly, the way you phrased it earlier in the thread was: "
YOU is the sum of things that are your body". I found that comically naive then, and I find it comically naive now. Are you aware that
ninety percent of the cells in and on a human body are not actually human cells, but cells belonging to bacteria and other mircroflora? Does that make ME part human and part microbe?