Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
First off, please explain how this situation differs from the way the meaning of the word "self" is obtained.

If you hadn't snipped the rest of my post you might know. The VERY NEXT sentence answers your question.

"Self" means "instance of human". You seem to be trying to attach a philosophical meaning to "self" other than a simple description of the boundaries of "you" or "me". No wonder you think it's a weird concept.
 
"Self" means "instance of human". You seem to be trying to attach a philosophical meaning to "self" other than a simple description of the boundaries of "you" or "me".
The thing is, it's not ME doing that. Your definition (an "instance of human", brain, fingers, warts and all) is cherry-picked for your purposes. What counts is the commonly accepted meaning of that term in the relevant context.

By your definition, a collection of fingers and warts and whatnot with a brain sitting on top is a "self". Every body IS a self. That may be true in the most trivial sense, but in psychology, or philosophy, that doesn't quite cut it. The intuitive default is "Every body has a self" -- which is not the same thing at all. Some philosophers argue that this is a phantasm. My personal favorite is Daniel Dennett's "useful fiction"; or "center of narrative gravity".

If you choose to be so bold as to present definitive statements regarding the nature of this phenomenon, you're either doing that in ignorance of the fact that a lot of others before you have tried to do that and failed, or you're acknowledging that. Either way, you incur an obligation to show why your effort should be more highly regarded than theirs; it's just that in the former case, it's an obligation you are not aware of.
 
The thing is, it's not ME doing that. Your definition (an "instance of human", brain, fingers, warts and all) is cherry-picked for your purposes.

How the hell do you even figure that ? If I say "do it yourself", what does it mean to you ? "Self" is just another way to refer to the person in question. Sheesh.

What counts is the commonly accepted meaning of that term in the relevant context.

Let's see what that is:

1.the identity, character, or essential qualities of any person or thing
2.one's own person as distinct from all others
3.one's own welfare, interest, or advantage; selfishness: obsessed with self

Sounds like it's close enough to what I said, at least for 1 and 2.

By your definition, a collection of fingers and warts and whatnot with a brain sitting on top is a "self".

Well, yeah. What other attribute would you ascribe to it ?

The intuitive default is "Every body has a self" -- which is not the same thing at all.

"Intuitive" ? The WORD was invented to refer to a person as a whole, and the dictionary definitions support that. You'll have to come up with more than your personal rant in order to counter that fact.
 
Let's see what that is:

1.the identity, character, or essential qualities of any person or thing
2.one's own person as distinct from all others
3.one's own welfare, interest, or advantage; selfishness: obsessed with self

Sounds like it's close enough to what I said, at least for 1 and 2.
As frequently as discussions around here turn to dictionary definitions as a means of resolving some issue, it's surprising to see this kind of ignorance not only displayed openly but brandished as if it were some badge of honor. I still never can quite shake the feeling that you're actually a lot smarter than your posts would suggest if taken at face value rather than just as a bit of lighthearted trolling. If it is the latter, then you've succeeded in making yourself annoying by introducing unnecessary noise into the channel, but I guess a lack of hard evidence for that obligates me to play along.

Look: dictionaries do not dictate usage; they follow it. The words most often featured as the points of contention around here are those for which dictionaries provide multiple meanings -- just as is the case with the one we're examining here. It's amazing to me to see self-described skeptics triumphantly post dictionary definitions they think constitute irrefutable evidence to support their claim that a word can only mean one thing when what those definitions actually do -- what those lists of definitions do -- is exactly the opposite: they show how the word in question may be invoked in different ways and in different contexts to mean different things -- just as is the case here, which you yourself noted.

What other attribute would you ascribe to it ?
This isn't about ME any more than it's about YOU. Do you understand what I mean by that?

"Intuitive" ? The WORD was invented to refer to a person as a whole, and the dictionary definitions support that.
*Sigh* Okay, Belz, let's see you come up with even ONE dictionary definition for the word "intuitive" which supports that.
 
All those "selfs" are not selfs. They are aspects of one complete "self." If they weren't, how could God punish Sorry Alfie for what Evil Alfie did? How could the courts jail Counsellor Alfie for what Bank Robber Alfie did?

They don't. They punish Alfie because he didn't keep the various aspects of his self under the control society, and heavens, deem appropriate.

While we are drifting away from the topic a little, I honestly see your point. I think however you are dismissing this duality of self with some scemantics. We do have that struggle of good and bad. It os not uncommon for one to call on the good part of self in a certain situation. Perhaps it is a misnomer to say "which self" but it certainly isn't uncommon.

Nor in law is it not recognised (eg. tremporary insanity). To borrow from your example, people are excused (per se) for their crimes every day because they (in common usage) "were not themselves".

So if they "were not themselves", perhaps you can explain to me who they were?
 
Last edited:
No, they don't. All that the steps tell me is what one is supposed to do.

Wrong again. No wonder you are confused.
I am surprised you are unaware that the steps are suggested;). Perhaps you could provide a dictionary definition for suggested? - better yet, I will do it for you:

1. To offer for consideration or action; propose: suggest things for children to do; suggested that we take a walk.
2. To bring or call to mind by logic or association; evoke: a cloud that suggests a mushroom; a ringlike symbol suggesting unity.
3. To make evident indirectly; intimate or imply: a silence that suggested disapproval.
4. To serve as or provide a motive for; prompt or demand: Such a crime suggests apt punishment.


Nothing about "supposed to", obligatory, "absolutely necessary", demanded etc in there.

If you read this page it also might clarify.

http://www.aa.org.au/members/twelve-steps.php

The suggestions for recovery are the Twelve Steps;

Or better yet, the opening comments prior to the steps which say:

Here are the steps we took, which are suggested as a program of recovery:
 
Last edited:
4. To serve as or provide a motive for; prompt or demand: Such a crime suggests apt punishment.[/I]

Nothing about "supposed to", obligatory, "absolutely necessary", demanded etc in there.

Oooops! I guess you didn't read that part.
 
Oooops! I guess you didn't read that part.

No I saw it - just not the way you did: the steps are not a punishment.

But the practice occuring in AA suggests that the word "suggest", suggests the offer for "consideration" as opposed to "demand", I would suggest. :)

In the meantime, which "self" is one when they are not themselves?
 
No I saw it - just not the way you did: the steps are not a punishment.

But the practice occuring in AA suggests that the word "suggest", suggests the offer for "consideration" as opposed to "demand", I would suggest. :)

The religion practiced in AA suggests that "suggestions" are just a euphamism for "Do it or die!" :D

In the meantime, which "self" is one when they are not themselves?

Do you mean to tell me that you think the courts mean a person literally became someone else when they committed a crime and then became themself again after or do you think the courts think they just acted out of character and they shouldn't have their life ruined for one error in a lifetime of doing things right? Because, really, I don't know a single judge who would try someone for the crimes of another . . . except the mythical judge. :D
 
The religion practiced in AA suggests that "suggestions" are just a euphamism for "Do it or die!"

Evidence and explanation please. On what do you base this ("do or die")?
Because in practice, it is/can be quite different.

Do you mean to tell me that you think the courts mean a person literally became someone else when they committed a crime and then became themself again after or do you think the courts think they just acted out of character and they shouldn't have their life ruined for one error in a lifetime of doing things right? Because, really, I don't know a single judge who would try someone for the crimes of another . . . except the mythical judge. :D

You tell me. If they are out of character, have they more than one character? If so, how does that work if there is only one self?
All I am saying is that there is more than one self when we talk in day-to-day terms - as per the type of definition/example I have provided.

I suspect you see it but just don't want to say so. ;)
 
Last edited:
As frequently as discussions around here turn to dictionary definitions as a means of resolving some issue, it's surprising to see this kind of ignorance not only displayed openly but brandished as if it were some badge of honor. I still never can quite shake the feeling that you're actually a lot smarter than your posts would suggest if taken at face value rather than just as a bit of lighthearted trolling.

Since you apparently CANNOT make posts without insulting your correspondants: reported.

Look: dictionaries do not dictate usage; they follow it.

And ? What does that change ? In both cases you can use dictionary definitions to reach an agreement as to what words mean. Apparently you are unwilling to do this. Why ?

It's amazing to me to see self-described skeptics triumphantly post dictionary definitions they think constitute irrefutable evidence to support their claim that a word can only mean one thing

What's amazing is the knee-jerk reaction that led you to think that this is what I thought. You seem far too busy "winning" this thread that you're no longer actually arguing: you're twisting words, inventing strawmen, insulting others, and answering what you think the other is thinking rather than what he is actually saying.

when what those definitions actually do -- what those lists of definitions do -- is exactly the opposite: they show how the word in question may be invoked in different ways and in different contexts to mean different things -- just as is the case here, which you yourself noted.

I noted that the first two definitions were clearer; but the third one does NOT contradict what I claimed. "Self" simply doesn't mean what YOU want it to mean.

This isn't about ME any more than it's about YOU. Do you understand what I mean by that?

No.

*Sigh* Okay, Belz, let's see you come up with even ONE dictionary definition for the word "intuitive" which supports that.

AGAIN with definitions ? What is it with you, anyway ?
 
The self changes, obviously. Just like changing the channel doesn't mean you just got a whole new television set.

So when the self changes, we have the old self and the new self? :confused:;)

But I ask again, how can a person be "not themselves", who are they when they aren't?

Again, this is simply an example of how language is used on a day-to-day basis.

You (and others) want to nail down usage to mean just one thing; and that is your interpretation only. We have already seen numerous discussions around the word "suggested", "self", "religious" and "spiritual".
There is clearly numerous uses for any words however 'your side' (for want of another term) seems to want to see things only in black and white.

This can be a serious problem for some people, for others it is simply a scotoma, or lastly they might just be being deliberately obtuse.

I am assuming that you and others are in the latter category; clearly you are not idiots and clearly you can read. Why is it you don't see the fuller picture? The biiger usage of these terms. I assume it is because it does not support your beliefs around this topic. Skepticism is one thing, but critical thinking suggests (there it is again:)) a review of all the facts and possibilities.
 
Last edited:
In both cases you can use dictionary definitions to reach an agreement as to what words mean.
Dictionary definitions provide meanings that have already been agreed upon. The dictionary is saying: "Here is one of the things a person may mean when they use this word; and here's another; and here is yet another, though it is seldom seen in common usage these days..." etc.

The only thing WE need to agree on is the proper context. I don't see there being any question that the definitions of "self" that interest us most are those used in psychology and philosophy, and to insist that the one we should be using is the naive "every body is a self" just strikes me as beyond stupid. We're not loading an elevator here. (And by the way, Belz, pointing out ignorance, and even stupidity, is not only allowed around here, and not merely encouraged; it's the whole reason this forum exists -- so report away; the mods probably don't have anything better to do than listen to you whine about how somebody hurt your feelings by pointing out how mind-bogglingly stupid one of your arguments was).

What's amazing is the knee-jerk reaction that led you to think that this is what I thought.
I am somewhat prone to knee-jerk reaction on this particular issue, I'll admit. I see dictionary-thumping like this all the time around here, and it bothers me. It wouldn't if I were chatting with some toothless hayseed down at the local bowling alley, but to see it from seasoned members of a skeptics forum is unsettling. Evidently, the quality of some of the discussions I've seen around here over the years has allowed me to develop an unrealistically high level of expectation.

I noted that the first two definitions were clearer; but the third one does NOT contradict what I claimed.
Actually, I found the second one to be the one that best expresses the meaning you want to use here: a simple description of the boundaries of "you" or "me". If I recall correctly, the way you phrased it earlier in the thread was: "YOU is the sum of things that are your body". I found that comically naive then, and I find it comically naive now. Are you aware that ninety percent of the cells in and on a human body are not actually human cells, but cells belonging to bacteria and other mircroflora? Does that make ME part human and part microbe?
 
Evidence and explanation please. On what do you base this ("do or die")?

On the AA claims that:

1) the only two options for alcoholics are recovery or death.

2) that AA is the only cure for alcoholism.

Because in practice, it is/can be quite different.

Oh, I know that, that's why I think AA and it's claims are dishonest and immoral.

You tell me. If they are out of character, have they more than one character?

No, that isn't what that means but I suspect you know that.

Now, you tell me, if they are out of character, are they really two people, with two brains, hearts, nose, four eyes, ears, legs and arms, etc. as you are claiming?

If so, how does that work if there is only one self?

They are the same person behaving in a slightly different manner. Perhaps they didn't want to be the "nice guy" for a change.

All I am saying is that there is more than one self when we talk in day-to-day terms - as per the type of definition/example I have provided.

In day to day terms we talk about the duality of good and evil being embodied in one person on occasion but you have expanded this to the point where every aspect of a personality is itself a completely new personality. That's psychobabble as someone said earlier.

I suspect you see it but just don't want to say so. ;)

I understand what you are saying but I think it is wrong. For one thing, it is useless in any practical application. You can't blame John for killing his wife becaue that's jealous Husband John who did it. You can't blame Nancy for her racist comments because that was ******* Nancy who did that.

I think the exaggeration you make about this concept is only used to get people to understand that there are different aspects to everyone's personality that they can allow to come to the front or not. No one, except you, seems to think there are different people inside us.

Or, are you claiming that QM suggests we are really a compilation of midgets? Because that would be so cool! :D
 
I'm aware that you think so.

They are suggested only in the sense that you are free to follow them or not, with the clear indication that if you don't, you can't sober up.

I am surprised you are unaware of that.

Exactly. I couldn't have phrased it any more succinctly than that myself.

GB
 
Gandalfs Beard said:
I'm aware that you think so.

They are suggested only in the sense that you are free to follow them or not, with the clear indication that if you don't, you can't sober up.

I am surprised you are unaware of that.

Exactly. I couldn't have phrased it any more succinctly than that myself.

GB
Using the theory Two Wrongs Make A Right?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom