Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Perhaps you did not recognize it as such, but your statement: "There is only one "self" IS a philosophical claim. I asked to see the evidence, and qayak tossed out a Wiki link, one which contained a couple of definitions for "self" that I actually find pretty comical. I mean, come on: "A unified being which is the source of consciousness"? Sounds more like a "soul" to me. By definition, each individual can only have one of those, too, you know. Would you like to see a list of things I can define but which I cannot provide any evidence to indicate that they actually exist?

If you go making unsupported philosophical claims in philosophy forums, you can expect to get schooled.

Dynamic if you can't find your self you are very confused.

If you say to a philosopher that water is wet you'll get a 10 page dissertation discussing water, wet and the meaning of "is".

ETA: Do you have a definition or "self"?
 
Last edited:
"Self" is singular; whether it "exists" or not, or whatever exactly it is, a person can have only one.
Funny how much different it looks if you change just one word:

"Soul is singular; whether it "exists" or not, or whatever exactly it is, a person can have only one."

I think a lot of people around here would regard that as a vacuous truth; analogous to a child saying, "I ate all the peas on my plate" when there were no peas on his plate to begin with.

I think it's great how you're "schooling" me in philosophy while Alfie is the one who first brought up the philosophical concept of the "self", though.
I don't see what difference that makes. Belz and I had a rather lengthy exhange on the subject of "self" much earlier in the thread, inspired by something AlBell had said. It's a free-or-all in here.
 
Dynamic if you can't find your self you are very confused.
Or perhaps if I am very confused it is because I can't find my self. And if I went looking for my self and reported being unable to find it, or if I reported having found multiple selves, on what basis could you refute either claim? What evidence would you bring to bear?

If you say to a philosopher that water is wet you'll get a 10 page dissertation discussing water, wet and the meaning of "is".
Especially if you presented the statement as a philosophical claim centered on the concept of "wetness".

ETA: Do you have a definition or "self"?
One that avoids hidden and unproveable assumptions? That has a firmer basis than an intuitive defaulting to some form of dualism, like the absurd: "A unified being which is the source of consciousness" (which, on close examination, is simply a rephrasing of Descartes' exercise in affirming the consequent: "cogito ergo sum")?

Not really.
 
I know Alfie's answer but AlBell's wasn't very clear. Your interpretation of his opinion doesn't make much sense, since non-alcoholics wouldn't need the 12 steps anyway. Hopefully that's not what he thinks.

That is exactly what AlBell said. They are optional for non-alcoholics but we should try them anyway as apparently the 12 Steps are a cure all. I need only direct you back to his posts to know that isn't true though! :D
 
And yours actually is exactly the answer I need to continue my annihilation of GB's argument.

Yeah, I don't think that's going to happen. The answer has been out there for awhile and you haven't done much to shake GB's argument.
 
Funny how much different it looks if you change just one word:

"Soul is singular; whether it "exists" or not, or whatever exactly it is, a person can have only one."

I think a lot of people around here would regard that as a vacuous truth; analogous to a child saying, "I ate all the peas on my plate" when there were no peas on his plate to begin with.

It is true nonetheless; so feel free to stop wasting my time with it.
 
Would Checkmite care to respond to Stevenson's example (Jekyll & Hyde)?

Well, I'm not Checkmite but if you think Stevenson was claiming that Jekyl and Hyde were two different people, you missed the entire point.

Jekyl and Hyde are the dualism of good and evil that exist inside all of use. They are not two different selfs any more than a coin with a head and tail is actually two different coins.
 
Crisply definable, empirically testable.

Then it should be easy for you to prove.

What is the evidence that a human being possesses even one of these? How big is it? What is it made of?

Aw, not this again. We've been through this. "Self" is a synonym for "instance of human", brain, fingers, warts and all. You don't have two of those, and neither do I, though I could use the extra hands.
 
"Soul is singular; whether it "exists" or not, or whatever exactly it is, a person can have only one."

:rolleyes: This thread is getting ridiculous. First off, yes. A person can have only one soul, but not by definition: by tradition. The fact that souls don't exist has no bearing on that, but I suppose some freak of nature could have two, if those existed.

Selves, however, are trickier. By definition, you can only have one, because it's defined as the entirety of a person. You're really getting desperate.
 
Yeah, I don't think that's going to happen.
Probably not, since he now openly states that he will not answer my questions for fear of being "led into a trap". Well, he's right about that. His logic cannot hold up to close scrutiny, and he knows it -- and rather than allow himself to be put into a position where his only recourse would be to admit to the flaws, he opts to simply ignore the questions. If you'd like to volunteer to try to argue his case for him, I'll repost what I find to be the observations most devastating to GB's attempt to equate AA's Steps with Christianity:

There is an obvious implication of viewing "character defects" as an integral aspect of alcoholism (which the steps clearly do): not every person is alcoholic; therefore not every person (apparently) suffers from these flaws. Is this consistent with what Christianity teaches about "sin"?

I see two logical alternatives here. One is that the process of identifying and admitting one's wrongdoings is itself inherently religious. The other is that it is not inherently religious, but becomes religious if performed in accordance with some formalized system of religious beliefs. Either way, it cannot stand as evidence that AA is inherently religious, because in the latter case, the religiousity is the very thing you'd be trying to prove; the argument would be completely circular.

The answer has been out there for awhile and you haven't done much to shake GB's argument.
GB himself agreed that "there can be something powerful and very healing in letting another human being see into those places we usually keep hidden, and talking about those things we usually don't like to talk about" -- in fact, he "couldn't agree more". But you're right about one thing: even that didn't stop him from turning right around and continuing to repeat the "Confessing of Sins" meme over and over.

Gotta give this GB guy one thing: he's unshakable.
 
You don't need to answer 6 times. AlBell needs to answer once.

The steps themselves actually answer it for you, but you still want someone elses opinion? :rolleyes:

What is CBT?

Cognitive behavioural therapy. Is that psychobabble too (or whatever you called it)? :confused:

A little research on this might do you good before you decide to slag off the whole "program". Why am I reminded of Herbert Spencer and "contempt prior to investigation"?

What evidence do I have of what? That I suspect AA's results are no better than chance? Well I can't really prove that I suspect anything; guess you'll have to take my word for it.

Then you wont mind if we pay no attention to your word will you? ;)

I already did. There is only one conscious entity in each person. That someone acts differently under the influence of a chemical is not proof that there's two separate conscious entities inside a single person who magically swap places when a special potion is consumed; it's proof that alcohol alters brain function.

Would you say there is good an bad in each of us? Would you say that as individuals we all have the capacity for evil? Do we all have the same values and apply them evenly?
As human beings do we not have two selves per se? Do we not all struggle with deeper questions of good and bad, right and wrong? What about when one is overly emotional (anger, whatever) is it that persons true self that acts out inappropriately, or is the true self that for the rest of their life has managed to control this emotion without reckless behavious?

Very often, raw emotion and reason do not mix - eg temporary insanity. Which self (or part thereof) was the insane one?

Once again, that is the kind of thing I'm talking about when I say "deflection". Alfie first evoked the "self" as something besides a pronoun, so obviously he's satisfied it exists. But by definition, each individual can only have one "self"; therefore, the question as to which "self" a person might be at any given time is nonsensical. Now you are attempting to hijack the discussion into some kind of philosophy class, evidently to try to find a way to make me "wrong" somehow.

Not wrong, just trying to open the eyes to new possibilities.
And why, "by definition" is it as singular as you say?

No it isn't; it's a semantical argument. "Self" is singular; whether it "exists" or not, or whatever exactly it is, a person can have only one.

And you have a point... - to a point, however we asked for evidence; why do you see this as narrowly as that when (to my mind anyway) it is far deeper?

I think it's great how you're "schooling" me in philosophy while Alfie is the one who first brought up the philosophical concept of the "self", though.

That might be fair enough, but you made a statement and were asked to support it.

Well, I'm not Checkmite but if you think Stevenson was claiming that Jekyl and Hyde were two different people, you missed the entire point.

Um, no. If you read the book you will find that he drank the poison and Jekyll became Hyde. Same body, different person, different self. Were they not in fact different people? Was not Jekyll appalled by Hyde? - wasn't Hyde virtually oblivious to his (moral and behavioural) wrongs. How is this the same person? Are these not a different self in the same body?

Jekyl and Hyde are the dualism of good and evil that exist inside all of use. They are not two different selfs any more than a coin with a head and tail is actually two different coins.

Yep. In other words, the one self with two aspects. Precisely the point I am making when I say "which self?" I suspect we are not that far apart on this one.

Like your coin example, the two sides are not the same, they look different and have different purposes depending on their use. Which side denotes value, which ownership? Which side sovereignty, which side purpose? Which side wins, which side loses? There is more than one dimension to the two sides of the coin and more than one aspect even to a particular side of it.

Can I not have a work self and home self? A parent self and a partner self? A son self and an adult self? etc....

With all this, I am reminded of a story:

Two wolves
An old Amercian Indian was telling his grandson about a battle that goes on inside people. He said,

"My son, the battle between two wolves is inside us all.

One is evil: It is anger, envy, jealousy, regret, greed, arrogance, self-pity, guilt, resentment, inferiority, lies, false pride, superiority and ego".

"The other is good: It is joy, peace, love, hope, serenity, humility, kindness, benevolence, empathy, generosity, truth, compassion and faith".

The grandson thought for a moment and then asked his grandfather: "Which wolf wins?"

The old man responded "The one you feed".
 
Last edited:
Um, no. If you read the book you will find that he drank the poison and Jekyll became Hyde. Same body, different person, different self. Were they not in fact different people? Was not Jekyll appalled by Hyde? - these are a different person in the same body?

Um, no. Same person. Here is the standard analysis from Wiki:

This story represents a concept in Western culture, that of the inner conflict of humanity's sense of good and evil.[6] In particular the novella has been interpreted as an examination of the duality of human nature (that good and evil exists in all), and that the failure to accept this tension (to accept the evil or shadow side) results in the evil being projected onto others.

Figured that one out when I was in grade school.

Yep.
In other words, the one self with two aspects. Precisely the point I am making when I say "which self?"

No, you had it right in the bolded part. There is only one self with many aspects.

Like your coin example, the two sides are not the same, they look different and have different purposes depending on their use.

You are talking about two different things here. The coin and the aspects of the coin, the same error you make with the self. That a self has many aspects doesn't mean there are many selfs. You seem to think that if I see you from the front, you are a different person than if I viewed you from the side.

Which side denotes value, which ownership?

It isn't a coin without both sides and it isn't your self without all aspects.

Which side sovereignty, which side purpose? Which side wins, which side loses? There is more than one dimension to the coin.

Yeah, there are four dimensions to the one single coin.

I am reminded of this story:
Two wolves

An old Amercian Indian was telling his grandson about a battle that goes on inside people. He said,

"My son, the battle between two wolves is inside us all.

One is evil: It is anger, envy, jealousy, regret, greed, arrogance, self-pity, guilt, resentment, inferiority, lies, false pride, superiority and ego".

"The other is good: It is joy, peace, love, hope, serenity, humility, kindness, benevolence, empathy, generosity, truth, compassion and faith".

The grandson thought for a moment and then asked his grandfather: "Which wolf wins?"

The old man responded "The one you feed".

Old story but it illustrates the point. There is only one self, with many aspects, inside each of us.
 
As I said, we are not far away from one another here; I actually think it is how it is phrased.
The one self can have many aspects, which self do I apply? The good self or the bad?


And just on your "grade school" observation, it was after grade school that I realised that things were not always as they mind appear to the immature mind. It was (like many things) a whole different experience as an adult. (As usual) you are looking at things with a rather narrow perspective:

Your Wiki
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strange_Case_of_Dr_Jekyll_and_Mr_Hyde

The duality in the novella has led to a variety of different interpretations.

and

Various direct influences have been suggested for Stevenson's interest in the mental condition that separates the sinful from moral self.


Oh dear! That sounds like two selfs?
The sinful self and the moral self.
Imagine!?!
Two selfs!
Two of them!?!
In the one person!!
;):rolleyes:
 
Last edited:
Probably not, since he now openly states that he will not answer my questions for fear of being "led into a trap". Well, he's right about that.

Again, thanks for confirming that I was right not to answer your Loaded Questions.

His logic cannot hold up to close scrutiny, and he knows it -- and rather than allow himself to be put into a position where his only recourse would be to admit to the flaws, he opts to simply ignore the questions.

Actually, I did NOT ignore your questions. I read them and I recognized they were loaded and refused to answer them on your terms. Now I am about to demonstrate that you have instead trapped yourself. You have been caught out using disingenuous (dishonest) debating tactics.

If you'd like to volunteer to try to argue his case for him, I'll repost what I find to be the observations most devastating to GB's attempt to equate AA's Steps with Christianity:

This should be good. ;)

There is an obvious implication of viewing "character defects" as an integral aspect of alcoholism (which the steps clearly do): not every person is alcoholic; therefore not every person (apparently) suffers from these flaws. Is this consistent with what Christianity teaches about "sin"?

The logical problems with your statement are that your conclusion doesn't follow from the premise (non-sequitur) and you are employing a form of denying the antecedent--two logical fallacies for the price of one: A is part of B, not everyone is B; therefore not everyone is A.

In other words, just because not everyone is an alcoholic, it doesn't follow that not everyone suffers from character defects. One can have character flaws wholly unrelated to alcoholism (as the saying goes, no-one's perfect). So there is no conflict with the equation of Christian Sin with AA's "Character Flaws."

And as the Empirical Evidence (the History of AA and its Founders) has shown, AA's Religious Language and Doctrines are based on Protestant Christianity. Your logic is flawed and the evidence is stacked against you.

I see two logical alternatives here. One is that the process of identifying and admitting one's wrongdoings is itself inherently religious. The other is that it is not inherently religious, but becomes religious if performed in accordance with some formalized system of religious beliefs.

Neither one of your "Alternative Answers" logically follows from your propositional paragraph and your question based on your proposition. You are substituting AA's 4th and 5th Steps (inventory and confession) for the 6th and 7th Steps (asking God to remove "defects of character/shortcomings") which your proposition is based on.

Either way, it cannot stand as evidence that AA is inherently religious, because in the latter case, the religiousity is the very thing you'd be trying to prove; the argument would be completely circular.

As my argument is based on the Historical Record (the linear development of AA from Protestant Christianity) and the Textual Evidence (AA's God and His related doctrines as passed down from Protestant Christianity with minor adjustments to broaden the appeal to other Monotheists), your assertion is False.

GB himself agreed that "there can be something powerful and very healing in letting another human being see into those places we usually keep hidden, and talking about those things we usually don't like to talk about" -- in fact, he "couldn't agree more". But you're right about one thing: even that didn't stop him from turning right around and continuing to repeat the "Confessing of Sins" meme over and over.

Sharing one's own suffering and pain with a sympathetic ear is not equivalent to confessing wrongs with the expectation of Forgiveness or Punishment from a Deity.

And thank you for confirming that you were lying when you implied that I had not answered these questions previously--though not in terms that you liked. And so you employed this lie, hoping to snare me with your "questions" but caught yourself.

Gotta give this GB guy one thing: he's unshakable.

Indeed. I've got you by the Short and Curlies as my Grandma used to say, and I ain't lettin' go.

In conclusion, your arguments are unbelievably full of crap; and your "logic" is fraudulent.

And because it has been a few pages since this has been quoted again in full, here is a piece of the Damning Evidence against you:


Service Material from the General Service Office
THE TWELVE STEPS OF ALCOHOLICS ANONYMOUS

1. We admitted we were powerless over alcohol—that our lives had become
unmanageable.

2. Came to believe that a Power greater than ourselves could restore us to
sanity.

3. Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we
understood Him.

4. Made a searching and fearless moral inventory of ourselves.

5. Admitted to God, to ourselves, and to another human being the exact nature of our wrongs.

6. Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character.

7. Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings.

8. Made a list of all persons we had harmed, and became willing to make
amends to them all.

9. Made direct amends to such people wherever possible, except when to do
so would injure them or others.

10. Continued to take personal inventory and when we were wrong promptly
admitted it.

11. Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with God, as we understood Him, praying only for knowledge of His will for us
and the power to carry that out.

12. Having had a spiritual awakening as the result of these Steps, we tried to
carry this message to alcoholics, and to practice these principles in all our
affairs.

You cannot deny that a Male Supernatural Deity is invoked in the Text.

You cannot deny that the AA member is to subsume his or her will to the Male Supernatural Deity's Will in the Text.

You cannot deny that the AA member is to admit his or her wrongs to the Male Supernatural Deity in the Text.

You cannot deny that the AA member is to ask for, and expect, his or her "defects of character/shortcomings" to be removed by the Male Supernatural Deity in the Text.

You cannot deny that the AA member is to pray and "consciously contact" and seek guidance from the Male Supernatural Deity in the Text.

You cannot deny that the AA member is to Proselytize after a "Spiritual Awakening" granted by the Male Supernatural Deity in the Text.




If you had any intellectual integrity at all, you would admit you were wrong, or at the very least, slink away and hide in shame. :boxedin:

GB
 
Last edited:
As I said, we are not far away from one another here; I actually think it is how it is phrased.
The one self can have many aspects, which self do I apply? The good self or the bad?

We are saying the same thing with one very important difference. You exchange the word "self" for "aspect." You say, "The one self can have many aspects, which self do I apply?" when what you really mean is "The one self can have many aspects, which aspect do I apply?"

The way you say it, it is logically impossible. "Aspect" doesn't become "self" just by using it in a sentence.

Oh dear! That sounds like two selfs?
The sinful self and the moral self.
Imagine!?!
Two selfs!
Two of them!?!
In the one person!!
;):rolleyes:

No, it doesn't. Unless you can demonstrate how aspects become selfs at the wave of your hand. I know that when I do something nasty, it isn't someone else taking me over, it is me allowing one aspect of my self to come to the fore. It appears that you are saying you have many selfs:

Jealous Alfie
Angry Alfie
Happy Alfie
Sad Alfie
Sympathetic Alfie
Hot Alfie
Cold Alfie
Funny Alfie
Good Alfie
Evil Alfie
Tired Alfie
Drinking Alfie
Not Drinking Alfie
Etc.
Etc.

Sounds pretty crowded in your head! :D

All those "selfs" are not selfs. They are aspects of one complete "self." If they weren't, how could God punish Sorry Alfie for what Evil Alfie did? How could the courts jail Counsellor Alfie for what Bank Robber Alfie did?

They don't. They punish Alfie because he didn't keep the various aspects of his self under the control society, and heavens, deem appropriate.
 
Again, thanks for confirming that I was right not to answer your Loaded Questions.
Thanks for confirming that you have no sincere interest in a public examination of the biased assumptions used in reaching your conclusions. Can't say that I blame you.

Actually, I did NOT ignore your questions. I read them and I recognized they were loaded and refused to answer them on your terms.

Either that, or:
Sorry I didn't respond to your question the first time. I didn't find it deserving of a response.
Maybe you're not always sure just what the heck it is that makes you do the things you do?

Dymanic said:
There is an obvious implication of viewing "character defects" as an integral aspect of alcoholism (which the steps clearly do): not every person is alcoholic; therefore not every person (apparently) suffers from these flaws. Is this consistent with what Christianity teaches about "sin"?
The logical problems with your statement are that your conclusion doesn't follow from the premise (non-sequitur) and you are employing a form of denying the antecedent--two logical fallacies for the price of one: A is part of B, not everyone is B; therefore not everyone is A. In other words, just because not everyone is an alcoholic, it doesn't follow that not everyone suffers from character defects.
I don't disagree -- but then, it wasn't my premise. The question here is not whether AA's premises are all logically sound; it's whether they are inherently religious.

One can have character flaws wholly unrelated to alcoholism (as the saying goes, no-one's perfect).
Indeed. The question seems to be whether AA's "character flaws" are (purported to be) of a unique nature, or simply that they play out differently in the life of an alcoholic. If it is the former, then the argument: "Christian Sin = AA's Character Flaws" collapses immediately, as the Christian doctrine of sin demands that it be acknowledged in alcoholic and non-alcoholic alike. If it is the latter, then the argument depends on answering "No" to any form of the question: Do you acknowledge any non-religious basis for a personal moral inventory?

You are substituting AA's 4th and 5th Steps (inventory and confession) for the 6th and 7th Steps (asking God to remove "defects of character/shortcomings") which your proposition is based on.
My wording was quite specific: the process of identifying and admitting one's wrongdoings. Steps four and five -- what you have referred to as "Confession of Sins". The 6th and 7th Steps are those you have equated with "seeking absolution".

Sharing one's own suffering and pain with a sympathetic ear is not equivalent to confessing wrongs
"Sharing pain and suffering" were your words -- words which reflect a lack of understanding of AA's Step Five, which is about sharing "the exact nature of our wrongs". Doesn't say a word about pain and suffering. It's about coming out of hiding. That can be painful (as well as scary), but the assumption is that not to do so results in even more pain. You've posted those steps more times than I'd care to count, but it doesn't look like you've ever really read them even once. You certainly are nowhere near understanding them.

...with the expectation of Forgiveness or Punishment from a Deity.
And here you are doing the very thing you just accused me of doing: conflating the 4th/5th with the 6th/7th. Now that you've decided to rejoin the actual discussion, then once we're done with this part I'll be more than happy to move on to a more detailed examination of the process you're referring to as "Seeking Absolution".

And thank you for confirming that you were lying when you implied that I had not answered these questions previously--though not in terms that you liked.
The statement of yours I quoted is from page 16 -- long before I ever asked any of these questions, ALL of which you have left unanswered:

"Would you agree that possession of an internalized set of moral principles presupposes a capacity for experiencing guilt?"

"Is there something inherently religious about considering where you may have made mistakes and trying to understand what caused you to make them?"

"Do you agree with those Christians who regard atheists as immoral (the more sophisticated ones might say "amoral") due to a lack of any possible basis for judging right from wrong?"

"You don't think it's important to consider whether there exists outside the framework of Christianity a legitimate basis for judging right from wrong? I find that hard to believe. Do you not judge ME for having committed what you perceive to be moral transgressions right here in this very thread?"

"You evidently do have some basis for judging right from wrong. Is that basis inherently religious in nature and origin? If not, what is its nature, and where did it originate?"

"Within a belief system based on the concept of "Original Sin", what possible value can there be in a personal inventory? Why bother listing the wrongs you may have committed, or making direct amends to those you've harmed, or considering whether you're willing to have your character defects removed -- when none of that counts for squat anyway because you're still filthy with Sin you inherited?"
 
The steps themselves actually answer it for you, but you still want someone elses opinion? :rolleyes:

No, they don't. All that the steps tell me is what one is supposed to do. They don't tell me if they're optional or not. I asked AlBell his opinion, yes. Why is that so problematic for you that you insist in replying to my posts every time I repeat the question to someone else ?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom