Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why attach the "atheist/skeptic" label to it if you don't already feel that, somehow, atheists/skeptics are more regularily being dicks than theists?

Read the chapter entitled "We Agnostics" for the answer. :D

Now, let's get back on track: Are the 12 steps optional for recovery in AA's program, according to you, or not?

To be fair, AlBell and Alfie already answered this. AlBell says they are only optional for non-alcoholics and alfie feels, just like everything else in AA, the 12 Steps are completely optional.
 
Then we may have found another point of agreement: that you cannot provide your answers to these questions without undermining huge chunks of your argument.

Wrong. You're undermining your own arguments with Sophistry. In fact, by definition the use of Sophistry instead of evidence means you have no argument.

Do you still beat your wife? Yes or No? Come on, answer it. It's a simple question right?


GB
 
I'm trying to get answers to what I consider to be important questions in this debate and all I get is childish nonsense.

It would be nice if AA's opponents would be able to answer my good-faith questions directly rather than with nebulous deflections, but apparently that's too much to ask.

I'm trying to get evidence to back up the assertions of your team in this debate and all I get is childish nonsense.

It would be nice if AAs proselytizers would be able to provide evidence instead of nebulous deflections and bad-faith questions, but apparently that's too much to ask.

GB
 
I find it amusing that I answered your question on whether guilt was about sin and yet you conveniently ignored it because it wasn't the answer you needed to continue with your word salad.
I very much appreciated your answer actually, though I suppose I might have acknowledged that more directly. I did acknowledge it indirectly, however, in this response to GB:
I've asked whether you acknowledge any non-religious framework within which acts might be judged wrong. I don't recall you having answered clearly, though others have.
You were among the "others" to whom I was referring. You and I also discussed it further, post #2778 being one I would recall to your attention, so it's not like I really have ignored your response altogether.

And yours actually is exactly the answer I need to continue my annihilation of GB's argument. GB has obviously not thought this through carefully enough to understand why his arguments are flawed, but he does seem to sense that my questions are leading in a direction he doesn't want to go in, because he's squirming all over the place to avoid them. But in order to expose those flaws, I need answers from him rather than from you, because it's his argument, not yours -- as you noted here:
I don't recall my ever being a part of any discussion about sin and I didn't really understand why you were asking me those questions because I had not engaged.
You're just a tag-along, frankly, and my advice would be to do a little more of the thinking for yourself.
 
D, next closed meeting you chair, you should suggest guilt and sin as the topic. That oughta fix em.

You will all (just want to ;)) go out for a drink after that one. :D
 
To be fair, AlBell and Alfie already answered this. AlBell says they are only optional for non-alcoholics and alfie feels, just like everything else in AA, the 12 Steps are completely optional.

I know Alfie's answer but AlBell's wasn't very clear. Your interpretation of his opinion doesn't make much sense, since non-alcoholics wouldn't need the 12 steps anyway. Hopefully that's not what he thinks.
 
I don't know what the hell's wrong with you two. I'm trying to get answers to what I consider to be important questions in this debate and all I get is childish nonsense. Maybe some of the ravages of alcohol are irreversible.

Some are sadly. Luckily we have AA. :)
But honestly, you did say you didn't get answers to this questions, it has been given time and again even observed by Qayak:
To be fair, AlBell and Alfie already answered this. AlBell says they are only optional for non-alcoholics and alfie feels, just like everything else in AA, the 12 Steps are completely optional.

But you've pretty much confirmed for me that AA offers nothing more than phantasms and pseudo-psychobabble.

What are your thoughts on CBT? Is it (and other therapies) also pseudo-psychobabble?

No wonder its efficacy is so disturbingly low; I suspect those who find success in the "program" probably owe their sobriety more to chance than to the organization.

Opinions don't seem to count for much here, what evidence have you of this?

It would be nice if its proponents would be able to answer my good-faith questions directly rather than with nebulous deflections, but apparently that's too much to ask.

Fair enough, which question can I help you with?

Now, let's get back on track: Are the 12 steps optional for recovery in AA's program, according to you, or not ?

They are "SUGGESTED"!
That said, I think they are very important.
I have done the steps any number of times for myself and with sponsees - the steps are tailored around their particluar belief system: Invoking God is not required if not relevant.

There is only one "self".
Evidence?

This interests me, especially in the area of alcoholism. The practicing alcoholic and their actions are certainly different from the sober one; yet they are the same person. With alcohol in the mix are they their true selves or does the true self only appear when sober; or is there a mixture.

Would Checkmite care to respond to Stevenson's example (Jekyll & Hyde)?
 
Last edited:
Good thing you say you aren't a drunk, so that shouldn't be a problem for you.

A decent attempt at a cheap shot, but misdirected. Not only am I "not a drunk", I am quite literally teetotal.

You got answers. Too bad a) you didn't believe them, b) didn't like them, or c) both.

I was looking for position statements and all I got was wishy-washy "what is a position?" deflections and doublespeak. That's not "answers"; that's refusal to answer.

ps. I find few things in this thread demonstrating "good faith".

Probably related to your penchant for implicitly suggesting that anyone who is skeptical about AA is a drunk looking for an excuse not to stop drinking.

What are your thoughts on CBT? Is it (and other therapies) also pseudo-psychobabble?

What is CBT?

Opinions don't seem to count for much here, what evidence have you of this?

What evidence do I have of what? That I suspect AA's results are no better than chance? Well I can't really prove that I suspect anything; guess you'll have to take my word for it.

Would Checkmite care to respond to Stevenson's example (Jekyll & Hyde)?

I already did. There is only one conscious entity in each person. That someone acts differently under the influence of a chemical is not proof that there's two separate conscious entities inside a single person who magically swap places when a special potion is consumed; it's proof that alcohol alters brain function.
 
Prove to me that Earth has only one moon.
Crisply definable, empirically testable.

The self? A unified being which is the source of consciousness? The agent responsible for the thoughts and actions of an individual? (Both from qayak's Wiki link).

What is the evidence that a human being possesses even one of these? How big is it? What is it made of?
 
Crisply definable, empirically testable.

The self? A unified being which is the source of consciousness? The agent responsible for the thoughts and actions of an individual? (Both from qayak's Wiki link).

What is the evidence that a human being possesses even one of these? How big is it? What is it made of?

Once again, that is the kind of thing I'm talking about when I say "deflection". Alfie first evoked the "self" as something besides a pronoun, so obviously he's satisfied it exists. But by definition, each individual can only have one "self"; therefore, the question as to which "self" a person might be at any given time is nonsensical. Now you are attempting to hijack the discussion into some kind of philosophy class, evidently to try to find a way to make me "wrong" somehow.
 
Once again, that is the kind of thing I'm talking about when I say "deflection". Alfie first evoked the "self" as something besides a pronoun, so obviously he's satisfied it exists. But by definition, each individual can only have one "self"; therefore, the question as to which "self" a person might be at any given time is nonsensical. Now you are attempting to hijack the discussion into some kind of philosophy class, evidently to try to find a way to make me "wrong" somehow.

That's what Dymanic does best. He's got no evidence to back up his assertions, so he resorts to BS Pseudo-philosophy.

GB
 
Others seem to think arm-waving in colored and/or bold fonts is all that's needed.
 
Now you are attempting to hijack the discussion into some kind of philosophy class, evidently to try to find a way to make me "wrong" somehow.
Perhaps you did not recognize it as such, but your statement: "There is only one "self" IS a philosophical claim. I asked to see the evidence, and qayak tossed out a Wiki link, one which contained a couple of definitions for "self" that I actually find pretty comical. I mean, come on: "A unified being which is the source of consciousness"? Sounds more like a "soul" to me. By definition, each individual can only have one of those, too, you know. Would you like to see a list of things I can define but which I cannot provide any evidence to indicate that they actually exist?

If you go making unsupported philosophical claims in philosophy forums, you can expect to get schooled.
 
I very much appreciated your answer actually, though I suppose I might have acknowledged that more directly. I did acknowledge it indirectly, however, in this response to GB:You were among the "others" to whom I was referring. You and I also discussed it further, post #2778 being one I would recall to your attention, so it's not like I really have ignored your response altogether.

And yours actually is exactly the answer I need to continue my annihilation of GB's argument. GB has obviously not thought this through carefully enough to understand why his arguments are flawed, but he does seem to sense that my questions are leading in a direction he doesn't want to go in, because he's squirming all over the place to avoid them. But in order to expose those flaws, I need answers from him rather than from you, because it's his argument, not yours -- as you noted here:You're just a tag-along, frankly, and my advice would be to do a little more of the thinking for yourself.

So, you confess your sins. Finally, an admission that you resort to fallacies and sophistry, because you have no evidence to support your position.

Obviously, I DID think the questions through, and realized you were baiting a hook with bogus and irrelevant questions.

You must really think I'm stupid.

There I was, giving you the benefit of the doubt and thinking that maybe you didn't realize you were employing Fallacious arguments. Now, beyond a shadow of a doubt, it is clear that you just lie when it suits you.

You are the one that has been squirming since the beginning of this thread to evade the concrete evidence that AA is Religious. Everything you've posted is a waste of your time and and intellect. The Flawed Arguments are all your own.

It's amusing that you think you can "annihilate" your opponent's arguments when you're shooting blanks. :rolleyes:

GB
 
Perhaps you did not recognize it as such, but your statement: "There is only one "self" IS a philosophical claim.

No it isn't; it's a semantical argument. "Self" is singular; whether it "exists" or not, or whatever exactly it is, a person can have only one.

I think it's great how you're "schooling" me in philosophy while Alfie is the one who first brought up the philosophical concept of the "self", though.
 
Last edited:
In that case, I think cognitive therapy as a concept can work; but, quite obviously, not every single "system" or set of goals one dreams up is going to be effective. (Possible case-in-point?)

Take your word for that last bit, Dunstan - thanks for the warning...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom