Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Where did I say "guilt" = "sin"?
You may notice that I did frame it as a question. These are not complicated questions, GB. You either equate "guilt" with "sin" or you don't. You either agree that it is possible for a non-religious person to possess an internalized set of moral principles or you don't. You either agree that possession of an internalized set of moral principles presupposes a capacity for experiencing guilt -- or you don't.
 
You may notice that I did frame it as a question. These are not complicated questions, GB. You either equate "guilt" with "sin" or you don't. You either agree that it is possible for a non-religious person to possess an internalized set of moral principles or you don't. You either agree that possession of an internalized set of moral principles presupposes a capacity for experiencing guilt -- or you don't.

How about we all agree that your posts are drifting further and further away from the topic, until (as above) they've wandered so far into lala (ie, philosophy for philosophy's sake) land they sound like gibberish translated into English?

Do you agree they sound like gibberish translated into English, or are you just talking Philosophy for Philosophy's sake?

:rolleyes:
 
You may notice that I did frame it as a question.

Frame being the operative word.

These are not complicated questions, GB. You either equate "guilt" with "sin" or you don't.

So you admit that your question is actually more than one question. The appropriate answer to this question is:

Which answer is the "right" one?

You either agree that it is possible for a non-religious person to possess an internalized set of moral principles or you don't.

Which answer is the "right" one?

You either agree that possession of an internalized set of moral principles presupposes a capacity for experiencing guilt -- or you don't.

Which answer is the "right" one?

Do you still beat your wife? Yes or No?

GB
 
I wasn't asking YOU, Alfie. I know what YOUR opinion is. I was asking AlBell, but he is too dishonest to answer my question.

That kinda reminds me of a young child, running around to different adults looking to get the answer they want. ;):)
 
That kinda reminds me of a young child, running around to different adults looking to get the answer they want. ;):)

And that post kinda reminds me of AlBell's trolling behaviour. Hopefully it's not contagious.

I don't know what the hell's wrong with you two. I'm trying to get answers to what I consider to be important questions in this debate and all I get is childish nonsense. Maybe some of the ravages of alcohol are irreversible.
 
Last edited:
And that post kinda reminds me of AlBell's trolling behaviour. Hopefully it's not contagious.

I don't know what the hell's wrong with you two. I'm trying to get answers to what I consider to be important questions in this debate and all I get is childish nonsense. Maybe some of the ravages of alcohol are irreversible.
Thanks for the continuing demonstration of what most would classify as meeting the Plait definition of "an atheist/skeptic being a dick".

Your questions, without context in some actual situation, are meaningless.
 
Which self? The alcoholic one or the the non alcoholic one. Jekyll or Hyde?

There is only one "self".

But you've pretty much confirmed for me that AA offers nothing more than phantasms and pseudo-psychobabble. No wonder its efficacy is so disturbingly low; I suspect those who find success in the "program" probably owe their sobriety more to chance than to the organization. It would be nice if its proponents would be able to answer my good-faith questions directly rather than with nebulous deflections, but apparently that's too much to ask.
 
Last edited:
I'm trying to get answers to what I consider to be important questions in this debate and all I get is childish nonsense.

It would be nice if AA's opponents would be able to answer my good-faith questions directly rather than with nebulous deflections, but apparently that's too much to ask.
 
Thanks for the continuing demonstration of what most would classify as meeting the Plait definition of "an atheist/skeptic being a dick".

Why attach the "atheist/skeptic" label to it if you don't already feel that, somehow, atheists/skeptics are more regularily being dicks than theists ?

I'm being adverserial because you're trolling, and I have no patience for that. That has nothing to do with my religious beliefs or lack thereof.

Now, let's get back on track: Are the 12 steps optional for recovery in AA's program, according to you, or not ?
 
There is only one "self".
You can define things as you wish.

But you've pretty much confirmed for me that AA offers nothing more than phantasms and pseudo-psychobabble. No wonder its efficacy is so disturbingly low; I suspect those who find success in the "program" probably owe their sobriety more to chance than to the organization.
Good thing you say you aren't a drunk, so that shouldn't be a problem for you.

It would be nice if its proponents would be able to answer my good-faith questions directly rather than with nebulous deflections, but apparently that's too much to ask.
You got answers. Too bad a) you didn't believe them, b) didn't like them, or c) both.

ps. I find few things in this thread demonstrating "good faith".
 
I'm trying to get answers to what I consider to be important questions in this debate and all I get is childish nonsense.

It would be nice if AA's opponents would be able to answer my good-faith questions directly rather than with nebulous deflections, but apparently that's too much to ask.

No, your posts consist of you making incorrect assumptions and then trying to get us to agree. I find it amusing that I answered your question on whether guilt was about sin and yet you conveniently ignored it because it wasn't the answer you needed to continue with your word salad.

Perhaps you would like to address it now: "Guilt is a feeling usually related to doing something wrong, or failing to do the right thing."
 
You can define things as you wish.

Most people recognize this as being wrong which is why dictionaries are still big sellers and dictionary sites get so many hits. There is only one side of this discussion changing definitionas.

Good thing you say you aren't a drunk, so that shouldn't be a problem for you.

The only problem is the lies AA puts out as truth in order to recruit and indoctrinate new members. Like most cults though, pointing out facts to members isn't of much use. Don't drink the Kool-Aid.

You got answers. Too bad a) you didn't believe them, b) didn't like them, or c) both.

Perhaps we should be more clear. Answers aren't enough, if they were, anything would do. We are looking for the answers to be true and that is why we are having trouble accepting the AA Think being regurgitated.

ps. I find few things in this thread demonstrating "good faith".

I find the belief some show in AA Think to be in great faith. There is nothing else to base it on.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom