You may notice that I did frame it as a question. These are not complicated questions, GB. You either equate "guilt" with "sin" or you don't. You either agree that it is possible for a non-religious person to possess an internalized set of moral principles or you don't. You either agree that possession of an internalized set of moral principles presupposes a capacity for experiencing guilt -- or you don't.Where did I say "guilt" = "sin"?