Gone over this ad nauseum. But what the Hell...My responses in red font.
If your objective was to create an unsightly and confusing mess, I'd say you succeeded. I'll try to work with it, but keep in mind that there are reasons why the practice of using the quote feature to post edited versions of previous posts is one that is frowned upon around here.
The confusion (yours) begins at the first line:
The 12 Steps refer to wrongful acts (GB: "Sins")
I've asked whether you acknowledge any non-religious framework within which acts might be judged
wrong. I don't recall you having answered clearly, though others have.
They also refer to the causes of those acts (defects of character (GB: "SIN")
There is an obvious implication of viewing "character defects" as an integral aspect of alcoholism (which the steps clearly do):
not every person is alcoholic; therefore not every person (apparently) suffers from these flaws. Is this consistent with what Christianity teaches about "sin"?
...leaving it up to the individual to identify those (GB: "Confession").
I think you're slinging the "Confession" label a bit prematurely here; I was talking about Step Four, which is a solitary exercise. I'm okay with taking the Four and Five together, but it is a potential cause for further confusion.
I see two logical alternatives here. One is that the process of identifying and admitting one's wrongdoings is itself inherently religious. The other is that it is not inherently religious, but
becomes religious if performed in accordance with some formalized system of religious beliefs. Either way, it cannot stand as evidence that AA is inherently religious, because in the latter case, the religiousity is the very thing you'd be trying to prove; the argument would be completely circular.
It seems reasonable to presume that non-religious and non-alcoholic persons may be capable of applying a similar process. Would you insist that this automatically equates to "Confession of Sins"? You didn't seem to think so last summer:
Dymanic said:
I don't believe in "God's Grace", but I do think there can be something powerful and very healing in letting another human being see into those places we usually keep hidden, and talking about those things we usually don't like to talk about.
I couldn't agree more with this. No Woo, No Religion, No Confession, just a Sharing of Pain and Suffering.
Are you recanting that?
Wrong, the 12 Steps directly and explicitly mention the role of God in the removal of Sins (Defects of character/Shortcomings).
Your biases are causing you to see things that aren't actually there. At best, what you've got there is an assumed implication.
Indeed. One day at a Time Pal. If you fall off the Grace Wagon, beg forgiveness and start again--just like AA.
Do you need it explained to you what the slogan "One Day at a Time" means in AA, or was that a deliberate mischaracterization you just tossed in hoping that it would help to make your point?