Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
So you are also of the opinion that the 12 steps are suggestions ? Why call it a 12-step program, then ?

And now you seem to be saying that the 12 steps are crucial...

That's what I was talking about when I mentioned "self-inconsistency" in my post, specifically about the religious aspects of the program. Evidently it's very important in AA for someone to have something you can abdicate responsibility for your actions to - but yet it's so unimportant that it can be literally anything? I've heard (as I mentioned) rocks, doorknobs, and "the ocean" suggested as perfectly viable "higher powers". But this is intelligence-insulting and can't possibly be right. How can you turn anything over to "the ocean"? Quite obviously, in order for the concept to "work right", your higher power has to actually be capable of controlling something in order for you to be able to "turn over" control to it.
 
Would you agree that possession of an internalized set of moral principles presupposes a capacity for experiencing guilt, or do you also equate "guilt" with "sin"?

Guilt is associated with wrong doing or lack of right doing.
 
That's what I was talking about when I mentioned "self-inconsistency" in my post, specifically about the religious aspects of the program. Evidently it's very important in AA for someone to have something you can abdicate responsibility for your actions to - but yet it's so unimportant that it can be literally anything? I've heard (as I mentioned) rocks, doorknobs, and "the ocean" suggested as perfectly viable "higher powers". But this is intelligence-insulting and can't possibly be right. How can you turn anything over to "the ocean"? Quite obviously, in order for the concept to "work right", your higher power has to actually be capable of controlling something in order for you to be able to "turn over" control to it.
Which of course is you; AA just tries to help you find the rational you instead of the you that's been in "control", and drinking alcoholically.

Damn, I think I let the cat out of the bag. Don't tell anyone else.
 
Hmm. What does that remind me of?


Oh. I know! It's similar to posting on skeptic forums. Not every atheist posting is a dick, but most of 'em are.

Nothing intentional, of course, just a self-selected group of highly intelligent egos each being the highest power there is.

Ah, insulting fellow members. How constructive.

It also has nothing to do with what I said, which shows how little you understand what you read.
 
Ah, insulting fellow members. How constructive.
I always heard you hit a jackass with a 2x4 to get his attention.

It also has nothing to do with what I said, which shows how little you understand what you read.
Yeah, that's the problem, dumb old me trying to keep up.


So are the 12 steps optional or not ?

For non-alcoholics? Sure, although they'd probably do many of you some good if you applied them to alleviating your problem areas.
 
Which of course is you; AA just tries to help you find the rational you instead of the you that's been in "control", and drinking alcoholically.

So if an attendee were asked who/what his higher power was, the answer 'myself' should be acceptable, right? In that case, what is the power 'higher' than?
 
I always heard you hit a jackass with a 2x4 to get his attention.

To get his attention, maybe. To have a reasonable conversation with him, definitely not.

For non-alcoholics? Sure, although they'd probably do many of you some good if you applied them to alleviating your problem areas.

Seriously, are you even capable of participating in a debate honestly ?

Are the 12 steps optional or mandatory for AA members ?
 
Become a drunk, seek help in AA, and find out for yourself would seem to be the only way you'd ever accept an answer.
 
Again, how do you read any resentment in there ?

You're kidding aren't you? :jaw-dropp

So you are also of the opinion that the 12 steps are suggestions ? Why call it a 12-step program, then ?

Does the word program mean there is nothing flexible within it?
What word would you suggest?

This isn't UFO's or Bigfoot, however, extraordinary evidence is not needed. I am willing to conclude on the basis of all the anecdotes provided here that some groups would welcome atheists, or just not care about religion, and in other groups they would be Smothered by Jesus.

Yup.
That does not make AA in itself inherently or overly religious, just those groups. Jesus is not mentioned in the big book or thge steps. As I pointed out earlier Christianity requires some devotion to Christ.

Actually, I think it can, and does. Turning over your responsibilities to someone/something else when you yourself admitted that, in the end, only YOU can get rid of your alcoholism seems counter-productive.

Where does it say we have to turn over responsibility? The steps teach the alcoholic to take responsibility for what is ours, and let go of what is not.

So are the 12 steps optional or not ?

Everything is optional.

So if an attendee were asked who/what his higher power was, the answer 'myself' should be acceptable, right? In that case, what is the power 'higher' than?

Which self? The alcoholic one or the the non alcoholic one. Jekyll or Hyde?

Are the 12 steps optional or mandatory for AA members ?

They are "suggested" how many times does this need to be pointed out to you?

Has Tinyal done the steps? Has he a higher power? I use him as an example simply because he rejects (or apepars to reject) all things religious in AA yet remains in the program with over 20 years sobriety. He has scaled the dizzying heights of trusted servant and helped spread the good word to millions of suffering alcoholics. All without God! (gasp!). In actual fact, I suspect he has done the steps - and like myself probably many times - all without the God that you and he insists is in there.

That's quite an achievement. :rolleyes:
 
This is how I know you are a liar.

Actually RAF, you have no idea.

It is possible that, I may have heard someone mention Christ in a meeting - but I would not swear to it. I have also heard atheists say they have no higher power. Neither one raises my eyebrown.
I heard Jesus mentioned on the telly after a football match by a player - does that mean footy is Christain too? Hardly.

But if you want to go down this Christendom path, you will need to show where Christ is mentioned, his teachings espoused (as his), how his power influences the alcoholic, etc.

That does not mean either that people cannot choose Christ as their higher power, I am positive many do. I am equally sure that many choose, Buddha, Ganesh etc - they are not mentioned anywhere in the literature or at meetings as a rule either.

I can honestly see why the link to "religion or god" can be made, but Christendom is a different matter altogether. Regardless of where AA got its' influences, Christ is not mentioned.
 
Last edited:
Gone over this ad nauseum. But what the Hell...My responses in red font.
If your objective was to create an unsightly and confusing mess, I'd say you succeeded. I'll try to work with it, but keep in mind that there are reasons why the practice of using the quote feature to post edited versions of previous posts is one that is frowned upon around here.

The confusion (yours) begins at the first line:
The 12 Steps refer to wrongful acts (GB: "Sins")
I've asked whether you acknowledge any non-religious framework within which acts might be judged wrong. I don't recall you having answered clearly, though others have.

They also refer to the causes of those acts (defects of character (GB: "SIN")
There is an obvious implication of viewing "character defects" as an integral aspect of alcoholism (which the steps clearly do): not every person is alcoholic; therefore not every person (apparently) suffers from these flaws. Is this consistent with what Christianity teaches about "sin"?

...leaving it up to the individual to identify those (GB: "Confession").
I think you're slinging the "Confession" label a bit prematurely here; I was talking about Step Four, which is a solitary exercise. I'm okay with taking the Four and Five together, but it is a potential cause for further confusion.

I see two logical alternatives here. One is that the process of identifying and admitting one's wrongdoings is itself inherently religious. The other is that it is not inherently religious, but becomes religious if performed in accordance with some formalized system of religious beliefs. Either way, it cannot stand as evidence that AA is inherently religious, because in the latter case, the religiousity is the very thing you'd be trying to prove; the argument would be completely circular.

It seems reasonable to presume that non-religious and non-alcoholic persons may be capable of applying a similar process. Would you insist that this automatically equates to "Confession of Sins"? You didn't seem to think so last summer:
Dymanic said:
I don't believe in "God's Grace", but I do think there can be something powerful and very healing in letting another human being see into those places we usually keep hidden, and talking about those things we usually don't like to talk about.
I couldn't agree more with this. No Woo, No Religion, No Confession, just a Sharing of Pain and Suffering.
Are you recanting that?

Wrong, the 12 Steps directly and explicitly mention the role of God in the removal of Sins (Defects of character/Shortcomings).
Your biases are causing you to see things that aren't actually there. At best, what you've got there is an assumed implication.

Indeed. One day at a Time Pal. If you fall off the Grace Wagon, beg forgiveness and start again--just like AA.
Do you need it explained to you what the slogan "One Day at a Time" means in AA, or was that a deliberate mischaracterization you just tossed in hoping that it would help to make your point?
 
Last edited:
So are the 12 steps optional or not ?

For non-alcoholics? Sure, although they'd probably do many of you some good if you applied them to alleviating your problem areas.

You and Alfie sure don't agree on that one. Of course, I think Alfie's opinion isn't very reliable as most of the AA'ers I know are in agreement with you.

Well, thanks for adding another nail into the coffin of AA not being religious.
 
Nothing intentional, of course, just a self-selected group of highly intelligent egos each being the highest power there is.

Your habit of throwing AA speak insults at us has much the same effect as having a catholic call us a "blasphemer." It just makes us realize how much of a zealot you are, and how childish your beliefs.
 
Again, how do you read any resentment in there ?

It's like the guy whose only tool is a hammer, he spends all his waking moments looking for nails. Alfie's tool is AA speak and he spends all his days looking for places too apply it. Unfortunately, the tool doesn't work.

He's using a nerf hammer to pound real nails into oak beams. :D
 
I've pitched it to GB twice, and twice he has declined to answer. I think it's important. So I'll pitch it to you instead:

Would you agree that possession of an internalized set of moral principles presupposes a capacity for experiencing guilt, or do you also equate "guilt" with "sin"?

Woah, Woah, Woah...hold on there Pardner. Where did I say "guilt" = "sin"?

If I didn't answer that particular question it's partly because:

1) I missed it while answering your stupid post #2970 (stupid, because you already know that I have previously answered those questions more than once, and the answer is always the same).

2) Your question above doesn't even make sense. The question seems like the sort of pre-loaded question "Do you still beat your wife?" AND its actually two separate questions in one, BOTH of which require me to accept YOUR presuppositions to answer them. Thus you're Tripling down on Fallacies of Interrogation and hoping to lead me into a trap.

I don't answer those sorts of disingenuous questions.

3) Whatever your question means, it's irrelevant to the fact that AA is Religious and based on Protestant Christian Doctrines.


By the way, do have any evidence to support your position yet?


GB
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom