Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
The eternal question.

Whilst this is in no way perfect or a black and white analogy, I often use the "red shirt" example as a starting place.

If it was suggested to someone that they can't wear a red shirt for three months, for their health, relationships, whatever. Most people would shrug and say "no problems" and do the three months with hardly a second thought.

Tell a non alcoholic they can't have a drink for three months for similar reasons, they will probably shrug, say "no problems" and get on with the three months with hardly a second thought.

Now tell an alcoholic they can't have a drink for three months and see the response.

It does not matter how much one drinks or when, us alkies often talk of the personality change that occurs when we drink.

Dependancy, obsession, allergy (physical processing) all contribute. As a general rule, alcoholics have very poor life/coping skills and alcohol is their crutch.

One does not need to be sleeping rough, drinking metho etc to be an alcoholic. In Australia, most alcoholics dying alcoholic deaths die in their own beds (loosely speaking). I assume this is the same in any other western country.

But as AlBell suggests, iit is the individual that has to decide, it is not for another AA member to tell anyone whether they are or are not an alcoholic.

I hope this helps.
This brings up an important point. Let's say that I have a friend who drinks 15-20 drinks per day. Under AA code, they couldn't suggest that he is an alcoholic. Under my definitions, however, he would be. If I ask him if he could give up alcohol for 3 months, he could lie. Does this mean that I shouldn't suggest treatment for him, since I shouldn't claim that he is an alcoholic?
 
The individual is free to call anything he wants "God" (quite different from your flawed paraphrasing of my statement that "he is free to call God whatever he wants", because reversing the order significantly changes the meaning), and he is free to call nothing "God", and to pronounce as ridiculous the whole idea of calling anything "God". In some groups, doing that might not get you a lot of offers to go for coffee after the meeting, but AA traditions say they can't toss you out on your ear whether they like what you have to say or not.

And yet they certainly can make it clear during meetings, implicitly or explicitly, that your presence is not considered to be of value for whatever reason - as a few examples from the very first page in this thread, regarding "court-ordered attendees", seem to illustrate.

This is an awful long thread, though. Before I reject "it could be a doorknob" as a condescending insult to any reader's intelligence, can anyone summarize for me why it is required important suggested that a participant have some kind of higher power in AA? How is your higher power relevant to/used in the program?

See, the problem I have with this tremendous 52-page thread is that it was begun with a complaint that, despite advocates' claims to the contrary, many people have found religion heavily pushed at AA meetings and this presents a problem because courts sentence people specifically to AA. The response has basically been a defense of why AA is good/functional/useful, while the main thrust of the thread has been completely blown off with "you just need to find a AA group you're comfortable with" and the criminally-ridiculous assertion that "if you put a little effort" in you will unfailingly, magically find a AA chapter you're comfortable with. Not everyone lives in New York City and I'm sure in many places where courts sentence individuals to attending AA meetings there may only be one or two AA groups in town and it's entirely possible that they're so filled with people who ooze about how much the Power Of Christ is helping them that they'd find it uncomfortable or impossible to participate beyond sitting there in agonized silence.
 
This brings up an important point. Let's say that I have a friend who drinks 15-20 drinks per day. Under AA code, they couldn't suggest that he is an alcoholic. Under my definitions, however, he would be. If I ask him if he could give up alcohol for 3 months, he could lie. Does this mean that I shouldn't suggest treatment for him, since I shouldn't claim that he is an alcoholic?

We are getting away from AA alittle here. It is not AAs job to describe or label anyone as an alcoholic; the individual needs to decide that for themself.

Therapists, GPs etc have no such 'resitrictions' placed on them and would tell the individual they have are "dependant".

If your friend is in denial, all you can do is educate. Trying to convince them they have a problem will be a waste of time and they will simply ignore you or end up resenting you.

If they are ready to hear the truth, then a suggestion about getting some help might be just what they need to hear, they may even need some help getting there (i.e. practical suggestions), so do some research.

If you have had enough of their drinking and perhaps have even become an enabler, enforcement of your personal boundaries by withdrawing or modifying that support (detaching with love) could be just what they need to get to "rock bottom" and decide to do something about their problem.

Honestly, I could write reams on what you have put in here but I would need to make all sorts of suppositions and conjecture around the individual circumstances. If you would like to pm me some additional details, I would be happy to give you my thoughts.

Cheers.
 
Last edited:
And yet they certainly can make it clear during meetings, implicitly or explicitly, that your presence is not considered to be of value for whatever reason - as a few examples from the very first page in this thread, regarding "court-ordered attendees", seem to illustrate.
Hmm. There were no AA meetings here, and I've been in groups which contained hard-core atheists who were in no way malinged, and seemed to manage.

This is an awful long thread, though. Before I reject "it could be a doorknob" as a condescending insult to any reader's intelligence, can anyone summarize for me why it is required important suggested that a participant have some kind of higher power in AA? How is your higher power relevant to/used in the program?
A drinking alcoholic has almost invariably been using his ego-centric "rational" mind to get to a place where AA meetings, or some form of help, were sought. Most help other than AA costs a fair amount of money.

"Higher-Power" is a place to turn it all over to; can't hurt. I'm not much for door-knobs; try 'praying to' the electricity in the nearest wall-socket to take over your problems. I used, and use, the 'subconscious' me to 'pray to'; I do tend to think of it as 'god-as I understand him, Good Orderly Direction', which I usually shorten to 'god'.

See, the problem I have with this tremendous 52-page thread is that it was begun with a complaint that, despite advocates' claims to the contrary, many people have found religion heavily pushed at AA meetings and this presents a problem because courts sentence people specifically to AA. The response has basically been a defense of why AA is good/functional/useful, while the main thrust of the thread has been completely blown off with "you just need to find a AA group you're comfortable with" and the criminally-ridiculous assertion that "if you put a little effort" in you will unfailingly, magically find a AA chapter you're comfortable with. Not everyone lives in New York City and I'm sure in many places where courts sentence individuals to attending AA meetings there may only be one or two AA groups in town and it's entirely possible that they're so filled with people who ooze about how much the Power Of Christ is helping them that they'd find it uncomfortable or impossible to participate beyond sitting there in agonized silence.
And I again just say every alcoholic, atheist or not, can always find a reason why something isn't working for him ... time to go have a few.

I'll also say I've never been in any meeting where the Power of Christ became a topic. ymmv.
 
I Haven't dodged it. Dealt with it quite a bit previously.
If something about the idea of examining the matter a little closer makes you uncomfortable, then just say so and I'll drop it. No need to send in the kitten brigade. I asked a question in that last round that you haven't dealt with before, and it's one I happen to find quite relevant. So here's me asking it again:

Would you agree that possession of an internalized set of moral principles presupposes a capacity for experiencing guilt, or do you also equate "guilt" with "sin"?

No, The Pivot Point is God, His Doctrines about Sin come next.
I stand corrected. Do you consider my questions on the subject of "Sin" to be too unimportant to be deserving of further attention? I mean, we've about exhausted the God thing anyway, wouldn't you say?

By the way, I love how YOU keep dodging the issue of The Historic Origins of AA and its Doctrines in Protestant Christianity.
I Haven't dodged it. Dealt with it quite a bit previously.

Seriously though, that's the very thing I'm inviting you to do: examine the origins of AA's concepts.

Perhaps you should do some research instead of spewing from the top of your head.
I suppose I might follow your example and try spewing from the other end.

(Sorry, that was just too obvious to resist)
 
Hmm. There were no AA meetings here, and I've been in groups which contained hard-core atheists who were in no way malinged, and seemed to manage.

Of course. Others have claimed they were at meetings and were uncomfortable with all the Jesusy at those meetings.


A drinking alcoholic has almost invariably been using his ego-centric "rational" mind to get to a place where AA meetings, or some form of help, were sought. Most help other than AA costs a fair amount of money.

What has any of this to do with the part of my post you quoted...?

"Higher-Power" is a place to turn it all over to; can't hurt. I'm not much for door-knobs; try 'praying to' the electricity in the nearest wall-socket to take over your problems. I used, and use, the 'subconscious' me to 'pray to'; I do tend to think of it as 'god-as I understand him, Good Orderly Direction', which I usually shorten to 'god'.

"Can't hurt" is not an answer; it does not address the self-inconsistency of this whole area of the "12 step" dogma. "A place to turn it all over to" is too vague to be meaningful. Turn all "what" over to? Why should it be turned over? What is the therapeutic value, the justification?


And I again just say every alcoholic, atheist or not, can always find a reason why something isn't working for him ... time to go have a few.

Are you reciting all these platitudes from a pamphlet or something? Another irrelevant one-liner. You seem to be suggesting that any critical examination of AA's practices, policies, or teachings should be discouraged because some people may use the flaws and inconsistencies as an excuse to not stop drinking; which makes no logical sense.

I'll also say I've never been in any meeting where the Power of Christ became a topic. ymmv.

If you've got nothing better to add than "that's not my experience", thanks for the input but it is useless. Others have gotten different results, and I'm seeking to explain, justify, or understand experiences like theirs, not like yours.
 
Last edited:
"Can't hurt" is not an answer; it does not address the self-inconsistency of this whole area of the "12 step" dogma. "A place to turn it all over to" is too vague to be meaningful. Turn all "what" over to? Why should it be turned over? What is the therapeutic value, the justification?

"Cant hurt" and "handing over" actually relates to a few areas: just off the top of my head...
1/. Ego deflation - alcoholics live with a paradox of huge ego and low self esteem. We like to try and control things we cannot. Acknowledgement of this is required.
2/. Recognition of boundaries, what is mine, what is not. What I can control, what I cant.
3/. If I can "hand over" expectations to something else (eg fate, the universe, god) then I am recognising I am no longer responsible for the outcome - as a reasult I can have no emotional investment in same and (some) triggers have been negated (hopefully).
4/. Grief and loss: The pain associated with unprocessed grief and loss usually revolves around either: the pain of not being able to have what is not ours, or not having what we can no longer have. Handing over helps here too.

The serenity prayer (affirmation) falls directly in line with this too:

Grant me the serenity
to accept the things I cannot change,
courage to change the things I can,
and wisdom to know the difference
.
 
Last edited:
I wouldn't say AA is disguised Christianity, I would say that the 12 steps are obviously Christian, with subsequent verbiage an attempt to offer greater inclusiveness.

If the mettings are a different story, if you aren't expected to believe in God, like the 12 steps specify, then so much the better.

TinyAl, what do you have to say on the issue on non-theists at the meetings?

In many thousands of meetings, I met a few dozen atheists. I know one atheist who is in a powerful AA position. None of these people are willing to mention their non-belief at any meeting, it's kept very much undercover. Some of these people have 35+ years sober time, with marriages, work relationships & friendships deeply embedded with other theist members, and most do not want to threaten these relationships (in many cases their jobs are tied to AA, and in the present economy just having a job is reason enough, for some, to keep their nonbelief a secret) by revealing their non belief. None that I know of have ever made the following statement at any AA gathering:

"Belief in God or any Higher Power is not necessary to get, and maintain, sobriety"

Such a statement invalidates nearly the entire AA program. For someone who's spent decades in AA, such a statement brings their entire world crashing down - and, coincidentally, brings a certain freedom.

I have made that exact statement at scores of meetings - many more than once (which is how I met nontheists in AA - they contacted me, privately, sometime after my statement).

Why am I doing this? Seeing the constant revolving door of new people come in and out, year after year, of seeing their reactions upon reading the nonsense that is the chapter We Agnostics (and most of the steps, and pretty much all of the big book) - to see their hopes dim (and confusion increase) when it finally hits them that AA isn't really about teaching (or supporting) someone how to quit or moderate their drinking - it's about joining a religious cult, it's about threatening vulnerable people that they will end up dead (or in jail, or some insane asylum), it's about shame and humiliation and control. AA is a religious cult, finely crafted to take people at their most downtrodden (supported by the courts! and doctors! and the multi-billion dollar treatment centers!!) and make them good cult members, so afraid, so shamed....all for the primary purpose of spreading this nonsense to other vulnerable people, ad infinitum.

I am there, at least 1 meeting a week, to demonstrate by example that people don't need some non-existent God to forgive them and take away their sins (so that they won't drink anymore) - that it IS possible to get and stay sober without God - without any of these non existing gods....

I've had some success, and over the last few years espescially have started to see more of us come out of the closet (to borrow a phrase). At some point, I won't be able to take the nonsense anymore - but I'm plugging away , chipping away at the core dogma of AA from inside for as long as I am able to stay sane.

Or with what passes for (sober) sanity these days :)
 
In many thousands of meetings, I met a few dozen atheists. I know one atheist who is in a powerful AA position. None of these people are willing to mention their non-belief at any meeting, it's kept very much undercover.

It seem that personal anecdotes are acceptable.
I too have been to many thousands of meetings, and guess what - I meet atheists at virtually every single one of them

Some of these people have 35+ years sober time, with marriages, work relationships & friendships deeply embedded with other theist members, and most do not want to threaten these relationships (in many cases their jobs are tied to AA, and in the present economy just having a job is reason enough, for some, to keep their nonbelief a secret) by revealing their non belief.

Principled individuals huh?

None that I know of have ever made the following statement at any AA gathering:

"Belief in God or any Higher Power is not necessary to get, and maintain, sobriety"

And yet there they are at AA with decades of sobriety without a hiogher power. How do they do it? :rolleyes:

I am there, at least 1 meeting a week, to demonstrate by example that people don't need some non-existent God .....

And here's your contradiction again. You said that a higher power is "absolutely necessary". It's now not. Which is it? I really wish you would make up your mind.

Yu might not know it Tinyal, but you are the shining beacon that helps show why AA is not religious. You have obtained 20+ years of sobriety, in AA no less, without a higher power.
And more luck to you.
 
Last edited:
Gone over this ad nauseum. But what the Hell...My responses in red font.

The 12 Steps refer to wrongful acts (Sins), leaving it up to the individual to identify those (Confession). They also refer to the causes of those acts (defects of character (SIN) ), also leaving it up to the individual to take responsibility for identifying those (Confession). Does the removal process require direct participation on the part of the individual? (Yes) Yes it does. In fact, there is no direct mention of any role played by anyone other than the alcoholic.

Wrong, the 12 Steps directly and explicitly mention the role of God in the removal of Sins (Defects of character/Shortcomings).

What you do defines what you are.

Christianity jumbles the two together. Wrongful acts are sins, and sin is also what causes a person to commit sinful acts.

Precisely, just like AA.

What you are defines what you do:

Why does a sinner sin?
Because he's a sinner; he was born that way; what else would you expect a sinner to do? (i.e. admitted we were powerless over SIN and Sins)

What does Christ do for a sinner?
He washes away his sins. (i.e. remove defects of character/shortcomings)

Does this process involve direct participation on the part of the sinner?
Not really.

Yes Really!!!! (you really don't know much about Christianity do you?). In fact a Christian has to actively believe in God, Confess Sins and actively beg Forgiveness for their sins--just like in AA.

3. Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we
understood Him.

Accept Christ as Lord and Saviour.

5. Admitted to God, to ourselves, and to another human being the exact nature of our wrongs. CONFESSION

6. Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character.


7. Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings.

6 & 7 Begging Forgiveness of SIN and Sins.



How does it work exactly?
Sorry, that's proprietary information.

Actually it's explicitly stated information in nearly all Christian Denominations. See above for how it works.

And does this process transform the sinner into a non-sinner?
Nope; he's still a sinner; all fall short of the glory of God; there is not a just man upon earth that doeth good and sinneth not.

Actually wrong again Bub! All Sinners start out "Fallen" but...

Denominations vary, but once one accepts the Will of God and Jesus as Lord and Saviour, Christ's blood covers one's sins (Grace).

Catholics generally believe that Good Works + Faith grants access to Grace.

Protestants generally believe that Faith alone leads to Grace, which THEN leads to Good Works.

Now, many believe that one can fall out of Grace and Sin again (though some believe once Grace is achieved it is never revoked), but beg Forgiveness, submit one's will to God's Will again and all will be Forgiven.

11. Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with God, as we understood Him, praying only for knowledge of His will for us
and the power to carry that out.
Praying to God for guidance in our daily lives.

12. Having had a spiritual awakening (GRACE) as the result of these Steps, we tried to carry this message to alcoholics (PROSELYTIZE), and to practice these principles in all our affairs.



Then he will surely commit sinful acts again, won't he?
Count on it. Very Likely so. Just like a drunk falling off the wagon.

What if he does?
Lather, rinse, repeat.

Indeed. One day at a Time Pal. If you fall off the Grace Wagon, beg forgiveness and start again--just like AA.

See Steps Above.


Do you not see a difference there?
NO!

GB
 
My, shall we call it, "subconscious" self.

There we go again, choosing part of yourself as something higher than yourself. :boggled:

Alcoholics are especially good at finding things that make something 'at odds' to their beliefs, which include the belief they don't need any help to 'just stop drinking -- first thing in the morning', yeah! that's the ticket!

And now you seem to be saying that the 12 steps are crucial...
 
In the absence of any data to show us which groups adhere to the religiousity inherent to the AA charter, and which are able to ignore it, I'd say all we have to go on are anecdotes. If we were to consider the strong evidence alone, we would have to conclude from the 12 Steps and the Big Book that AA is indeed strongly religious.

This isn't UFO's or Bigfoot, however, extraordinary evidence is not needed. I am willing to conclude on the basis of all the anecdotes provided here that some groups would welcome atheists, or just not care about religion, and in other groups they would be Smothered by Jesus.
 
Why am I doing this? Seeing the constant revolving door of new people come in and out, year after year, of seeing their reactions upon reading the nonsense that is the chapter We Agnostics (and most of the steps, and pretty much all of the big book) - to see their hopes dim (and confusion increase) when it finally hits them that AA isn't really about teaching (or supporting) someone how to quit or moderate their drinking - it's about joining a religious cult, it's about threatening vulnerable people that they will end up dead (or in jail, or some insane asylum), it's about shame and humiliation and control. AA is a religious cult, finely crafted to take people at their most downtrodden (supported by the courts! and doctors! and the multi-billion dollar treatment centers!!) and make them good cult members, so afraid, so shamed....all for the primary purpose of spreading this nonsense to other vulnerable people, ad infinitum.

To be fair, I don't think this is intentional. It's just a result of individual groups of people following what are essentially mandated Christian "teachings" in their efforts to get sober.

According to Alfie, AlBell and Dymanic's experiences, it seems like that's not the case everywhere. But it IS the case in a lot of AA groups, obviously.
 
To be fair, I don't think this is intentional. It's just a result of individual groups of people following what are essentially mandated Christian "teachings" in their efforts to get sober.
Hmm. What does that remind me of?

According to Alfie, AlBell and Dymanic's experiences, it seems like that's not the case everywhere. But it IS the case in a lot of AA groups, obviously.
Oh. I know! It's similar to posting on skeptic forums. Not every atheist posting is a dick, but most of 'em are.

Nothing intentional, of course, just a self-selected group of highly intelligent egos each being the highest power there is.
 
...it's about shame and humiliation and control.
It's often noted that newcomers to AA seldom arrive on the heels of a big winning streak. As long as an alcoholic can continue to drink and not have his life fall apart as a result, he'll usually do just that. The mental/emotional state described in these words is, typically, not one that occurs as a result of participation in AA -- participation in AA is something that occurs after this state has already been experienced:

"All of us felt at times that we were regaining control, but such intervals -- usually brief -- were inevitably followed by still less control, which led in time to pitiful and incomprehensible demoralization."


I've pitched it to GB twice, and twice he has declined to answer. I think it's important. So I'll pitch it to you instead:

Would you agree that possession of an internalized set of moral principles presupposes a capacity for experiencing guilt, or do you also equate "guilt" with "sin"?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom