I wouldn't say AA is disguised Christianity, I would say that the 12 steps are obviously Christian, with subsequent verbiage an attempt to offer greater inclusiveness.
If the mettings are a different story, if you aren't expected to believe in God, like the 12 steps specify, then so much the better.
TinyAl, what do you have to say on the issue on non-theists at the meetings?
In many thousands of meetings, I met a few dozen atheists. I know one atheist who is in a powerful AA position. None of these people are willing to mention their non-belief at any meeting, it's kept very much undercover. Some of these people have 35+ years sober time, with marriages, work relationships & friendships deeply embedded with other theist members, and most do not want to threaten these relationships (in many cases their jobs are tied to AA, and in the present economy just having a job is reason enough, for some, to keep their nonbelief a secret) by revealing their non belief. None that I know of have
ever made the following statement at any AA gathering:
"Belief in God or any Higher Power is
not necessary to get, and maintain, sobriety"
Such a statement invalidates nearly the
entire AA program. For someone who's spent decades in AA, such a statement brings their entire world crashing down - and, coincidentally, brings a certain freedom.
I
have made that
exact statement at scores of meetings - many more than once (which is how I met nontheists in AA - they contacted me, privately, sometime after my statement).
Why am I doing this? Seeing the constant revolving door of new people come in and out, year after year, of seeing their reactions upon reading the
nonsense that is the chapter We Agnostics (and most of the steps, and pretty much
all of the big book) - to see their hopes dim (and confusion increase) when it
finally hits them that AA
isn't really about teaching (or supporting) someone how to quit or moderate their drinking - it's about joining a
religious cult, it's about threatening vulnerable people that they
will end up dead (or in jail, or some insane asylum), it's about
shame and humiliation and
control. AA
is a religious cult, finely crafted to take people at their most downtrodden (supported by the courts! and doctors! and the multi-billion dollar
treatment centers!!) and make them good cult members, so afraid, so shamed....all for the primary purpose of spreading this nonsense to
other vulnerable people, ad infinitum.
I am there, at least 1 meeting a week, to
demonstrate by example that people
don't need some non-existent God to forgive them and take away their sins (so that they won't drink anymore) - that it IS possible to
get and stay sober without God - without
any of these non existing gods....
I've had some success, and over the last few years espescially have started to see more of us come out of the closet (to borrow a phrase). At some point, I won't be able to take the nonsense anymore - but I'm plugging away , chipping away at the core dogma of AA from inside for as long as I am able to stay sane.
Or with what passes for (sober) sanity these days
