Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I found a new religious organization that offers redemption for alcoholics online. Its Big Book includes the following chapters:

Chapter 3:

Moses ran away and started to hang out with a bad crowd; he learned some nasty habits & hit rock bottom.

MosesTheCatHhitsRockBottom.JPG



Chapter 4:

In a 12-Step group, Moses finds redemption. With God's grace, he recovers. Moses prays for forgiveness for his impertinence

MosesPrays.JPG

More of this wonderful new Religious Programme can be found here.


GB
 
Very true; many drunks have quit hundreds of times.

Whom do you think you are fooling, anyway ? You're arguing like a teenager who just discovered the internet.

I assume you know what I meant but for the benefit of lurkers:

People who definitely solve their alcohol problems with AA are as proportionally numerous as those who do it without such help.
 
Woah, woah, woah. Before I address any of this latest post, shall I take your silence on the question I asked in my last response to you as a tacit concession of the point I was making -- that the concept of SIN as it is applied under Christianity is VERY different from the whole business about wrongs, character defects, amends, and all that, under AA?
[/i]
<my bold>
Dymanic, you are incorrect in the bolded part of your quote above. AA's character defects are one of the half-dozen or so ways Bill described sins. AA's doctrine pulls one of it's many 'bait & switch' routines where it starts out describing the problem physically (using phrases such as an allergy in the beginning chapter 'the doctor's opinion'), and then gradually gets to the real point Bill wanted to make - the point he got from his Oxford group training under Buchman & Shoemaker - which is that alcoholism is caused by separation from God - from not living a life according to God's Will - from not living & practicing a Spiritual Program of Action. According to AA dogma, not living according to God's Will for us = Sin. Therefore, confession of defects (sins!), Amends, & Continuing to seek & do God's Will were the methods AA claims ('rarely have we seen a person fail who thoroughly followed our path') would near-guarantee a daily reprieve from alcohol abuse (these spiritual methods are, of course, equally 'guaranteed' to work for all our other problems, according to AA - and should be strongly suggested to other people such as our non-aa family members).

Bill got all of the ideas for the 12 steps from the oxford group.

From Wikipedia:

"The Oxford Group was a Christian Fellowship founded by American Christian missionary Dr. Franklin Nathaniel Daniel Buchman. Buchman was a Lutheran minister who had a conversion experience in 1908 in a Chapel in Keswick, England. As a result of that experience, in 1921 he founded a movement called A First Century Christian Fellowship, which by 1931 became known as the Oxford Group. The Group believed in the practice of meditation, a belief in God in accord with each believer's own understanding, and adherence to The five C's: Confidence, Confession, Conviction, Conversion, Continuance. Along with being dedicated to the Four Absolutes as the summary of the Sermon on the Mount, Absolute-Honesty, Absolute-Purity, Absolute-Unselfishness, Absolute-Love.

The Oxford Group influenced the structure of Alcoholics Anonymous and many of the ideas that formed the foundation of AA's suggested twelve-step program.[7][8] Later in life, Bill Wilson gave credit to the Oxford Group for saving his life.[9]

An Oxford Group understanding of the human condition is evident in Wilson's formulation of the dilemma of the alcoholic; Oxford programs for recovery and influences of Oxford evangelism can still be detected in key practices of Alcoholics Anonymous.[10] The Oxford Group writers sometimes treated sin as a disease.[11] Sin was anything that stood between the individual and God. Sin frustrated God's plan for oneself, and selfishness and self-centeredness were considered the key problem. Therefore, if one could surrender the ego to God, sin would go with it. In early AA, Wilson spoke of sin and the need for a complete surrender. " <my bold>

Side Derail: The Oxford Group itself would make for a very interesting thread, in my view. A real bunch of cult crazies.
 
No! Not when '"character defects" and "shortcomings" which can only be removed by God' is based on the Christian concept of Sin, which can only be removed by God.
Did you review the post in which I asked that question? Because you haven't really addressed my argument there at all; you've simply restated your assertion.

There is an obvious implication of viewing "character defects" as an integral aspect of alcoholism (which the steps clearly do): not every person is alcoholic; therefore not every person (apparently) suffers from these flaws. Is this consistent with what Christianity teaches about "sin"?

Would you agree that possession of an internalized set of moral principles presupposes a capacity for experiencing guilt, or do you also equate "guilt" with "sin"? Sorry -- I know that's another question, and I do hate to add to your backlog, but I just gotta ask.

By the way, don't take my silence as a concession (argumentum ex silentio).
Aw, just having a little fun with you there, GB. I find this "sin" business quite important, and you seem to be wanting to dodge it. I knew you wouldn't be able to resist that prodding, so it was a matter of using the tools avalible.

Sorry I didn't respond to your question the first time. I didn't find it deserving of a response. I took what stood out, and responded to that.
Partly because you're now saying that you don't find my questions "deserving", and partly because it came up earlier in an exchange with qayak (which you may have overlooked), I wonder if you would mind now stating for the record whether you agree with my observation that the "Sin" issue is the pivot point for most of your argument, and at the very heart of this discussion?
 
Whom do you think you are fooling, anyway ? You're arguing like a teenager who just discovered the internet.
My statement was a fact. Sorry you didn't like it.

Takes an alcoholic, I guess.

I assume you know what I meant but for the benefit of lurkers:

People who definitely solve their alcohol problems with AA are as proportionally numerous as those who do it without such help.
Based on suspect studies and your wishful thinking. The answer is actually 'not known with any certainty', but recidivism is usual, not unusual.

The way an alcoholic definitely solves the problem is easy. No More Alcohol ... Ever.
 
Side Derail: The Oxford Group itself would make for a very interesting thread, in my view. A real bunch of cult crazies.

Not to mention a few kind words for Hitler:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oxford_Group

In 1936 Buchman had hope that Germany could be diverted from its course. When he returned from the Berlin Olympics he gave an interview to the New York World-Telegram.

"I thank Heaven for a man like Adolf Hitler, who built a front line of defense against the anti-Christ of Communism," he said today in his book-lined office in the annex of Calvary Church, Fourth Ave and 21st St. "My barber in London told me Hitler Nazis do Anti-Semitism? Bad, naturally. I suppose Hitler sees a Karl Marx in every Jew. But think what it would mean to the world if Hitler surrendered to the control of God. Or Mussolini. Or any dictator. Through such a man God could control a nation overnight and solve every last, bewildering problem. The world won't listen to God, but God has a plan for every person, for every nation. The world needs the dictatorship of the living spirit of God. I like to put it this way: God is a perpetual broadcasting station and all you need to do is tune in. What we need is a supernatural network of live wires across the world to every last man, in every last place, in every last situation... Human ingenuity is not enough. That is why the isms are pitted against each other and blood falls. Spain has taught us what godless Communism will bring. Who would have dreamed that nuns would be running naked in the streets? Human problems aren't economic. They're moral and they can't be solved by immoral measures. They could be solved within a God-controlled democracy, or perhaps I should say a theocracy, and they could be solved through a God-controlled Fascist dictatorship." [32][33]


GB
 
You said you didn't want your information posted on the internet. Of course, you have provided ample evidence in this thread, so I don't really know what your concern is. It isn't like you've kept it a secret. :v:

I have to admit that this line of argument ("Christian counselor") leads us nowhere, Qayak. We're already having trouble keeping this thread together as it is.
 
Aw, just having a little fun with you there, GB. I find this "sin" business quite important, and you seem to be wanting to dodge it. I knew you wouldn't be able to resist that prodding, so it was a matter of using the tools avalible.

I Haven't dodged it. Dealt with it quite a bit previously. I was busy knocking down some of your other arguments at the time you repeated the question which I've dealt with for the umpeenth time.

Partly because you're now saying that you don't find my questions "deserving", and partly because it came up earlier in an exchange with qayak (which you may have overlooked), I wonder if you would mind now stating for the record whether you agree with my observation that the "Sin" issue is the pivot point for most of your argument, and at the very heart of this discussion?

No, The Pivot Point is God, His Doctrines about Sin come next.

By the way, I love how YOU keep dodging the issue of The Historic Origins of AA and its Doctrines in Protestant Christianity. Perhaps you should do some research instead of spewing from the top of your head.

GB
 
Do I believe the claim of 10k meetings?

Tell ya the truth, I really don't care anymore...this thread has become a thread arguing about arguing, and a colossal waste of time. Nothing determined here will have any lasting effect on ANYONE, so any "victory" you might attain here is a hollow victory...


Congratulations...:)
 
Tell ya the truth, I really don't care anymore...this thread has become a thread arguing about arguing, and a colossal waste of time. Nothing determined here will have any lasting effect on ANYONE, so any "victory" you might attain here is a hollow victory...


Congratulations...:)

Well, Dymanic and Alfie are arguing about arguing, but some of us keep posting the Relevant Evidence. Which is necessary as long as Dymanic in particular attempts to derail the thread with Pseudo-Philosophical Red Herrings.

Wouldn't want newcomers to the thread to mistake Sophistry for Evidence. ;)

GB
 
Tell ya the truth, I really don't care anymore...this thread has become a thread arguing about arguing, and a colossal waste of time. Nothing determined here will have any lasting effect on ANYONE, so any "victory" you might attain here is a hollow victory...


Congratulations...:)

Thanks. I assume from that you see my point.
Is this finally the respect you said you'd afford? :D

In the meantime, Tinyal remains conspicously silent on my points raised. ;)
 
Tell ya the truth, I really don't care anymore...
Don't worry, we'll try to struggle on without you.

this thread has become a thread arguing about arguing, and a colossal waste of time.
As it's been starting with the OP. Check.

Nothing determined here will have any lasting effect on ANYONE, so any "victory" you might attain here is a hollow victory...


Congratulations...:)
Thanks.

You gonna stay up late? Honey, someone on the internet is wrong!
 
Alcoholics are especially good at finding things that make something 'at odds' to their beliefs, which include the belief they don't need any help to 'just stop drinking -- first thing in the morning', yeah! that's the ticket!

Been there, done that.

Some who actually desire to stop drinking and are looking for (again, low cost) help may find that AA meetings don't put them at odds with what is 'suggested' in the literature.
Okay, it seems you are saying that one may safely ignore the 12 steps, at least at the meetings that you attend. That is a good thing in my book, I'm not an alcoholic, but I know people who are, and it would be good if they could kick the habit without embracing sky daddy.

On an off topic note( I rarely see the need to stay strictly on topic, sorry) how would you classify an alcoholic? I have always thought that drinking first thing in the morning qualifies, but drinking a six pack after work does not(I prefer 2-3 drinks after work). Some of my friends disagree.
 
Not very usefull, people drinking a bottle a day don't admit they are alcoholics until they decide to quit.
 
On an off topic note( I rarely see the need to stay strictly on topic, sorry) how would you classify an alcoholic? I have always thought that drinking first thing in the morning qualifies, but drinking a six pack after work does not(I prefer 2-3 drinks after work). Some of my friends disagree.

The eternal question.

Whilst this is in no way perfect or a black and white analogy, I often use the "red shirt" example as a starting place.

If it was suggested to someone that they can't wear a red shirt for three months, for their health, relationships, whatever. Most people would shrug and say "no problems" and do the three months with hardly a second thought.

Tell a non alcoholic they can't have a drink for three months for similar reasons, they will probably shrug, say "no problems" and get on with the three months with hardly a second thought.

Now tell an alcoholic they can't have a drink for three months and see the response.

It does not matter how much one drinks or when, us alkies often talk of the personality change that occurs when we drink.

Dependancy, obsession, allergy (physical processing) all contribute. As a general rule, alcoholics have very poor life/coping skills and alcohol is their crutch.

One does not need to be sleeping rough, drinking metho etc to be an alcoholic. In Australia, most alcoholics dying alcoholic deaths die in their own beds (loosely speaking). I assume this is the same in any other western country.

But as AlBell suggests, iit is the individual that has to decide, it is not for another AA member to tell anyone whether they are or are not an alcoholic.

I hope this helps.
 
Last edited:
While simultaneously excluding those Christians (and there are quite a few of them) who would recoil in horror at the very notion of inclusiveness where higher powers are concerned. It's JEHOVAH God through his only begotten Son, JESUS CHRIST -- or you're a devil worshipper, end of story. The most outspoken and rigidly fundamentalist among Christians are as rare a breed at AA meetings as militant atheists -- and, ironically, for the very same reason: they simply wouldn't be caught dead joining a group that does not espouse beliefs strictly in line with their own. It isn't about inclusiveness. It's about personal responsibility.

AA does not demand that the individual believe anything. Like others here have done, you are affirming the consequent: "AA is thinly disguised Christianity. Christianity places great emphasis on belief (Whosoever believeth in him shall not perish etc), therefore AA places great emphasis on this as well". -- But it doesn't. Unbelievers are not challenged on their unbelief. The specific details of individual belief are not often discussed at meetings anyway. The individual is free to call anything he wants "God" (quite different from your flawed paraphrasing of my statement that "he is free to call God whatever he wants", because reversing the order significantly changes the meaning), and he is free to call nothing "God", and to pronounce as ridiculous the whole idea of calling anything "God". In some groups, doing that might not get you a lot of offers to go for coffee after the meeting, but AA traditions say they can't toss you out on your ear whether they like what you have to say or not.

So, if making the substitutions mentally does not seem like enough, what you do is you take the book, black out every instance of the word(s) you find objectionable, and write in "FSM" or whatever you like. It wouldn't be the first time anyone's ever done that, by a long shot.

There it is.
I wouldn't say AA is disguised Christianity, I would say that the 12 steps are obviously Christian, with subsequent verbiage an attempt to offer greater inclusiveness.

If the mettings are a different story, if you aren't expected to believe in God, like the 12 steps specify, then so much the better.

TinyAl, what do you have to say on the issue on non-theists at the meetings?
 
Really??? Meetings of ANY group nearly always have some sort of Senior Member running them. It doesn't make them religious necessarily. It's just Group Dynamics.

GB
This is a huge load of crap. Senior Member? (again with the random capitalization) Anyone, absolutely anyone with 90 continuous days of sobriety can chair a meeting and frequently do.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom