Woah, woah, woah. Before I address any of this latest post, shall I take your silence on the question I asked in my last response to you as a tacit concession of the point I was making -- that the concept of SIN as it is applied under Christianity is VERY different from the whole business about wrongs, character defects, amends, and all that, under AA?
[/i]
<my bold>
Dymanic, you are incorrect in the bolded part of your quote above. AA's character defects are one of the half-dozen or so ways Bill described
sins. AA's doctrine pulls one of it's
many 'bait & switch' routines where it starts out describing the problem
physically (using phrases such as an
allergy in the beginning chapter 'the doctor's opinion'), and then gradually gets to the
real point Bill wanted to make - the point he got from his Oxford group training under Buchman & Shoemaker - which is that alcoholism is
caused by separation from God - from
not living a life according to God's Will - from
not living & practicing a Spiritual Program of Action. According to AA dogma,
not living according to God's Will for us = Sin. Therefore, confession of defects (sins!), Amends, & Continuing to seek & do God's Will were the methods AA claims ('rarely have we seen a person fail who thoroughly followed our path') would near-guarantee a daily reprieve from alcohol abuse (these spiritual methods are, of course, equally 'guaranteed' to work for all our other problems, according to AA - and should be
strongly suggested to other people such as our non-aa family members).
Bill got
all of the ideas for the 12 steps from the oxford group.
From Wikipedia:
"The Oxford Group was a Christian Fellowship founded by American Christian missionary Dr. Franklin Nathaniel Daniel Buchman. Buchman was a Lutheran minister who had a conversion experience in 1908 in a Chapel in Keswick, England. As a result of that experience, in 1921 he founded a movement called A First Century Christian Fellowship, which by 1931 became known as the Oxford Group. The Group believed in the practice of meditation, a belief in God in accord with each believer's own understanding, and adherence to The five C's: Confidence, Confession, Conviction, Conversion, Continuance. Along with being dedicated to the Four Absolutes as the summary of the Sermon on the Mount, Absolute-Honesty, Absolute-Purity, Absolute-Unselfishness, Absolute-Love.
The Oxford Group influenced the structure of Alcoholics Anonymous and many of the ideas that formed the foundation of AA's suggested twelve-step program.[7][8] Later in life, Bill Wilson gave credit to the Oxford Group for saving his life.[9]
An Oxford Group understanding of the human condition is evident in Wilson's formulation of the dilemma of the alcoholic; Oxford programs for recovery and influences of Oxford evangelism can still be detected in key practices of Alcoholics Anonymous.[10] The Oxford Group writers sometimes treated sin as a disease.[11]
Sin was anything that stood between the individual and God. Sin frustrated God's plan for oneself, and selfishness and self-centeredness were considered the key problem. Therefore, if one could surrender the ego to God, sin would go with it. In early AA, Wilson spoke of sin and the need for a complete surrender. " <my bold>
Side Derail: The Oxford Group itself would make for a very interesting thread, in my view. A real bunch of cult crazies.