Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I am sure that nothing I can say will make aaalfie believe me, and indeed, I should never have made the part of my previous post that mentioned the time I spent in GSO NY - I should have known better (as a skeptic) than to make claims I wouldn't be able to prove. So, for those who doubt my word - I don't blame you, as I myself would more than likely act the same way if someone made that same claim to me. So first thing, I will remove that claim ( the one about NY service positions) from my statement (should I edit it out??).
For those who are inclined to believe me, or are curious about AA's structure (the Organization that makes the silly & false claim it isn't organized ), at the link below you will find an organization chart. Between 1995 and 2005 I was either Chairman or Technical Adviser (Neutral Non-Voting) for 2 of the blocks on the right side of the chart, under the Trustee Division. My membership was based on 2 out of 3 skillsets it was deemed I could provide(those being Public Speaking, Document Preservation, or Business Management) - I am unwilling to provide more specific details.

Removing that claim from my previous post (I shouldn't edit historical posts, unless most here agree I should take it out since I choose not to prove it - providing proof would cause me several problems, including a possible lawsuit based on something I signed at the time); removing that, based on my long experience & knowledge of the AA program I feel confident I am qualified to answer Marcus's question.

In summary, regardless of the believability of that one small portion of my claim, I believe the Evidence presented in this thread combined with readings of the core documents, as well as the considerations made through numerous legal judgments is sufficient to conclude the statement "AA is a religious organization" is a true claim.

My next goal (the evidence of which I've been working on for a few years, on and off) is to demonstrate the degree to which AA fits the definition of a Cult - perhaps even a potentially dangerous one, as well as providing support for the claim that other treatments are, if not equally effective, then actually more effective as a treatment for alcohol abuse.

Chart Link: http://www.aa.org/pdf/products/en_bm-31.pdf
 
Last edited:
In the meantime, I will await his responses to same, especially how the "absolutely necessary" requirement of a hp works with his sobriety.

Please explain.

My next goal (the evidence of which I've been working on for a few years, on and off) is to demonstrate the degree to which AA fits the definition of a Cult - perhaps even a potentially dangerous one, as well as providing support for the claim that other treatments are, if not equally effective, then actually more effective as a treatment for alcohol abuse.

No axe to grind there......... much. That is one great big resentment. :boggled:

That said, I look forward to hearing about the other treatments, the more on the table, the more options for the suffering alcoholic.

But in the meantime, how did you get sober again? :rolleyes:
 
Based on my experience I can answer your question Marcus ; my AA experience consists of experience at nearly the highest levels of the AA organization (just below Trustee at World Service Headquarters), plus attendance at more than 10,000 meetings over 20+ years in 5 different countries. Additionally, I have been an active participant or leader of Regional, Area, District, and group meetings & Conferences, and have had access to stacks of AA archives not generally available to members of the public (nor to most AA members themselves) - some of these archives were marked with release dates 99 years after Bill's death, and remain sealed to this day.

So, yes indeed - practicing the 12 steps as shown - in detail - in the big book is widely considered absolutely essential to getting (and, perhaps more importantly, remaining) sober. When aaalfie (and a very few others) in this thread keep harping on things such as 'the only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking' they are speaking specifically about membership. Membership does not equal getting and maintaining sobriety - as stated (in many different ways, in many different AA core documents) in the big book (I'm paraphrasing here): "We are not cured of Alcoholism - what we have is a daily reprieve based on maintaining a Spiritual Program of Action"
The evidence is clear - AA is a religious & spiritual program best summed up as AA's ABC's (as it is frequently stated in AA meetings and written in the big book):

"(a) That we were alcoholic and could not manage our own lives.
(b) That probably no human power could have relieved our alcoholism.
(c) That God could and would if He were sought."

AA's Big Book, Chapter 5 'How It Works' page 60
Thanks Tinyal. This is the internet, so there are bound to be people who don't believe you, but it sounds plausible to me, especially since we have the evidence of the 12 steps and the Big Book. Of course, there could be individual groups who practice a more secular variation, earlier in the thread a poster referred to an Atheist AA group, and A.A.Alfie, Dymanic, and AlBell seem to have had non-religious experiences.

This country is full of theists anyway, if I had a theist friend who was an alcoholic, I wouldn't see any harm in referring him to AA. For an atheist, however, I don't believe it would be the first choice.

The religious vs spiritual debate seems a bit silly to me, the docs are full of the word "God" , that is not negated by attempts at inclusiveness characterizing the program as "spiritual".
 
This is the internet, so there are bound to be people who don't believe you...
Perhaps a better way to phrase that would be: This is a skeptic's forum, so people often consider themselves to be bound by certain principles when it comes to "believing" things. The opinion of an authority may be accepted as evidence in support of a particular claim so long as it can be established that the cited authority really is an accepted authority speaking within his field of expertise.

Here, we have an instance of an individual who claims first-hand knowledge of the inner workings of AA's organizational structure, and implies privileged access to certain secret documents. The second part of that is prima facie self-contradictory if you really look at it. The first part I can accept as probably true, but the very mention of it in this context is problematic. Tradition Nine states that: "AA as such ought never be organized; but we may create service boards or committees directly resposible to those they serve".

"Power to direct or govern is the essence of organization everywhere. Yet Alcoholics Anonymous is an exception. It does not conform to this pattern. Neither its General Service Conference, its Foundation Board, nor the humblest committee can issue a single directive to an AA member and make it stick, let alone mete out any punishment."
- 12&12, page 173.

In other words: The organizational structure is independent of the fellowship.

By way of analogy, I have a friend who specializes in organizing musical events. She herself is a great lover of music, but if she has a speck of playing ability herself, I've never seen it (okay, heard it). What happens at the level of organizing the events is entirely separate and of a completely different nature than what happens at the level of actually playing the music. If my friend were listening to some musicians playing and making observations about what was going on, I would not be quick to brush her opinions aside. What she would not do is presume to possess penetrating insights into music theory deriving from her experience in organizing musical events. If she did -- and if her insights were inconsistent with what the musicians themselves had to say about their own music -- I would be inclined to defer to their opinions rather than hers. I would also wonder what in the heck was going on in her head when she decided it was okay to make that leap.

The religious vs spiritual debate seems a bit silly to me, the docs are full of the word "God" , that is not negated by attempts at inclusiveness characterizing the program as "spiritual".
It's not about inclusiveness, and it's not about "the docs".

Even the most fervent among God-believers, say Christians, do not usually consider their God to be an entity which resides in a book. God is God; the Bible is the Word of God. The magic which is purported to happen takes place when a person takes the Word and applies it in his life.

Similarly, the "spiritual life" described in the Big Book does not reside in the book. The magic which is purported to happen takes place when a person takes the concepts presented in the book and applies them in his own life. The individual is encouraged to choose his own concept of a "higher power", and if that ends up being something not very well described by the word "God", he is free to call it whatever he wants -- and no, that doesn't negate the things written in "the docs"; it actualizes them. It takes some patterns of ink on paper and puts them to work in the life of a living, breathing, human being.
 
What other areas of group dynamics are considered religious that are not lead by a priest/rabbi/imam/whatever? Usual AA meetings don't have any such individual.
 
What other areas of group dynamics are considered religious that are not lead by a priest/rabbi/imam/whatever? Usual AA meetings don't have any such individual.

Really??? Meetings of ANY group nearly always have some sort of Senior Member running them. It doesn't make them religious necessarily. It's just Group Dynamics.

GB
 
Really??? Meetings of ANY group nearly always have some sort of Senior Member running them.
Hogwash. I've run meetings, most I attended traded off member to member meeting by meeting. Arrive early, arrange room, make coffee, open it up, discuss, chips out as needed, clean up, go home instead of to a bar or liquor store.

And damn sure even if a pastor happened to be the person up, religion was not on the agenda.

It doesn't make them religious necessarily. It's just Group Dynamics.

GB
Indeed, CBM in action. Religious content, zero. Except I guess for those who can't figure out that god-as-you-understand-him has no agenda at a meeting.
 
Perhaps a better way to phrase that would be: This is a skeptic's forum, so people often consider themselves to be bound by certain principles when it comes to "believing" things. The opinion of an authority may be accepted as evidence in support of a particular claim so long as it can be established that the cited authority really is an accepted authority speaking within his field of expertise.
True. You'll note that I said it seems plausible, I'm not automatically accepting his word. By the same token, I'm not automatically accepting yours either, I'm not sure how either one of you could prove your creds.
Here, we have an instance of an individual who claims first-hand knowledge of the inner workings of AA's organizational structure, and implies privileged access to certain secret documents. The second part of that is prima facie self-contradictory if you really look at it. The first part I can accept as probably true, but the very mention of it in this context is problematic. Tradition Nine states that: "AA as such ought never be organized; but we may create service boards or committees directly resposible to those they serve".

"Power to direct or govern is the essence of organization everywhere. Yet Alcoholics Anonymous is an exception. It does not conform to this pattern. Neither its General Service Conference, its Foundation Board, nor the humblest committee can issue a single directive to an AA member and make it stick, let alone mete out any punishment."
- 12&12, page 173.

In other words: The organizational structure is independent of the fellowship.

By way of analogy, I have a friend who specializes in organizing musical events. She herself is a great lover of music, but if she has a speck of playing ability herself, I've never seen it (okay, heard it). What happens at the level of organizing the events is entirely separate and of a completely different nature than what happens at the level of actually playing the music. If my friend were listening to some musicians playing and making observations about what was going on, I would not be quick to brush her opinions aside. What she would not do is presume to possess penetrating insights into music theory deriving from her experience in organizing musical events. If she did -- and if her insights were inconsistent with what the musicians themselves had to say about their own music -- I would be inclined to defer to their opinions rather than hers. I would also wonder what in the heck was going on in her head when she decided it was okay to make that leap.
It's not about inclusiveness, and it's not about "the docs".

By emphasizing spiritual aspects, encouraging you to choose your own higher power, they are being more inclusive, including more people than just Christians. This isn't going to do much for atheists though, we don't believe in supernatural entities, and therefore aren't likely to choose one, no matter what it's called.
Even the most fervent among God-believers, say Christians, do not usually consider their God to be an entity which resides in a book. God is God; the Bible is the Word of God. The magic which is purported to happen takes place when a person takes the Word and applies it in his life.

Similarly, the "spiritual life" described in the Big Book does not reside in the book. The magic which is purported to happen takes place when a person takes the concepts presented in the book and applies them in his own life. The individual is encouraged to choose his own concept of a "higher power", and if that ends up being something not very well described by the word "God", he is free to call it whatever he wants -- and no, that doesn't negate the things written in "the docs"; it actualizes them. It takes some patterns of ink on paper and puts them to work in the life of a living, breathing, human being.

So he is free to call God whatever he wants, as long as he Believes. Personally, I would like to see "FSM" substituted for "God" in "the docs" or The 12 Steps and The Big Book, if you insist on having it spelled out.:D

If AA does work, and I am sure it does at least some of the time, it is the people themselves who are responsible, not a higher power.
 
So he is free to call God whatever he wants, as long as he Believes.
The only belief needed is that one has a problem with alcohol and that one would like to stop drinking it.

Personally, I would like to see "FSM" substituted for "God" in "the docs" or The 12 Steps and The Big Book, if you insist on having it spelled out.:D
You are free to chose FSM as your higher-power; quite frankly no one besides you gives a damn. The FSM is certainly more well-known than you are.

If AA does work, and I am sure it does at least some of the time, it is the people themselves who are responsible, not a higher power.
No kidding.

Most alcoholics need some help to get to the point where they notice their ego-centric viewpoint hasn't helped them stop drinking even thought they and others around them all think it would be the logical, rational choice.

AA offers a no-cost option for those who want it. Many other options are (usually) available, although seldom at no cost.
 
Last edited:
Hogwash. I've run meetings, most I attended traded off member to member meeting by meeting. Arrive early, arrange room, make coffee, open it up, discuss, chips out as needed, clean up, go home instead of to a bar or liquor store.

And damn sure even if a pastor happened to be the person up, religion was not on the agenda.


Indeed, CBM in action. Religious content, zero. Except I guess for those who can't figure out that god-as-you-understand-him has no agenda at a meeting.
I believe you, but I'm also curious. Which higher power did you choose? Did you experience the magic, when this higher power helped you stop drinking? I'm not being sarcastic, I'm just looking at step one, admit you are powerless over alcohol, and step two, believe that a Power greater than yourself could restore you to sanity.
 
The only belief needed is that one has a problem with alcohol and that one would like to stop drinking it.


You are free to chose FSM as your higher-power; quite frankly no one besides you gives a damn. The FSM is certainly more well-known than you are.


No kidding.

Most alcoholics need some help to get to the point where they notice their ego-centric viewpoint hasn't helped them stop drinking even thought they and others around them all think it would be the logical, rational choice.

AA offers a no-cost option for those who want it. Many other options are (usually) available, although seldom at no cost.
You posted this while I was typing, and it all sounds perfectly rational. Except that it is at odds with the 12 steps and the Big Book.
 
I believe you, but I'm also curious. Which higher power did you choose?
My, shall we call it, "subconscious" self.

Did you experience the magic, when this higher power helped you stop drinking?
Something seems to be working, now going on 19 years, but I don't classify it as magic.

I'm not being sarcastic, I'm just looking at step one, admit you are powerless over alcohol,
That's the problem with ego-centrism run amok and not making logical, rational choices ; for AA purposes, regarding alcohol use.

and step two, believe that a Power greater than yourself could restore you to sanity.
My life not-as-an-alcohoiic is a grand improvement to me and those around me compared to me as a drinking alcoholic.

Sanity? That's a tougher problem ... ;) I'd like to hope so anyway.
 
You posted this while I was typing, and it all sounds perfectly rational. Except that it is at odds with the 12 steps and the Big Book.
Alcoholics are especially good at finding things that make something 'at odds' to their beliefs, which include the belief they don't need any help to 'just stop drinking -- first thing in the morning', yeah! that's the ticket!

Been there, done that.

Some who actually desire to stop drinking and are looking for (again, low cost) help may find that AA meetings don't put them at odds with what is 'suggested' in the literature.
 
Perhaps a better way to phrase that would be: This is a skeptic's forum, so people often consider themselves to be bound by certain principles when it comes to "believing" things. The opinion of an authority may be accepted as evidence in support of a particular claim so long as it can be established that the cited authority really is an accepted authority speaking within his field of expertise.

Here, we have an instance of an individual who claims first-hand knowledge of the inner workings of AA's organizational structure, and implies privileged access to certain secret documents. The second part of that is prima facie self-contradictory if you really look at it. The first part I can accept as probably true, but the very mention of it in this context is problematic. Tradition Nine states that: "AA as such ought never be organized; but we may create service boards or committees directly resposible to those they serve".

"Power to direct or govern is the essence of organization everywhere. Yet Alcoholics Anonymous is an exception. It does not conform to this pattern. Neither its General Service Conference, its Foundation Board, nor the humblest committee can issue a single directive to an AA member and make it stick, let alone mete out any punishment."
- 12&12, page 173.

In other words: The organizational structure is independent of the fellowship.

By way of analogy, I have a friend who specializes in organizing musical events. She herself is a great lover of music, but if she has a speck of playing ability herself, I've never seen it (okay, heard it). What happens at the level of organizing the events is entirely separate and of a completely different nature than what happens at the level of actually playing the music. If my friend were listening to some musicians playing and making observations about what was going on, I would not be quick to brush her opinions aside. What she would not do is presume to possess penetrating insights into music theory deriving from her experience in organizing musical events. If she did -- and if her insights were inconsistent with what the musicians themselves had to say about their own music -- I would be inclined to defer to their opinions rather than hers. I would also wonder what in the heck was going on in her head when she decided it was okay to make that leap.


It's not about inclusiveness, and it's not about "the docs".

Even the most fervent among God-believers, say Christians, do not usually consider their God to be an entity which resides in a book. God is God; the Bible is the Word of God. The magic which is purported to happen takes place when a person takes the Word and applies it in his life.

Similarly, the "spiritual life" described in the Big Book does not reside in the book. The magic which is purported to happen takes place when a person takes the concepts presented in the book and applies them in his own life. The individual is encouraged to choose his own concept of a "higher power", and if that ends up being something not very well described by the word "God", he is free to call it whatever he wants -- and no, that doesn't negate the things written in "the docs"; it actualizes them. It takes some patterns of ink on paper and puts them to work in the life of a living, breathing, human being.

No, the Spiritual Life in The Big Book and the 12 Steps resides in God, the Biggest Organizer of Them All. And the core of the Programme are these texts.

And the alleged "self-contradiction" is not on Tinyal's part (in fact he immediately qualified his previous statement to acknowledge that he could not verify his claim without compromising privileged information). The contradiction is within the statements of AA's documents themselves.

Tradition 9 is "prima facie"* :rolleyes: self-contradictory. It states that AA ought never be organized, except insofar as it is organized.

*By the way, are you sure you meant to use "prima facie" in that manner? It
implies that maybe a second look might be warranted. In other words, a statement might NOT be "self-contradictory" if examined more carefully (then again, it might still be self-contradictory if the second look doesn't reveal any new information).

Also you implied that Tinyal's statement was "self-contradictory", when what you really meant was: Tinyal's statement contradicts Step 9 (you're not the only one that can be pedantic and nit-picky; except you're pedantic, nit-picky, and wrong :p ).

"Power to direct or govern is the essence of organization everywhere. Yet Alcoholics Anonymous is an exception. It does not conform to this pattern. Neither its General Service Conference, its Foundation Board, nor the humblest committee can issue a single directive to an AA member and make it stick, let alone mete out any punishment."
- 12&12, page 173.

And this statement is also self-contradictory (as are your statements which accept it at face value).

It implies that AA at the Organizational Level is wholly distinct from AA at the Fellowship Level. Yet...

1) AA groups specifically use and distribute AA Literature provided by the GSO, and the use and distribution is certainly directed and governed by the GSO. A 12 Step group that uses their own modified 12 Steps (such as the Secular 12 Steps) is not affiliated with AA.

2) And senior members of AA at the "Fellowship Level" can become members of the Parent Organization.

In this way, the Organizational (Hierarchical) Structure of AA as a whole is similar to the model of many affiliated Churches--the Anglican Communion comes to mind: http://www.anglicancommunion.org/

That AA uses this particular model for the structure of their organization is hardly surprising, as they are a Religious Organization based on a Protestant model.

And the self-contradictory messaging of AA is nothing new, as evidenced by the Religious Language and Doctrines of their Officially Approved Texts, and the contradictory passages that either claim they are not Religious or that the Steps are "Suggested."

GB
 
Last edited:
By emphasizing spiritual aspects, encouraging you to choose your own higher power, they are being more inclusive, including more people than just Christians.
While simultaneously excluding those Christians (and there are quite a few of them) who would recoil in horror at the very notion of inclusiveness where higher powers are concerned. It's JEHOVAH God through his only begotten Son, JESUS CHRIST -- or you're a devil worshipper, end of story. The most outspoken and rigidly fundamentalist among Christians are as rare a breed at AA meetings as militant atheists -- and, ironically, for the very same reason: they simply wouldn't be caught dead joining a group that does not espouse beliefs strictly in line with their own. It isn't about inclusiveness. It's about personal responsibility.

So he is free to call God whatever he wants, as long as he Believes.
AA does not demand that the individual believe anything. Like others here have done, you are affirming the consequent: "AA is thinly disguised Christianity. Christianity places great emphasis on belief (Whosoever believeth in him shall not perish etc), therefore AA places great emphasis on this as well". -- But it doesn't. Unbelievers are not challenged on their unbelief. The specific details of individual belief are not often discussed at meetings anyway. The individual is free to call anything he wants "God" (quite different from your flawed paraphrasing of my statement that "he is free to call God whatever he wants", because reversing the order significantly changes the meaning), and he is free to call nothing "God", and to pronounce as ridiculous the whole idea of calling anything "God". In some groups, doing that might not get you a lot of offers to go for coffee after the meeting, but AA traditions say they can't toss you out on your ear whether they like what you have to say or not.

Personally, I would like to see "FSM" substituted for "God" in "the docs" or The 12 Steps and The Big Book, if you insist on having it spelled out.
So, if making the substitutions mentally does not seem like enough, what you do is you take the book, black out every instance of the word(s) you find objectionable, and write in "FSM" or whatever you like. It wouldn't be the first time anyone's ever done that, by a long shot.

If AA does work, and I am sure it does at least some of the time, it is the people themselves who are responsible, not a higher power.
There it is.
 
No, the Spiritual Life in The Big Book and the 12 Steps resides in God, the Biggest Organizer of Them All....
Woah, woah, woah. Before I address any of this latest post, shall I take your silence on the question I asked in my last response to you as a tacit concession of the point I was making -- that the concept of SIN as it is applied under Christianity is VERY different from the whole business about wrongs, character defects, amends, and all that, under AA?

In case you've forgotten, it was post #2790, and the question still pending is:

Do you not see a difference there?
 
Woah, woah, woah. Before I address any of this latest post, shall I take your silence on the question I asked in my last response to you as a tacit concession of the point I was making -- that the concept of SIN as it is applied under Christianity is VERY different from the whole business about wrongs, character defects, amends, and all that, under AA?

In case you've forgotten, it was post #2790, and the question still pending is:

Do you not see a difference there?

No! Not when '"character defects" and "shortcomings" which can only be removed by God' is based on the Christian concept of Sin, which can only be removed by God.

By the way, don't take my silence as a concession (argumentum ex silentio). I seem to recall someone saying this:

There's no doubt that every one of your posts is so fascinating and insightful as to be completely deserving of a full line-by-line response -- but the thing is, I just don't always have time for that. I take what stands out for me and I respond to that.

Sorry I didn't respond to your question the first time. I didn't find it deserving of a response. I took what stood out, and responded to that.

GB
 
In particular the number of meetings attended.
Any reason to doubt that?
attendance at more than 10,000 meetings over 20+ years in 5 different countries.


Unless my maths are wrong, that would equate to approximately one and a half meetings per day for 20 years.
No, I do not doubt that it is possible for someone to become so immersed in a group as to be dependant on it - I have seen it before, there is nothing wrong with that if it keeps you sober; whatever works is good.

What I do find interesting is that Tinyal firmly suggests that:
1. AA is religious
2. For the program to work it is "absolutely necessary" to have god.

If #1 is true, why an atheist would attend one and a half meetings per day for 20 years to be bashed around the head by religion is beyond me. Not to mention spreading the good word to millions of others by climbing to "the highest levels".

If #2 is true how has he remained sober for all this time without adopting god/religion whatever.

Do I believe the claim of 10k meetings? It is possible, but that makes him something of a curiosity. People go to AA to learn to live in the outside world, not so they can stay totally insulated within AA.

But what I do see is a lot of contradictions in Tinyals talk and walk. Curiously he prefers not to explain himself on these points nor why he now (seemingly) hates AA, when clearly he loved it for so long. As a result I take whatever he says with a very healthy application of salt; he clearly has an axe to grind.

I believe you, but I'm also curious. Which higher power did you choose? Did you experience the magic, when this higher power helped you stop drinking? I'm not being sarcastic, I'm just looking at step one, admit you are powerless over alcohol, and step two, believe that a Power greater than yourself could restore you to sanity.

The "magic" happened for me when the power greater than myself (the fellowship of AA) wrapped me up, loved me when I could not love myself and supported me through early recovery. Until one day I realised I was happy and the desire to drink had left me altogether.
Is that magic, a miracle? Did a power greater than myself restore me to sanity?
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom