Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
You and GB do not appear to be in agreement on this. Let's ask him.

I don't speak for GB. My opinion is that although sin is definitely addressed in AA morality, it hasn't any bearing on whether AA is religious or not.

Kierkegaard (if I may be forgiven for referring to him yet again) spoke of herds of unbelieving believers. His whole assault on Christiandom was based on its weakening of the individual's sense of responsibility. Newcomers to AA ask the same question that those who attempt to teach art, English composition, or anything that depends so heavily on individual creativity and initiative often regard as their least favorite words to hear from their students: "What am I supposed to do?" The only valid answer possible is: "You are supposed to decide what you are supposed to do". To be sure, some of these newcomers hang around for years without ever really getting that -- but Kierkegaard would have seen it instantly and embraced it enthusiastially. I guarantee it. It is exactly what he was trying to convey with his vitriolic attacks on the priests he called "man-eaters", "liars", "hypocrites", and "destroyers of Christianity".

Not sure how this relates to whether AA is religious or not. Could you explain that more clearly.

As my own tangent, the chapter of the Big Book entitled "We Agnostics" clearly states that using the group, or anything else, as a higher power is is only a start and that true success in AA only comes once one has accepted that there is a universe creating God. It does say that a member can use their own definition of what a "universe creating God" is but only a universe creating God will do.

how does that fit in with your belief that AA is not religious?

Said a mouthful there, you did. But if you're still thinking that those obstacles are imposed externally upon the AA member by a prescribed set of external rules, then all I can say is that you simply could not possibly be more wrong, and our only recourse may be to add this to the list of things we'll never agree on.

I would say that when the organization sets down the one way change can come about, it is pretty much a set of rules imposed on members. That the members "perceive" something different is not unusual. Everyone likes to believe they are free.

My understanding of what we agreed on is that a moral code may exist independent of those formalized systems of thought we refer to as "religions".

It is the "independent" part we disagree on.

"What is good, Phaedrus, and what is not good -- need we ask anyone to tell us these things?" My answer would be: No; we humans possess a unique ability to imagine what it would be like to be in another person's place, and a basic sense of morality would naturally emerge out of that regardless of whether anyone had explicitly spelled out for us a particular set of rules. Reason, evidence and contemplation may help to resolve those specific moral dilemmas we all encounter from time to time, but the fundamental concepts may be aquired intuitively. Nonetheless, during the period when we were aquiring this knowledge, most of us did have someone to "tell us what is good and what is not good":
So if a desperate alcoholic goes looking for a moral code in AA, he'll find one -- but the thing is, won't be AA's moral code; it'll be his moral code; the very one he brought with him the first time he walked in the door. If he experiences a sense of guilt, it will be because of his failure to live up to that code; not someone else's. For that reason, the Big Book's advice is to begin the inventory process by considering one's own resentments and fears and tracing those to their sources: "The first thing apparent was that this world and its people were often quite wrong". "Putting out of our minds the wrongs others had done, we resolutely looked for our own mistakes".

I think you forget just how easy it is to "suggest" things to someone, especially when they are at a low point in their lives, and have it become their "own belief." Religions, cults, the Republicans (kidding) prey on that.

This has been demonstrated time and time again. What you call "suggestions" are, in fact, hard and fast rules to almost anyone under certain conditions. That alcoholism provides a large population of people under those conditions is very important to the success of AA. (I mean success as in "viable organization" here, not as in "cure rate."

Again: Is there something inherently religious about considering where you may have made mistakes and trying to understand what caused you to make them?

No, but you are ignoring all the other stuff and focusing on one of the few that is more universal. However, it IS usually an important part of religions.
 
Moral code used by AA; DUI's aren't good; giving spouse black eye followed by night in jail isn't good; being a thieving, lying no-good drunken bastard isn't good; etc.

As to what goes on in meetings start with wiki:
AA meetings are "quasi-ritualized therapeutic sessions run by and for, alcoholics".[39] They are usually informal and often feature discussions. Local AA directories list a variety of weekly meetings. Those listed as "closed" are only for those with "a desire to stop drinking",[3] while "open" meetings are available to anyone. At speaker meetings one or two members tell their stories, while discussion meetings allocate the most time for general discussion. Some meetings are devoted to studying and discussing the AA literature. Except for men's and women's meetings, most meetings for specific demographics (including newcomers, gays, and young people) do not exclude other alcoholics. While AA has pamphlets that suggest meeting formats,[40][41] groups have the autonomy to hold and conduct meetings as they wish "except in matters affecting other groups or A.A. as a whole".[3] Different cultures affect ritual aspects of meetings, but around the world "many particularities of the AA meeting format can be observed at almost any A.A. gathering".[42]
The "many particularities" (in a closed discussion meeting) basically involve a group of (hopefully no longer drinking) drunks sitting around discussing how their lives are going; coffee is usually available. In larger meetings a microphone gets passed around to any who wish to share, with no need to share if you don't wish to. Most people start their remarks with "I'm (first name), an alcoholic", and the group usually responds Hi (first name). Meetings usually last about an hour; at the end of one drop a dollar in the hat to buy coffee supplies (or not--no big deal), and if you wish to stay and help clean up, wash coffee pot, rearrange chairs, etc, thanks. If not, bye, see you next meeting. Big groups may have several meetings a day in a room specifically funded by AA for that purpose, many just once or twice a week in a church, grange hall, private home, or ??.
 
My opinion is that although sin is definitely addressed in AA morality, it hasn't any bearing on whether AA is religious or not.
Unless you're making a distinction between the concept of Sin as it is used within the framework of Christianity and guilt as an indispensible consequence of violating the precepts of any system of moral values (a distinction which GB does not make; at least, not here), then I have to see that as rather contradictory.

Not sure how this relates to whether AA is religious or not. Could you explain that more clearly.
Not sure if I can, unless you're willing to read at least some of the source material yourself -- but I have a feeling we're going to find out.

As my own tangent, the chapter of the Big Book entitled "We Agnostics" clearly states that using the group, or anything else, as a higher power is is only a start and that true success in AA only comes once one has accepted that there is a universe creating God.
An observation which (for about the gazilionth time) flies in the face of statements like: "Much to our relief, we discovered we did not need to consider another's conception of God" and "When, therefore, we speak to you of God, we mean your own conception of God. This applies, too, to other spiritual expressions which you find in this book", and "As soon as we admitted the possible existence of a Creative Intelligence, a Spirit of the Universe...", etc.

Personally, I reject the existence of God primarily for the same reason that I reject the existence of Leprechuans, or of the Loch Ness monster: a simple lack of evidence -- but that's not the same as rejecting the possibility of the existence of these things, is it? Yet if you subscribe to weak atheism (as do I, though I'm not crazy about the term), does that not also involve at least a tiny "leap of faith"? The so-called strong atheist requires affirmative evidence to support his unbelief. He is the flipside of that rare breed of unbelieving believer who practices the same folly in reverse, basing his belief on the claim that he can provide empirical proof that God does exist. In the final analysis, all of our knowledge is built on fundamental and ultimately unknowable principles. Some of us are just more uncomfortable with that than others.

As far as "using the group as a start" goes, I believe the passage you're referring to actually appears in the 12&12 (on page 27):

"This is only one man's opinion based on his own experience, of course. I must quickly assure you that A.A.'s tread innumerable paths in their quest for faith. If you don't care for the one I've suggested, you'll be sure to discover one that suits if only you look and listen. Many a man like you has begun to solve the problem by the method of substitution. You can, if you wish, make A.A., itself your 'higher power.' Here's a very large group of people who have solved their alcohol problem. In this respect they are certainly a power greater than you, who have not even come close to a solution. Surely you can have faith in them. Even this minimum of faith will be enough. You will find many members who have crossed the threshold just this way. All of them will tell you that, once across, their faith broadened and deepened. Relieved of the alcohol obsession, their lives unaccountably transformed, they came to believe in a Higher Power, and most of them began to talk of God."

So one man's opinion is that "most" of the folks who "crossed the threshold" using the group as a "higher power" ended up "talking about God". We've talked a fair amount about God ourselves since this thread first began, and this is but one thread among a very great many on this forum in which participants have talked about God -- and in very fine detail -- and it's been observed a number of times that a lot more of that goes on around here than does in AA. I'd be interested in seeing what significance can you read into that.

I would say that when the organization sets down the one way change can come about, it is pretty much a set of rules imposed on members.
If "rule number one" is: no rules, is that really a rule? If I build a robot and program it with the instruction: "Do something I didn't tell you to do" -- and it does that -- was the robot obeying my command, or not? The steps (not the "organization", by the way) suggest a direction, but do not presume to dictate a specific destination, and no amount of assertion to the contrary will ever change that fact.

It is the "independent" part we disagree on.
I disagree.

I think you forget just how easy it is to "suggest" things to someone, especially when they are at a low point in their lives, and have it become their "own belief."
I find the scare-quotes appropriate there, as they imply the very thing I'm saying (and it's also very compatible with what Kierkegaard argued) -- that assimilating an external set of standards is not only lazy and dishonest; it also doesn't work. Trying to adhere to a set of standards that force you to violate your own is a recipe for a life lived in deep conflict (hence the anguish often so apparent in self-described "Christians", in my opinion -- as well as Kiergegaard's, by the way).

No, but you are ignoring all the other stuff and focusing on one of the few that is more universal. However, it IS usually an important part of religions.
My argument is that the extent to which AA may properly be regarded as "religious" depends entirely on the degree to which it can be established that the principles on which it is built can rightfully be considered the exclusive intellectual property (if you will) of religions, versus being built on principles that are more universal and more fundamental, regardless of whether they may have spent time in the hands of some religion.
 
Last edited:
I agree with Dymanic (a shock I know). Weak Atheism is Weak Language. Which is why I prefer Agnostic.

Sin is most certainly addressed in the 12 Steps: "defects of character" and "shortcomings" which can only be removed by God. This is not why the 12 Steps are Generally Religious (the God part does that), but it is a clear Specifically Christian concept. There is no question that AA is a Religious Programme built on Christian concepts...But:

Because I've been arguing with UncaYimmy on another thread about the ability (or lack thereof) to choose being a Foodaholic, I thought I would like to reiterate some points of (partial) agreement with the 12 Steps.

I agree that SOME (but not all) people are indeed powerless over alcohol (or other OCD disorders--which is arguably what a "Real" Addiction is), and that in such cases, some sort of intervention is necessary.

And though I do not believe that the programme in and of itself is necessarily effective, I agree that the sense of camaraderie and commiseration in a group can be helpful to SOME people.

As to the Religious aspect of the Programme (the God and Doctrinal stuff), it may be more effective for those who actually believe in that stuff.

There, that's as far as I can go in meeting Dymanic and Alfie partway. :)

But until AA drops the "God Stuff", it will remain a Religious Programme. :p

GB
 
The only religion one finds in an AA meeting is the one they already have and bring with them.
 
What religion did you find in the Big Book that you hadn't brought with you?

Of course, take what you like, leave the rest.

Or have a few more drinks.
 
What religion did you find in the Big Book that you hadn't brought with you?

Of course, take what you like, leave the rest.

Or have a few more drinks.

The over 400 references to God and the related Doctrines.

GB

PS: And the chapter to atheists and agnostics that tells us we really need to find God to make the programme work.
 
Last edited:
Read it again; try for understanding and then Take what you want, leave the rest.
 
Sin is most certainly addressed in the 12 Steps: "defects of character" and "shortcomings" which can only be removed by God.
The 12 Steps refer to wrongful acts, leaving it up to the individual to identify those. They also refer to the causes of those acts (defects of character), also leaving it up to the individual to take responsibility for identifying those. Does the removal process require direct participation on the part of the individual? Yes it does. In fact, there is no direct mention of any role played by anyone other than the alcoholic. What you do defines what you are.

Christianity jumbles the two together. Wrongful acts are sins, and sin is also what causes a person to commit sinful acts. What you are defines what you do:

Why does a sinner sin?
Because he's a sinner; he was born that way; what else would you expect a sinner to do?
What does Christ do for a sinner?
He washes away his sins.
Does this process involve direct participation on the part of the sinner?
Not really.
How does it work exactly?
Sorry, that's proprietary information.
And does this process transform the sinner into a non-sinner?
Nope; he's still a sinner; all fall short of the glory of God; there is not a just man upon earth that doeth good and sinneth not.
Then he will surely commit sinful acts again, won't he?
Count on it.
What if he does?
Lather, rinse, repeat.

Do you not see a difference there?
 
The only religion one finds in an AA meeting is the one they already have and bring with them.
The 12 steps is full of religious references. You tell me, I acknowledge you are more familiar with AA, are the 12 steps, or are they not, central to the AA program?
 
The 12 steps is full of religious references. You tell me, I acknowledge you are more familiar with AA, are the 12 steps, or are they not, central to the AA program?

Indeed they are (central), however they are not a prerequisite to recovery nor membership.

The steps are "suggested as a program for recovery" and one's higher power (that the steps refer to as god) is one - or not - of your own choosing.

Tradition three confirms "the only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking."
 
Last edited:
Based on my experience I can answer your question Marcus ; my AA experience consists of experience at nearly the highest levels of the AA organization (just below Trustee at World Service Headquarters), plus attendance at more than 10,000 meetings over 20+ years in 5 different countries. Additionally, I have been an active participant or leader of Regional, Area, District, and group meetings & Conferences, and have had access to stacks of AA archives not generally available to members of the public (nor to most AA members themselves) - some of these archives were marked with release dates 99 years after Bill's death, and remain sealed to this day.

So, yes indeed - practicing the 12 steps as shown - in detail - in the big book is widely considered absolutely essential to getting (and, perhaps more importantly, remaining) sober. When aaalfie (and a very few others) in this thread keep harping on things such as 'the only requirement for membership is a desire to stop drinking' they are speaking specifically about membership. Membership does not equal getting and maintaining sobriety - as stated (in many different ways, in many different AA core documents) in the big book (I'm paraphrasing here): "We are not cured of Alcoholism - what we have is a daily reprieve based on maintaining a Spiritual Program of Action"
The evidence is clear - AA is a religious & spiritual program best summed up as AA's ABC's (as it is frequently stated in AA meetings and written in the big book):

"(a) That we were alcoholic and could not manage our own lives.
(b) That probably no human power could have relieved our alcoholism.
(c) That God could and would if He were sought."

AA's Big Book, Chapter 5 'How It Works' page 60
 
Last edited:
my AA experience consists of experience at nearly the highest levels

Could you please post an organisational chart (or similar) showing where you might fit into this supposed heirarchy. :confused:

Additionally, I have been an active participant or leader of Regional, Area, District, and group meetings & Conferences,

Leader!?! LOL!
Please explain.
Like me, you have been a "trusted servant" of the group. Methinks your ego gets the better of you. :rolleyes:

and have had access to stacks of AA archives not generally available to members of the public (nor to most AA members themselves) - some of these archives were marked with release dates 99 years after Bill's death, and remain sealed to this day.

Are you suggesting you read the "sealed" archives? Or just the ones available in the central office that thousands of others can access? :confused:

Is there something in these that you have read that is not public knowledge - such as Bills dabblings with psychedelic drugs, Leary, his philandering? If so, let's hear it, if not ......

So, yes indeed - practicing the 12 steps as shown - in detail - in the big book is widely considered absolutely essential to getting (and, perhaps more importantly, remaining) sober.

Perhaps, however they still remain only "suggested" whatever way you wish to try and bend it.
It seems you have managed to maintain sobriety without a higher power within AA, so you might want to explain exactly how this was "abolutely essential" for you. :boggled:
 
Last edited:
Based on my experience I can answer your question Marcus ; my AA experience consists of experience at nearly the highest levels of the AA organization (just below Trustee at World Service Headquarters), plus attendance at more than 10,000 meetings over 20+ years in 5 different countries. Additionally, I have been an active participant or leader of Regional, Area, District, and group meetings & Conferences, and have had access to stacks of AA archives not generally available to members of the public (nor to most AA members themselves) - some of these archives were marked with release dates 99 years after Bill's death, and remain sealed to this day.
As a member of the sooper seekrit inner circle, aren't you violating some kind of oath just by revealing even this much?

(b) That probably no human power could have relieved our alcoholism.
Just thinking how that "probably" thing would fly under Christianity: "We were sinners and probably the only thing that could wash away our sins was the blood of Christ".
 
Leader!?! LOL!
Please explain.
Like me, you have been a "trusted servant" of the group. Methinks your ego gets the better of you. :rolleyes:


Um, you're talking a local group level, Alfie. There is a formal organization with a hierarchical structure, rules of how the money AA brings in gets spent, on what and so on. It's a business, like any other. Why you can't distinguish the two, I don't know.

1.

Final responsibility and ultimate authority for A.A. world services should always reside in the collective conscience of our whole Fellowship.

2.

The General Service Conference of A.A. has become, for nearly every practical purpose, the active voice and the effective conscience of our whole society in its world affairs.

3.

To insure effective leadership, we should endow each element of A.A.—the Conference, the General Service Board and its service corporations, staffs, committees, and executives—with a traditional “Right of Decision.”

4.

At all responsible levels, we ought to maintain a traditional “Right of Participation,” allowing a voting representation in reasonable proportion to the responsibility that each must discharge.

5.

Throughout our structure, a traditional “Right of Appeal” ought to prevail, so that minority opinion will be heard and personal grievances receive careful consideration.

6.

The Conference recognizes that the chief initiative and active responsibility in most world service matters should be exercised by the trustee members of the Conference acting as the General Service Board.

7.

The Charter and Bylaws of the General Service Board are legal instruments, empowering the trustees to manage and conduct world service affairs. The Conference Charter is not a legal document; it relies upon tradition and the A.A. purse for final effectiveness.

8.

The trustees are the principal planners and administrators of over-all policy and finance. They have custodial oversight of the separately incorporated and constantly active services, exercising this through their ability to elect all the directors of these entities.

These are just a few of the rules laid out as fully described in this pdf document.
 
Correct - perhaps I was unclear in my differentiation between the two - apologies. For that quote I was talking about local level. He was no "leader".

And unless Tinyal was on the board of trustees he was merely a trusted servant regardless of his "highest levels" claim. That is why I asked to be shown where he fits in an org chart.

In the meantime, I will await his responses to same, especially how the "absolutely necessary" requirement of a hp works with his sobriety.
 
Correct - perhaps I was unclear in my differentiation between the two - apologies. For that quote I was talking about local level. He was no "leader".

And unless Tinyal was on the board of trustees he was merely a trusted servant regardless of his "highest levels" claim. That is why I asked to be shown where he fits in an org chart.

In the meantime, I will await his responses to same, especially how the "absolutely necessary" requirement of a hp works with his sobriety.


I think it's good that you brought it up so that there is some clarity to this particular sub-issue.

The actual rigid structure of AA has seen no reason to change "what works" and there are no apologies made to the fact that the AA is spiritual. The AA paradigm states very clearly that sobriety can only be achieved through a spiritual program. However, that being said, there are other sobriety-achieving paradigms which, according to the studies that have been done so far, have been "more successful" than AA.

As far as "it's spiritual not religious" I tend to think that ultimately it's a distinction without a difference. The end effect is the same -- the entire AA philosophy and program is specifically laid out to promote a belief in some Other; something indefinable (except where Bill W. et al define this Other as God), yet this Other indefinable thing has a consciousness, ability to control what goes on in your life, and cares about you.

As I've said before, the only way to really get away from the religious nature of AA is to get away from AA. LifeRing, SOS, and Rational Recovery are smaller though at minimum, as effective as AA is in helping people achieve and maintain sobriety (as shown through the studies that have been done on this subject over the past 30 or so years).
 
Based on my experience I can answer your question Marcus ; my AA experience consists of experience at nearly the highest levels of the AA organization (just below Trustee at World Service Headquarters), plus attendance at more than 10,000 meetings over 20+ years in 5 different countries.

Alfie, dymanic...any reason whatsoever not believe this claim?

The evidence is clear - AA is a religious & spiritual program

Alfie, dymanic...it's time for you to admit that your personal views concerning AA are not shared by a majority of those who have "experienced" AA firsthand.

Of course you can believe anything ya want, but as long as "God" is included in the AA steps/literature, it will be looked upon as a religious organization. You may protest that all ya want, but if won't do ya a lick of good.
 
Alfie, dymanic...any reason whatsoever not believe this claim?
Any more or less than any other unverifiable claim made by anonymous internet posters citing themselves as authorities? Not really.

Alfie, dymanic...it's time for you to admit that your personal views concerning AA are not shared by a majority of those who have "experienced" AA firsthand.
My personal views on a number of things are not shared by a majority of any kind. And I'm usually pretty okay with that. In this thread, we're not taking a poll, we're hoping to gain a better understanding of why "people" insist that AA is not religious (whether they represent a majority of AA "experiencers" or not).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom