qayak
Penultimate Amazing
- Joined
- Jul 31, 2006
- Messages
- 13,844
You and GB do not appear to be in agreement on this. Let's ask him.
I don't speak for GB. My opinion is that although sin is definitely addressed in AA morality, it hasn't any bearing on whether AA is religious or not.
Kierkegaard (if I may be forgiven for referring to him yet again) spoke of herds of unbelieving believers. His whole assault on Christiandom was based on its weakening of the individual's sense of responsibility. Newcomers to AA ask the same question that those who attempt to teach art, English composition, or anything that depends so heavily on individual creativity and initiative often regard as their least favorite words to hear from their students: "What am I supposed to do?" The only valid answer possible is: "You are supposed to decide what you are supposed to do". To be sure, some of these newcomers hang around for years without ever really getting that -- but Kierkegaard would have seen it instantly and embraced it enthusiastially. I guarantee it. It is exactly what he was trying to convey with his vitriolic attacks on the priests he called "man-eaters", "liars", "hypocrites", and "destroyers of Christianity".
Not sure how this relates to whether AA is religious or not. Could you explain that more clearly.
As my own tangent, the chapter of the Big Book entitled "We Agnostics" clearly states that using the group, or anything else, as a higher power is is only a start and that true success in AA only comes once one has accepted that there is a universe creating God. It does say that a member can use their own definition of what a "universe creating God" is but only a universe creating God will do.
how does that fit in with your belief that AA is not religious?
Said a mouthful there, you did. But if you're still thinking that those obstacles are imposed externally upon the AA member by a prescribed set of external rules, then all I can say is that you simply could not possibly be more wrong, and our only recourse may be to add this to the list of things we'll never agree on.
I would say that when the organization sets down the one way change can come about, it is pretty much a set of rules imposed on members. That the members "perceive" something different is not unusual. Everyone likes to believe they are free.
My understanding of what we agreed on is that a moral code may exist independent of those formalized systems of thought we refer to as "religions".
It is the "independent" part we disagree on.
"What is good, Phaedrus, and what is not good -- need we ask anyone to tell us these things?" My answer would be: No; we humans possess a unique ability to imagine what it would be like to be in another person's place, and a basic sense of morality would naturally emerge out of that regardless of whether anyone had explicitly spelled out for us a particular set of rules. Reason, evidence and contemplation may help to resolve those specific moral dilemmas we all encounter from time to time, but the fundamental concepts may be aquired intuitively. Nonetheless, during the period when we were aquiring this knowledge, most of us did have someone to "tell us what is good and what is not good":
So if a desperate alcoholic goes looking for a moral code in AA, he'll find one -- but the thing is, won't be AA's moral code; it'll be his moral code; the very one he brought with him the first time he walked in the door. If he experiences a sense of guilt, it will be because of his failure to live up to that code; not someone else's. For that reason, the Big Book's advice is to begin the inventory process by considering one's own resentments and fears and tracing those to their sources: "The first thing apparent was that this world and its people were often quite wrong". "Putting out of our minds the wrongs others had done, we resolutely looked for our own mistakes".
I think you forget just how easy it is to "suggest" things to someone, especially when they are at a low point in their lives, and have it become their "own belief." Religions, cults, the Republicans (kidding) prey on that.
This has been demonstrated time and time again. What you call "suggestions" are, in fact, hard and fast rules to almost anyone under certain conditions. That alcoholism provides a large population of people under those conditions is very important to the success of AA. (I mean success as in "viable organization" here, not as in "cure rate."
Again: Is there something inherently religious about considering where you may have made mistakes and trying to understand what caused you to make them?
No, but you are ignoring all the other stuff and focusing on one of the few that is more universal. However, it IS usually an important part of religions.
