Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Please show me where I said I was an expert.

All through this thread.

Please show everyone how you figure I am a christian counsellor, this is an outright lie.

No. it isn't.

Not even close, what I have seen here is your inability to produce this so called moral code of AA that you invented which you purport to be religious.

I already have and Dynamic agreed there is a moral code in AA.

Now I know you love definitions, so here are a couple that contradict (at least in part) your "list" claim:

Oh, I know a list is one form of a moral code but it isn't the only. The bible has several lists depending on what question is being addressed. Not all are numbered and only taken together can they be called the bible's moral code.

That is the same with AA literature and the Big Book. There are several small lists and individual moral "lessons," when they are taken together they form the moral code of AA.

I think you will also find that the ten commandments might be interpreted as a moral code by Christians, buddism also has a well established moral code (doing a quick google search revealed same) - so much for a lack of lists

Yeah, like the 12 Steps. Also, both religions have other moral lessons through out their texts as do many other religions.

The term moral code (when applied to AA is yours it seems) is yours and the onus of proof (or effort to provide it) is also yours.

Already done. AA has as much a moral code as any religion.

So I ask again, where do we find this moral code?

And I say again, read the book, and literature, you claim to be an expert on.
 
Last edited:
All through this thread.

Lie

No. it isn't.

He he - how very grown up of you.
But, sure it is. Prove it or retract it.

I already have and Dynamic agreed there is amoral code in AA.

So there is a list? I wish you'd make up your mind. :)

And I am not surprised you confuse amoral with moral. ;)

Oh, I know a list is one form of a moral code but it isn't the only. The bible has several lists depending on what question is being addressed. Not all are numbered and only taken together can they be called the bible's moral code.

LOL (again - you really are making my day here)
Backpedalling and flip flopping noted.

That is the same with AA literature and the Big Book. There are several small lists and individual moral "lessons," when they are taken together they form the moral code of AA.

Evidence?
 
Last edited:

Only the part where you deny it.

So there is a list? I wish you'd make up your mind. :)

I never said their wasn't. You came up with the list idea. I said there was more to it than just a list. I was waiting for someone to bring up the ten commandments specifically for their relationship to the 12 Steps. Dynamic beat you to it.

Backpedalling and flip flopping noted.

The problem is that you projected your beliefs onto what I said, creating a strawman that you went on a crusade against. What you see as backpedalling and flip flopping is actually the distruction of your strawman.

Your inability to discern the difference has been noted, in fact, it is number 13, 592 on the list of errors you have made in this thread alone. :p


http://www.aa.org/bigbookonline/en_tableofcnt.cfm
 
Only the part where you deny it.

Then you will have no difficulty in providing evidence, will you?

I never said their wasn't.

orly?

2) A moral code also doesn't need to be specifically written down, it can be expressed by example.
and
If a moral code can only exist if it is written down in the manner you claim, show me one in the bible or other religious text. They don't have them and neither does the religious text known as the Big Book

Lies lies and flip flopping.


Show me where?

Ignore is relooming large.

Please provide evidence that I am "a christian counsellor" or retract it.
 
Last edited:
@Alfie & Dymanic

AA's Moral Code: The 12 Commandments*

Service Material from the General Service Office
THE TWELVE STEPS OF ALCOHOLICS ANONYMOUS

1. We admitted we were powerless over alcohol—that our lives had become
unmanageable.

2. Came to believe that a Power greater than ourselves could restore us to
sanity.

3. Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we
understood Him.

4. Made a searching and fearless moral inventory of ourselves.

5. Admitted to God, to ourselves, and to another human being the exact nature of our wrongs.

6. Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character.

7. Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings.

8. Made a list of all persons we had harmed, and became willing to make
amends to them all.

9. Made direct amends to such people wherever possible, except when to do
so would injure them or others.

10. Continued to take personal inventory and when we were wrong promptly
admitted it.

11. Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with God, as we understood Him, praying only for knowledge of His will for us
and the power to carry that out.

12. Having had a spiritual awakening as the result of these Steps, we tried to
carry this message to alcoholics, and to practice these principles in all our
affairs.

*How many more ******* times do I have to repost this **** for you get shut the hell up with your ******* stupid repetitive questions?

Seriously, you're just deliberately trying to wind us up.You both know very well that a Christian based Religious group has a Religious moral code. So not only are you two pretending AA isn't Religious, you're pretending to be stupid.

I really don't believe either of you are as stupid as that. So you are lying to yourselves, and to us.

GB
 
Apart from making amends to those we have harmed and apologising when we are wrong. What other moral codes/rules are there in those steps. Surely a person's morality needs substantially more than that.

Perhaps "live and let live" is moral code. Sounds like it might seriously undermine society as we know it too :rolleyes:

Where in the 12 steps is this code?
Why do you think it is in there?
I can't see it? Please show me where it is.
 
Apart from making amends to those we have harmed and apologising when we are wrong. What other moral codes/rules are there in those steps. Surely a person's morality needs substantially more than that.

Perhaps "live and let live" is moral code. Sounds like it might seriously undermine society as we know it too :rolleyes:

Where in the 12 steps is this code?
Why do you think it is in there?
I can't see it? Please show me where it is.

I'm sorry. my computer doesn't post in braille.

If you can't see it, get eye surgery.

GB
 
Then you will have no difficulty in providing evidence, will you?

You're right, it was easy. The difficulty is in getting you to read. Your dishonest argument style is not my issue though. The good news is that others who were not sure have read the links I, and others, have posted and came to realize that AA is very religious. Your inability to respond honestly has been a big help in convincing them. Thanks for that.


Aussie speak for "Alfie's got noooooooooothiiiiiiiing!"

and


Lies lies and flip flopping.

Where in the Ten Commandments does it say what a man must do to get into heaven? Where does it say the proper procedure for offering a burnt offering?

You see, Alfie. There isn't an all inclusive list but go ahead, beat it :deadhorse some more!

Show me where?

I gave you the link, your job is to read. I'm :seteacher: not to do your work for you.

Ignore is relooming large.

:dl: I'm shaking in my boots! Not the ignore, Alfie! Not the ignore! :dl:

Please provide evidence that I am "a christian counsellor" or retract it.

You said you didn't want your information posted on the internet. Of course, you have provided ample evidence in this thread, so I don't really know what your concern is. It isn't like you've kept it a secret. :v:
 
Fails fails lies and fails.
Thanks for playing.

I've got a Big Book and 12 Steps full of God and Doctrines to back me up (not to mention letters, biographies, historical evidence, quotes from the founders etc).

Show me your evidence. Oh, that's right, you can't, because you don't have any.

GB
 
Last edited:
sigh.... hang on brains. The onus of proof is on you and Q to show where in the big book this supposed moral code is.

Q reckons posting the big book is proof. I could simply post it back saying "here's mine", but that really wont cut it, will it? :boggled:

You post the 12 steps (for the 83rd time), saying "here's my proof" and again, I could post it back saying "here's mine". Either way it really doesn't give us much detail on the moral lessons that you reckon AA is supposed to be teaching us, does it? :boggled:

I can't disprove something that isn't there.

Show me where this code is.

In the meantime I am waiting on Qayak to prove I said I am an "expert" and I am "a christian counsellor".
Prove it or withdraw it Qayak. Show us what an honest poster really is.
popcorn anyone?:)
 
Last edited:
Apart from making amends to those we have harmed and apologising when we are wrong. What other moral codes/rules are there in those steps. Surely a person's morality needs substantially more than that.

Perhaps "live and let live" is moral code. Sounds like it might seriously undermine society as we know it too :rolleyes:

Where in the 12 steps is this code?
Why do you think it is in there?
I can't see it? Please show me where it is.
Come on now, you've got to see the religious moral teachings, it's right in fromt of you. Turn your will over to God, admit to God your wrongs,ask God to remove your defects, admit when you are wrong to others,(do you do this one?),pray to God to find out what to do, have a spiritual awakening. Clearly religious. The moral code part is incomplete just looking at the twelve steps, but I don't see how you can question its religious nature.
 
Last edited:
... snip ... Clearly religious.

Right now we are discussing this supposed moral code, the one that isn't written down, then it is, but no-one can see it.

The moral code part is incomplete just looking at the twelve steps, .. snip..

And that's why I want them to explain what the moral code is that is being taught. Clearly you don't see it either.
 
Right now we are discussing this supposed moral code, the one that isn't written down, then it is, but no-one can see it.
Okay, but you are not limited to discussing only one thing, you could also discuss the thread topic and tell me how AA can be not religious when the 12 steps is full of religion.
And that's why I want them to explain what the moral code is that is being taught. Clearly you don't see it either.
I see two moral strictures in the 12 steps, perhaps there are others in the assorted AA literature, I don't know. Perhaps at meetings they talk about a moral code similiar to the Christian one they are so obviously inspired by, just speculation on my part. I can easily envision discussions about how suicide is immoral(through drinking), how it is wrong to harm loved ones, or stray from your marrige because of drink.
 
Perhaps at meetings they talk about a moral code similiar to the Christian one they are so obviously inspired by, just speculation on my part.
If your speculations concerning reality are usually that disconnected from reality you are in deep trouble.

I can easily envision discussions about how suicide is immoral(through drinking), how it is wrong to harm loved ones, or stray from your marrige because of drink.
Your envisoning isn't working well either.

But go ahead and share your lack of knowledge of AA as others here are more than willing to do.
 
If your speculations concerning reality are usually that disconnected from reality you are in deep trouble.


Your envisoning isn't working well either.

But go ahead and share your lack of knowledge of AA as others here are more than willing to do.
Don't you get it? By stating my lack of knowledge, I'm inviting those who have experience with AA to tell me what goes on at the meetings. You have told me that my suppositions are incorrect, which is fine, but your need to include the insults is telling in the context of this thread.
 
Dymanic said:
The stuff about sin and such is at the very heart of this discussion.
No, no it isn't.

You and GB do not appear to be in agreement on this. Let's ask him.

It is the lowest form of democracy, akin to mob rule. It is more accurately defined as group think or herd behaviour as I cited yesterday.
Kierkegaard (if I may be forgiven for referring to him yet again) spoke of herds of unbelieving believers. His whole assault on Christiandom was based on its weakening of the individual's sense of responsibility. Newcomers to AA ask the same question that those who attempt to teach art, English composition, or anything that depends so heavily on individual creativity and initiative often regard as their least favorite words to hear from their students: "What am I supposed to do?" The only valid answer possible is: "You are supposed to decide what you are supposed to do". To be sure, some of these newcomers hang around for years without ever really getting that -- but Kierkegaard would have seen it instantly and embraced it enthusiastially. I guarantee it. It is exactly what he was trying to convey with his vitriolic attacks on the priests he called "man-eaters", "liars", "hypocrites", and "destroyers of Christianity".

But even at the individual level there are still a lot of obstacles to change.
Said a mouthful there, you did. But if you're still thinking that those obstacles are imposed externally upon the AA member by a prescribed set of external rules, then all I can say is that you simply could not possibly be more wrong, and our only recourse may be to add this to the list of things we'll never agree on.

I already have and Dynamic agreed there is a moral code in AA.
My understanding of what we agreed on is that a moral code may exist independent of those formalized systems of thought we refer to as "religions".

"What is good, Phaedrus, and what is not good -- need we ask anyone to tell us these things?" My answer would be: No; we humans possess a unique ability to imagine what it would be like to be in another person's place, and a basic sense of morality would naturally emerge out of that regardless of whether anyone had explicitly spelled out for us a particular set of rules. Reason, evidence and contemplation may help to resolve those specific moral dilemmas we all encounter from time to time, but the fundamental concepts may be aquired intuitively. Nonetheless, during the period when we were aquiring this knowledge, most of us did have someone to "tell us what is good and what is not good":
3)It began with my parents...
So if a desperate alcoholic goes looking for a moral code in AA, he'll find one -- but the thing is, won't be AA's moral code; it'll be his moral code; the very one he brought with him the first time he walked in the door. If he experiences a sense of guilt, it will be because of his failure to live up to that code; not someone else's. For that reason, the Big Book's advice is to begin the inventory process by considering one's own resentments and fears and tracing those to their sources: "The first thing apparent was that this world and its people were often quite wrong". "Putting out of our minds the wrongs others had done, we resolutely looked for our own mistakes".

Again: Is there something inherently religious about considering where you may have made mistakes and trying to understand what caused you to make them?

There are certain sets of moral precepts under which harming one's own loved ones is not merely allowed, and not merely encouraged, but obligatory. If there has ever been a man who had so thoroughly assimilated such a set of "moral" codes that in the interest of conforming to that he could stone his own daughter to death -- for any reason -- without incurring a huge debt in guilt from another, more fundamental set of moral codes, then I'm not even sure I want to know that. But, hypothetically, if he truly was free of a sense of guilt from that, such a person would have no reason to include such acts on his list of wrongdoings.
 
I'm inviting those who have experience with AA to tell me what goes on at the meetings.
If you are sincere in this, then you must understand that not one person has taken this approach in 70 pages of discussion. We're still in shock.
 
If you are sincere in this, then you must understand that not one person has taken this approach in 70 pages of discussion. We're still in shock.
I am sincere, I don't have anything against AA. They do appear to have some strong religious ties, but if they are sucessfull at treating alcoholics, to me this is something that can be overlooked, no one (and no organization) is perfect.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom