The stuff about sin and such is at the very heart of this discussion.
No, no it isn't.
Democracy comes to mind: noble, but not so practical.
It is the lowest form of democracy, akin to mob rule. It is more accurately defined as group think or herd behaviour as I cited yesterday.
Not quite sure what you're getting at here, but you must know that what happens at the level of AA's organizational structure and what happens at the level of the individual AA member are two entirely different things.
Well, I wouldn't say "entirely" different. Somewhat different in that an individual can easily meet with other members in their local meeting which is more likely to result in change where as that same member hasn't got a hope in hell of changing anything on a larger scale. But even at the individual level there are still a lot of obstacles to change.
A member's concept of a "higher power" (or the lack thereof) is not submitted to the "group conscience" as if it were some decision on whether to purchase a new coffeepot, if that's what you're thinking.
You have obviously NOT read the Big Book. Read the chapter entitled "We Agnostics" and you will see that AA is definitely talking about nothing short of the Creator of the Universe being everyone's higher power. The only leeway they give is to allow the individual to use their own interpretation of what that Creator is. Go ahead and read it.
You will also notice that AA is a Creationist organization.

'Tis true.
Not it at all, really. Even those members of AA who are religious often say, "I go to AA to get the things I can't get at church, and I go to church to get the things I can't get at AA" -- or something along those lines.
Not that what you say here makes one bit of difference, but have you polled all the members of AA and come up with 51% agreement on that? Please submit the data.
What difference does it make if someone doesn't get all their religion at one place?
Hello....? The Commandments?.
Thank you! I was hoping someone would mention those. Do you see the similarity to the 12 Steps? A bunch of rules on how to worship God followed by a couple of moral do's and don'ts.
No need to go looking for scattered tidbits. The guideline is quite explicit: Look at those things in your life that have brought resentment and fear. (Page 64).
Well, there's a lot more than that. Anyone who has read the Big Book knows, which is how I know Alfie hasn't read it.
1) You are powerless and it is wrong to think otherwise.
2) It is wrong to think for yourself and right to turn your thinking over to God.
3) You must make amends for all wrongs, real and perceived.
4) You must humbly ask God to remove your short comings.
It's making me puke just writing these!
