Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Now to address the real issue I see in the portion of your post I quoted: Why do you think that I must have a moral compass based on religion?
You too, qayak? Someone who missed big chunks of this discussion might easily be forgiven for mistaking that as my position, but I know for certain that you have been following right along. Is it not obvious to you that I am arguing against the notion that religion is the only possible basis for judging right from wrong? That Christianity has wrongfully claimed as its own fundamental principles it absorbed from earlier systems of thought? How far back would you have to go to find me saying exactly that? (I'll give you a hint: six posts above yours). Have you missed all of the other times I've said something like this?:

"Do you agree with those Christians who regard atheists as immoral (the more sophisticated ones might say "amoral") due to a lack of any possible basis for judging right from wrong?"

One more question: Why do you think AA is better with a religious foundation than it would be without it?
Quote me saying anything remotely suggesting that I think that.
 
That no refutation was ever done and presented in this thread might be telling.

As I posted before, AA ranks 38th out of 48 measured treatment modalities.
Compiling meaningful stats for a group of people who tend to wish to remain anonymous might be a problem, but none of the modalities accomplish good recovery stats with (self-admitted) alcoholics.


AA is specifically designed as a spiritual program. There is, IMO, no reason to go to AA if you don't have even a slightest interest in the woo of spirituality.
Then don't. If you get a court-ordered stretch, fight it as being illegal, or grin and bear it for the few meetings you'd be required to attend. Cost=0.


Again, there have been posted many secular alternatives which provide all the benefits of the group support, sharing of experiences, and so on that AA provides without the religious or spiritual verbiage.
They just charge for their services, and offer no better recovery rates than any other method, again for individuals who are alcoholics.

Most AAers probably tried one or more over the years before finally admitting their problems were actually due to alcoholism, ending up and staying with AA. Jails, institutions, and death eventually lose their appeal.
 
That you see it as an insult indicates that you have no idea where I'm coming from with this.

Yeah...it must be MY misperception, because it couldn't possibily be yours...sheesh...

Your faked "surprise" that someone not religious could understand the concept of right and wrong was insulting...understand now??
 
Your faked "surprise" that someone not religious could understand the concept of right and wrong was insulting...understand now??
Strange. I read the exchange as asking what you base your concepts of right and wrong on since it apparently isn't religion.

How do you think the culture you live in defined them before instilling them in your worldview when you were a child?
 
Yeah...it must be MY misperception, because it couldn't possibily be yours...sheesh...

Your faked "surprise" that someone not religious could understand the concept of right and wrong was insulting...understand now??
You're so lost you don't even realize you're lost.
 
You really need to qualify your opinion. You can only speak of AA meetings in Australia as you have no "experience" with AA meetings in the US.

Perhaps. But then by extension, if one doesn't go to, or has never attended AA they shouldn't be posting here?

Why don't you rephrase this to be less insulting.

So only drunks can discuss AA, and only those that are "religious" can "judge" right from wrong??

Does anyone else have a "problem" with this??

Wow! :jaw-dropp
Where did that come from?

You're so lost you don't even realize you're lost.

Denial?
 
Last edited:
You too, qayak? Someone who missed big chunks of this discussion might easily be forgiven for mistaking that as my position, but I know for certain that you have been following right along. Is it not obvious to you that I am arguing against the notion that religion is the only possible basis for judging right from wrong? That Christianity has wrongfully claimed as its own fundamental principles it absorbed from earlier systems of thought? How far back would you have to go to find me saying exactly that? (I'll give you a hint: six posts above yours). Have you missed all of the other times I've said something like this?:

Yes, I have read all this thread but you have said a lot of things in one post that contradicted other things you have said in other posts. I responded to the particular question aimed at me. You were off on some tangent about R.A.F.'s reasons for posting in the thread. That's none of my business but you asked a question of me that I responded to.

There is more to respond to in that post and I will.

"Do you agree with those Christians who regard atheists as immoral (the more sophisticated ones might say "amoral") due to a lack of any possible basis for judging right from wrong?"

No, and if you had read my last post to you, who would already know that.

Quote me saying anything remotely suggesting that I think that.

Right here:

I know you identify yourself as a non-religous person, yet you evidently do have some basis for judging right from wrong. Is that basis inherently religious in nature and origin? If not, what is its nature, and where did it originate? I'm now putting these questions to you, as GB has avoided answering them directly -- despite having consistently shown no hesitation whatsoever in deriding certain of AA's steps as equating to the process of confession and absolution from SIN as practiced by, say, Catholics; and despite having repeatedly espoused a love for "willingness to engage in honest debate".

The fact that those Steps come from a religion has no bearing on whether my moral compass, or GB's for that matter, is religion based or not. AA's moral code must stand on its own regardless of where mine came from. If mine came from religion and I thought AA's was wrong, it would have no bearing on whether AA's was actually wrong or not.

Bill W. and others stated exactly where the Big Book and AA came from and that was their religion. You can't dispute that, it's fact. Nothing significant has happened in AA over the years to change the foundation, meaning, and practice of the original. It is still religion based and a religious organization. The collective conscious has never seen fit to leave that in the past.

Here's the disconnect. A few individuals claim that the collective consciousness model of organization is a noble and practical thing. They then go on to say that AA isn't religious because they, and a few other individuals, belong and aren't religious. They forget that they, and the few, are NOT the collective conscious. They do not recognize that this is what makes the collective conscious model of organization so ignoble. They think the organization has changed because they have but the organization doesn't care about them and its organizational structure makes sure that their advances never become the norm.

AA hasn't changed even if you have.
 
Compiling meaningful stats for a group of people who tend to wish to remain anonymous might be a problem, but none of the modalities accomplish good recovery stats with (self-admitted) alcoholics.

'Tis true but it is disingenuous to make claims regarding the effectiveness of AA knowing full well that there is no basis for the claims because of the issue you raise. With that being the case, why do AA'ers and AA itself, do that?
 
The fact that those Steps come from a religion has no bearing on whether my moral compass, or GB's for that matter, is religion based or not. AA's moral code must stand on its own regardless of where mine came from. If mine came from religion and I thought AA's was wrong, it would have no bearing on whether AA's was actually wrong or not.

Can you explain to us what AAs moral code is, what it teaches, and where it outlines same?
 
One more question: Why do you think AA is better with a religious foundation than it would be without it?

Quote me saying anything remotely suggesting that I think that.



It's heavily implied by your actions defending AA's usage of the word God, Him, and so on; why AA shouldn't remove those words; that a mere definitional change is enough to render the whole concept null.

So -- you never explicitly said such. Still, what would your answer be to the question posed?
 
Here's the disconnect. A few individuals claim that the collective consciousness model of organization is a noble and practical thing. They then go on to say that AA isn't religious because they, and a few other individuals, belong and aren't religious. They forget that they, and the few, are NOT the collective conscious. They do not recognize that this is what makes the collective conscious model of organization so ignoble. They think the organization has changed because they have but the organization doesn't care about them and its organizational structure makes sure that their advances never become the norm.

AA hasn't changed even if you have.



QFT.
 
Yes, I have read all this thread but you have said a lot of things in one post that contradicted other things you have said in other posts.
Challenged to quote me saying anything remotely suggesting that I think that "AA is better with a religious foundation than it would be without it", you point to this statement: "I know you identify yourself as a non-religous person, yet you evidently do have some basis for judging right from wrong". I know that you have read, but the ridiculous mistake you've just made indicates that you either have not understood or not remembered. Perhaps a bit of review will help to clarify:

Suppose that floating around somewhere out there in idea-space there were certain ideas that happened to work out pretty well as a set of guidelines for keeping human societies running smoothly: Don't kill each other, don't steal each other's stuff, etc. By and by, along comes this organized system which eventually comes to be called "Christianity", and it subsumes these ideas and presents them (along with some others) as a formalized set of "commandments". Now, I would argue that (aside from the others I mentioned, which are based on purely supernatural claims), people didn't really need to have these ideas spelled out for them. They emerge naturally as consequences of societies comprised of individuals who need to be able to work together cooperatively despite frequently being in competition with each other at the same time. Even some animal societies (examples on request) exhibit systems for rewarding cooperators and punishing defectors. But Christianity begins by claiming original authorship of these ideas, and then goes on to add another layer: the concept of sin.

According to the best picture I've got of how this sin thing works, you can follow every one of those commandments to the letter and you still won't be free of sin, because you're an heir to the original sin of Adam and Eve. The only way clear of that is grace through His only begotten Son bla bla bla and at about this point is where my inability to resolve what I see as some rather glaring logical inconsistencies begins to preclude any possibility there might have ever been of my becoming a Christian.

My point is this: by refusing to differentiate between the original substrate (the pretty good ideas for getting along) and the overlay (the supernatural claims) -- which is what you are doing when you equate "making amends" with seeking "absolution from sin" -- you are not only throwing the baby out with the bathwater; you're also co-signing Christianity's illegitimate claim to those ideas.
 
Challenged to quote me saying anything remotely suggesting that I think that "AA is better with a religious foundation than it would be without it", you point to this statement: "I know you identify yourself as a non-religous person, yet you evidently do have some basis for judging right from wrong". I know that you have read, but the ridiculous mistake you've just made indicates that you either have not understood or not remembered. Perhaps a bit of review will help to clarify:

You are correct. My bad.

I don't recall my ever being a part of any discussion about sin and I didn't really understand why you were asking me those questions because I had not engaged. I only answered because that post seemed to make it clear that you felt that morality was best, or could only be, based on religion and it also seemed that you were saying that AA is best with a religious basis. The stuff in this thread about sin and such, I didn't much more than scan and realize I wasn't interested.

I guess that's where the confusing lies but I do wish one of the AA supporters would address the issue about the 'collective conscious' I brought up. To recap:

Here's the disconnect. A few individuals claim that the collective consciousness model of organization is a noble and practical thing. They then go on to say that AA isn't religious because they, and a few other individuals, belong and aren't religious. They forget that they, and the few, are NOT the collective conscious. They do not recognize that this is what makes the collective conscious model of organization so ignoble. They think the organization has changed because they have but the organization doesn't care about them and its organizational structure makes sure that their advances never become the norm.

AA hasn't changed even if they have.
 
The fact that those Steps come from a religion has no bearing on whether my moral compass, or GB's for that matter, is religion based or not. AA's moral code must stand on its own regardless of where mine came from. If mine came from religion and I thought AA's was wrong, it would have no bearing on whether AA's was actually wrong or not.

Can you explain to us what AAs moral code is, what it teaches, and where it outlines same?

Waiting.....
 
Waiting.....

It's tempting to just write "I hear you knocking" like you but . . .

That's like asking "what's the bible's moral code, where is it found, and what does it teach? and expecting someone to type it all out for you. We both know that isn't going to happen and if it did, just like the bible, not everyone would agree. However:

1) 12 Steps.

2) A moral code also doesn't need to be specifically written down, it can be expressed by example. AA teaches that it is okay to lie as long as it serves AA's purposes. That's what success rate claims without evidence are. That's what claiming to be non-religious while being completely religious is.

3) Much like the bible, moral tidbits are scattered all through the Big Book. Here's a few:

a) Final responsibility and ultimate authority for A.A. world services should always reside in the collective conscience of our whole Fellowship.

b) That means we have written a book which we believe to be spiritual as well as moral. And it means, of course, that we are going to talk about God.

c) We talked of intolerance while we were intolerant ourselves.

4) See, especially, the personal stories in the Big Book.

I will stop here. You claim to be a long standing member of AA and to be an expert on it and alcoholic treatment. I really don't see how that is possible with how much has to be explained to you about AA literature and the Big Book. I am pretty sure you are a christian counsellor more than a counsellor for alcoholics.
 
That's like asking "what's the bible's moral code, where is it found, and what does it teach?

Not being an expert on Christianity, I really wouldn't know where it is found in the bible.
But you made a statement that this moral code is found in the big book/AA. Where?

1) 12 Steps.

Except for apoloigising when we are wrong and/or making amends, I don't see to much there associated with moral values. Nor what "harm" means when applied to AA. It seems to me it is something the individual has to decide for themselves.
So. Fail here

2) A moral code also doesn't need to be specifically written down, it can be expressed by example.

So how does AA stand by its moral code if it doesn't know what it is and it's not written down?

AA teaches that it is okay to lie as long as it serves AA's purposes.

Please show me where.

That's what success rate claims without evidence are.

Where are these claims made and what are they precisely?

That's what claiming to be non-religious while being completely religious is.

That is where we are having a difference of opinion, nothing factual here.

So... #2: Fail

3) Much like the bible, moral tidbits are scattered all through the Big Book. Here's a few:

a) Final responsibility and ultimate authority for A.A. world services should always reside in the collective conscience of our whole Fellowship.

Is this a moral code, or practical/procedural code?

b) That means we have written a book which we believe to be spiritual as well as moral. And it means, of course, that we are going to talk about God.

Can you show me where this is written? Or is this just another of your opinions?

c) We talked of intolerance while we were intolerant ourselves.

... when we were drinking you mean?

#3: Fail

4) See, especially, the personal stories in the Big Book.

Individual stories (as you have pointed out time and again) are not AA.

#4: Fail

I will stop here. You claim to be a long standing member of AA and to be an expert on it and alcoholic treatment.

I never claimed to be an expert, but I believe I speak with some authority. :)
But yes, 11 years sober and a professional AOD counsellor (among other disciplines).

I am pretty sure you are a christian counsellor more than a counsellor for alcoholics.

And I am positive you are wrong. So much for your opinion.

So, let's review:

Fail, fail, fail, fail and wrong.

Thanks for playing.
 
Last edited:
Not being an expert on Christianity, I really wouldn't know where it is found in the bible.

You claim to be a AA expert and can't find anything in the Big Book, it isn't surprising that being a christian counsellor doesn't help you find things in the bible. :rolleyes:

But you made a statement that this moral code is found in the big book/AA. Where?

You mistakenly interpret that to mean there is a numbered list and will now hide behind your error like no one can see through your tactic.

:dl: Good luck with that.

If a moral code can only exist if it is written down in the manner you claim, show me one in the bible or other religious text. They don't have them and neither does the religious text known as the Big Book but all have moral codes written in them. If you punch "moral code" into your search engine, you will see that many of the moral codes listed are in the exact form they take in the Big Book and that I have given examples of already.

The fail is yours as per usual. Come to think of it, you haven't done well in this thread. You've been pwned by everyone you crawl out from behind your ignore button to engage.
 
The stuff in this thread about sin and such, I didn't much more than scan and realize I wasn't interested.
The stuff about sin and such is at the very heart of this discussion.

A few individuals claim that the collective consciousness model of organization is a noble and practical thing.
Democracy comes to mind: noble, but not so practical. Not quite sure what you're getting at here, but you must know that what happens at the level of AA's organizational structure and what happens at the level of the individual AA member are two entirely different things. A member's concept of a "higher power" (or the lack thereof) is not submitted to the "group conscience" as if it were some decision on whether to purchase a new coffeepot, if that's what you're thinking.

They then go on to say that AA isn't religious because they, and a few other individuals, belong and aren't religious.
Not it at all, really. Even those members of AA who are religious often say, "I go to AA to get the things I can't get at church, and I go to church to get the things I can't get at AA" -- or something along those lines.

That's like asking "what's the bible's moral code, where is it found, and what does it teach?
Hello....? The Commandments?.

Much like the bible, moral tidbits are scattered all through the Big Book.
No need to go looking for scattered tidbits. The guideline is quite explicit: Look at those things in your life that have brought resentment and fear. (Page 64). Søren ("Truth is Subjectivity") Kierkegaard would have loved it.
 
You claim to be a AA expert and can't find anything in the Big Book, it isn't surprising that being a christian counsellor doesn't help you find things in the bible.

Hehe.
Please show me where I said I was an expert.
Please show everyone how you figure I am a christian counsellor, this is an outright lie.

You mistakenly interpret that to mean there is a numbered list and will now hide behind your error like no one can see through your tactic.

Not even close, what I have seen here is your inability to produce this so called moral code of AA that you invented which you purport to be religious.

Now I know you love definitions, so here are a couple that contradict (at least in part) your "list" claim:

Definitions of Moral code on the Web:

•Morality (from the Latin moralitas "manner, character, proper behavior") is a system of conduct and ethics that is virtuous. It can also be used in regard to sexual matters and chastity. ...
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Moral_code

•A written, formal, and consistent set of moral rules, accepted by a person or by a group of peopleen.wiktionary.org/wiki/moral_code

I think you will also find that the ten commandments might be interpreted as a moral code by Christians, buddism also has a well established moral code (doing a quick google search revealed same) - so much for a lack of lists

The term moral code (when applied to AA is yours it seems) is yours and the onus of proof (or effort to provide it) is also yours.

So I ask again, where do we find this moral code?
 
The stuff about sin and such is at the very heart of this discussion.

No, no it isn't.

Democracy comes to mind: noble, but not so practical.

It is the lowest form of democracy, akin to mob rule. It is more accurately defined as group think or herd behaviour as I cited yesterday.

Not quite sure what you're getting at here, but you must know that what happens at the level of AA's organizational structure and what happens at the level of the individual AA member are two entirely different things.

Well, I wouldn't say "entirely" different. Somewhat different in that an individual can easily meet with other members in their local meeting which is more likely to result in change where as that same member hasn't got a hope in hell of changing anything on a larger scale. But even at the individual level there are still a lot of obstacles to change.

A member's concept of a "higher power" (or the lack thereof) is not submitted to the "group conscience" as if it were some decision on whether to purchase a new coffeepot, if that's what you're thinking.

You have obviously NOT read the Big Book. Read the chapter entitled "We Agnostics" and you will see that AA is definitely talking about nothing short of the Creator of the Universe being everyone's higher power. The only leeway they give is to allow the individual to use their own interpretation of what that Creator is. Go ahead and read it.

You will also notice that AA is a Creationist organization. :D 'Tis true.

Not it at all, really. Even those members of AA who are religious often say, "I go to AA to get the things I can't get at church, and I go to church to get the things I can't get at AA" -- or something along those lines.

Not that what you say here makes one bit of difference, but have you polled all the members of AA and come up with 51% agreement on that? Please submit the data.

What difference does it make if someone doesn't get all their religion at one place?

Hello....? The Commandments?.

Thank you! I was hoping someone would mention those. Do you see the similarity to the 12 Steps? A bunch of rules on how to worship God followed by a couple of moral do's and don'ts.

No need to go looking for scattered tidbits. The guideline is quite explicit: Look at those things in your life that have brought resentment and fear. (Page 64).

Well, there's a lot more than that. Anyone who has read the Big Book knows, which is how I know Alfie hasn't read it.

1) You are powerless and it is wrong to think otherwise.

2) It is wrong to think for yourself and right to turn your thinking over to God.

3) You must make amends for all wrongs, real and perceived.

4) You must humbly ask God to remove your short comings.

It's making me puke just writing these! :D
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom