Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
I can see the difference, did I ever say otherwise.

But you agreed - re spiritually - that individual members are "free to interpret these values as they think best, or not to think about them at all."

If it were a religious program, one would think these were requirements, not options. I understood that you had been saying all along they were a requirement?

So, in answer to the OP's question "why do people insist AA is not religious?" The answer is simple, it is because one has a choice as to whether to buy into all the "suggestions" and/or, we consider it a spiritual program, not religious. And those that care, see a huge differencve between the two ideas.
 
Just so you understand: Kierkegaard's point was not that truth is subjective, but that truth is subjectivity; that is, what is most important is how one stands in relation to objective truth.

:confused:

Sorry, but your personal interpretation of the meaning of a word is irrelevant. Only dictionary definitions allowed here.

Is that a joke, or did you finally realize something ?
 
Is that a joke, or did you finally realize something ?
Yes, Belz, it was a joke.

Yes, and deriding it is definitely not.
I don't disagree. But suspicions have often arisen in this thread regarding the personal motives of the posters -- hardly surprising, considering the wording of the question the OP asks. It is, in fact, a question about motives.

It also happens to be a question which assumes its own answer: they're lying. One poster condescendingly allows for another possibility -- they're deluded -- and shamelessly cites himself as an authority:
On the other hand, I understand human nature and I understand why someone with so much vested interest in "the program" will defend it beyond the rational.

The OP's question can be turned around: "Why do people insist that AA is religious?" -- which (taking the same sorts of liberties the OP took) can be expanded to: "Why would anyone bother to contribute hundreds of posts to a thread concerned with claims made by members of an organization he does not even belong to?" Some of these posters have responded to that with sort of mumbled references to Sense of Duty, Committment to Truth, etc. -- and I regard those as admirable, when genuine -- but if there is an obligation here to accept these sorts of claims at face value, what happens to the indictments implicit in the OP, and everything that follows that?

I suspect that the most parsimonious explanation of RAF's motive is best expressed by this quote, which I liked very much (and which I will leave unattributed as it appears to have been edited out of the original post): "Our interest is the same is yours, we like arguing on forums about topics that interest us." It's worth noting that this also assumes an ability to penetrate the motives of others, but I suppose we're pretty much sunk if we can't presume to be able to make some reasonably accurate guesses about that.

Leaving guesswork aside and taking RAF's stated reason for posting to this thread at face value, what I'd like to know is this: Why is a sense of duty noble and admirable, and why is deriding it ignoble and contemptible? I know you identify yourself as a non-religous person, yet you evidently do have some basis for judging right from wrong. Is that basis inherently religious in nature and origin? If not, what is its nature, and where did it originate? I'm now putting these questions to you, as GB has avoided answering them directly -- despite having consistently shown no hesitation whatsoever in deriding certain of AA's steps as equating to the process of confession and absolution from SIN as practiced by, say, Catholics; and despite having repeatedly espoused a love for "willingness to engage in honest debate".
 
Pardon the interruption, I was just wondering something.

There is no doubt in my mind that AA is religious, as evidenced by the language in the 12 steps, But I was also under the impression that it was an effective program.

Has anyone introduced data that directly addresses the effectiveness of AA?
 
There is no doubt in my mind that AA is religious, as evidenced by the language in the 12 steps, But I was also under the impression that it was an effective program.

Well, yes and no. :) Since there is no such thing as god, when an AAer "relies" on god as a higher power to achieve his sobriety, he is actually relying on himself. Neither god nor AA can keep a person from drinking...for that, you really must rely on yourself.

Of course if you were to say this at an AA meeting, you'd get pelted by cigarettes and cups of coffee. :)

Has anyone introduced data that directly addresses the effectiveness of AA?

I imagine that sort of data would be similar to studies done on the effectiveness of prayer. But to answer your question, I am unaware of any such data existing anywhere.
 
So, in answer to the OP's question "why do people insist AA is not religious?" The answer is simple, it is because one has a choice as to whether to buy into all the "suggestions" and/or, we consider it a spiritual program, not religious. And those that care, see a huge differencve between the two ideas.

You really need to qualify your opinion. You can only speak of AA meetings in Australia as you have no "experience" with AA meetings in the US.
 
I know you identify yourself as a non-religous person, yet you evidently do have some basis for judging right from wrong.

Why don't you rephrase this to be less insulting.

Is that basis inherently religious in nature and origin?

So only drunks can discuss AA, and only those that are "religious" can "judge" right from wrong??

Does anyone else have a "problem" with this??
 
Pardon the interruption, I was just wondering something.

There is no doubt in my mind that AA is religious, as evidenced by the language in the 12 steps, But I was also under the impression that it was an effective program.

Has anyone introduced data that directly addresses the effectiveness of AA?

According to some posts upthread, AA is about as successful as quitting on your own.
 
Why don't you rephrase this to be less insulting.
That you see it as an insult indicates that you have no idea where I'm coming from with this. Can it be that you've skipped significant portions of the thread?

So only drunks can discuss AA
Quote me saying anything of the sort.

...and only those that are "religious" can "judge" right from wrong??
Obviously not, as it's being done here. Whether there is a legitimate basis for a non-religious person to make such judgements depends on whether religion (we were specifically talking about Christianity) invented such concepts as "good verus evil" and "just versus unjust" (in which case making those sorts of judgements is an inherently religious practice) or merely absorbed them from earlier, more fundamental systems of thought and then appointed themselves their rightful custodians (a claim which I dispute, in case you can't figure it out). It is an inquiry into the nature of religiosity.
 
According to some posts upthread, AA is about as successful as quitting on your own.
Very true; many drunks have quit hundreds of times. AA provides what is actually CBT coping techniques to assist in having it last longer than overnight.

And of course in the final analysis you are the only thing who can stop you from drinking.
 
I imagine that sort of data would be similar to studies done on the effectiveness of prayer. But to answer your question, I am unaware of any such data existing anywhere.

According to some posts upthread, AA is about as successful as quitting on your own.

I wouldn't mind the religious stuff if the program is effective, that seems to be in doubt.

The AA language does imply that supernatural beliefs are required to succeed, perhaps so many people wouldn't be put off if they used "The Secular 12 Steps".
 
AA provides what is actually CBT coping techniques to assist in having it last longer than overnight.

Religious based training that are as much to do with indoctrinating people as they are with helping drunks.

And of course in the final analysis you are the only thing who can stop you from drinking.

Exactly! The 12 Steps and all the other "god does it" tripe that AA pushes are all lies. What took you so long to figure it out?
 
Do you see the matter of effectiveness having any direct bearing on the stated topic of this thread?
No. it's off topic. It doesn't seem like that heinous of a derail though, it's not like we have a lot of threads about AA. Also, the people who insist AA is not religious have already told us why.
 
I know you identify yourself as a non-religous person, yet you evidently do have some basis for judging right from wrong. Is that basis inherently religious in nature and origin? If not, what is its nature, and where did it originate?

First, to answer your questions:

1) The basis and origin of my moral compas is not religious.

2) The basis is reason, evidence and contemplation.

3)It began with my parents who encouraged me to consider all sides of issues. It continued as I grew and became aware of all sorts of other moral questions that I was going to have to deal with.

My one time attendance at church ended with my being kicked out of Sunday school at the age of eight for asking simple questions. I never went back, a) because I thought it was completely childish and b) because there were a lot better things to be doing on a Sunday morning.

4) I became aware that religion really had nothing to say about morality in grade school by the simple fact that in a discussion of a moral question religious people who based their morality on the bible, often came to two different conclusions. They both claimed they were right because the bible said so. I came to believe that the bible could be used to justify any behaviour and that religious people didn't have a bible based morality. They had their own code that they used the bible to justify.

I first read the bible in my first year of high school, to find out if what I suspected was true. It was very true. I became aware that adages were used in much the same way, "The early bird catches the worm" if you succeeded, "Fools rush in where angels fear to tread," if you didn't.

So, that was the origin and basis of my morality.

Now to address the real issue I see in the portion of your post I quoted: Why do you think that I must have a moral compass based on religion? What evidence do you have that such a basis is possible? Or desireable?

You see, I didn't decide religious based morality was bad because I was an atheist and disliked religion so I was looking to justify what I already believed. I wasn't an atheist. I didn't know what one was and I didn't extend my lack of god believe past the fact that I didn't belief in any god. I came to the conclusion about religious based morality by observing religious people addressing moral issues, issues that I had some knowledge of and had considered on my own. I never could understand why it was wrong to do something only because God supposedly had someone write it in the bible. I knew there were a lot of reasons why murder was wrong but "It says so in the bible" isn't one of them.

That is what I also don't understand about this thread. Many here fear AA changing because it will eliminate the effectiveness of AA. To me, that's like saying "AA is effective because God said so!" If that were true, or even possible, I can understand where their fear comes from. There is no other reason for it.

Like I have said, there are many organizations that had a religious based beginning. So changed, some won't. The ones that won't are always at the centre of conflicts with the people they exclude while the others tend not to be in conflict because there is no conflict.

The other important thing is that the organizations that changed have not disappeared. They are just as vital, or more so, than they were before. So the fear of an organization disappearing because of a change, is unfounded.

One more question: Why do you think AA is better with a religious foundation than it would be without it?
 
Pardon the interruption, I was just wondering something.

There is no doubt in my mind that AA is religious, as evidenced by the language in the 12 steps, But I was also under the impression that it was an effective program.

Has anyone introduced data that directly addresses the effectiveness of AA?


Yes, I have several times after another poster linked this:

http://www.behaviortherapy.com/whatworks.htm

Godofpie tried to dismiss the evidence provided, claiming a bias in the website's creators, though the actual evidence is cited and free for anyone to try and refute. That no refutation was ever done and presented in this thread might be telling.

As I posted before, AA ranks 38th out of 48 measured treatment modalities.



I wouldn't mind the religious stuff if the program is effective, that seems to be in doubt.

The AA language does imply that supernatural beliefs are required to succeed, perhaps so many people wouldn't be put off if they used "The Secular 12 Steps".


AA is specifically designed as a spiritual program. There is, IMO, no reason to go to AA if you don't have even a slightest interest in the woo of spirituality. Again, there have been posted many secular alternatives which provide all the benefits of the group support, sharing of experiences, and so on that AA provides without the religious or spiritual verbiage.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom