Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Did you happen to hear kind of a whooooooooshing sound when you posted that?

No, it must have been in your head. The sound of ideas flowing through empty space, perhaps! :D

(Sorry, couldn't resist making the joke.)
 
No, it must have been in your head. The sound of ideas flowing through empty space, perhaps! :D

(Sorry, couldn't resist making the joke.)

Now, now...you shouldn't make fun of the intellectually disadvantaged. :)
 
Nope. But ones who are alcoholic have something to actually base their opinion on. And more than a few are alcoholics.

Sounds like you couldn't make up your mind what your answer would be, so we get this "nope/but" response.

Nice dodge...
 
...there is nothing wrong with AA being a Religious Programme (as long as the judicial system doesn't force people to attend).

Exactly the reason I started posting to this thread...to point out this fact.

What is wrong, is pretending it's not Religious.

Little did I know that this discussion would degenerate into a stupid argument about "higher powers" not being god...I mean, only on an internet forum would people think they could "get away" with something as ignorant as the idea that AA isn't religious. Saying something like that in the real world would only get you laughed at.
 
Now, now...you shouldn't make fun of the intellectually disadvantaged. :)
Anyone reading through the morass this thread has become and who concludes Dymanic is intellectually disadvantaged actually is intellectually disadvantaged.
 
Anyone reading through the morass this thread has become and who concludes Dymanic is intellectually disadvantaged actually is intellectually disadvantaged.

I don't think anyone really believes Dymanic is intellectually disadvantaged. It's just disappointing to see someone waste a perfectly good intellect on concocting bogus arguments to defend an indefensible position.

Which is also a Violation of Step 10 (promptly admitting you were wrong) when you think about it.

GB
 
I'm afraid not. That you consider it important enough to ask makes me curious as to whether you claim to know for certain which of your own ideas are truly free of influence by those of others.


de
 
Last edited:
What is wrong, is pretending it's not Religious.
This may be the closest I'll ever get to an answer to this question I asked above:

You don't think it's important to consider whether there exists outside the framework of Christianity a legitimate basis for judging right from wrong? I find that hard to believe. Do you not judge ME for having committed what you perceive to be moral transgressions right here in this very thread?
You evidently do have some basis for judging right from wrong. Is that basis inherently religious in nature and origin? If not, what is its nature, and where did it originate?

And this one:
Do I detect in that a trace of acknowledgement that other possible frameworks might exist for examining one's own qualities?
This one requires a bit of inference, as it is not a direct answer. The textual evidence contained in your post clearly indicates that you do have a framework for examining the qualities of others, and I might infer that you are able to apply this to yourself, though the actual evidence does not clearly indicate this to be the case.

Thanks for sort of answering.
 
Exactly the reason I started posting to this thread...to point out this fact.
A sense of duty, then. Noble and admirable.

...only on an internet forum would people think they could "get away" with something as ignorant as the idea that AA isn't religious. Saying something like that in the real world would only get you laughed at.
Did you read the OP?
 
Why?
Can you define spiritual for me?



:D

Hmmm!....how did you manage to miss all the DEFINITIONS of Both Religious and Spiritual that have previously been posted?

Why do you continue to beat a dead horse? :deadhorse

Why have you not responded to the clear distinctions between a 12 Steps without a Deity (Spiritual but not Religious), and the AA 12 Steps WITH A DEITY (RELIGIOUS and Spiritual)?

Cat got your tongue? :bigcat


GB
 
I have been intermittently following this thread and would like to interject my own favorite quote from AA literature. It appear in pamphlet #25 entitled: _Members of the Clergy ask about Alcoholics Anonymous._

"A.A does not inquire into alcoholic's religious beliefs - or lack of them - when the turn to the Fellowship for help.

However, the A.A. program of recovery is based on certain spiritual values. Individual member are free to interpret these values as they think best, or not to think about them at all."

That's me. In addition to being free, for today anyway, from alcohol, I am also free to ignore all the spiritual bs and enjoy the marvelous fruits and fellowship of AA.

I'd also like to invite any atheist AAs onboard here to join us at the google group "Atheist AA" at http://groups.google.com/group/atheist-aa?
 
I have been intermittently following this thread and would like to interject my own favorite quote from AA literature. It appear in pamphlet #25 entitled: _Members of the Clergy ask about Alcoholics Anonymous._

"A.A does not inquire into alcoholic's religious beliefs - or lack of them - when the turn to the Fellowship for help.

However, the A.A. program of recovery is based on certain spiritual values. Individual member are free to interpret these values as they think best, or not to think about them at all."

That's me. In addition to being free, for today anyway, from alcohol, I am also free to ignore all the spiritual bs and enjoy the marvelous fruits and fellowship of AA.

I'd also like to invite any atheist AAs onboard here to join us at the google group "Atheist AA" at http://groups.google.com/group/atheist-aa?

Wonder if those "certain spiritual values" have something to do with God (i.e. Religious Values)? ;)

So instead of "faking it till you make it" like Alfie and Dymanic, you just ignore the "spiritual BS" (i.e. Religious BS). That's refreshing to hear on this thread. :D My hat is off to you sir.

GB
 
Funnily enough GB, you have never heard me say (or seen me write) "fake it till you make it". I have said all along that the choice is that of the individual to decide what form their recovery will take, including that of spirituality.

What was it you said earlier about dishonest posting? :rolleyes:

btw, spiritual and religious are different things. :boggled:
 
Funnily enough GB, you have never heard me say (or seen me write) "fake it till you make it". I have said all along that the choice is that of the individual to decide what form their recovery will take, including that of spirituality.

What was it you said earlier about dishonest posting? :rolleyes:

btw, spiritual and religious are different things. :boggled:

My Bad, I just assumed that you bought into Dymanic's "Fake it" strategy. :) (maybe it's because you pretend AA is not religious ;) ...i.e. "fake it")

AA is Religious AND Spiritual.

Honestly, how can you not tell the significant difference between the Secular 12 Steps (Spiritual but not Religious) and AA's 12 Steps (Religious AND Spiritual)? If you addressed that, perhaps that would go a long way to demonstrating that you are "ignoring the religious BS" rather than "faking it."

GB
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom