You know, I really do appreciate you being honest about just putting stuff out there without a lot of reflection on it.
Heh. Well, I wonder if you're fully taking into account the fact that I've been reflecting on and discussing and reading about (and then
re-reflecting, and
re-reading) some of this stuff for more than twenty years. I won't deny that a lot of that probably does not rise above the level of philosophical rumination. I've spent long hours in coffee shops discussing various insights (many of which are not to be found in AA literature) that may (or may not) apply to recovery, and while it may have been an enjoyable enough activity, I often went home feeling that the only thing it
accomplished was to keep us from running wild in the streets. Mind candy. I've often left AA meetings thinking the same thing.
But there comes a time when a sober alcoholic has to hit the street ready or not. Sooner or later, the street will jump up and hit
him. During the first six months of my sobriety, I lost a business. And then a house. About the time I took my first year chip, an eleven-year marriage ended, and I was outdoors. Just after the two year mark, I buried one of my children; two weeks after his seventeeth birthday. When face meets asphalt, you get a real good look at how much protection is provided by the lingering taste of some piece of mind candy. What counts is whether you've found any truths you can
live for. Not truths somebody else can live for. Truths YOU can live for.
If you've been kidding yourself that you might be able to get by on what somebody else or some book says is true, a close encounter of the asphalt kind is an opportunity to see how futile that is. But instead of simply trying to
tell me what to believe, AA
asked me. Instead of trying to
tell me who and what I was, AA
suggested that I take a closer look at that
myself. I had thought about these things before. I thought about them some more.
Ruminated on them. Waxed philosophical. And then when I found myself looking up at the sky with gravel in my teeth, the answers finally became clear: I was a stone-cold atheist, and always had been, but I had fairly clear ideas about what was right and what was wrong, and on what kind of person I wanted to be -- and where I had failed to live up to those standards it wasn't
always because they were impossible to meet in the first place, but
sometimes it was simply because I had
chosen not to.
And what AA told me was that I could start my life over anytime I wanted, as long as I was willing to make a
committment to that and stick to it -- except it didn't just
tell me that. It
showed me. It's not what you
believe in that counts; it's what you're willing to
work for; to
live for. When I staggered in numb and flailing from the last of the abovementioned asphalty encounters, I didn't need to ponder philosophically on whether I was in the hands of a loving and powerful force. Those people wrapped themselves around me like a big warm blanket. Led me around like a blind man. Fed me like a baby. You want to call that "religious", knock yourself out. I'll tell you this, though: If any GOD person ever shows up wanting to lay claims on me, I'll tell him he can piss off, this one's spoken for. AA never taught me to believe in God. It taught me to believe in people. Drugs and alcohol depopulated my life. AA is where I rejoined the human race. I think I'd be dead if I hadn't.
That's more about me than I was really inclined to present, but it's hard for me to show how Kierkegaard is relevant here otherwise. It's still hard, because all I'd really be doing is dumping text. With the obvious exception of his personal choice regarding "unknowable things to have faith in", just about everything I've just written (in the first three paragraphs or so at least) can basically be taken straight from Kierkegaard: Truth is subjectivity. What is true is
what is true for me. It is a truth I
live, not merely
observe. The esthete "is" what he is because he wills it, he allows himself to be swallowed up by externalities, and the ethicist "becomes" what he becomes because he wills it. Philosophers are best judged by their lives rather than just by their intellectual artifacts. I can't know anything about God; all I can do is be true to myself.
I provided one link. I'd be happy to provide more. If there are specific questions, I'd be happy to address them. I could provide more quotes, but it soon begins to require the reading of entire chapters, at least. Is there any good reason for me to post that reading material here? Because I can think of at least one reason not to.