Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
No, THAT is exactly wrong. Words have multiple and very often ambiguous meanings, and it is very often disputed just what the agreed upon meanings of those words are, and that is why contract lawyers make so much money. Unless we want to pay some of them to do that work for us here, we're going to have to continue to do the best we can to perform that work ourselves.

And there we have it. This had to happen at some point. Now we're arguing about the semantics of semantics.
 
Some would say Dymanic is attempting (with little help) to define the meaning of the word religious. That would seem a good starting point to decide if some specific activity fit the definition.

I'll mention, again, I assign my meaning to the word, and don't find AA activities meeting it.
 
Some would say Dymanic is attempting (with little help) to define the meaning of the word religious. That would seem a good starting point to decide if some specific activity fit the definition.

You mean "redefine the meaning of the word 'religious,' it already has a meaning.

I'll mention, again, I assign my meaning to the word, and don't find AA activities meeting it.

And I'll mention again, if your words can mean anything, they mean nothing.
 
Last edited:
You know, I really do appreciate you being honest about just putting stuff out there without a lot of reflection on it.
Heh. Well, I wonder if you're fully taking into account the fact that I've been reflecting on and discussing and reading about (and then re-reflecting, and re-reading) some of this stuff for more than twenty years. I won't deny that a lot of that probably does not rise above the level of philosophical rumination. I've spent long hours in coffee shops discussing various insights (many of which are not to be found in AA literature) that may (or may not) apply to recovery, and while it may have been an enjoyable enough activity, I often went home feeling that the only thing it accomplished was to keep us from running wild in the streets. Mind candy. I've often left AA meetings thinking the same thing.

But there comes a time when a sober alcoholic has to hit the street ready or not. Sooner or later, the street will jump up and hit him. During the first six months of my sobriety, I lost a business. And then a house. About the time I took my first year chip, an eleven-year marriage ended, and I was outdoors. Just after the two year mark, I buried one of my children; two weeks after his seventeeth birthday. When face meets asphalt, you get a real good look at how much protection is provided by the lingering taste of some piece of mind candy. What counts is whether you've found any truths you can live for. Not truths somebody else can live for. Truths YOU can live for.

If you've been kidding yourself that you might be able to get by on what somebody else or some book says is true, a close encounter of the asphalt kind is an opportunity to see how futile that is. But instead of simply trying to tell me what to believe, AA asked me. Instead of trying to tell me who and what I was, AA suggested that I take a closer look at that myself. I had thought about these things before. I thought about them some more. Ruminated on them. Waxed philosophical. And then when I found myself looking up at the sky with gravel in my teeth, the answers finally became clear: I was a stone-cold atheist, and always had been, but I had fairly clear ideas about what was right and what was wrong, and on what kind of person I wanted to be -- and where I had failed to live up to those standards it wasn't always because they were impossible to meet in the first place, but sometimes it was simply because I had chosen not to.

And what AA told me was that I could start my life over anytime I wanted, as long as I was willing to make a committment to that and stick to it -- except it didn't just tell me that. It showed me. It's not what you believe in that counts; it's what you're willing to work for; to live for. When I staggered in numb and flailing from the last of the abovementioned asphalty encounters, I didn't need to ponder philosophically on whether I was in the hands of a loving and powerful force. Those people wrapped themselves around me like a big warm blanket. Led me around like a blind man. Fed me like a baby. You want to call that "religious", knock yourself out. I'll tell you this, though: If any GOD person ever shows up wanting to lay claims on me, I'll tell him he can piss off, this one's spoken for. AA never taught me to believe in God. It taught me to believe in people. Drugs and alcohol depopulated my life. AA is where I rejoined the human race. I think I'd be dead if I hadn't.

That's more about me than I was really inclined to present, but it's hard for me to show how Kierkegaard is relevant here otherwise. It's still hard, because all I'd really be doing is dumping text. With the obvious exception of his personal choice regarding "unknowable things to have faith in", just about everything I've just written (in the first three paragraphs or so at least) can basically be taken straight from Kierkegaard: Truth is subjectivity. What is true is what is true for me. It is a truth I live, not merely observe. The esthete "is" what he is because he wills it, he allows himself to be swallowed up by externalities, and the ethicist "becomes" what he becomes because he wills it. Philosophers are best judged by their lives rather than just by their intellectual artifacts. I can't know anything about God; all I can do is be true to myself.

I provided one link. I'd be happy to provide more. If there are specific questions, I'd be happy to address them. I could provide more quotes, but it soon begins to require the reading of entire chapters, at least. Is there any good reason for me to post that reading material here? Because I can think of at least one reason not to.
 
Not trying to minimize your troubles here so don't take offense but you assume that no one else has been researching/thinking/investigating this for any length of time. You also assume that no one else has had their own trials and tribulations to deal with.

The recipe you give here is not one for finding truth, it is one for self delusion and woo.

I was an atheist before I even knew there was such a thing. When bad stuff happened to me, I didn't need to resort to woo and self delusion to get through it. When my grandson was lost I didn't fall to my knees and pray, I contacted the people searching and asked how I could help. When I lost my wife and almost everything else, I didn't need to resort to it either.

My world view (philosophy, if you will) has atheism as a major part and every other part of that view must line up with atheism or else it is discarded. There is no conceivable way that I can consider myself an atheist and then buy into the AA program.

Don't get me wrong, I could, if I was willing to redefine what "atheism," "religion," and "God" mean but that is just self delusion. The issue is one of connection and consistency, without that a world view means nothing.

Now, you think truth is subjective. That my truth is different from your truth. I completely disagree. There is only one truth and that is what is real, whether we know what that truth is or not. Our differences are that of knowledge of, and desire to know, the truth. I am not saying I am smarter or know more, it maybe that the exact opposite is true. What I am saying that any difference in truth is because of a difference in our respective data base. Which leads to my belief that you have changed the definition of "truth" to be more in line with "acceptable amount of ignorance."

I say this because I don't think "truth" is whatever gets you through. Something that might "get me through" but is clearly wrong doesn't give me the desire to believe it. If I find a part of my world view is wrong, even if it helps get me through, I discard it and rearrange my view to align more closely with the new knowledge.

So, when bad things happen, I have a choice. I can discard my atheism and believe in a higher power to get me through, or I can find another way of getting through that is in line with my athesism. So far, finding another way has worked awesomely.

Having said that, being an alcoholic is nothing special in the "troubles" department. Other things are as bad or worse. So, should I become an alcoholic, you can bet I am not going to start believing in God or a higher power just to get me through. Nor will I delude myself by changing definitions of words so that I can pretend to hold onto an all important world view while activley living something completley different.

In my view, that's what this thread boils down to. Either people are willing to delude themselves to "make it" or they are not. I'm not. Somethings are just too important to fake.
 
Thanks Dynamic.
Wonderful post.

Among other things, for me you have outlined the basis for spirituality; the psychosocial supports and influences around us that we can find in AA.
 
qayak:You, not being an alcoholic, have no idea what you're talking about in this regard.

Raw brainpower and unrestrained ego is something many alcoholics know a lot about.
 
Last edited:
qayak:You, not being an alcoholic, have no idea what you're talking about in this regard.

Special pleading fallacy.

Raw brainpower and unrestrained ego is something many alcoholics know a lot about.

Could you define "raw brainpower" and "unrestrained ego" and explain why non-alcoholics cannot know anything about them simply because they are non-alcoholics?
 
Interesting tidbit:

Collective consciousness: was a term coined by the French sociologist Émile Durkheim (1858–1917) to refer to the shared beliefs and moral attitudes which operate as a unifying force within society.

Various forms of what might be termed "collective consciousness" in modern societies have been identified by other sociologists, such as Mary Kelsey, going from solidarity attitudes and memes to extreme behaviors like groupthink or herd behavior.

Groupthink: is a type of thought within a deeply cohesive in-group whose members try to minimize conflict and reach consensus without critically testing, analyzing, and evaluating ideas. It is a second potential negative consequence of group cohesion.

Herd behavior: describes how individuals in a group can act together without planned direction. The term pertains to the behavior of animals in herds, flocks and schools, and to human conduct during activities such as stock market bubbles and crashes, street demonstrations, sporting events, religious gatherings, episodes of mob violence and even everyday decision making, judgment and opinion forming.

I think Groupthink and Herd Behaviour are pretty accurate descriptions of the organizational workings of AA.
 
Not trying to minimize your troubles here so don't take offense but you assume that no one else has been researching/thinking/investigating this for any length of time.
I don't, actually. I've also been around this forum long enough to know that it's always a mistake to assume that.

My world view (philosophy, if you will) has atheism as a major part and every other part of that view must line up with atheism or else it is discarded.
It's not hard to understand why a religious person would make their beliefs the center of their world, but... well, to borrow a phrase, making atheism the center of your existence doesn't make any more sense to me than would making not collecting stamps the center of your existence. A lot of people, after achieving some length of sobriety, sort of pull their heads up and say, "Okay, I'm sober. Now what?" With that in mind: okay, you're an atheist. Now what?

You also assume that no one else has had their own trials and tribulations to deal with.
That you can suppose for a moment that anyone could indulge an idiotic notion like that after twenty years in AA only stands as further evidence of just how little you know about AA. One of the first things that kept me coming back early on was that no matter how ugly my situation looked I always seemed to hear somebody talk about how they were going through stuff ten times worse -- and some of them would laugh about it! I had no idea how to walk through my own trials with that kind of dignity and grace, and I wanted that. Now that I've been around longer, I know that that was actually a bit naive. What drove the point home was having more than one friend in AA who ended up taking his own life. Sober. I never assume that others are not going through their own stuff.

Now, you think truth is subjective. That my truth is different from your truth. I completely disagree.
Just so you understand: Kierkegaard's point was not that truth is subjective, but that truth is subjectivity; that is, what is most important is how one stands in relation to objective truth.

So, when bad things happen, I have a choice. I can discard my atheism and believe in a higher power to get me through, or I can find another way of getting through that is in line with my athesism.
Kiergegaard would have agreed with that; that for you to attempt to adopt some external concept of a "higher power" would not only not work, but it would be to deny who you really are.

I think Groupthink and Herd Behaviour are pretty accurate descriptions of the organizational workings of AA.
Ditto the JREF forum. You could be the poster boy.
 
You may be right -- I believe I just said I don't always remember where my ideas originally came from, so it's possible that I attribute to them some ideas that are actually my own (or that my recollections are corrupted by my own flawed interpretations). When time allows (which isn't now, unfortunately), I'll see about comparing the content of some arguments made by Kierkegaard, and Wittgenstein, and perhaps Dennett, to the content of some of mine, and we'll see if we can sort some of that out. If you're really interested, that is. You might demonstrate that by having a go at some of the questions I've asked.

As I recall, in the case with Dennett (in particular) the problem was not stupidity. You simply did not have an adequate familiarity with the relevant material to reasonably judge whether his arguments supported my position or yours.


So when you post here we can't tell if it's your own thought or some half-remembered, regurgitated opinion of someone else?
 
Thanks Dynamic.
Wonderful post.

Among other things, for me you have outlined the basis for spirituality; the psychosocial supports and influences around us that we can find in AA.



AA isn't religious but it provides a support group based on spirituality. Sounds like a religious group to me.
 
So when you post here we can't tell if it's your own thought or some half-remembered, regurgitated opinion of someone else?
I'm afraid not. That you consider it important enough to ask makes me curious as to whether you claim to know for certain which of your own ideas are truly free of influence by those of others.
 
Regrade it as you will.

Hopefully with another wiseass and useless comment.

How about medical doctors? Must they be alcoholics to have a medical opinion regarding alcoholism?

Sorry, but your personal interpretation of the meaning of a word is irrelevant. Only dictionary definitions allowed here.

We're not discussing this on your terms, so why don't you stop acting like you "run" this board.
 
How about medical doctors? Must they be alcoholics to have a medical opinion regarding alcoholism?
Nope. But ones who are alcoholic have something to actually base their opinion on. And more than a few are alcoholics.
 
I've posted this before, but I think it's worth posting again to illustrate a point.

The Secular 12 Steps

1. We admitted we were powerless over addiction--that our lives had become unmanageable.

2. Came to believe that The Program, as a power greater than ourselves, could help us toward normal living.

3. Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care this program and to the loving care of this group.

4. Made a searching and fearless inventory of our character for ourselves.

5. Admitted to our group, to ourselves and to another human being the exact nature of our faults and misdeeds.

6. Were entirely ready to practice the program in order to remove our defects of character.

7. Humbly asked the help of others in the removal of our short comings and resolved to work to remove these faults ourselves.

8. Made a list of all persons we harmed, and became willing to make amends to them all.

9. Made direct amends to such people whenever possible, except when to do so would injure them or others.

10. Continued to take personal inventory and when we were wrong promptly admitted it.

11. Sought through study and meditation to improve our awareness of law and of the natural forces that govern life hoping only for knowledge of right and wrong and the strength to follow that knowledge.

12. Having had a spiritual awakening as the result of these steps, we tried to carry this message to addicts and to practice these principles in all our affairs.

Alrighty then, now I think there are a host of problematic issues with the above is it simply substitutes The Programme, or The Group, for God, without actually changing the Doctrines (see Qayaks Group-Think post for details).

But I would concede that the above Secular 12 Steps are "Spiritual but not Religious."

Now compare it with AA's (almost) original 12 Steps that continues to be the core document (along with the Big Book) of AA.

Service Material from the General Service Office
THE TWELVE STEPS OF ALCOHOLICS ANONYMOUS

1. We admitted we were powerless over alcohol—that our lives had become
unmanageable.

2. Came to believe that a Power greater than ourselves could restore us to
sanity.

3. Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we
understood Him.

4. Made a searching and fearless moral inventory of ourselves.

5. Admitted to God, to ourselves, and to another human being the exact nature of our wrongs.

6. Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character.

7. Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings.

8. Made a list of all persons we had harmed, and became willing to make
amends to them all.

9. Made direct amends to such people wherever possible, except when to do
so would injure them or others.

10. Continued to take personal inventory and when we were wrong promptly
admitted it.

11. Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with God, as we understood Him, praying only for knowledge of His will for us
and the power to carry that out.

12. Having had a spiritual awakening as the result of these Steps, we tried to
carry this message to alcoholics, and to practice these principles in all our
affairs.

It's very obvious when they are side by side. AA's 12 Steps include a Deity. By definition the Steps are Religious. AA is a Religious programme BY DEFINITION. It is thus "Spiritual AND Religious.

So pretend all you like that it's not a Religious Programme, but until AA adopts the Secular 12 Steps (and relegates the Big Book as it currently stands to an Historical Archive) it will remain a Religious Programme.

There really is no legitimate argument you guys can possibly come up with to demonstrate otherwise.

However, as I have ALSO stated previously, there is nothing wrong with AA being a Religious Programme (as long as the judicial system doesn't force people to attend). What is wrong, is pretending it's not Religious.

In fact, the Pretense is a Violation of the Step that calls for a "searching and fearless moral inventory of ourselves."

GB
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom