Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Still missing the point though aren't you?

Where in the big book (or other literature) are references to Jesus Christ made? That was the question that you cannot/will not respond to. Hmmmm?

No, I'm not missing the point. You are.

Dymanic conveniently ignored all the references to a Male Supernatural Deity in the Big Book.

Whether or not Christ is specifically mentioned is irrelevant to the question of AA being Religious.

However, if you or Dymanic are claiming that AA isn't Historically based on Christianity, you are simply demonstrating your ignorance of all the evidence to the contrary.

GB
 
Observing that words often mean different things to different people is not the same as saying that they mean nothing. If one person takes the word "God" to mean: "what they said", or: "what it says in that book" -- while another person says, "screw what they say, and screw what some book says, here's what it means to me -- which one of them (if either) has a more meaningful concept of "God"?

That is exactly wrong. Words have an agreed to meaning which is why contract lawyers make so much money. If you want the agreed to meaning of the word "God" you need to look in an English dictionary and you will find your definition is wrong. You may have different beliefs about what God is but there are other words to describe those beliefs so use them, don't lie and say the words really mean something they don't.

But it is worse than this. You are taking the words of another person and claiming your made up definitions are what they really meant which is contrary to all evidence. It is nearly impossible for you to guess what that person meant but you go ahead and pretend it is a fact that the meaning is what you say it is and directly contrary to what they actually wrote. You even ignore when they wrote other texts that explain the meaning of the first because it is convenient.


You also claim words can have any meaning one wants unless they are your words and then they have a specific meaning that you get to decide on. That's rather smug of you. Your words mean what you say but no one else's words mean what they say.

Indeed. Lots of them, in fact.

In the context there is only one definition.

I think Kierkegaard would have taken "God as we understood Him" to mean something like "The un-understandable, in terms of our understanding", or perhaps "The infinite, in terms of the finite." In short, a contradiction. A folly. His solution may (though perhaps ambitiously) be reduced to the sentiment expressed on the coins given to AA members to mark years of sobriety: "To thine own self be true."

Is that what Kierkegaard would say or is that what you say he says? It's getting difficult to tell. If it's the former, Kierkegaard is wrong. If it is the latter, you are wrong.

"God as we understood him" only applies to the original founders of AA because it was written before you were born. Your definition has no bearing. You need to understand what those founders meant and, surprise, surprise, they told us. They specifically meant the christian god with the capital 'G.'

I personally don't care if AA changes or not. It seems rather obvious that the membership of AA as a whole DOES -- either correctly or incorrectly -- view the program (the steps and all of it) as effective, and therefore favors the "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" approach.

Well, yeah, but that wasn't the question. I couldn't care less if it changes either but that doesn't mean it isn't religious or that it shouldn't change.
 
What I particularly enjoy about Kierkegaard is his ability to just invent stuff to justify his belief in the Christian God.
Pretty much the opposite of his whole approach to that, actually. One of Kierkegaard's main arguments was that nothing can be objectively known about God. Inventing things in order to justify belief seems like a pointless exercise for one who would argue that. Do you have any particular "stuff" in mind?

Having a little problem with reconciling a Morally Absolute God with God's Moral Relativity? No problem...just rename it "Teleological Suspension of the Ethical" and hope that people will be bamboozled enough by the Big Words to not figure out it just means that "God is Morally Relative whenever it suits Him, but because He's God and God is Morally Absolute by definition, He's not really Morally Relative."

It's pretty clear that YOU were bamboozled by the phrase "Teleological Suspension of the Ethical", but then, all you did was about five minutes of Googling, wasn't it? Kierkegaard was not merely rehashing the Euthyphro dilemma ("Is is pious because the Gods love it, or do the gods love it because it is pious?") What he was talking about is that for the individual at the second, or ethical level, "doing the right thing" basically means conforming to social norms (think of the way "duty" and "responsibility" were defined in, say Nazi Germany), whereas for the individual at the third, or "religious" level, faith may require committment to something higher than that which is dictated by mere social norm. May I ask you again (since you chose not to answer) whether you consider that there exists outside the framework of Christianity (or any religion) a legitimate basis for judging right from wrong?

Why does this style of argumentation remind me of yours so much Dymanic?
Perhaps because you are completely unaquainted with the style of Kierkegaard's argumentation? I do find much in the content of some of his arguments that parallel some of my own ideas. Could that be what you meant?

Maybe you want to rethink namedropping Kierkegaard.
For the same reason that a discussion on some matter related to physics need not entail re-inventing that entire branch of science, I don't see any good reason to reject all of the work previously done by others which may bear on the matters we're discussing here. If we were in a forum dedicated to evolutionary theory, I'd likely be "dropping" names like Darwin, Dawkins, Fisher, Wright, Gould, and others -- and not just because I like the way they look printed out, but because I've actually read some of what the gentlemen had to say on that subject. And it's worth noting that it would be a mistake to regard my doing so as implicit agreement with every word they ever wrote. The ideas of others who have previously travelled and mapped the territory we're moving across can provide a starting point; they need not necessarily be considered an end point.

Maybe you want to rethink dismissing every mention of one of those ideas as "namedropping" simply because an author is attributed. It's another of your bad habits which contribute nothing while making you look bad without you even realizing it. (As another example, you appear not to realize that carelessly accusing others of sophistry is itself often regarded as a form of sophistry).
 
That is exactly wrong. Words have an agreed to meaning which is why contract lawyers make so much money.
No, THAT is exactly wrong. Words have multiple and very often ambiguous meanings, and it is very often disputed just what the agreed upon meanings of those words are, and that is why contract lawyers make so much money. Unless we want to pay some of them to do that work for us here, we're going to have to continue to do the best we can to perform that work ourselves.

You are taking the words of another person and claiming your made up definitions are what they really meant
Yes.
which is contrary to all evidence.
Don't tell me; show me.
In the context there is only one definition.
I propose this be added to the list of "things we may never agree on".

Is that what Kierkegaard would say or is that what you say he says?
It's what I say he would say. (See the top of my last response to GB). If you think Kierkegaard is wrong, don't tell me; show me. Before you begin, ask yourself whether you really disagree. Do you think anything can be objectively known about God? I sure don't.

"God as we understood him" only applies to the original founders of AA because it was written before you were born.
A lot of AA members who came along after would be disappointed to hear that. The founders were not speaking only for themselves, but were doing their best to anticipate those who would come after and to speak, as best they could, for them -- in much the same way as were the architects of the Constitution of the United States.

I couldn't care less if it changes either but that doesn't mean it isn't religious or that it shouldn't change.
Just out of curiosity, on your list of "things that should change" how high does this issue rank?
 
I am actually familiar with the works of many of the Famous Philosophers Dymanic (having devoted a lot of my time to studying philosophies and religions).

However, instead of just "spewing whatever comes out of my head" (I think you put it something like that when referring to yourself), I take the time to refresh and/or confirm my recall by either hitting the books (if I have time) or googling (if I don't have the time).

Your snide and arrogant assumptions that others cannot possibly be more aware than you of what the Famous Philosophers mean, demonstrates that your arguments cannot stand on their own merits.

I spent a lot of time analyzing the Christian Existentialist Kierkegaard's "Teleological Suspension of the Ethical" during my studies, because it seemed remarkable to me that a philosopher of no mean intellect could concoct such a pile of dubious claptrap.

My conclusion was that he just couldn't get past his own Christian Theological Assumptions.

In any case, your arguments still amount to evidence free assertions that AA is not religious.

GB
 
PS: Bill W, Dr Bob, Rev Shoemaker, and Dr Silkwood all knew who THEY meant when they referred to God (maybe you should actually try Researching instead of Spewing). Apparently it is only you and Alfie who don't.


It was their Heavenly Father, their Christian Deity, or as Dr Silkwood and Bill W are both Quoted: Christ the Great Physician--for only Christ could truly heal the Alcoholic they believed.

http://www.cyberrecovery.net/forums/showthread.php?t=22057

At the time of Bill Wilson’s third visit as a patient at Towns Hospital, Bill had a discussion with his psychiatrist and treating physician, Dr. William D. Silkworth on the subject of the “Great Physician.” Several sources, including Norman Vincent Peale in his book The Positive Power of Jesus Christ, that it was Dr. Silkworth who used the term “the Great Physician” to explain the need in recovery for a relationship with Jesus Christ. In fact, Dr. Silkworth’s biographer points out:

In the formation of AA, Wilson initially insisted on references to God and Jesus, as well as the Great Physician. [Dale Mitchel, Silkworth: The Little Doctor Who Loved Drunks: The Biography of William Duncan Silkworth, M.D. (Center City, MN: Hazelden, 2002), page 50.]

Silkworth and Norman Vincent Peale became very good friends. Dr. Silkworth and his wife once held their membership at Marble Collegiate Church in New York where Peale was the lead pastor. And Dr. Peale set forth at great length the account of how Dr. Silkworth had specifically informed one of Dr. Peale’s parishioners named Charles that Charles could be cured of alcoholism by the Great Physician, Jesus Christ. [See Mitchell, Silkworth, pages 50-51; Norman Vincent Peale, The Positive Power of Jesus Christ: Life-Changing Adventures in Faith (Pauling, NY: Foundation for Christian Living, 1980), pages 59-63; Dick B., The Conversion of Bill W.: More on the Creator’s Role in Early A.A. (Kihei, HI: Paradise Research Publications, Inc., 2006), pages 50-71.]

Bill Wilson himself made several very important statements confirming that he had heard and heeded Dr. Silkworth’s advice that the Great Physician could cure him. Thus Bill stated in his own autobiography that he had had long talks at Towns Hospital with Dr. Silkworth. [See Bill W.: My First 40 Years: An Autobiography by the Cofounder of Alcoholics Anonymous (Center City, MN: Hazelden, 2000), pages 107-112.] Then, prior to his final visit to Towns Hospital and his discussions with Dr. Silkworth there, he concluded:

Yes, if there was any great physician that could cure the alcohol sickness, I’d better seek him now, at once. . . . If getting well required me to pray at high noon in the public square with the other sufferers, would I swallow my pride and do that? . . . Anyhow, I’d better start for the hospital right now. [See Wilson, Bill W., page 139.]

GB
 
The book doesn't have to say Christ to be religious. Mentioning God is quite sufficient.

And I might agree with you. Except the discussion moved to Christian teachings and other wish to point out that AA is CHRISTIAN. If that were true, then Christ would be mentioned.

Whether or not Christ is specifically mentioned is irrelevant to the question of AA being Religious.

see above

However, if you or Dymanic are claiming that AA isn't Historically based on Christianity, you are simply demonstrating your ignorance of all the evidence to the contrary.

I think I can speak for Dynamic when I say that I have conceded many times that AAs founders had their feet firmly in religion (specifically Christianity). I (we actually agree with you).

But a very good try at conflating issues again. :)
 
And I might agree with you. Except the discussion moved to Christian teachings and other wish to point out that AA is CHRISTIAN. If that were true, then Christ would be mentioned.



see above



I think I can speak for Dynamic when I say that I have conceded many times that AAs founders had their feet firmly in religion (specifically Christianity). I (we actually agree with you).

But a very good try at conflating issues again. :)

Right, because the added phrase "as we understood" changes everything! :rolleyes:

The only people obfuscating, conflating, and distorting issues on this thread are you and Dymanic. But nice try at Projecting (that's a psychological term, maybe you've heard of it).

Adding a few words doesn't change the fact that the Deity is Male Monotheistic and Supernatural, nor the fact that the Capitalized Pronouns identify that Deity as being of Christian Origin. Nor does it change the fact that most of the references to God in the Big Book are Christian References. Nor does it change the fact that the doctrines espoused are Christian Doctrines.

GB
 
However, instead of just "spewing whatever comes out of my head" (I think you put it something like that when referring to yourself), I take the time to refresh and/or confirm my recall by either hitting the books (if I have time) or googling (if I don't have the time).
This isn't a test. It's just a casual discussion. If you feel that you have a great deal at stake here, it may be because you chose to adopt a certain tone early on. You can choose to lower the heat anytime you want.

If I mention (or paraphrase) something said by Socrates or Wittgenstein or Kierkegaard or Glenn Beck, it's because I find that somehow relevant to the discussion we're having. You seem to find that an objectionable practice, which strikes me as odd considering that we are in a forum ostensibly dedicated to Religion and Philosophy. Are you capable of allowing for the possibility that I may have an interest in some of these questions that goes beyond my interest in recovery in general or Alcoholics Anonymous in particular? You may have met some AA members for whom AA represents the center of the universe. I'm not one of them.

Your snide and arrogant assumptions that others cannot possibly be more aware than you of what the Famous Philosophers mean, demonstrates that your arguments cannot stand on their own merits.
Your inferiority complex is showing. I'm not always able to attribute a source for the ideas I'm "spewing" onto the page because I sometimes can't remember where they came from, but I don't see why I shouldn't at least be allowed to do so when I can remember. I used to like to think I was capable of coming up with truly unique and original ideas on this sort of thing, but reading has nearly cured me of that. Here, I presented some ideas, attributed a source, and offered my personal take on those ideas and how I see them fitting into this discussion. Then, by asking some specific questions (which remain unanswered by the way), extended to you what I thought was a perfectly civil invitation to respond. You chose not to respond, but instead to attack. That was a choice. Kierkegaard placed great emphasis on the importance of choices. So does AA. You I'm not so sure about.

Christianity teaches that what you are determines what you do. Kierkegaard argued that what you do determines what you are, and while your behavior here suggests that you may not agree, this happens to be one of the ideas I thought I could claim as my own until I read some stuff written by a guy who died before my great-grandfather was born. And then, after reading it again, I decided I could claim it as my own, as long as I was prepared to treat it as a truth I could live for rather than merely an intriguing intellectual tidbit. (I've had to do a lot less amends since I made that switch).

My conclusion was that he just couldn't get past his own Christian Theological Assumptions.
You may recall that he was also rather well known for describing certain Christian Theological Assumptions as "offensive to reason" -- and they happen to be some of the ones most often challenged around here on the very same basis (though, granted, not necessarily coming from quite the same place).

I spent a lot of time analyzing the Christian Existentialist Kierkegaard's "Teleological Suspension of the Ethical" during my studies, because it seemed remarkable to me that a philosopher of no mean intellect could concoct such a pile of dubious claptrap.
Kierkegaard himself was not much kinder to Hegel. The thing is, he fleshed that out with some actual arguments. Looks like you must not have retained much from those studies. Might have been easier had you found something you could apply rather than just digest. Ah, well. To each his own. Do you agree with that? Wait, let me try another one: the sky is blue.
 
Dymanic,

This is the reason why I made my complaint about these posts being off-topic much earlier in the thread -- it's fine that you may remember some sources of these philosophical heavyweights or not, and it's fine you bring up them and their philosophies -- but you still need to explicitly tie them all in to how these people relate to why or why not AA is considered religious.
 
Adding a few words doesn't change the fact that the Deity is Male Monotheistic and Supernatural, nor the fact that the Capitalized Pronouns identify that Deity as being of Christian Origin. Nor does it change the fact that most of the references to God in the Big Book are Christian References. Nor does it change the fact that the doctrines espoused are Christian Doctrines.

But you said it is a Christian faith (or words to that effect).

So being a Christian religious body, Christ is mentioned, surely?
Please show me where?

If not, perhaps it is more jewish movement with a jewish bent,.... or moslem, with a moslem bent?

Can you please explain how a supposedly Christian movement does not have Christ in it? Anywhere! :)
 
Last edited:
Just out of curiosity, on your list of "things that should change" how high does this issue rank?

It is top priority until I change to another thread, then the new thread has top priority. So, of things I think should change, it is somewhere between Travis' virginity and women being raped.
 
This isn't a test. It's just a casual discussion. If you feel that you have a great deal at stake here, it may be because you chose to adopt a certain tone early on. You can choose to lower the heat anytime you want.

If I mention (or paraphrase) something said by Socrates or Wittgenstein or Kierkegaard or Glenn Beck, it's because I find that somehow relevant to the discussion we're having. You seem to find that an objectionable practice, which strikes me as odd considering that we are in a forum ostensibly dedicated to Religion and Philosophy. Are you capable of allowing for the possibility that I may have an interest in some of these questions that goes beyond my interest in recovery in general or Alcoholics Anonymous in particular? You may have met some AA members for whom AA represents the center of the universe. I'm not one of them.

Your inferiority complex is showing. I'm not always able to attribute a source for the ideas I'm "spewing" onto the page because I sometimes can't remember where they came from, but I don't see why I shouldn't at least be allowed to do so when I can remember. I used to like to think I was capable of coming up with truly unique and original ideas on this sort of thing, but reading has nearly cured me of that. Here, I presented some ideas, attributed a source, and offered my personal take on those ideas and how I see them fitting into this discussion. Then, by asking some specific questions (which remain unanswered by the way), extended to you what I thought was a perfectly civil invitation to respond. You chose not to respond, but instead to attack. That was a choice. Kierkegaard placed great emphasis on the importance of choices. So does AA. You I'm not so sure about.

Christianity teaches that what you are determines what you do. Kierkegaard argued that what you do determines what you are, and while your behavior here suggests that you may not agree, this happens to be one of the ideas I thought I could claim as my own until I read some stuff written by a guy who died before my great-grandfather was born. And then, after reading it again, I decided I could claim it as my own, as long as I was prepared to treat it as a truth I could live for rather than merely an intriguing intellectual tidbit. (I've had to do a lot less amends since I made that switch).

You may recall that he was also rather well known for describing certain Christian Theological Assumptions as "offensive to reason" -- and they happen to be some of the ones most often challenged around here on the very same basis (though, granted, not necessarily coming from quite the same place).

Kierkegaard himself was not much kinder to Hegel. The thing is, he fleshed that out with some actual arguments. Looks like you must not have retained much from those studies. Might have been easier had you found something you could apply rather than just digest. Ah, well. To each his own. Do you agree with that? Wait, let me try another one: the sky is blue.

The problem is mainly that you substitute argument by referencing Famous Philosophers instead of argument by evidence (when you're not just substituting sophistry for evidence). Thus taking on an undeserved tone of Intellectual Superiority for yourself.

Then, you provide little to no relevant content of the philosophies they espoused (instead you just spout off the top of your head and attribute it to the philosophers).

Then, when I point out how your favourite philosophers occasionally engaged in sophistry and disingenuity that mirrors your own (or, as with Dennett, point out that their ideas which are relevant to the topic of this thread undermine your arguments), you accuse me of being too stupid to understand those philosophers.

Then you posit I have an inferiority complex. Like Alfie, I think you are engaging in a lot of Projection

Excuse me if I don't take your comments regarding tone or my understanding of those Famous Philosophers very seriously.

So, back to brass tacks, do you have any evidence that AA is not religious?

Not Spin, Sophistry, Obfuscation, Famous Philosophers, repeating AA's own sophistry, no Faux Indignation, no pretense that everyone in a religious group with religious texts has to share the same beliefs for that group to be considered religious.

No arguments that God doesn't really mean God or that Capitalized Personal Pronouns referring to a Male God aren't really an artifact of Christianity, no arguments that we can pretend all those Christian names for God in the Big Book written by Christians aren't Christian just because you say so...

Just Evidence.

GB
 
Last edited:
Dymanic,

This is the reason why I made my complaint about these posts being off-topic much earlier in the thread -- it's fine that you may remember some sources of these philosophical heavyweights or not, and it's fine you bring up them and their philosophies -- but you still need to explicitly tie them all in to how these people relate to why or why not AA is considered religious.
I understand your complaint. All I can do is ask for continued patience. Lot of noise in the channel.
 
It is top priority until I change to another thread, then the new thread has top priority. So, of things I think should change, it is somewhere between Travis' virginity and women being raped.
Great answer!
 
But you said it is a Christian faith (or words to that effect).

So being a Christian religious body, Christ is mentioned, surely?
Please show me where?

If not, perhaps it is more jewish movement with a jewish bent,.... or moslem, with a moslem bent?

Can you please explain how a supposedly Christian movement does not have Christ in it? Anywhere! :)

How many colours and what size font should I use when I repost all the evidence that AA is a Religious Organization BASED ON the PROTESTANT CHRISTIANITY of it's FOUNDERS and that it retains all the Religious Language and Doctrines as those CHRISTIANS wrote it with a few COSMETIC changes that Semi-Universalize the GOD of AA?

I'll do it if you really want me to. :rolleyes:

But you are probably having too much fun mis-representing my arguments and/or pretending that I haven't ALREADY pointed out (repeatedly) that by positing a Singular Male Supernatural Deity, AA fits the model of the Abrahamic Monotheistic Religions.

GB
 
Then, you provide little to no relevant content of the philosophies they espoused (instead you just spout off the top of your head and attribute it to the philosophers).
You may be right -- I believe I just said I don't always remember where my ideas originally came from, so it's possible that I attribute to them some ideas that are actually my own (or that my recollections are corrupted by my own flawed interpretations). When time allows (which isn't now, unfortunately), I'll see about comparing the content of some arguments made by Kierkegaard, and Wittgenstein, and perhaps Dennett, to the content of some of mine, and we'll see if we can sort some of that out. If you're really interested, that is. You might demonstrate that by having a go at some of the questions I've asked.

Then, when I point out how your favourite philosophers occasionally engaged in sophistry and disingenuity that mirrors your own (or, as with Dennett, point out their ideas relevant to the topic of this thread which undermine your arguments), you accuse me of being too stupid to understand those philosophers.
As I recall, in the case with Dennett (in particular) the problem was not stupidity. You simply did not have an adequate familiarity with the relevant material to reasonably judge whether his arguments supported my position or yours.
 
You may be right -- I believe I just said I don't always remember where my ideas originally came from, so it's possible that I attribute to them some ideas that are actually my own (or that my recollections are corrupted by my own flawed interpretations). When time allows (which isn't now, unfortunately), I'll see about comparing the content of some arguments made by Kierkegaard, and Wittgenstein, and perhaps Dennett, to the content of some of mine, and we'll see if we can sort some of that out. If you're really interested, that is. You might demonstrate that by having a go at some of the questions I've asked.

You know, I really do appreciate you being honest about just putting stuff out there without a lot of reflection on it. And if this really is the case, it seems to me you really don't realize how disingenuous many of your arguments and tactics are.

And honestly, from MY point of view, philosophizing about a question which can be answered empirically just confuses the issues instead of illuminating them. I'm basically a Pragmatist when it comes to topics than can be confirmed or denied with evidence.

When I enter into a discussion or a debate I do my homework, and I don't argue points I can't back up (for the most part, I make no claims to infallibility). If I want to put something out there based on a memory, I double-check it against my sources before I post. And if I do post something based on a faulty memory or bad sourcing, I'll cop to it when called on it.

If we were just ruminating on the "meaning of life," I can wax philosophical with the best of them.

But that's not what we're doing here.

As I recall, in the case with Dennett (in particular) the problem was not stupidity. You simply did not have an adequate familiarity with the relevant material to reasonably judge whether his arguments supported my position or yours.

No, the problem was that you quoted a Dennett passage that wasn't relevant to the topic, and it was a passage that didn't stand on its own merits.

I am quite familiar with the relevant Dennett material (Breaking the Spell). And the problem there was that his definition of religion (being essentially the primary definition of religion, and that which I base my position on) supported my arguments, not yours.

If AA's literature used the Secular 12 Steps, you and Alfie would be on firmer ground in arguing "Spiritual but not Religious." Though I would still argue that the core Religious doctrines were retained, but with the Group taking the place of the Deity.

However AA continues to use the Religious 12 Steps and the Religious big Book. God features prominently in both, and is the key to the programme. As long as this is the case, AA will remain a Religious Organization.

GB
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom