Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
Everything that the program itself ostensibly stands for is change.
And AA has changed, and it has so without major changes to the book -- underscoring a point some posters here seem to find difficult to grasp: AA is not a book. You know, a great deal has been written about evolutionary theory since Darwin first published On the Origin of Species, and while modern thinkers on the subject do not agree with Uncle Chuck on every point, his book is still highly revered as the one that started it all, and for a person interested in learning about evolution it's still not a bad place to start.

One of Alfie's points bears repeating: "AA members have far more on their minds than what a 70 year old book says.". That's probably a lot truer than you might think. One observation I've made is that not all alcoholics are real big on reading. For all I know, it may actually be that not all adult members of the society I live in are real big on reading, and that in fact the numbers of them who are at best borderline literate are surprisingly high but that AA meetings offer more opportunities to see that than do most other places.

I've always found it quite touching to see a group of maybe fifty people patiently wait while some member with reading skills that would score in the "below proficient" category on a third grade assessment test struggle to get through one of the passages typically read at the beginning of meetings, gently offering assistance only when he gets completely stuck. I just can't see a guy who couldn't define or even correctly pronounce a word like "anonymity" spending a lot of his spare time reading the Big Book -- so while we're here scrutinizing subltle nuances and minute details of AA literature, it might be worth keeping in mind that we may already have spent more time doing that than a lot of AA members ever will.

The book is a starting point. The factually more inclusive part is handled the same way it was originally expected that it would be handled -- when an alcoholic shares his own personal experiences with the group. Consider these quotes from the Big Book:

"To show other alcoholics precisely how we have recovered is the main purpose of this book."

"We realize that we have been giving you much direction and advice. We may have seemed to lecture. If that is so we are sorry, for we ourselves don't always care for people who lecture us. But what we have related is based upon experience, some of it painful."


There's a big difference between saying "This is what this principle means, and this is how it works" and saying "This is what this principle means to me, and this is how it works for me". Is ex cathedra pontificating never seen at AA meetings? Definitely not. If you really want to see this whole recovery thing spelled out in clear and unequivocal terms, try the same approach you might take if you wanted definitive answers to some complex question in, say, economics or political science: ask a sophomore (in other words, ask someone with maybe a year or so of sobriety). These experts can often be seen delivering lengthy lectures at AA meetings, scolding others on their shortcomings (without addressing them directly, of course), reciting passages from the Big Book, etc -- and either not noticing or not correctly interpreting the smiles on the faces of the members who've been around a while.
 
Again I ask: how does posting exerpts from AA litterature, history and statistics considered a matter of conviction ?
Have you asked that before? Show me where. Yeah, right. Never mind. The answer to your question is this: what demonstrates to me the strength of GB's conviction is not so much the content of his posts but the tone in which it is delivered. Nothing says "I feel very strongly about this" quite like BIG RED letters.

If you think that's required in order for AA to be religious you are greatly mistaken.
A position on the Nicene creed? No. That was offered merely as an example. My position is (and has consistently been all throughout this thread) that some kind of specific supernatural beliefs (taught as doctrine or dogma; your choice) is a vital aspect of religiousity. If these details are not what distinguishes one religion from another, and the religious from the secular, then what does?

What I find tiresome and dissapointing is that you claim NOT to remember having experienced those things in this thread, and demand that people repeat the same things over and over.
I guess I gotta go with this response then: I've already answered every objection you've made to the definitions I've provided.




(Note to GB: I'm out of time here, so I'll have to respond to you later, but in the meantime, thanks for keeping it small and black).
 
Are you saying that only a woman would find a singular, male deity a problem?

An appeal for inclusiveness + a problem with "Him" with a capital h is only something that would bother women? Is that what you are saying?

Not even close.

Are you being deliberately obtuse or do you really have a problem understanding that when you go "Him" with a capital h, then that "Him" is equal to "You know, God. That god fellow what we christians - whether we admit to it or not - believe in. You know that judeochristian dude in the bible and ****. That one. I use the capital h, because I want you to be perfectly clear that I am talking about that one."

No I understand that that was the language of the day and the individual writing it.

And you also claim that a call for more inclusive language would ONLY be a benefit to women? Because obviously it is the gender specificness of the noun that excluded people women.

You have taken a huge leap here, and completely the wrong way. I never said any of this, nor meant to. You might also have noticed that Norseman apologised for the framing of his question to me as it caused confusion.

You just keep on endearing yourself don't you. You have just outed yourself as clearly misogynistic, as well as all your other lovely traits.

Wow, just wow!
At the risk of being rude here (and frankly after this little tirade who's blame me?), what the hell are you talking about?

Firstly: you more or less admit that it IS religious, but that you are afraid that people will not seek its help if they perceive it as such. The solution, obviously not being more inclusive language and a purging of the religious overtones, but to flat out deny the evidence there for every person who can read. So - you really accept that it is, except you don't want anyone to know that.

Second : since AA does not perform any better than quitting on your own, I really think that you shouldn't worry too much about people avoiding AA if they know it for what it actually is - lots of people would probably stand a far better chance if they got help from psychiatry instead.

Cool. So you are one of those who wants something that doesn't work, to change to become more inclusive? What for if it has no benefit?

Once those whose abuse problems are comorbid with adhd, unstable personality disorder, bipolar disorders, depressive disorders and other psychiatric conditions that often are strongly linked with substance abuse get the help (and sometimes meds) that they ACTUALLY need, then the rest of you can have your little god club in peace, secure in the knowledge that people are getting the help.

AA is for alcohol, not mental health. One needs to seek outside help for outside problems.
I mentioned earlier that a sponsee of mine came to me once saying his anxiety hadn't left him. I made it clear to him that AA stands for Alcoholics Anonymous, not Anxiety Anonymous and he needed to get help for his mental health issues.

Substance abuse is just one of the symptoms of these conditions. There is so much suffering that keeps going on even after people get sober.

You may not be aware that I work in the industry and have a very good grasp of this fact. AA is not all things to all people and I've never said it was.
 
FACT: The specifically Male pronoun is an artifact of Protestant Christianity which posits a Male Deity.
I suspect that at the very least there might be one or two Catholics who would dispute Protestantism's claim to that particular artifact.

Subsuming one's Will to the Will of a Male Supernatural Deity inherently posits that there is a Male Supernatural Deity with a Will.
How many "wills" does a person have? Only one? When I experience that inner struggle between the desire to have that last piece of chocolate cake and my desire to conform to my own sense of fairness -- the one that dictates that the last piece rightfully belongs another family member -- am I not making more than one decision? In choosing one course of action over another, am I not also choosing what kind of person to be? Is it not possible to subsume one of my wills to another without involving a supernatural deity (of any particular brand or gender)?

3) FACT: "As we understood" was added later in an attempt to Unversalize Jehovah/Jesus. However it was a half-assed measure that left in place a Singular Supernatural Male Deity. This was originally added to allow other Christian Denominations, namely Catholics.
This habit of labelling your inferences "FACT" establishes only one thing: that you are not clear on the distinction between inference and fact.

Instead of altering the text even further to allow for the membership of other religions altogether, AA decided that the additions already made were "good enough."
You sure can infer a lot from a pronoun. Is it possible that a more parsimonious explanation is that it was simply thought that replacing every instance of that pronoun with something like "He/She/It/Them/What-have-you" would have disturbed the flow of the prose?

If the Sacred Texts state that one can ask God to remove one's Sins, the assumption that God will respond is being taught.
First, let's see if we can clean this up a little by getting rid of another thoroughly transparent rhetorical device: your "Sacred Texts" bit. Resorting to such low-rent tactics is not consistent with your denouncement of sophistry. It would be one thing if you did so metaphorically, but it looks like you actually are arguing that the book, "Alcoholics Anonymous" really does deserve that designation. So let's look at that. Maybe I should pause to ask whether you are invoking this phrase metaphorically, perhaps as a sort of inline poke in the eye to anyone who does not share your conclusions? If not, what basis, if any, would you consider reasonable in distinguishing (genuine) Sacred Texts in general from other texts? For instance, a claim of divine inspiration is one criterion I would apply. Does the Big Book make this claim? Do you see significant numbers of AA members making this claim?

And I still have the same complaint with regard to your use of the word, "Sins". I must ask (again, to be sure) whether you consider Christianity (be it Protestantism or Catholicism or whatever) to be the either the original source of wisdom on all matters related to good versus evil (justice versus injustice, etc) or the legitimate custodians of that wisdom? Do you agree with those Christians who regard atheists as immoral (the more sophisticated ones might say "amoral") due to a lack of any possible basis for judging right from wrong? AA's steps Four, Five, and Six talk about character defects and about becoming willing to have them removed. Up to that point, do you see that process as inherently religious in nature?

I realize that in posing these questions I'm asking for a revisiting of some arguments made earlier in the thread, but I do so in the hope that we can actually do that in a civil manner -- therefore I am quoting some specific posts to see if anything has changed (beyond the one or two points we've already identified) over several months of discussion. Here are a couple of statements relevant to what I've just written, and they appear somewhat contradictory:
I do agree that some of the Moral tenets mentioned by Christ are Universal; and that those tenets which are Universal do not require a Deity, but can be reached through Reason.
The historical context for AA is that it was founded on Protestant Christian Doctrines. That some of those Christian doctrines were borrowed from other Religions centuries ago isn't relevant to the discussion at hand. It's a Red Herring.
I tried to get you to clear that up at the time, but we got bogged down in some stuff about decontextualizing and whatnot. Maybe this time I'll have a chance of catching you in a different mood. Might've been better if I had gotten back to you when you were still glowing from the cathartic effects of your latest multicolor text dump, but it's been a long, busy day.

As this post is more than long enough already, I believe I'll let you answer first before proceeding.

I agree that the the Trinitarian conception of Christianity amounts to a Monistic Polytheism rather than Monotheism. However, NO major denomination of Christianity will ever concede that point. Catholic, Reformed, and Orthodox Christianity all claim to be Monotheist. As AA is based on Protestant Doctrine, the same intellectual baggage is passed on to AA.

The Sophistry they use to dance around this fact reminds me of your Sophistry to dance around the facts of the Religiosity of AA.
For unintentional irony -- particularly as an answer to the question I asked (Which AA passages provide clarity on this?) -- this response scores particularly high on the comic value scale.
 
I suspect that at the very least there might be one or two Catholics who would dispute Protestantism's claim to that particular artifact.

No Duh! Who founded AA again? ...Protestant Christians!

How many "wills" does a person have? Only one? When I experience that inner struggle between the desire to have that last piece of chocolate cake and my desire to conform to my own sense of fairness -- the one that dictates that the last piece rightfully belongs another family member -- am I not making more than one decision? In choosing one course of action over another, am I not also choosing what kind of person to be? Is it not possible to subsume one of my wills to another without involving a supernatural deity (of any particular brand or gender)?

Yes, but that's not what the sacred texts of AA say. The sacred texts of AA say God's Will.

This habit of labelling your inferences "FACT" establishes only one thing: that you are not clear on the distinction between inference and fact.

FACT: You are not clear on Facts. In Fact you seem to have a thing against Facts.

You sure can infer a lot from a pronoun. Is it possible that a more parsimonious explanation is that it was simply thought that replacing every instance of that pronoun with something like "He/She/It/Them/What-have-you" would have disturbed the flow of the prose?

Again, you display a clear disdain of facts. There's nothing to infer; the Capitalized personal pronoun is a feature of Christianity. However, as that FACT is inconvenient to your pretense that AA isn't religious you have to make stuff up.

First, let's see if we can clean this up a little by getting rid of another thoroughly transparent rhetorical device: your "Sacred Texts" bit. Resorting to such low-rent tactics is not consistent with your denouncement of sophistry. It would be one thing if you did so metaphorically, but it looks like you actually are arguing that the book, "Alcoholics Anonymous" really does deserve that designation. So let's look at that. Maybe I should pause to ask whether you are invoking this phrase metaphorically, perhaps as a sort of inline poke in the eye to anyone who does not share your conclusions? If not, what basis, if any, would you consider reasonable in distinguishing (genuine) Sacred Texts in general from other texts? For instance, a claim of divine inspiration is one criterion I would apply. Does the Big Book make this claim? Do you see significant numbers of AA members making this claim?

Are you denying that The Big Book and the 12 Steps are the Central Texts of AA?

Do you question any of the following definitions of Sacred, of which any or all might fairly be applied to the Central Texts of AA?
sa·cred   
[sey-krid] Show IPA
–adjective
1.
devoted or dedicated to a deity or to some religious purpose; consecrated.
2.
entitled to veneration or religious respect by association with divinity or divine things; holy.
3.
pertaining to or connected with religion ( opposed to secular or profane): sacred music; sacred books.
4.
reverently dedicated to some person, purpose, or object: a morning hour sacred to study.
5.
regarded with reverence: the sacred memory of a dead hero.
6.
secured against violation, infringement, etc., as by reverence or sense of right: sacred oaths; sacred rights.
7.
properly immune from violence, interference, etc., as a person or office.

Do you deny that Bill W and Dr Bob saw themselves as Divinely Inspired to create AA and its central texts?

http://www.dickb.com/articles/bible_roots_dsb.shtml

In 1948, at his last major talk to AAs, Dr. Bob made these important statements about the Bible:

In the early days . . . our stories didn’t amount to anything to speak of. When we started in on Bill D. [Bill Dotson was A.A. Number Three], we had no Twelve Steps either; we had no Traditions. But we were convinced that the answer to our problems was in the Good Book. . . . It wasn’t until 1938 that the teachings and efforts and studies that had been going on were crystallized in the form of the Twelve Steps. I didn’t write the Twelve Steps. I had nothing to do with the writing of them. . . . We already had the basic ideas, though not in terse and tangible form. We got them, as I said, as a result of our study of the Good Book [The Co-Founders of Alcoholics Anonymous Biographical sketches Their last major talks, pp. 13-14].

Dr. Bob said A.A.’s basic ideas came from the Bible. Dr. Bob and Bill each stated quite often that Jesus’s sermon on the mount contained the underlying spiritual philosophy of A.A. And Dr. Bob often read to AAs from those Bible passages. He pointed out that the A.A. slogans “First Things First” and “Easy Does It” were taken respectively from Matthew 6:33 and 6:34 in the Sermon. When someone asked Dr. Bob a question about the A.A. program, his usual response was: “What does it say in the Good Book?” He declared that A.A. pioneers were “convinced that the answer to their problems was in the Good Book.” He added: “To some of us older ones, the parts we found absolutely essential were the Sermon on the Mount, the 13th chapter of First Corinthians, and the Book of James.” In fact, Bill Wilson said that James was so popular with the pioneers that many favored calling the A.A. fellowship “The James Club” [Pass It On, p. 147].

And I still have the same complaint with regard to your use of the word, "Sins". I must ask (again, to be sure) whether you consider Christianity (be it Protestantism or Catholicism or whatever) to be the either the original source of wisdom on all matters related to good versus evil (justice versus injustice, etc) or the legitimate custodians of that wisdom? Do you agree with those Christians who regard atheists as immoral (the more sophisticated ones might say "amoral") due to a lack of any possible basis for judging right from wrong? AA's steps Four, Five, and Six talk about character defects and about becoming willing to have them removed. Up to that point, do you see that process as inherently religious in nature?

The process is inherently religious when that process explicitly requires a Male Supernatural Deity to remove those "Defects of Character."

And the terms "defects of character" and "shortcomings" can more than fairly be equated to "SINS" given that the Origin of AA's Male Supernatural Deity who is expected to remove them is explicitly the Christian Deity.

This is such a clear reference to asking Christ to cover our Sins, that only the ignorant or self-deluded can claim otherwise.

The question is not whether Christianity originated the concept of Good and Evil (Red Herring), the question is whether AA is based on the doctrines of Christianity (which is the only major religion to promote the concept of "Original Sin").

So back at you: Given the clear reference to God being asked to remove our Sins (with the expectation that He can--indeed that ONLY He can [as the First Step explicitly states that we are Powerless to do so ourselves]), how can you NOT see that process as inherently Religious?

The only real answer is that you are deluding yourself. You Faked it and you Made it. You even openly admit that you are deluding yourself: Tom Hanks and the Volleyball Analogy--according to you, you have to trick your mind with another part of your mind, and then you redefine AA's Higher Power to mean your Trickssssy Mind instead of God.

Talk about a Gollum Complex.
gollum.jpg


I realize that in posing these questions I'm asking for a revisiting of some arguments made earlier in the thread, but I do so in the hope that we can actually do that in a civil manner -- therefore I am quoting some specific posts to see if anything has changed (beyond the one or two points we've already identified) over several months of discussion. Here are a couple of statements relevant to what I've just written, and they appear somewhat contradictory:

I tried to get you to clear that up at the time, but we got bogged down in some stuff about decontextualizing and whatnot. Maybe this time I'll have a chance of catching you in a different mood. Might've been better if I had gotten back to you when you were still glowing from the cathartic effects of your latest multicolor text dump, but it's been a long, busy day.

No, we got bogged down in your bogus Fact Free arguments, your Sophistry, your red Herrings, and your Straw Men.

As to my two quotes, they are not mutually exclusive. It doesn't make a whit of difference that The Golden Rule can be found in Confucianism, Christianity, and Secular Humanism. That is irrelevant to the topic, thus it is a Red Herring.

What IS relevant are the Christian Doctrines of Sin, Confession, Absolution, and subsuming one's will to the Will of God, who just happens to be a Male Supernatural Deity.

You have presented no new information, and certainly no evidence to back up your assertions. And I have been forced to resort to repeatedly rubbing the Blatantly Religious Language and Doctrines of AA in your face.

What else can I do? Depart the thread and let you claim (evidence free) Victory? Not Bloody Likely.


For unintentional irony -- particularly as an answer to the question I asked (Which AA passages provide clarity on this?) -- this response scores particularly high on the comic value scale.

What is Ironic and Depressing, is that you refuse to acknowledge the FACT that Christians don't provide any clarity on the topic of the Trinity. They simply claim they are Monotheists and "God works in mysterious ways that our puny minds can't understand."

So why on Earth would the Christian based AA be expected to provide any clarity on that topic?

GB
 
Last edited:
Do you know3 how to spell literature, or are you making a joke? That was my point. :rolleyes:

So I was supposed to guess what was going on in your mind ? I'd rather not go there, thanks.

ADD: Also, it's not my fault English speakers removed a "t" from the French word Littérature.

What you find "odd" and what is do not have to match.

Trivial. Please adress my point.

Explanation and evidence please.

It's basically like saying that the bible is optional to Christianity, when in fact it contains its core beliefs and teachings. The 12 steps are the core of AA. Saying they are optional is kinda silly.
 
Last edited:
Have you asked that before? Show me where. Yeah, right. Never mind.

By this I suppose you actually made the effort to check and realized it was just a couple of posts prior.

The answer to your question is this: what demonstrates to me the strength of GB's conviction is not so much the content of his posts but the tone in which it is delivered.

And since "tone" in written texts if often a matter of the reader's interpretation, we could say that what demonstrates GB's conviction is your own conviction about his tone. How ironic.

A position on the Nicene creed? No. That was offered merely as an example.

An example of something you think is irrelevant ? Why did you even mention it, then ?

My position is (and has consistently been all throughout this thread)

You keep saying that as though you expect me to accuse you of being inconsistent again. Must've hit a nerve.

that some kind of specific supernatural beliefs (taught as doctrine or dogma; your choice) is a vital aspect of religiousity. If these details are not what distinguishes one religion from another, and the religious from the secular, then what does?

Sure. Does AA not mention more-or-less a very specific god ?
 
No Duh! Who founded AA again? ...Protestant Christians!
And who founded Protestantism?

Yes, but that's not what the sacred texts of AA say. The sacred texts of AA say God's Will.
GodAsWeUnderstoodHim. That could mean anything.

Are you denying that The Big Book and the 12 Steps are the Central Texts of AA?
"Central text" is much better. Not only accurate, but free of biased assumptions.

Do you question any of the following definitions...
Here we go again. SEVEN senses this time. Kudos for including even the ones that don't support your position, though. It bespeaks honesty and sincere interest in the questions at hand.

Do you deny that Bill W and Dr Bob saw themselves as Divinely Inspired to create AA and its central texts?
Is every book a Sacred Text that was written by an author who claimed divine inspiration, or is it necessary that a lot of others also regard it as such? If "regarded with reverence" is the sense you're applying, then sure: the Big Book is a "Sacred Text". And so is "On the Origin of Species". And "Atlas Shrugged".

And the terms "defects of character" and "shortcomings" can more than fairly be equated to "SINS" given that the Origin of AA's Male Supernatural Deity who is expected to remove them is explicitly the Christian Deity.
Interesting choice of words there: "more than fairly", and "equated". Do I detect in that a trace of acknowledgement that other possible frameworks might exist for examining one's own qualities?

This is such a clear reference to asking Christ to cover our Sins
Where does that name appear in the Big Book? I can find "Creative Intelligence", "Universal Mind", and "Spirit of Nature", but I guess I forget what page "Jesus Christ" is on.
...that only the ignorant or self-deluded can claim otherwise.
Do you see the addition of such phrases such as having anything of value to add either to the truth value your statements (to anyone but yourself) or to the quality of this discussion?

The question is not whether Christianity originated the concept of Good and Evil.
You don't think it's important to consider whether there exists outside the framework of Christianity a legitimate basis for judging right from wrong? I find that hard to believe. Do you not judge ME for having committed what you perceive to be moral transgressions right here in this very thread?

the question is whether AA is based on the doctrines of Christianity (which is the only major religion to promote the concept of "Original Sin").
Within a belief system based on the concept of "Original Sin", what possible value can there be in a personal inventory? Why bother listing the wrongs you may have committed, or making direct amends to those you've harmed, or considering whether you're willing to have your character defects removed -- when none of that counts for squat anyway because you're still filthy with Sin you inherited?

The only real answer is that you are deluding yourself. You Faked it and you Made it. You even openly admit that you are deluding yourself: Tom Hanks and the Volleyball Analogy--according to you, you have to trick your mind with another part of your mind, and then you redefine AA's Higher Power to mean your Trickssssy Mind instead of God.
I have not spoken of my own concept of a higher power, but merely asked you to entertain possible alternatives to the God of Protestant Christianity (which I will henceforth refer to as "ProtGod" for the sake of brevity). This discussion has not always run most smoothly when we began talking about ourselves personally (or, especially, about each other), but as I have already mentioned that I find the "disease" concept useful as a metaphor, I will say that (though the character Gollum never used the word "tricksy" to refer to either of his own sub-personalities) what you have just described is not far from the way I use that as a symbol for helping to manage my own internal affairs. Is it delusional to observe an inner struggle taking place over that piece of chocolate cake? Have you never experienced anything like this yourself? Never felt multiple "wills" within you, each struggling to come out on top? Ever read any Kierkegaard? I find Either/Or particularly relevant to chocolate cake type questions.

No, we got bogged down in your bogus Fact Free arguments, your Sophistry, your red Herrings, and your Straw Men.
Fine. All my fault then. Shall we try again?

As to my two quotes, they are not mutually exclusive. It doesn't make a whit of difference that The Golden Rule can be found in Confucianism, Christianity, and Secular Humanism.
I submit that due to the great emphasis you place on the provenance of AA's concepts, it IS relevant. What basis can you provide in support of your insistence that Christianity represents the stopping point for all previous chains of ownership and the starting point for everything to follow? I've asked this before, though in different words: If somewhere among the "intellectual baggage passed on to AA from Christianity" are some items of value which Christianity itself inherited (as opposed to having created), would you throw those away unexamined?

What IS relevant are the Christian Doctrines of Sin, Confession, Absolution, and subsuming one's will to the Will of God, who just happens to be a Male Supernatural Deity.
I'm no expert on the Christian concept of Original Sin, but my understanding is that it is something very different from the Big Book's concept of "character flaws". As is the solution; Absolution is not the end result of having one's defects removed, nor of having made amends for one's wrongful deeds, it is an alternative to that.

What is Ironic and Depressing, is that you refuse to acknowledge the FACT that Christians don't provide any clarity on the topic of the Trinity.
Quizzing Christians on the nature of the Trinity can be a lot of fun, if perhaps somewhat cruel -- and yes, it is deliciously ironic, especially considering the importance placed on the matter. Reject the Trinity, and you're going to HELL, according to some -- but press them, and they can't actually explain what it is they're embracing! But if you look back, you'll see that I was asking for passages clarifying whether AA does or does not embrace the Trinity (aka the "Nicene creed"). Some folks consider that mighty important, regardless of whether they can explain why.

What else can I do? Depart the thread and let you claim (evidence free) Victory? Not Bloody Likely.
Two things are abundantly clear at this point: neither you nor I will ever be free of a daily obligation to service this thread as long as we both have working computers, an active internet connection, and posting privileges on this forum (none of which should be taken for granted), and our differences will not be resolved by any declaration of victory. I suggest we review those points on which we already agreed, because those represent the closest thing we'll ever come to accomplishing anything here. If we identify some which we have yet to fully explore, that'll be a bonus. But there are some points on which we will clearly never agree. Is there any value in sitting down every day and trying to find new ways to say the same things? Evidently, that's one of the things we DO agree on.
 
Last edited:
Several more posts have been removed to AAH. Try to avoid having this thread once again devolve into a cesspool of off topic bickering.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Cuddles
 
GodAsWeUnderstoodHim. That could mean anything.

This statement is patently false unless you are saying that the words used mean nothing in which case, what is the point of all the words in the AA bible?

There are definite meanings to the word "God."

There is a definite meaning to "as we understood Him."

(All that has been gone over before and was never addressed by you or anyone else.)

The thing that I find interesting is that the AA supporters here have adopted a "God of the gaps" defense. Their god keeps getting squeezed into smaller and smaller places but they don't see it that way, they see it as being a case of more and more gaps for their god to hide.

The two claims: "AA is an effective recovery program" and "they [Steps, Traditions, and other points of the AA program] are just suggestions," are mutually exclusive. It is like saying that antibiotics cured you when you didn't take them. All the dancing done around this issue by the AA supporters here has not managed to reconcile the conflict, it only makes it more apparent when all the bluster in their posts is stripped away.

A couple of them have made a point of asking why we want AA to change if we don't think the program is effective. That has been answered but what hasn't been answered is "Why, if AA is such and effective program, do AAers deny there is a program, only suggestions that no one, apparently, follows?" In other words, why are they claiming antibiotics cured them when they didn't take antibiotics?

On the other hand, I understand human nature and I understand why someone with so much vested interest in "the program" will defend it beyond the rational. So, I already have my answers to these questions and the question asked in the OP.

CIAO
 
That's the problem with apologetics. Inevitably they produce mutually-exclusive arguments because the goal is not truth, but the protection of a belief.
 
At least we agree on that two-edged sword.

Thanks for that admission. As for myself, I actually have no horse in this race: I neither hate nor love AA. But the evidence speaks for itself, and the inability of the opposition to provide any counter evidence speaks even louder.
 
This statement is patently false unless you are saying that the words used mean nothing...
Observing that words often mean different things to different people is not the same as saying that they mean nothing. If one person takes the word "God" to mean: "what they said", or: "what it says in that book" -- while another person says, "screw what they say, and screw what some book says, here's what it means to me -- which one of them (if either) has a more meaningful concept of "God"?

There are definite meanings to the word "God."
Indeed. Lots of them, in fact.

There is a definite meaning to "as we understood Him."
I think Kierkegaard would have taken "God as we understood Him" to mean something like "The un-understandable, in terms of our understanding", or perhaps "The infinite, in terms of the finite." In short, a contradiction. A folly. His solution may (though perhaps ambitiously) be reduced to the sentiment expressed on the coins given to AA members to mark years of sobriety: "To thine own self be true."

The two claims: "AA is an effective recovery program" and "they [Steps, Traditions, and other points of the AA program] are just suggestions," are mutually exclusive.
I'll remind you that, for my part, I never have argued that "AA is an effective recovery program", if that is taken to mean something like: demonstrably effective using powerful and well defined methods of distinguishing "success" from "failure", collecting and verifying data, etc. Individuals may report that AA's steps have been helpful to them, but we have no way of knowing whether a given individual would have achieved recovery some other way, and there still remains the question of the extent to which their success was a result of having "thoroughly followed" the path versus having adopted the "take what you can use and leave the rest" approach. The whole question of effectiveness is hopeless, in my opinion. Fortunately for our purposes here, it is also completely irrelevant.

A couple of them have made a point of asking why we want AA to change if we don't think the program is effective.
I personally don't care if AA changes or not. It seems rather obvious that the membership of AA as a whole DOES -- either correctly or incorrectly -- view the program (the steps and all of it) as effective, and therefore favors the "if it ain't broke, don't fix it" approach.
 
What I particularly enjoy about Kierkegaard is his ability to just invent stuff to justify his belief in the Christian God.

Having a little problem with reconciling a Morally Absolute God with God's Moral Relativity? No problem...just rename it "Teleological Suspension of the Ethical" and hope that people will be bamboozled enough by the Big Words to not figure out it just means that "God is Morally Relative whenever it suits Him, but because He's God and God is Morally Absolute by definition, He's not really Morally Relative."

Why does this style of argumentation remind me of yours so much Dymanic? ;)

Maybe you want to rethink namedropping Kierkegaard. Your record on namedropping Famous Philosophers (instead of providing evidence) to back up your positions regarding the religiosity of AA isn't that good.

GB
 
Last edited:
Where does that name appear in the Big Book? I can find "Creative Intelligence", "Universal Mind", and "Spirit of Nature", but I guess I forget what page "Jesus Christ" is on.

Did you forget the following names: Creator, Maker, Father, Heavenly Father, Father of Light, God of our fathers, Almighty God? Or the over 400 references to God in the Big Book including the Capitalized pronouns? Did you forget the Protestant Christian History of AA?

Just to refresh your memory of all the Christian Names for God in the Big Book:

http://www.aa.org/bigbookonline/en_tableofcnt.cfm

GB
 
Funnily enough, the word CHRISTIAN relates to Christ. Dynamic's point (for those of you with comprehension difficulties) is that references to Jesus Christ are not to be found in the big book. :rolleyes:
 
Funnily enough, the word CHRISTIAN relates to Christ. Dynamic's point (for those of you with comprehension difficulties) is that references to Jesus Christ are not to be found in the big book. :rolleyes:

Funnily enough all the references to God in the Big Book are Christian Names for God (for those of you with Historical Frame of Reference difficulties).

GB
 
Still missing the point though aren't you?

Where in the big book (or other literature) are references to Jesus Christ made? That was the question that you cannot/will not respond to. Hmmmm?

I will just wait here while you find that reference. You now, the one that links Christ to the Christianity you say is in the big book?

picture.php
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom