No Duh! Who founded AA again? ...Protestant Christians!
And who founded Protestantism?
Yes, but that's not what the sacred texts of AA say. The sacred texts of AA say God's Will.
GodAsWeUnderstoodHim. That could mean anything.
Are you denying that The Big Book and the 12 Steps are the Central Texts of AA?
"Central text" is much better. Not only accurate, but free of biased assumptions.
Do you question any of the following definitions...
Here we go again. SEVEN senses this time. Kudos for including even the ones that don't support your position, though. It bespeaks honesty and sincere interest in the questions at hand.
Do you deny that Bill W and Dr Bob saw themselves as Divinely Inspired to create AA and its central texts?
Is every book a Sacred Text that was written by an author who claimed divine inspiration, or is it necessary that a lot of
others also regard it as such? If "regarded with reverence" is the sense you're applying, then sure: the Big Book is a "Sacred Text". And so is "On the Origin of Species". And "Atlas Shrugged".
And the terms "defects of character" and "shortcomings" can more than fairly be equated to "SINS" given that the Origin of AA's Male Supernatural Deity who is expected to remove them is explicitly the Christian Deity.
Interesting choice of words there: "more than
fairly", and "
equated". Do I detect in that a trace of acknowledgement that other possible frameworks might exist for examining one's own qualities?
This is such a clear reference to asking Christ to cover our Sins
Where does that name appear in the Big Book? I can find "Creative Intelligence", "Universal Mind", and "Spirit of Nature", but I guess I forget what page "Jesus Christ" is on.
...that only the ignorant or self-deluded can claim otherwise.
Do you see the addition of such phrases such as having anything of value to add either to the truth value your statements (to anyone but yourself) or to the quality of this discussion?
The question is not whether Christianity originated the concept of Good and Evil.
You don't think it's important to consider whether there exists outside the framework of Christianity a legitimate basis for judging right from wrong? I find that hard to believe. Do you not judge ME for having committed what you perceive to be moral transgressions right here in this very thread?
the question is whether AA is based on the doctrines of Christianity (which is the only major religion to promote the concept of "Original Sin").
Within a belief system based on the concept of "Original Sin", what possible value can there be in a personal inventory? Why bother listing the wrongs you may have committed, or making direct amends to those you've harmed, or considering whether you're willing to have your character defects removed -- when none of that counts for squat anyway because you're still filthy with Sin you
inherited?
The only real answer is that you are deluding yourself. You Faked it and you Made it. You even openly admit that you are deluding yourself: Tom Hanks and the Volleyball Analogy--according to you, you have to trick your mind with another part of your mind, and then you redefine AA's Higher Power to mean your Trickssssy Mind instead of God.
I have not spoken of my own concept of a higher power, but merely asked you to entertain possible alternatives to the God of Protestant Christianity (which I will henceforth refer to as "ProtGod" for the sake of brevity). This discussion has not always run most smoothly when we began talking about ourselves personally (or, especially, about
each other), but as I have already mentioned that I find the "disease" concept useful as a
metaphor, I will say that (though the character Gollum never used the word "tricksy" to refer to either of
his own sub-personalities) what you have just described is not far from the way I use that as a symbol for helping to manage my own internal affairs. Is it
delusional to observe an inner struggle taking place over that piece of chocolate cake? Have you never experienced anything like this yourself? Never felt multiple "wills" within you, each struggling to come out on top? Ever read any Kierkegaard? I find
Either/Or particularly relevant to chocolate cake type questions.
No, we got bogged down in your bogus Fact Free arguments, your Sophistry, your red Herrings, and your Straw Men.
Fine. All my fault then. Shall we try again?
As to my two quotes, they are not mutually exclusive. It doesn't make a whit of difference that The Golden Rule can be found in Confucianism, Christianity, and Secular Humanism.
I submit that due to the great emphasis you place on the provenance of AA's concepts, it IS relevant. What basis can you provide in support of your insistence that Christianity represents the stopping point for all previous chains of ownership and the starting point for everything to follow? I've asked this before, though in different words: If somewhere among the "intellectual baggage passed on to AA from Christianity" are some items of value which Christianity
itself inherited (as opposed to having created), would you throw those away unexamined?
What IS relevant are the Christian Doctrines of Sin, Confession, Absolution, and subsuming one's will to the Will of God, who just happens to be a Male Supernatural Deity.
I'm no expert on the Christian concept of Original Sin, but my understanding is that it is something
very different from the Big Book's concept of "character flaws". As is the solution;
Absolution is not the end result of having one's defects removed, nor of having made amends for one's wrongful deeds, it is an
alternative to that.
What is Ironic and Depressing, is that you refuse to acknowledge the FACT that Christians don't provide any clarity on the topic of the Trinity.
Quizzing Christians on the nature of the Trinity can be a lot of fun, if perhaps somewhat cruel -- and yes, it is deliciously ironic, especially considering the importance placed on the matter. Reject the Trinity, and you're going to HELL, according to some -- but press them, and they can't actually explain what it is they're embracing! But if you look back, you'll see that I was asking for passages clarifying whether AA does or does not embrace the Trinity (aka the "Nicene creed"). Some folks consider that mighty important, regardless of whether they can explain
why.
What else can I do? Depart the thread and let you claim (evidence free) Victory? Not Bloody Likely.
Two things are abundantly clear at this point: neither you nor I will ever be free of a daily obligation to service this thread as long as we both have working computers, an active internet connection, and posting privileges on this forum (none of which should be taken for granted), and our differences will not be resolved by any declaration of victory. I suggest we review those points on which we already agreed, because those represent the closest thing we'll ever come to accomplishing anything here. If we identify some which we have yet to fully explore, that'll be a bonus. But there are some points on which we will clearly never agree. Is there any value in sitting down every day and trying to find new ways to say the same things? Evidently, that's one of the things we DO agree on.