Sorry for the wind up, but I honestly saw a change in tack here. We went from more inclusive with regard to atheists, to more inclusive with regard to women. I found the change interesting and commented.
Are you saying that only a woman would find a singular, male deity a problem?
An appeal for inclusiveness + a problem with "Him" with a capital h is only something that would bother women? Is that what you are saying?
Are you being deliberately obtuse or do you really have a problem understanding that when you go "Him" with a capital h, then that "Him" is equal to "You know, God. That god fellow what we christians - whether we admit to it or not - believe in. You know that judeochristian dude in the bible and ****. That one. I use the capital h, because I want you to be perfectly clear that I am talking about that one."
And you also claim that a call for more inclusive language would ONLY be a benefit to women? Because obviously it is the gender specificness of the noun that excluded
people women.
You just keep on endearing yourself don't you. You have just outed yourself as clearly misogynistic, as well as all your other lovely traits. You do realize that quitting drinking only is a good thing if you quit the behaviour as well?
Because it doesn't really matter if you are drunk or sober as long as you engage in self aggrandizement, self pity, aggressiveness and positron reality?
And you do realize that your explanation to why it is important to you that AA is not a religious movement is both very telling and completely misguided?
Firstly: you more or less admit that it IS religious, but that you are afraid that people will not seek its help if they perceive it as such. The solution, obviously not being more inclusive language and a purging of the religious overtones, but to flat out deny the evidence there for every person who can read. So - you really accept that it is, except you don't want anyone to know that.
Second : since AA does not perform any better than quitting on your own, I really think that you shouldn't worry too much about people avoiding AA if they know it for what it actually is - lots of people would probably stand a far better chance if they got help from psychiatry instead.
Third: the constant banging on about god, no matter how you try to dress it up, clearly puts people off anyway no matter how much you lie about it. People do not seek the help of AA because all the steps still refer to "Him". That train has left and will not visit your station until the steps are changed - or you admit that your little club is religiously motivated (and belladonna motivated) and clearly state: "But it's ok if you're not."
As we say in Sweden. "Det blir varken hackat, eller malet" ("This gets neither chopped, nor milled." - I.e trying to sit on two chairs will cause your ass to end up on the ground.)
Once those whose abuse problems are comorbid with adhd, unstable personality disorder, bipolar disorders, depressive disorders and other psychiatric conditions that often are strongly linked with substance abuse get the help (and sometimes meds) that they ACTUALLY need, then the rest of you can have your little god club in peace, secure in the knowledge that people are getting the help.
Substance abuse is just one of the symptoms of these conditions. There is so much suffering that keeps going on even after people get sober.
AA is a direct hindrance in getting help for that. Not least because of the selfsatisfied attitude they have to all other treatment forms and anyone who happens to disagree with them.
Because if what you really want is for people to get the help they need to get healthy and sober, then you will recognize and accept that for a whole lot of people that is everything, except AA. And you will recognize and accept that you are already putting people off. Lying about it doesn't change that.
And the you I use above is double. It is the impersonal you as in "one", but it is also you personally who in this thread has done more to damage AA's reputation than I can remember seeing anywhere else before. "God" "Himslef" couldn't put people off AA more efficiently than you do here.
If anyone was considering AA and stumbled upon this thread, none of its detractors would be a stronger deterrent (despite the fact that they actually back their stuff up) than you have been.
Also remember that because alcoholism is a "family disease" small children of people going through Minnesota treatments and AA get roped in, against their will, to spend weeklong sessions existing only for the benefit of their alcoholic - yet again. Another example of the repressive and self obsessed nature of alcoholics, drunk or sober, and of the repressive and self obsessed nature of AA, which doesn't even shy at forcing children into its Alanonsense, Alateen-groups and Alalpub-crap.
No one asked us if we wanted to go. No one asked us if we wanted to say prayers. No one asked us if we wanted to contribute to the collection plate. Desperate sober parents got roped in to forcing us to go because AA ******** said that it was good for us. It wasn't *********** good for us, it was *********** traumatic. How is forcing children into a small room, having them read prayers and taking up collection NOT a bloody Sunday school? And WE had no bloody choice. Becuase our (mostly) dads had been brainwashed into thinking they needed to go to "church" two times per day and our (mostly) mums had been convinced/coerced that it was good for us to get locked into rooms full of upset people and force us to say prayers and share things we weren't ready to share yet and when we did would much rather share in a loving and trusting environment, rather than a roomfull of trauma.
It was bloody abusive, that's what it was. And it was also bloody religion.
We were not the ones who chose to drink our asses off. Yet we were stuck doing counter productive **** instead of healing.
When I was 14 dad got so violent the neighbours heard it and stepped in. (We all lived in houses with big yards between us) Mum and I were whisked off to a women's shelter where people who actually knew **** about traumatized children didn't ask me a thing, but simply found me artist's paints and let me at it for as long as I wanted. They never asked me anything. Just listened whenever I talked, even if it wasn't about something important. Also note that the shelter never recommended Alanon, Alateen etc. They didn't disapprove either, they simply did not have it on their list of useful contacts, because they aren't useful.
Because of that I have put the violence and that day in particular behind me. I'm ok with being someone who had to spend a bit of my teens in a shelter. That shelter was bloody nice.
But the trauma of having to go to Alapub and Alateen wasn't handled anywhere. After all - they were supposed to be the help.
There is one thing that AA certainly shares with the church, and that is the complete denial and ostrich attitude they take to what they do to children.