Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
If someone truly wants to kick alcoholism, they don't need AA. They can do it on their own. It's been done many times.
True enough. I personally did it hundreds of times. (Well, dozens, anyway.) The problem I had was that I couldn't seem to make it stick. If I had been able to do that, AA is the last place I'd have gone. Call it a selection process: the ones who can do it on their own and all alone probably just go ahead and do it that way -- wouldn't you think? For the ones who can't, there's some good news and some bad news. The bad news is that ultimately, you do have to do it on your own. The good news is that you don't have to do it alone.

AA can turn into a crutch.
I completely agree. People come limping into AA, and AA offers a crutch that can help them get around better while they're healing (a process which, AA teaches, takes place "sometimes quickly, sometimes slowly"). Some of them get better, lose the crutch, leave AA, and go on to live fulfilling and meaningful lives (or whatever kind of lives; scoring lives is a treacherously subjective affair, after all). There is little doubt in my mind that some of them stick around simply because they're unwilling to relinquish the crutch. Some of them lose the crutch but stick around AA anyway because they find fulfillment in helping each new influx of walking wounded learn to get around on crutches. Maybe some of them stick around because they find amusement in watching these newcomers fumbling around trying to learn to use the crutches -- who knows? That's the thing: people are different. They don't all do the same things, or for the same reasons, or see things the same way, or define words the same way. Go figure.
 
So now it's sexism that's the problem, not religion?

Honestly, alcoholics that are trying to get and stay sober have far more important things to worry about than amending the big book to be reflective of today's politically correct terminology.


You must be just trying to wind me up; after all, you stated many times in the thread that you were posting just for the laughs.

Which part of "more inclusive" do you not understand? Which part of "more inclusive" that I posted three times just passed you by?

Honestly, Alfie, when I finally make it to Oz for a visit, you'd be a person I'd like to have a pint (of soda :)) with, but in the meantime, I'm hard pressed to not put you on ignore.
 
Same answer as last time:

We fear change.



Everything that the program itself ostensibly stands for is change. Not only that, but the AA World Organization has non-alcoholics on the board of directors -- this is specific (seven members out of the 21 member board of trustees).

Sorry, fearing change doesn't cut it in my mind as to why basic textual changes are made to be factually more inclusive and not *just* leaving it to individual groups to decide how they wish to operate.
 
So stipulated. Largely an artifact of language in the days before feminism when the use of the male pronoun was the accepted norm when refering to any unspecified person. "It" just doesn't work, and never did. These days, AA members often override this by referring to God as "She", usually placing extra emphasis on the word in order to drive home the point -- no one is bound by the cultural biases of the time when the Big Book was written.

FACT: The specifically Male pronoun is an artifact of Protestant Christianity which posits a Male Deity.


"Refers to the subsuming of one's Will to a Male Supernatural Deity."
Which says nothing about the deity itself. It is entirely concerned with the individual's internal states.

FACT: You're Wrong. Subsuming one's Will to the Will of a Male Supernatural Deity inherently posits that there is a Male Supernatural Deity with a Will.

"Refers to an ability to communicate with a Male Supernatural Deity."
If I talk to a volleyball, does that say anything about the volleyball's ability to respond?

1) Yes, when in fact following Steps REQUIRE the "Volleyball" to respond.

"The explicit reference to a Male Supernatural Deity that can be communicated with, Whose Will can be known to us negates the "as we understood" part."
Can you explain how it negates that?

1) FACT: It's an Explicitly Male Supernatural Deity.

2) FACT: The Explicitly Male Supernatural Deity is the Protestant version of the Christian Deity.

3) FACT: "As we understood" was added later in an attempt to Unversalize Jehovah/Jesus. However it was a half-assed measure that left in place a Singular Supernatural Male Deity. This was originally added to allow other Christian Denominations, namely Catholics.

Instead of altering the text even further to allow for the membership of other religions altogether, AA decided that the additions already made were "good enough."

"The best YOU can claim is that said Male Supernatural Deity is SEMI-UNIVERSAL."
Are you recanting your earlier claims that AA is thinly disguised Protestant Christianity? Because I still don't see how you have resolved the conflict between a deity which is universal (or even "semi-universal", whatever that means) with the constraints imposed by Matthew 7:13-14, universally embraced by Protestants everywhere, and which I will repost now for your convenience:

"Enter ye in at the strait gate: for wide is the gate, and broad is the way, that leadeth to destruction, and many there be which go in thereat: Because strait is the gate, and narrow is the way, which leadeth unto life, and few there be that find it."

No, I am not recanting my statement because it is factual, and it is consistent with my prior statements.

The addition of "as we understood" was an attempt to camouflage the Protestant version of the Christian Deity, to allow for the membership of other Christian denominations.

Yes, it was an attempt at "broadening the road" as I have acknowledged repeatedly. From the beginning I have pointed out that AA could at best be seen as only Universal enough to allow for those that followed religions that believed in a Singular Supernatural Male Deity (which is limited for the most part to the 3 Abrahamic Religions); i.e. Semi-Universal.

Despite the fact that members of all Faiths and no Faiths were later claimed to be welcomed, further adjustments of the texts were considered to be unnecessary.

Therefore, despite all claims to the contrary, to this day AA's Doctrines are still narrowly Monotheistic and the core tenets of AA are still contained in the text. The addition of the phrase "as we understood," does not significantly alter the Doctrines in and of themselves.


"I stated that I recanted that Spiritual=Religious as you well know seeing as you have just quoted it."
I was asking whether you're recanting the recanting, seeing that you just bolded a passage referencing "spiritual awakening" as evidence of religious belief.

1) No, I bolded that passage as evidence of the advocacy of Proselytizing.

2) And given the context of all the Steps that refer to subsuming one's will to the Will of a Male Supernatural Deity it is clear that "Spiritual Awakening" is referring to the subsuming of one's will to the Will of a Male Supernatural Deity.

I stated that the CORRECT equation is that Religious is a SUBSET of Spiritual."
I cannot help but notice that you have made no attempt to respond in any way to this:
Will you not make any effort at all to refute this argument that "religious" and "spiritual" are intersecting sets, or are you just going to continue to stand on your assertion that "religious" is a subset of "spiritual" as if I had never presented that argument?

I did respond by pointing out that all Religious Sets are Spiritual by definition (including the set of definitions of Spiritual that YOU POSTED); therefore all Religious Sets are a Subset of Spiritual Sets.

Are you now recanting the set of definitions for Spiritual you posted?

Odd really that you question me on this, because once you pointed out that some of the definitions of Spiritual were broader than--but inclusive of--the definitions of Religious, I conceded the point to you and altered my previous stance.

Which is what I do when someone demonstrates I have made an error. I honestly admit the error.

"As the texts of AA refer to a Male Supernatural Deity, an ability to communicate with said Male Supernatural Deity, an ability of the Male Supernatural Deity to respond to these communications, an ability of the Male Supernatural Deity to "remove our shortcomings/defects of character"

No. The ability of the deity to receive communications, and to act, is assumed, not taught. Nowhere do those steps say that any of these appeals will be either heard or answered -- a fact which is quite often pointed out at AA meetings. The goal of the steps has nothing to do with quality of life after death. It's behavior modification.


FALSE DISTINCTION: If the Sacred Texts state that one can ask God to remove one's Sins, the assumption that God will respond is being taught.

GB

EDIT: Sorry, I somehow lost the following portion of Dymanic's Post:

"A reference to a Semi-Universal Supernatural Deity (He's Male and He's Monotheistic) is still a reference to a Supernatural Deity."
Is the Christian God truly Monotheistic? What's up with this whole Trinity thing then? I've asked several times now: Which AA passages provide clarity on this?

I agree that the the Trinitarian conception of Christianity amounts to a Monistic Polytheism rather than Monotheism. However, NO major denomination of Christianity will ever concede that point. Catholic, Reformed, and Orthodox Christianity all claim to be Monotheist. As AA is based on Protestant Doctrine, the same intellectual baggage is passed on to AA.

The Sophistry they use to dance around this fact reminds me of your Sophistry to dance around the facts of the Religiosity of AA.
 
Last edited:
All social drinkers now?

Or not drinking, period?

I don't know, as I don't drink and I don't go out with them. I do know that they seem perfectly normal and when I do hang out with them (sometimes on weekend camping trips) there's no alcohol.
 
I have no doubt, but it is not that simple for most.

Please define "seriously ex-alcoholic"

Sorry, that is a bit confusing for sure. What I meant was they were knock-down drunks. The kind of guys who drink constantly, don't have jobs, and throw up all over themselves, and now aren't.

One of them told me he was passed out on the floor and woke up thinking, I have to change now or I'm going to die. He enrolled in school that day and is now in his third year, straight A's and no alcohol. The two others basically did the same thing, but one returned to his wife and got a job and is fine, that was 8 years ago, the other ended up in rehab and when he got out he moved to Alaska and became a fishing guide, that was about 11 years ago. None went to AA. It wasn't simple for any of them, they just did it anyway. Determination. One of them (the student, who is in his 40s) told me the reason he didn't go to AA was the religious bent.
 
You must be just trying to wind me up; after all, you stated many times in the thread that you were posting just for the laughs.

I post for a variety of things, sometimes it's for laughs, but it is never "just" for laughs.

Which part of "more inclusive" do you not understand? Which part of "more inclusive" that I posted three times just passed you by?

Sorry for the wind up, but I honestly saw a change in tack here. We went from more inclusive with regard to atheists, to more inclusive with regard to women. I found the change interesting and commented.

But back to my original answer to this question (perhaps in the first three pages), there is any number of reasons:
- there no need to change history
- applying the pc language of today to the past is unnecessary in the minds of many
- people in AA don't care enought to have it changed
- if there was sufficient that cared for it to change it would be
- AA members have far more on their minds than what a 70 year old book says.

Honestly, Alfie, when I finally make it to Oz for a visit, you'd be a person I'd like to have a pint (of soda :)) with, but in the meantime, I'm hard pressed to not put you on ignore.

You wouldn't be the first to put me on ignore, and I dare say not the last.

I look forward to catching up for a cuppa whenever you get here. :cool:
 
Sorry for the wind up, but I honestly saw a change in tack here. We went from more inclusive with regard to atheists, to more inclusive with regard to women. I found the change interesting and commented.

But back to my original answer to this question (perhaps in the first three pages), there is any number of reasons:
- there no need to change history
- applying the pc language of today to the past is unnecessary in the minds of many
- people in AA don't care enought to have it changed
- if there was sufficient that cared for it to change it would be
- AA members have far more on their minds than what a 70 year old book says.


Okay, I apologize. I was just using it as an example of changes made to an important text by the group when it's decided that, for the better of all involved, these changes should be made. I wasn't clear enough that I meant to use gender changes in the bible as a simple example of becoming more inclusive for women and that AA, if the World Organization were so inclined, can make similar changes in the big book text to be more inclusive of others.

One point which I've made several times is that a Higher Power can be considered anything you desire, but it's not said once in any literature that no higher power is necessary either.

But it's explicitly stated that AA is a spiritual program; so someone who wishes no spiritualistic program ultimately needs to go elsewhere.


I look forward to catching up for a cuppa whenever you get here. :cool:



Right on.
 
One point which I've made several times is that a Higher Power can be considered anything you desire, but it's not said once in any literature that no higher power is necessary either.

True enough.
Many of us believe that the HP non requirement is implied, if not stated outright. That said, I personally believe that it is more than desirable that one find an HP or God of their understanding.

But it's explicitly stated that AA is a spiritual program;

Yup.

so someone who wishes no spiritualistic program ultimately needs to go elsewhere.

It would depend on the definition of spiritual that one is using.
 
Devoid of content and filled with personal conviction. Based almost entirely on personal conviction, as a matter of fact.

Again I ask: how does posting exerpts from AA litterature, history and statistics considered a matter of conviction ?

I'm quite well aware of what GB has posted in the past. I'm also quite well aware (though perhaps you are not) that he has NOT posted anything to show that what AA's teachings are when it comes to the sort of details I referred to above, not the least reason being that there simply aren't any. Does AA embrace the Nicene creed?

If you think that's required in order for AA to be religious you are greatly mistaken. AA as a whole operated based on religious beliefs in a higher power which can make your need for alcohol go away. And since it does so at the group level, I think we can call it a cult, or at least a collection of smaller ones. And what is a cult if not religious ?

Are these not the details that distinguish one religion from another, and the religious from the secular?

No.

Second, I've already asked you to back up your claim by doing that, and here again you respond in vacuous GB fashion, simply restating your claim, and in addition, restating your claim to have already provide these answers. Tiresome. Disappointing. This is typing practice, nothing more.

What I find tiresome and dissapointing is that you claim NOT to remember having experienced those things in this thread, and demand that people repeat the same things over and over. YOU are the one who forgets. Why don't you make a little effort to remember by looking back ?

I am seeing a bit of dishonesty here, now that you mention it. I've had suspicions previously, though I wanted to allow for such possibilities as that I was mostly just seeing laziness, or perhaps a slight deficiency in short term memory. But this latest round of posts is making it harder for me to continue to extend the benefit of that doubt.

I'll let that pass, because you don't know me personally. Otherwise you couldn't even consider such an accusation.

Also, this "I know you are" argument is childish, to the extreme.
 
As you well know, the 12 steps are "suggestions" only

So you keep saying.

Doesn't it seem odd to you that the very foundation of AA would only be optional ?

And what about the claim that, if one doesn't follow the 12 steps, they end up crazy, in prison, or dead ? Does that sound optional to you ?

Here are the steps we took, which are suggested as a program of recovery:

And that is dishonest, as well.
 
Last edited:
Honestly, alcoholics that are trying to get and stay sober have far more important things to worry about than amending the big book to be reflective of today's politically correct terminology.

Yeah, like admitting they do not and cannot have any amount of control over what they do.
 
Do you or do you not know about the "AA litterature" you denied existed a few posts ago ?

Do you know3 how to spell literature, or are you making a joke? That was my point. :rolleyes:

So you keep saying.

Doesn't it seem odd to you that the very foundation of AA would only be optional ?

sigh....
What you find "odd" and what is do not have to match.

And that is dishonest, as well.

Explanation and evidence please.
 
Sorry for the wind up, but I honestly saw a change in tack here. We went from more inclusive with regard to atheists, to more inclusive with regard to women. I found the change interesting and commented.

Are you saying that only a woman would find a singular, male deity a problem?

An appeal for inclusiveness + a problem with "Him" with a capital h is only something that would bother women? Is that what you are saying?

Are you being deliberately obtuse or do you really have a problem understanding that when you go "Him" with a capital h, then that "Him" is equal to "You know, God. That god fellow what we christians - whether we admit to it or not - believe in. You know that judeochristian dude in the bible and ****. That one. I use the capital h, because I want you to be perfectly clear that I am talking about that one."

And you also claim that a call for more inclusive language would ONLY be a benefit to women? Because obviously it is the gender specificness of the noun that excluded people women.

You just keep on endearing yourself don't you. You have just outed yourself as clearly misogynistic, as well as all your other lovely traits. You do realize that quitting drinking only is a good thing if you quit the behaviour as well?

Because it doesn't really matter if you are drunk or sober as long as you engage in self aggrandizement, self pity, aggressiveness and positron reality?

And you do realize that your explanation to why it is important to you that AA is not a religious movement is both very telling and completely misguided?

Firstly: you more or less admit that it IS religious, but that you are afraid that people will not seek its help if they perceive it as such. The solution, obviously not being more inclusive language and a purging of the religious overtones, but to flat out deny the evidence there for every person who can read. So - you really accept that it is, except you don't want anyone to know that.

Second : since AA does not perform any better than quitting on your own, I really think that you shouldn't worry too much about people avoiding AA if they know it for what it actually is - lots of people would probably stand a far better chance if they got help from psychiatry instead.

Third: the constant banging on about god, no matter how you try to dress it up, clearly puts people off anyway no matter how much you lie about it. People do not seek the help of AA because all the steps still refer to "Him". That train has left and will not visit your station until the steps are changed - or you admit that your little club is religiously motivated (and belladonna motivated) and clearly state: "But it's ok if you're not."

As we say in Sweden. "Det blir varken hackat, eller malet" ("This gets neither chopped, nor milled." - I.e trying to sit on two chairs will cause your ass to end up on the ground.)

Once those whose abuse problems are comorbid with adhd, unstable personality disorder, bipolar disorders, depressive disorders and other psychiatric conditions that often are strongly linked with substance abuse get the help (and sometimes meds) that they ACTUALLY need, then the rest of you can have your little god club in peace, secure in the knowledge that people are getting the help.

Substance abuse is just one of the symptoms of these conditions. There is so much suffering that keeps going on even after people get sober.

AA is a direct hindrance in getting help for that. Not least because of the selfsatisfied attitude they have to all other treatment forms and anyone who happens to disagree with them.

Because if what you really want is for people to get the help they need to get healthy and sober, then you will recognize and accept that for a whole lot of people that is everything, except AA. And you will recognize and accept that you are already putting people off. Lying about it doesn't change that.

And the you I use above is double. It is the impersonal you as in "one", but it is also you personally who in this thread has done more to damage AA's reputation than I can remember seeing anywhere else before. "God" "Himslef" couldn't put people off AA more efficiently than you do here.

If anyone was considering AA and stumbled upon this thread, none of its detractors would be a stronger deterrent (despite the fact that they actually back their stuff up) than you have been.

Also remember that because alcoholism is a "family disease" small children of people going through Minnesota treatments and AA get roped in, against their will, to spend weeklong sessions existing only for the benefit of their alcoholic - yet again. Another example of the repressive and self obsessed nature of alcoholics, drunk or sober, and of the repressive and self obsessed nature of AA, which doesn't even shy at forcing children into its Alanonsense, Alateen-groups and Alalpub-crap.

No one asked us if we wanted to go. No one asked us if we wanted to say prayers. No one asked us if we wanted to contribute to the collection plate. Desperate sober parents got roped in to forcing us to go because AA ******** said that it was good for us. It wasn't *********** good for us, it was *********** traumatic. How is forcing children into a small room, having them read prayers and taking up collection NOT a bloody Sunday school? And WE had no bloody choice. Becuase our (mostly) dads had been brainwashed into thinking they needed to go to "church" two times per day and our (mostly) mums had been convinced/coerced that it was good for us to get locked into rooms full of upset people and force us to say prayers and share things we weren't ready to share yet and when we did would much rather share in a loving and trusting environment, rather than a roomfull of trauma.

It was bloody abusive, that's what it was. And it was also bloody religion.

We were not the ones who chose to drink our asses off. Yet we were stuck doing counter productive **** instead of healing.

When I was 14 dad got so violent the neighbours heard it and stepped in. (We all lived in houses with big yards between us) Mum and I were whisked off to a women's shelter where people who actually knew **** about traumatized children didn't ask me a thing, but simply found me artist's paints and let me at it for as long as I wanted. They never asked me anything. Just listened whenever I talked, even if it wasn't about something important. Also note that the shelter never recommended Alanon, Alateen etc. They didn't disapprove either, they simply did not have it on their list of useful contacts, because they aren't useful.

Because of that I have put the violence and that day in particular behind me. I'm ok with being someone who had to spend a bit of my teens in a shelter. That shelter was bloody nice.

But the trauma of having to go to Alapub and Alateen wasn't handled anywhere. After all - they were supposed to be the help.

There is one thing that AA certainly shares with the church, and that is the complete denial and ostrich attitude they take to what they do to children.
 
I'm truly sorry for the pain you've endured.

I can only say zealots are capable of seizing any program and shaping it to untoward ends, and in ways that would not be agreed to by most rational people. AA is no different than any other program in that regard.
 
I'm truly sorry for the pain you've endured.

I can only say zealots are capable of seizing any program and shaping it to untoward ends, and in ways that would not be agreed to by most rational people. AA is no different than any other program in that regard.

:dl:

We have witnessed the behaviour of said zealots right here in this thread, and you are right, most rational people don't agree with you.
 
Firstly: you more or less admit that it IS religious, but that you are afraid that people will not seek its help if they perceive it as such. The solution, obviously not being more inclusive language and a purging of the religious overtones, but to flat out deny the evidence there for every person who can read. So - you really accept that it is, except you don't want anyone to know that.

A very succinct summation of Alfie's entire argument. Alfie, you've been :busted
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom