Why do people insist AA is not religious?/Efficacy of AA & other treatment programs

Status
Not open for further replies.
In other words, "I have nothing, cant produce anything but will spit BS at every opportunity".

In other word's, You have Nothing. You never did have anything. Most of your arguments are BS.

You speak of honesty GB? Let's see you be honest now and produce what has been asked for. If you have produced it before, great, let's see it again. It can't be that hard for you to find your own post as you know your own work.

Put up or shut up.

Service Material from the General Service Office
THE TWELVE STEPS OF ALCOHOLICS ANONYMOUS


1. We admitted we were powerless over alcohol—that our lives had become
unmanageable.

2. Came to believe that a Power greater than ourselves could restore us to sanity.

3. Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we understood Him.

4. Made a searching and fearless moral inventory of ourselves.

5. Admitted to God, to ourselves, and to another human being the exact nature of our wrongs.

6. Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character.

7. Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings.

8. Made a list of all persons we had harmed, and became willing to make
amends to them all.

9. Made direct amends to such people wherever possible, except when to do
so would injure them or others.

10. Continued to take personal inventory and when we were wrong promptly
admitted it.

11. Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with God, as we understood Him, praying only for knowledge of His will for us
and the power to carry that out.

12. Having had a spiritual awakening as the result of these Steps, we tried to carry this message to alcoholics, and to practice these principles in all our affairs. (i.e. Proselytize)

There's some honesty for you.
mooning.gif


Put Up, Or Shut Up.

GB

Rule 6. You will not spam, flood or otherwise post in a manner that disrupts the functioning of the Forum, this includes using disruptive formatting in your posts.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: arthwollipot
 
Last edited by a moderator:
No, that's dishonest mate.

As you well know, the 12 steps are "suggestions" only, they do not constitute religious teachings, dogma nor practices.

Your post does not answer any of the questions that have been raised. Actually, it is merely another crude and dishonest post by you.

Back on ignore you go. :p
 
In other words, "I have nothing, cant produce anything but will spit BS at every opportunity".

You speak of honesty GB? Let's see you be honest now and produce what has been asked for. If you have produced it before, great, let's see it again. It can't be that hard for you to find your own post as you know your own work.

Put up or shut up.

Why do you not want AA to be called religious?
 
No, that's dishonest mate.

As you well know, the 12 steps are "suggestions" only, they do not constitute religious teachings, dogma nor practices.

Your post does not answer any of the questions that have been raised. Actually, it is merely another crude and dishonest post by you.

Back on ignore you go. :p


What is dishonest is calling them suggestions!

GB
 
Argle-bargle back atcha.

Now THERE'S a Reasoned comeback! :rolleyes:

What is also DISHONEST is pretending that RELIGIOUS LANGUAGE and DOCTRINES, aren't RELIGIOUS LANGUAGE and DOCTRINES.

Can you prove (without referring to the lies printed by AA) that they are not RELIGIOUS LANGUAGE and DOCTRINES when the language and doctrines refer to a DEITY and SUBSUMING one's WILL to said DEITY?

Of course you can't.

GB
 
"Came to believe that a Power greater than ourselves could restore us to sanity."
Is that what you call "detailed"? Do you consider details important?
Let's look at the rest of what you bolded and see what details we can find.

"Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we understood Him."

You complain that I argue without facts. Can you point to any facts about this deity contained in this statement? What specific supernatural claims do you see being made here? No need to go all BIG RED on me; let's try to just discuss this calmly. Can you do that?


"Admitted to God, to ourselves, and to another human being the exact nature of our wrongs."
"Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character."
"Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings."


The only detail regarding the specific nature of this "God" in any of these statements resides in the use of the pronoun "He". On that basis alone, it could be Ra, or Odin, or Kukailimoku, or any of a hundred other male deities. Do you dispute the importance of addressing the proper deities as central to the essence of religiousity?


"Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with God, as we understood Him, praying only for knowledge of His will for us and the power to carry that out."

"As we understood Him" leaves things WIDE open, don't you agree? How do you resolve that with the biblical passage above which speaks of wide and narrow roads? Do you see that as something that can be ignored rather than resolved?


"Having had a spiritual awakening as the result of these Steps, we tried to carry this message to alcoholics, and to practice these principles in all our affairs."

And Spiritual = Religious. Right? I mean, that either IS your position or it ISN'T.

Are you recanting this?:
I have previously stated in posts that the distinctions between Spiritual and Religious are too fuzzy to clearly distinguish between them.

Further investigation has demonstrated that I was wrong:

One CAN make certain Distinctions between Religious and Spiritual, insofar as Religious is a subset of Spiritual.
If it isn't your position that those two are equivalent, why include that implication in the "EVIDENCE that proves that AA is a Religious Organization"?

Can you prove (without referring to the lies printed by AA) that they are not RELIGIOUS LANGUAGE and DOCTRINES when the language and doctrines refer to a DEITY and SUBSUMING one's WILL to said DEITY?
Does the mere mention of a deity constitute doctrine?
 
Is that what you call "detailed"? Do you consider details important?
Let's look at the rest of what you bolded and see what details we can find.

"Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we understood Him."

You complain that I argue without facts. Can you point to any facts about this deity contained in this statement? What specific supernatural claims do you see being made here? No need to go all BIG RED on me; let's try to just discuss this calmly. Can you do that?

Fact 1) Refers to a specifically Male Supernatural Deity.
Fact 2) Refers to the subsuming of one's Will to a Male Supernatural Deity.

"Admitted to God, to ourselves, and to another human being the exact nature of our wrongs."
"Were entirely ready to have God remove all these defects of character."
"Humbly asked Him to remove our shortcomings."


The only detail regarding the specific nature of this "God" in any of these statements resides in the use of the pronoun "He". On that basis alone, it could be Ra, or Odin, or Kukailimoku, or any of a hundred other male deities. Do you dispute the importance of addressing the proper deities as central to the essence of religiousity?

Fact 1) Refers to an ability to communicate with a Male Supernatural Deity.

Fact 2) Refers to the ability of said Male Supernatural Deity to respond to our communications, and to take away our "defects of character" (AKA SINS).

Fact 3) A reference to a Semi-Universal Supernatural Deity (He's Male and He's Monotheistic) is still a reference to a Supernatural Deity.

"Sought through prayer and meditation to improve our conscious contact with God, as we understood Him, praying only for knowledge of His will for us and the power to carry that out."

"As we understood Him" leaves things WIDE open, don't you agree? How do you resolve that with the biblical passage above which speaks of wide and narrow roads? Do you see that as something that can be ignored rather than resolved?

Fact 1) The explicit reference to a Male Supernatural Deity that can be communicated with, Whose Will can be known to us negates the "as we understood" part.

Fact 2) Given Fact 1: The best YOU can claim is that said Male Supernatural Deity is SEMI-UNIVERSAL.

"Having had a spiritual awakening as the result of these Steps, we tried to carry this message to alcoholics, and to practice these principles in all our affairs."

And Spiritual = Religious. Right? I mean, that either IS your position or it ISN'T.

Are you recanting this?: If it isn't your position that those two are equivalent, why include that implication in the "EVIDENCE that proves that AA is a Religious Organization"?

Does the mere mention of a deity constitute doctrine?


Fact 1) I stated that I recanted that Spiritual=Religious as you well know seeing as you have just quoted it.

Fact 2) I stated that the CORRECT equation is that Religious is a SUBSET of Spiritual

Fact 3) As the texts of AA refer to a Male Supernatural Deity, an ability to communicate with said Male Supernatural Deity, an ability of the Male Supernatural Deity to respond to these communications, an ability of the Male Supernatural Deity to "remove our shortcomings/defects of character" (AKA SIN), and the Subsuming of one's Will to the Male Supernatural Entity, the texts are Religious in Nature.

Fact 4) As the texts are Religious in Nature they are thus ALSO Spiritual by DEFINITION.

Fact 5) As the texts enumerate the Doctrines of a Male Supernatural Deity that one can communicate with, that can respond to said communications, that can remove our "defects of character/shortcomings (AKA SIN), and the fact that one's will can be SUBSUMED to said Male Supernatural Deity, YOUR CONTENTION THAT THIS CONSTITUTES A MERE MENTION OF SAID MALE SUPERNATURAL DEITY IS FALSE.

REFUTE THAT! :p

(with EVIDENCE please)

GB
 
Last edited:
Fact 1) Refers to a specifically Male Supernatural Deity.
So stipulated. Largely an artifact of language in the days before feminism when the use of the male pronoun was the accepted norm when refering to any unspecified person. "It" just doesn't work, and never did. These days, AA members often override this by referring to God as "She", usually placing extra emphasis on the word in order to drive home the point -- no one is bound by the cultural biases of the time when the Big Book was written.


"Refers to the subsuming of one's Will to a Male Supernatural Deity."
Which says nothing about the deity itself. It is entirely concerned with the individual's internal states.


"Refers to an ability to communicate with a Male Supernatural Deity."
If I talk to a volleyball, does that say anything about the volleyball's ability to respond?


"A reference to a Semi-Universal Supernatural Deity (He's Male and He's Monotheistic) is still a reference to a Supernatural Deity."
Is the Christian God truly Monotheistic? What's up with this whole Trinity thing then? I've asked several times now: Which AA passages provide clarity on this?


"The explicit reference to a Male Supernatural Deity that can be communicated with, Whose Will can be known to us negates the "as we understood" part."
Can you explain how it negates that?


"The best YOU can claim is that said Male Supernatural Deity is SEMI-UNIVERSAL."
Are you recanting your earlier claims that AA is thinly disguised Protestant Christianity? Because I still don't see how you have resolved the conflict between a deity which is universal (or even "semi-universal", whatever that means) with the constraints imposed by Matthew 7:13-14, universally embraced by Protestants everywhere, and which I will repost now for your convenience:

"Enter ye in at the strait gate: for wide is the gate, and broad is the way, that leadeth to destruction, and many there be which go in thereat: Because strait is the gate, and narrow is the way, which leadeth unto life, and few there be that find it."


"I stated that I recanted that Spiritual=Religious as you well know seeing as you have just quoted it."
I was asking whether you're recanting the recanting, seeing that you just bolded a passage referencing "spiritual awakening" as evidence of religious belief.


"I stated that the CORRECT equation is that Religious is a SUBSET of Spiritual."
I cannot help but notice that you have made no attempt to respond in any way to this:
But I would conjecture that a vanishingly small percentage of people ("religious" or otherwise) would regard the activities of the Westboro Baptist Church as "spiritual" in nature, yet it's hard to deny that they are inspired by (justified by is probably a better choice of words) a system of "religious" beliefs -- in other words, religious, but not spiritual. There are other possible examples with which we are all familiar: the Spanish Inquisition, the Crusades, etc.
Will you not make any effort at all to refute this argument that "religious" and "spiritual" are intersecting sets, or are you just going to continue to stand on your assertion that "religious" is a subset of "spiritual" as if I had never presented that argument?


"As the texts of AA refer to a Male Supernatural Deity, an ability to communicate with said Male Supernatural Deity, an ability of the Male Supernatural Deity to respond to these communications, an ability of the Male Supernatural Deity to "remove our shortcomings/defects of character"
No. The ability of the deity to receive communications, and to act, is assumed, not taught. Nowhere do those steps say that any of these appeals will be either heard or answered -- a fact which is quite often pointed out at AA meetings. The goal of the steps has nothing to do with quality of life after death. It's behavior modification.
 
Why do you not want AA to be called religious?

I have explained this before. Simply put: I would hate a fellow alcoholic who, in huge amounts of pain rejects the possibility of recovery and a good life because of some incorrect assumption that they need to convert to religion. They do not.
 
What is dishonest is calling them suggestions!

GB

Orly?

Here are the steps we took, which are suggested as a program of recovery:

I think any further claims of yours about "dishonesty" can be taken with a grain of salt.
You are now looking incredibly foolish.
 
Last edited:
I would hate a fellow alcoholic who, in huge amounts of pain rejects the possibility of recovery and a good life because of some incorrect assumption that they need to convert to religion. They do not.

Then why is it necessary to promote lying to yourself? How else would you characterize "fake it till you make it"?

...and don't even bother to say that wasn't ever said at an AA meeting...I've personally heard it a dozen or so times.
 
If someone truly wants to kick alcoholism, they don't need AA. They can do it on their own. It's been done many times. It's called determination.

My dad kicked smoking, he carried a pack of cigs in his pocket for weeks until he lost interest and was over the physical addiction.

I have several seriously ex-alcoholic friends who kicked drinking the same way - they were damn serious about it. AA can turn into a crutch. And they don't going around saying, "I'm an alcoholic," or any nonsense like that, which AA wants you to do, even after you're not, which is very demeaning. They are now non-addicted normal people.
 
I have several seriously ex-alcoholic friends who kicked drinking the same way - they were damn serious about it. AA can turn into a crutch. And they don't going around saying, "I'm an alcoholic," or any nonsense like that, which AA wants you to do, even after you're not, which is very demeaning. They are now non-addicted normal people.
All social drinkers now?

Or not drinking, period?
 
If someone truly wants to kick alcoholism, they don't need AA. They can do it on their own. It's been done many times. It's called determination.

I have no doubt, but it is not that simple for most.

I have several seriously ex-alcoholic friends who kicked drinking the same way - they were damn serious about it.

Please define "seriously ex-alcoholic"
 
So stipulated. Largely an artifact of language in the days before feminism when the use of the male pronoun was the accepted norm when refering to any unspecified person. "It" just doesn't work, and never did. These days, AA members often override this by referring to God as "She", usually placing extra emphasis on the word in order to drive home the point -- no one is bound by the cultural biases of the time when the Big Book was written.


The Lutheran church (for one example) has made textual changes to their book of worship to be more inclusive and less sexist. The bible itself has been rewritten (certain versions) to be more inclusive and less sexist.

Why, after seventy plus years, cannot the big book be rewritten to be more inclusive and less sexist?
 
So now it's sexism that's the problem, not religion?

Honestly, alcoholics that are trying to get and stay sober have far more important things to worry about than amending the big book to be reflective of today's politically correct terminology.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom